News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by akvadrako on Thursday March 12, 2020 @05:34PM (#22562020)
Superdeterminism in general is a pretty absurd idea. It basically says the measurement settings you choose were predetermined. But you can use a random source from another galaxy to select them. So something like the configuration of stars in another galaxy must be conspiring to help you choose just the correct settings to fake the results QM predicts, instead of QM being actually true.
Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by millstone on Thursday March 12, 2020 @06:06PM (#22562371)
In QM, configurations may be "close together" in a way that defies intuition. An example is spatially separated, entangled particles.

So why can't configurations be "far apart" in a way that defies intuition? We model measuring at 45.01° as a perturbation of 45°, but perhaps these are very distant configurations.

Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by neltnerb on Thursday March 12, 2020 @05:58PM (#22562275)
This does not sound that absurd to me, just wildly different. It would require evidence to believe, of course.
Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by Grieverheart on Thursday March 12, 2020 @06:05PM (#22562368)
I do not understand your statement. Superdeterminism does not imply QM is wrong. You can not dismiss superdeterminism with the pretext that it would render everything pointless as our paths are predetermined. Basically you are arguing that you choose not to consider superdeterminism because you have free will. What sounds more absurd? I suggest you read the original paper for a better reply to your argument.
Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by wnoise on Thursday March 12, 2020 @06:47PM (#22562776)
It's not literally saying QM is false in the sense of "gives wrong predictions", but it is saying it is not "what is really going on", because it is incomplete.

> it would render everything pointless as our paths are predetermined

The objection is subtler than this. It's that it's pointless because it's not a productive stance. Science is in large part about predicting results of interventions. It throws its hands up and says everything happens for essentially conspiratorial reasons, and taken fully doesn't admit the possibility of interventions. Further this is stronger than the normal determinism of classical mechanics -- there, even if we believe in determinism, nondeterminism with respect to unobserved things (such as experimenters brains) is a useful stance for discovering truths about the universe. In contrast, with superdeterminism, any possible "intervention" in this stance is "compensated for" by the initial conditions. It explains quantum mechanics only by saying "initial conditions did it", which is no better than "God did it" of medieval philosophy. In neither case can we usefully ask further questions.

Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by Grieverheart on Friday March 13, 2020 @03:37AM (#22565466)
If you go down that route, you can always dismiss objective reality. There is no way of knowing that what we experience is actually happening. But we still assume it does. The same holds for superdeterminism. You can say we have no way of knowing if what we measure is not a conspiracy, but that doesn't hinder us from doing science as we know it.
Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by akvadrako on Friday March 13, 2020 @04:04AM (#22565565)
Without conspiracies it isn’t superdeterminism and you won’t get the right outcomes.
Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by edoo on Thursday March 12, 2020 @07:08PM (#22563000)
We paradoxically could have free will and still live in a purely deterministic universe. Even if it is deterministic, we could never do the math to determine the exact state of everything. Our inability to model the universe (without a universe sized computer) means for all intents and purposes we do have free will. Even if the arrow of time runs backwards and our perception is forward, I'm still going to pick what I eat for dinner tonight.
Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by NOGDP on Thursday March 12, 2020 @08:55PM (#22563713)
What is the difference between you picking what to eat and a computer 'picking' what 2 + 3 is? What you pick to eat is determined by your taste, mood, available food, a bunch of subconscious processes in your brain that you're not aware of and many other factors. If we ran a simulation of the same deterministic universe you would pick the same thing every time. Just because you don't know exactly why you did something or you aren't able to fully rationalise your choice, doesn't mean you have free will.
Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by kruasan on Thursday March 12, 2020 @10:46PM (#22564254)
There is so much wrong with this. It's clear that you're essentially presupposing there is either "free will" or "determinism" when in fact the right distinction to make is "free will" as opposed to "no free will".

Anyway, when you make a rerun of the universe from the same initial conditions, you get randomness because of quantum mechanics, so the future outcome is not exactly the same, and you can't predict anything with certainty because of probabilities. But look, all of this has nothing to do with free will. Neither determinism nor quantum mechanical randomness give you an absolute-metaphysical-libertarian superwill when you're not a subject to the laws of physics at all (unless you believe that you're a soul/cartesian ego/some other supra-physical mental entity with dubious ontological status). You're basically arguing against this abovementioned concept. But actually default, regular free will is just an effective description of reality where persons have volition, and it exists as an emergent rather than fundamental thing.

