News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by simion314 on Friday March 13, 2020 @07:36AM (#22566445)
What if I want to buy a car that has no lights,breaks and pollutes 100x more then the norms?

There are many hardened phones that are repairable.

Edit: also a main issue with repairability is DRM and evil companies trying to use the copyright law so you won't publish repair manuals and schematics. Your ceramic phone won't suffer if someone shares a manual about it's internals .

Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by userbinator on Friday March 13, 2020 @08:23AM (#22566671)
Ironically, a car that "pollutes 100x more then the norms" is also very likely to be the most repairable...
Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by simion314 on Friday March 13, 2020 @08:30AM (#22566710)
Most cars are repairable, there is an industry of alternative parts, you go to a mechanic, he plugs the laptop with the software , find the problem, then you chose from a website with parts the one you want , you have different alternatives. Also you can visit places with scraped cars and you can find parts there for cheap. There is no DRM at the moment to stop you reusing a door from a different car or a door made by any third party(not sure about latest models, maybe Tesla does this).

I am not familiar with the latest models, do they changed that dramatically and I am out of date? Can't a competent mechanic replace any part on your new car?

Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by bluGill on Friday March 13, 2020 @10:54AM (#22567706)
On a car most electronics are locked to the one VIN and it is difficult or impossible to change the part to a new VIN latter.

This is done to ensure that "strippers" will not steal a car for the parts since the most valuable parts can't be sold.

Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by hutzlibu on Friday March 13, 2020 @03:58PM (#22570384)
And it has the nice sideeffect, the the owner company controlls, what you can do with your car/where you buy your parts from.
Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by falcolas on Friday March 13, 2020 @10:19AM (#22567410)
Yeah, Tesla does (though perhaps not with doors, yet). And if you look at the industrial tractor industry, you can see the future where it applies to even more and more vehicles.
Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by JoshTriplett on Friday March 13, 2020 @07:43AM (#22566477)
> Edit: also a main issue with repairability is DRM and evil companies trying to use the copyright law so you won't publish repair manuals and schematics. Your ceramic phone won't suffer if someone shares a manual about it's internals .

I certainly think that you should have the absolute right to attempt to repair your device, and you shouldn't be legally prevented from doing so.

On the other hand, I would like a secure, lightweight device, which lasts as long as possible on battery. All of those things will suffer if people who don't understand how modern phones achieve those things attempt to force them to be made up of piecewise-replaceable components.

Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by simion314 on Friday March 13, 2020 @07:46AM (#22566497)
The idea is not that you should be able to swap your battery as easy as you can with an Nokia 3310 but that you or a competent person could swap the battery with tools made for that purpose. Also I should have the right to use components from a broken iPhone into a different broken iPhone so I get a working iPhone(and if you claim security then wipe the phone before you allow this swap).
Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by JoshTriplett on Friday March 13, 2020 @08:05AM (#22566591)
> The idea is not that you should be able to swap your battery as easy as you can with an Nokia 3310 but that you or a competent person could swap the battery with tools made for that purpose.

On many modern devices, you don't have "a battery", you have battery cells fit into every available space and wired together. You're certainly welcome to try replacing those. I just don't want to see that reverted to a discrete battery design.

> Also I should have the right to use components from a broken iPhone into a different broken iPhone so I get a working iPhone

By all means! And "components" here may well mean "single integrated board", as it does on many laptops and phones.

Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by avianlyric on Friday March 13, 2020 @08:22AM (#22566668)
> On many modern devices, you don't have "a battery", you have battery cells fit into every available space and wired together. You're certainly welcome to try replacing those. I just don't want to see that reverted to a discrete battery design.

Source for this. No device has unpackaged unprotected battery cells just floating around.

They may have many discrete batteries to use up all of the available space, but each unit is self contained with protection electronics and can be swapped independently of the others.

Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by JoshTriplett on Friday March 13, 2020 @08:31AM (#22566714)
I didn't say "unpackaged" or "unprotected". But I've seen the internals of multiple devices that have simple plastic wrappers (not hard shells) around the various battery cells, with wires connecting those plastic wrappers, and they don't have duplicated battery electronics, just one set.
Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by imtringued on Friday March 13, 2020 @09:36AM (#22567119)
I'm not sure how that is relevant to the right of being allowed to swap parts. If you can't make parts yourself but you can take salvageable parts from a broken device. Why should you be prevented from doing this repair? Also, why should third party manufacturers be prevented from making compatible parts?
Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by JoshTriplett on Friday March 13, 2020 @12:35PM (#22568668)
> I'm not sure how that is relevant to the right of being allowed to swap parts. If you can't make parts yourself but you can take salvageable parts from a broken device. Why should you be prevented from doing this repair?

As I stated earlier in this thread, you should absolutely have the right to attempt such repairs. I just don't believe that there should be requirements to make devices use more modular components, at the potential expense of other desirable properties.

Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by avianlyric on Saturday March 14, 2020 @08:08PM (#22579811)
Those are pouch batteries, they never need a hard shell.

Each one will have a tiny PCB with protection circuitry on it. It’s the only way to prevent them from accidentally catching fire or exploding.

Batteries are far more complex than most people expect. Especially lithium batteries found in phones. The chemistry is super sensitive, and anything except careful monitoring of each battery pack risks catastrophic failure. Hence the tiny PCB on each battery pack.

Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by beckingz on Friday March 13, 2020 @11:22AM (#22567968)
You mean pouch batteries? Those things are pretty durable.
Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by ClumsyPilot on Friday March 13, 2020 @09:32AM (#22567101)
Firstly there is component level repair, faulty chips on a circuitboard can be de-soldered and replaced. It is not rocket science, it's perfectly normal level of repair and is worthwhile on a $500+ device.

Then there is no phone that literally has a single board, there are other components such as the camera, earpiece, screen, etc. that are still replaceable.

Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by nnq on Friday March 13, 2020 @09:25AM (#22567050)
> I just don't want to see that reverted to a discrete battery design.

WHY?! You'd end up with stuff 3-5mm thicker, but basically the same weight. Let's drop the "thinner" fetish once and for all, nobody cares about some mm of "wasted" space (that usually improves cooling anyway) inside a devices case and it being a bit chunkier, as long as it's almost just as lightwieght!

Fffs, let's go back to getting gold plated or diamond encrusted laptops and watches for showing off status! That's way better than the thinner/lighter nonsense...

Sure, getting smth. thinner bc technology actually improves (eg. displays) is cool, but shaving micrometers by packing everything close together is stupid.

(Oh, and we could start fixing our brains to think the same about cases for... people! Eg. housing. Like in kill the micro-apparments disease, there's enough room on the planet for all to leave confortable... in bigger rooms, and with chunkier laptops if that makes them more recyclable. "Space" IS mostly "free" ya know - very little of Earth's surface is actually usable for stuff like agriculture, energy production, mining etc.)

Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by TomMarius on Friday March 13, 2020 @07:38AM (#22566450)
I was not talking about hardened phones, quite the opposite, a pure design item, so small and precise that any breakage of the shell could destroy it - that's the current direction of the market, which I like very much. Who exactly will I hurt with my phone, and when exactly is it going to gain around 1 metric ton and be hurtling down a highway? Since when is it fashionable to justify regulation with completely unrelated health/safety issues?
Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by playfool on Friday March 13, 2020 @08:07AM (#22566602)
It was a metaphor for how things are wrong in the grand scheme of things even if they are possible and available. Repairability of things makes for less waste, if you ignore that fact and knowingly buy a phone which is going to end up in a bin after 2 years with no possibility to get proper recycling and repairing, you have a similar mindset to the SUV buying bunch. That is what he is trying to say (I think).
Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by rat9988 on Friday March 13, 2020 @07:44AM (#22566484)
As a society we have to make choices. We prefer having repairable items over beautiful unrepairable ones, as the latter has been abused as an excuse to deny repairability even when possible.
Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by TomMarius on Friday March 13, 2020 @07:46AM (#22566494)
Do we? I am not really sure we do. I think it's very hard to talk about what "the society" wants, and I know that it differs very much around 150 km to the north from me (where the border is) and that it is also roughly the opposite around 300 km to the south from me (where another border is).
Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by simongray on Friday March 13, 2020 @08:06AM (#22566592)
> I think it's very hard to talk about what "the society" wants

People vote for representatives, those representatives enact legislation, and the free press reports on it, causing a feedback effect. Over time we have a picture of what society wants. It's really not that hard.

