News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by freeAgent on Saturday March 07, 2020 @10:11AM (#22511865)
This article brings up one of the biggest problems I have with our justice system. When someone is falsely suspected or accused of a crime, they typically have to hire a lawyer and take time off work and out of their lives. This can cost thousands of dollars that many people can't really afford to spend. The police or court may eventually say, "oops, our bad," but the accused typically has no way to recover what they spent on their own defense. The whole situation is asymmetric given that investigators, courts, and prosecution don't have to spend personal funds to conduct investigations and try people in court.
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by hypersoar on Saturday March 07, 2020 @11:28AM (#22512379)
My sister is a lawyer who works with poor clients with criminal cases (though not a defense attorney). She believes strongly that most people are better off with their public defender than with private council. I asked her if she could square this with the general perception that the criminal justice system is stacked for with wealthy, she answered that the, most of the time, the connections matter more than the actual money. There are a lot of bad private lawyers out there, and it's hard for most people to tell them apart from the good ones. For a lot of us here, if we suddenly need a lawyer, then we'll ask our friends and family to help us find a good one. But if you don't know anybody who knows anybody who knows a lawyer, what do you do? Look at online reviews? If I were freaked out about criminal charges, needed a lawyer now, and didn't have my connections, it'd be up to blind luck. That's the reality for most criminal defendants.

They'll hire private council and think that because they're paying for it, it's better. But it's often not. For a typical defendant with an aggravated assault charge, a public defender has handled dozens of similar cases before. Moreover, they'll have done it with your judge and your prosecutor. A private lawyer probably won't have that. Granted, this probably holds a lot less for the HN comments section.

I'll add that there is no right to defense council for civil cases. These can have consequences just as dire as a criminal case, as in immigration or eviction proceedings. An indigent defendant with no lawyer has a very poor chance. There's a movement to create this right [1]. The current Supreme Court, however, seems more likely to weaken Gideon v. Wainwright than expand it.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by ALittleLight on Saturday March 07, 2020 @02:09PM (#22513361)
Responding to the point about what you are supposed to do if you need a lawyer and don't know any - I needed a lawyer once and didn't know any. I first read about what I was accused of, I read the relevant parts of the law I was accused of violating, and then I googled and read whatever I could about the crime. I then looked up local lawyers and read their websites and bios and googled them to see if there was anything to read about them.

Background research done I created a list of lawyers I wanted to talk to and called them one by one and discussed the case over the phone. The crime I was accused of was somewhat rare and none of the five lawyers I called were familiar with it. I could tell fairly quickly that several of the lawyers were, for lack of a better term, bullshitting me about their familiarity with crime because I had first done the basic research so I had some understanding of what was reasonable to say about it. One lawyer was obviously reading passages from wikipedia verbatim to me, which I recognized having recently read the same wikipedia article myself. Another lawyer didn't seem to listen to me - after hearing my story he confidently assured me he could get the charge reduced... to what I was already charged with. Others just didn't seem that competent.

The lawyer I ultimately went with was a former prosecutor, which I liked because I figured it meant he would know the other prosecutors, and he was the only one who, when I called him, said "I don't know much about this. Let me do some reading and call you back." I immensely respected that more than the people who tried to pretend like they knew what they were talking about.

Ultimately, we had an extremely successful result and now if anyone I know ever needs a lawyer, I have one to recommend. It may be a bit harder if you don't have connections, but there is no reason why the average person retaining a lawyer can't go through the effort of finding one they are comfortable with.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by jackpirate on Saturday March 07, 2020 @02:31PM (#22513483)
there is no reason why the average person retaining a lawyer can't go through the effort of finding one they are comfortable with.

You are vastly overestimating the ability of an "average" person to be able to understand and analyze legal complications for themselves. The average person, for example, does not have a college degree [1], let alone a degree in a technical subject that has trained them in analytic reasoning.

[1] Only 37% of people age 25-30 in the US have a bachelors: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Educational_attainment_in_the_...