Before you start to make the same argument that free will doesn't really exist, consider the question: does Hacker News exist? Well, duh, of course not! There are no websites, no Internet and no computers, it's obviously all just fundamental particles acting in some ways, you know, just the wave function of the universe deterministically obeying the Schrodinger equation, etc. Naive reductionism. But here we are, reading Hacker News. Guess what, you don't live on a level of fundamental particles. Does, for example, chess exist? Your argument implies that it does not, but here I am, playing chess in a separate tab.

So, do persons exist?

Does free will exist?

It strikes me that people don't bother to make real arguments against free will, like a psychological one, for example.

Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by NOGDP on Friday March 13, 2020 @11:27AM (#22568009)
> It's clear that you're essentially presupposing there is either "free will" or "determinism"

Yes, free will doesn't seem possible in a deterministic universe.

> Anyway, when you make a rerun of the universe from the same initial conditions, you get randomness because of quantum mechanics, so the future outcome is not exactly the same, and you can't predict anything with certainty because of probabilities

Then the universe is not deterministic.

> Before you start to make the same argument that free will doesn't really exist, consider the question: does Hacker News exist? Well, duh, of course not! There are no websites, no Internet and no computers, it's obviously all just fundamental particles acting in some ways, you know, just the wave function of the universe deterministically obeying the Schrodinger equation, etc. Naive reductionism.

No, there is a difference between something existing and free will. A computer can calculate an answer to some query, and the answer exists, doesn't mean it was generated through the computer's free will.

Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by perl4ever on Thursday March 12, 2020 @11:14PM (#22564403)
I never see people discussing the statistical aspects of free will.

For instance, I may decide to have an apple tonight, or spaghetti, or whatever. Thus, I seem to have free will. But if one collected statistics on what I ate over time, there would be patterns and it would be much more difficult for me to overcome those patterns with "will". The more time and events you look at the more you see things like unconcious maintenance of weight, preferences of types of food, and so on.

Yet the long term patterns are made up of the individual choices that seem free.

I have this vague idea that some further exploration of this might be compared to the statistical ideas of quantum mechanics.

Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by tsimionescu on Friday March 13, 2020 @05:46AM (#22565953)
That's because it's not an interesting thought as related to the notion of free will. Everyone accepts that humans have subconscious biases that impact their decisions. The discussion of free will is higher level than that. The fact that you can't will yourself into not breathing is not a refutation of free will.

The question is essentially, when all biases are accounted for, is there some aspect of free will that remains? You experience free will constantly, and you assume it in all interactions with other agents. Is that an illusion, are we just puppets in a play? Many philosophers believe that it isn't, even if determinism is real. I'm not sure if super-determinism is still compatible or not, but it may well be.

Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by perl4ever on Saturday March 14, 2020 @08:49AM (#22574895)
I mean, I can will myself into not breathing. I used to hold my breath between subway stations. But that's about as long as I can do it.

I feel like there's some sort of analogy between how you can have local violations of conservation of energy where particles pop into existence from nowhere, but longer term it has to even out.

Bias isn't the word I would use.

Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by temppsychonaut on Thursday March 12, 2020 @07:30PM (#22563158)
My problem with compatibalism, is compatibilism is so rigid. Why can’t we just overtly define free will in such a way that we have “free will,” and at the same time acknowledge that we lack “free will” for another definition. I guess what I’m trying to say is compatibilism just seems to me like it takes a hard stance on a word game.
Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by AnimalMuppet on Thursday March 12, 2020 @08:30PM (#22563543)
I agree. Compatibilism either defines "free will" to be something I don't consider to be free will, or defines "determinism" into something I don't consider to be determinism (or both).
Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by GoblinSlayer on Friday March 13, 2020 @08:39AM (#22566758)
Another definition like "nondeterministic free will" doesn't make much sense, so when you say such will does or doesn't exist, it's unclear what it means and what conclusions should follow from it. Some people assume it makes sense, but only until you question it.
Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by o_p on Thursday March 12, 2020 @05:50PM (#22562178)
I see it more as if the universe was a 4D picture, with time as the 4th dimension, any concept of time "going forward" is just an illusion by how our brains work (we need time to compute every moment), so the outcomes are already written, we just havent seen it.
Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by aaron-santos on Thursday March 12, 2020 @06:11PM (#22562439)
Similar to the B-theory of time.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/B-theory_of_time

Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by gus_massa on Thursday March 12, 2020 @11:10PM (#22564384)
This is essentially one of the main ideas of Special Relativity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_relativity You can mix space an time, using the Lorentz transformation.
Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by phkahler on Thursday March 12, 2020 @11:00PM (#22564328)
I have long been a fan of the 4d fixed universe. If you think of fractals you can get a hint at how everything is interrelated. As you indicated, the fundamental issue is why we experience the passage of time. I dont think it's an illusion, but the most important question.
Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by ebg13 on Thursday March 12, 2020 @05:53PM (#22562202)
In that framework something most still be moving through an external time to be experiencing individual parts of it sequentially.
Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by gicop on Thursday March 12, 2020 @06:56PM (#22562876)
Here's a thought experiment, similar to the one-electron universe thought experiment: there exists one particle, the "consciousness particle," which randomly jumps around throughout 4D space. Whenever it appears at a 4D position, consciousness is experienced as computed by integrated information theory (or a similar model) [1].