Obviously, there are many different interconnected societies in the world and not all of them have representative democracy or a free press. Maybe that was your objection?

Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by TomMarius on Friday March 13, 2020 @10:48AM (#22567650)
During the last EU parliament elections, 28.4% people voted (in my country of 10 million). These 28.4% have chosen 21 representatives into a parliament of 736, which means 2.85% of all seats.

I think it's clear why this tells us nothing about what the society here wants. It might be said that the EU was the voice of the nations before they removed the unilateral agreement requirement, but not today.

Nobody here (parties, the representatives) is even talking about the right to repair, how can you be so sure the society here wants it?

Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by simongray on Friday March 13, 2020 @11:07AM (#22567821)
> I think it's clear why this tells us nothing about what the society here wants.

On the contrary, it very clearly tells us that your society is apathetic about the EU and does not care about decisions made in the European parliament.

In my own country, 2/3 voted in the latest EU parliament elections. The debates here were dominated by environmental policy, so I'm really not surprised that legislation like this is now being considered in the EU parliament.

Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by TomMarius on Friday March 13, 2020 @11:11AM (#22567865)
> On the contrary, it very clearly tells us that your society is apathetic about the EU and does not care about decisions made in the European parliament.

Exactly, that is the only thing that is clear. And the reason is that we have much greater political problems to deal with so the EU is not that relevant to us, especially not issues like right to repair (which is not an issue to anyone I know and google gives me mostly no online discussions in our language). It still does not give anyone the right to shovel us "what the society wants". Our society didn't want the Lisboa agreement, but our politicians signed it anyways - so what exactly does our society want and what exactly should the EU be saying about it?

Even if 100% of people voted, still the 2.85% of voice don't seem like much space to express what our society wants, you know? And why there should only be space for one central opinion? That doesn't seem that diverse.

Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by simongray on Friday March 13, 2020 @11:32AM (#22568052)
> Our society didn't want the Lisboa agreement, but our politicians signed it anyways - so what exactly does our society want and what exactly should the EU be saying about it?

Then vote for a different set of politicians and leave the EU. The UK paved the way. I believe in you!

> Even if 100% of people voted, still the 2.85% of voice don't seem like much space to express what our society wants, you know? And why there should only be space for one central opinion? That doesn't seem that diverse.

Humans aren't borgs, but that doesn't mean we can't generalise about the general tendencies of society. Do you want me to admit that not everyone in a society has the same opinion? Seems a bit pointless, but sure, I'll admit that.

Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by TomMarius on Friday March 13, 2020 @01:58PM (#22569383)
> Then vote for a different set of politicians and leave the EU. The UK paved the way. I believe in you!

That's nice of you. I am not a leaver, I believe in European cooperation, maybe even federalization - but I don't believe in centralization.

Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by matz1 on Friday March 13, 2020 @08:48AM (#22566807)
Yes in the end its a preference, we have to make choices and I too would like to have the choice to buy unrepairable item. We too are "the society" so if we want to still have the option we have to fight the law. One thing to do is obviously do not vote for or support the law .
Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by lm28469 on Friday March 13, 2020 @08:37AM (#22566751)
> a pure design item, so small and precise that any breakage of the shell could destroy it

We have to come to term with the fact that owning such devices isn't good for humanity in the long term.

> Who exactly will I hurt with my phone

https://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/burning-truth-...

https://www.euronews.com/2019/07/27/europe-s-electronic-wast...

Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by TomMarius on Friday March 13, 2020 @11:07AM (#22567825)
Eh, no, my country is one of the best of EU in recycling and waste management. I dispose of all waste exactly as I should in a clear, structured and very practical way. (any) phones are taken back for recycling by most sellers, for example.
Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by lm28469 on Friday March 13, 2020 @01:05PM (#22568949)
Which country is that ? You can easily check recycling import/export per country online so that should be trivial to fact check. Pro tip: it doesn't look good for US/EU.
Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by TomMarius on Friday March 13, 2020 @01:55PM (#22569359)
It is not my fault what the state does with it after I correctly dispose it. I am not sure how that looks for my country and I mostly don't care - not my job to do, I (have to) pay taxes for that.

https://zpravy.aktualne.cz/czechs-become-eu-leaders-in-plast... ;-)

Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by lm28469 on Monday March 16, 2020 @11:04AM (#22593317)
Your source date from 2008. Newer sources describe exactly what I'm talking about : https://www.radio.cz/en/section/business/czech-republic-caug...

> I mostly don't care

Yeah, I figured out that part. The good thing is that there are less and less people like you in this world.

Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by TomMarius on Monday March 16, 2020 @03:19PM (#22596449)
I can't change anything about that. I need to pick my battles. I am doing my part exactly as I should, now the politicians need to do theirs. These things are already unlawful - what can I do to fix it? The administration nor the justice is an elected body.
Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by simion314 on Friday March 13, 2020 @07:40AM (#22566460)
E-waste is a problem that affect everyone. Also I edited my answer to add the DRM and copyright on the manuals issues.
Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by TomMarius on Friday March 13, 2020 @07:42AM (#22566469)
And how exactly does this change the fashion of buying the latest iPhone-looking phone every second year? The older devices are perfectly functioning, they just don't look like the owners wish. Most people I know have a drawer full of 100% working phones, some broken displays here and there but that is trivial to have repaired today.
Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by simion314 on Friday March 13, 2020 @07:53AM (#22566535)
Don't iPhone look very similar? why do people need a new one? There are probably many answers depending on person, some just want latest and greatest, some people were affected by the battery issue(while it was hidden from them), some people break the phone and don't have an Apple store near or don't have the time to wait for a repair and they get a new phone. Sometimes the updates make the old phones slow or incompatible and websites and applications are pushing you to buy a new one.
Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by paulryanrogers on Friday March 13, 2020 @09:18AM (#22567005)
Apparently they are different enough that people mod them to look like year-later models. Since these wouldn't have different capabilities it can only be for asthetics or social signaling.
Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by TomMarius on Friday March 13, 2020 @10:49AM (#22567659)
We're talking about Europe, iPhone is the minority here. Most phones are Androids, so no battery issue of iPhone is much relevant, same with Apple Stores.

Any phone (including iPhone) can be taken to nearly any service shop and it will probably be repaired within a day for an affordable price (if they have all parts, which they can order no problem; tools are not a problem a tall).

They also don't want the latest and greatest because that costs them way too much, most phones are mid market here, and the capabilities of these phones don't change much (same hardware for a number of years is not an exception) - but the design does. And no, the display notch is a very distinct status symbol that made the upgrade very much needed, same with multiple cameras on the back.

The few people who are buying Apple can choose between Apple stores, official Apple resellers and also a huge selection of unofficial (called "post-warranty") service shops. Not sure if it's OK with Apple, but it's definitely legal here, and it doesn't seem like these people have any problems with getting parts, getting tools or repairing the phones, but I agree that there should be an official way of doing so.

It's true that some phones became unusable with and because of software updates - that is wrong, but also an unrelated issue.

Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by efdee on Friday March 13, 2020 @08:10AM (#22566614)
Most people you know have a drawer full of 100% working phones?

I guess that suffices to conclude that you have an extremely a-typical social circle.

Re:Europe Wants a ‘Right to Repair’ Smartphones and Gadgets by TomMarius on Friday March 13, 2020 @10:49AM (#22567668)
But the point still stands - older phones are perfectly capable (and these phones are very repairable, too), just not beautiful enough. Some people having drawers of them signifies that even though these phones work, there is no demand for them.