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by wolco on Saturday March 07, 2020 @03:17PM (#22513756)
And a bachelors tells us very little.
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by HumblyTossed on Saturday March 07, 2020 @03:31PM (#22513826)
> but there is no reason why the average person retaining a lawyer can't go through the effort of finding one they are comfortable with.

I'm sorry, but this is laughably out of touch with reality for the "average person".

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by x86_64Ubuntu on Saturday March 07, 2020 @07:42PM (#22515401)
You just explained why the average person can't find one they are comfortable with by detailing the amount of research you had to do. And you didn't bring up the financial aspect of it all either. I may find a lawyer that can make the charge go away, but my wallet may say otherwise.
[dead]
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by perl4ever on Saturday March 07, 2020 @09:04PM (#22515805)
To be fair, the lawyers who are below average often end up in other places rather than representing clients in court.

It used to be people would talk about the hellish conditions doing hourly document review, but that got offshored years ago, so I'm not sure what the situation is now.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by pault on Sunday March 08, 2020 @03:10AM (#22516753)
Learning react at a bootcamp and becoming a front end developer?
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by perl4ever on Monday March 09, 2020 @06:22PM (#22530541)
One of the client managers where I used to work (litigation support) is in fact getting a CS degree.
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by berberous on Saturday March 07, 2020 @12:17PM (#22512675)
Finding a good lawyer is hard, but to your point about public defenders having more relevant experience, there’s a simple heuristic: ask the lawyers you interview what direct experience they have. If you have an aggravated assault charge, and your potential private lawyer has done many DUIs but only one of those, move on.

A public defender might not be _bad_, but in many jurisdictions they are egregiously overworked. Their case load is so over burdened they don’t have the time to do a thorough job. I’d much rather take my chances with a paid lawyer.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by sfkdjf9j3j on Saturday March 07, 2020 @12:48PM (#22512864)
I think this post has a big misconception in it. Public defenders are for the destitute. You have to ask for one, and convince a judge that based on your assets and income, you can't afford a private attorney. There's no choice here, if you can afford a private defense, you won't be given a public defender.
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by bryanrasmussen on Saturday March 07, 2020 @01:44PM (#22513217)
I think this depends on the state, I think in a lot of states getting a public defender is just based on the Judge saying that in the case you cannot afford a lawyer one will be appointed for you and then asking if you need a lawyer appointed. Sure, if you're Bill Gates and you say yes, he might shut that down but the average person I don't think most jurisdictions actually investigate their means.
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by anfilt on Saturday March 07, 2020 @04:29PM (#22514228)
I am not a lawyer, but if you have the means and say you don't I am pretty sure thats perjury.
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by DonHopkins on Saturday March 07, 2020 @09:41PM (#22515970)
And then you need ANOTHER more expensive lawyer, so you get a second chance at not being able to afford both lawyers.
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by bryanrasmussen on Saturday March 07, 2020 @04:33PM (#22514269)
Ok, but I'm pretty sure that perjury is generally understood as being under oath and you aren't under oath when the judge is first reading you the charges against you and offering you the recourse of a public defender.

Although I suppose the court could hold you in contempt if it found you had the means and said you didn't. But I've never seen or heard of anyone being means checked.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by 1123581321 on Saturday March 07, 2020 @07:24PM (#22515269)
Is your comment based on experience? It seems wrong.

All the search results (Findlaw, Avvo lawyer answers, etc) seem to be saying that you have to qualify financially, you have to submit your income and assets of your household under penalty of perjury (signed statement, not oath) and you may also be asked to get quotes from lawyers to compare against your means. I think the most you could say is that courts are so overloaded you might get away with perjury.

A few sample links:

https://www.expertlaw.com/forums/showthread.php?t=61781

https://www.newsherald.com/news/20180304/in-court-majority-s...

https://www.avvo.com/legal-answers/can-i-be-denied-a-public-...

http://gapubdef.org/index.php/faqs

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by bryanrasmussen on Sunday March 08, 2020 @04:11AM (#22516925)
I qualified my original statement by saying "I think this depends on the state". Although now that I think of it, the laws in the states I know also say you can be made to pay back the costs if it is determined you could afford an attorney, however I have never seen anything done about it.