When you experience a moment of consciousness at a specific 4D position, you experience all the memories of the "past" that are in your brain. Thus, the consciousness particle interpretation of consciousness is compatible with your direct perception of living a 3D life along a time dimension.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Integrated_information_theory

Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by ebg13 on Friday March 13, 2020 @10:33AM (#22567529)
You still need real time for this. Without real time that particle can't move.
Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by tylerjwilk00 on Thursday March 12, 2020 @11:36PM (#22564504)
So basically we're all the same person we just think we're different people.
Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by o_p on Thursday March 12, 2020 @06:02PM (#22562339)
What do you mean by experiencing sequentially?
Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by tylerjwilk00 on Thursday March 12, 2020 @11:32PM (#22564486)
He means We (you, me, other humans) experience time passing consciously and sequentially.

We are on the inside of a 4 dimensional bulk. We are traveling through the temporal dimension.

As opposed to outside of it looking in. In which case we would "see" past, present, and future simultaneously.

Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by ebg13 on Friday March 13, 2020 @10:24AM (#22567455)
Better yet, if we're traveling through that temporal dimension there must be real time. Otherwise how would we be traveling?
Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by mihaaly on Friday March 13, 2020 @04:35AM (#22565693)
The way I get is that we are measuring something with itself. Measuring an unknown attribute with something (actually the same thing) having the same unknown attribute. We cannot predetermine the settings of the measurement as we do not know its attributes or parameters. We have no means of calibrating something we do not know. It does not have to be an atom from a distant galaxy - very well may be, we do not know yet - but unknown underlying interdependence locally. The superposition of unknown number of underlying unknowns combine into what happens when we measure an unknown with an other unknown. We measure our universe with itself, the taste of an apple with an other apple.
Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by magicalhippo on Thursday March 12, 2020 @05:42PM (#22562110)
You can also generate them using a mathematical algorithm, say a cryptographically secure PRNG. Then what?
Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by phyzome on Thursday March 12, 2020 @08:15PM (#22563453)
Then you've used a worse randomness source.
Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by chopin on Thursday March 12, 2020 @05:56PM (#22562255)
If superdeterminism is true your PRNG isn't random.
Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by vardump on Thursday March 12, 2020 @06:08PM (#22562402)
PRNG by definition is not random.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pseudorandom_number_generator

"A pseudorandom number generator (PRNG), also known as a deterministic random bit generator (DRBG)..."

Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by chopin on Friday March 13, 2020 @02:43AM (#22565273)
I was referring to the seed.
Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by tylerjwilk00 on Thursday March 12, 2020 @11:41PM (#22564520)
This always seemed like the easiest way to explain superdeterminism. It's a universe where the laws of physics do not permit you to generate a truly random number.
Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by magicalhippo on Thursday March 12, 2020 @05:57PM (#22562268)
But that would mean math is not math, which seems a rather hard pill to swallow.
Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by millstone on Thursday March 12, 2020 @06:07PM (#22562389)
PRNGs need a seed, and that choice is superdetermined.
Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by magicalhippo on Thursday March 12, 2020 @08:22PM (#22563498)
The distribution of the experiment results, say correlation in a Bell test, should not matter (significantly) on the choice of seed. But the single electron being sent through the experiment still needs to "know" what the outcome of my PRNG is in order to "know" if it should be spin up or spin down this time.

But the measurement setting (PRNG outcome) can be arbitrarily removed from the seed value (by combining PRNGs in various ways). So that doesn't sound very convincing to me.

Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by nl on Thursday March 12, 2020 @09:17PM (#22563834)
It's unclear if you mean PRNG (pseudo random number generator) which is already deterministic, or a true random number source (eg, radioactive decay or something).

If you mean true random, then, yes, superdeterminism does indeed mean that number is predetermined.

Math still works though - there is no way for someone to peek and see what that predetermined number is so it is still random for any observer.

Re:Superdeterminism may help us overcome the current crisis ... by ur-whale on Friday March 13, 2020 @04:25PM (#22570608)
Weren't all particles pretty darn correlated at t=0 (big bang)?