So I think you're right, it is perjury that doesn't really get anything done about it - I think based on the idea that if you had the money to get an attorney you would do it so anyone saying they can't get an attorney doesn't have the money.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by hypersoar on Saturday March 07, 2020 @04:12PM (#22514098)
I did a bit of digging and found some (old) data to (largely) back me up! The Bureau of Justice Statistics released a report in 2000 [2] on "Defense Counsel in Criminal Cases". The following points are for defendants in state court in the 75 largest counties. The report has data for Federal defendants, too, and the broader picture looks pretty similar for them. According to the report, only 5% of criminal cases are in Federal courts.

- Felony defendants were represented by publicly-financed attorneys over 80%(!) of the time.

- Defendants with public and private attorneys had similar conviction rates. They pled out at similar rates, too.

- Defendants with public attorneys were more likely to get prison sentences, but got shorter sentences on average.

- Defendants with private attorneys who were already in prison (i.e., convicted) talked to their lawyers earlier and more often. The part about prison just seems to be because that's where they collected the data.

- Defendants with public attorneys got pretrial release a lot less often (50% vs 80%) than those with private attorneys. This looks to me like it's mostly about not being able to afford bail.

- Workloads for Federal appointed attorneys rose faster than spending on them. I would guess the same to be true of state courts and for the trend to have continued to today.

[1] http://civilrighttocounsel.org/, the civil right to counsel I forgot in my post.

[2] https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/dccc.pdf 2000 appears to be the most recent report on this subject. It's possible they've collected more recent data elsewhere and I didn't turn it up.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by perl4ever on Saturday March 07, 2020 @09:08PM (#22515818)
I hate to point out the obvious, but you can't say anything meaningful about the effectiveness of lawyers without separating their clients into the ones that were guilty and the ones that weren't. It's very probably a wrong assumption that public and private lawyers have the same percentage split. And if the system actually worked, then a good lawyer shouldn't affect the conviction rate of the guilty...
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by imtringued on Sunday March 08, 2020 @01:02PM (#22519094)
A convict might be guilty of a lesser crime than he was charged with.
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by irjustin on Saturday March 07, 2020 @12:15PM (#22512656)
This is very insightful and makes a ton of sense.

I'm not related to the company, but this is exactly what avvo.com is solving. I have known others to use it for traffic infractions all the way to criminal defence. In general they speak positively about the experience.

I don't know any particular lawyer's connections, but I can see the reviews/self-reported-track records.

But, this creates a new problem - gamification of reviews. But now that it's in the "reviews" space, I know how to at least manage that problem as opposed to something I know zero about such as judging a lawyer's relationships and effectiveness.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by rflrob on Saturday March 07, 2020 @12:36PM (#22512803)
Though one’s right to a public defender only applies once you’ve been charged, right? In TFA, the guy being investigated was only the subject of a warrant.
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by desdiv on Saturday March 07, 2020 @01:08PM (#22512985)
I believe you have the right to a public defender during questioning (which can happen both before and after you are charged) based on the wording of the Miranda warning:

>You have the right to have a lawyer with you during questioning. If you cannot afford a lawyer, one will be appointed for you before any questioning if you wish.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miranda_warning

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by roywiggins on Saturday March 07, 2020 @01:09PM (#22512989)
Federal public defenders have a very good reputation. State public defenders, less so. Mostly because many public defenders offices are deeply underfunded.
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by scarface74 on Saturday March 07, 2020 @03:26PM (#22513805)
I can’t disagree with this more. Public Defenders are overworked and underfunded. They have a high case load and are usually just interested in getting their clients to plea. Why would I put my life in the hands of someone paid by the same government trying to convict me if I could afford a private attorney?
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by bryanrasmussen on Saturday March 07, 2020 @01:42PM (#22513203)
Ok, but having a public defender because you've been accused of burglarizing a house because you drove by it on your bike and google tracked the trip might not be that good since the public defender is generally focused on cutting a deal. Getting a deal cut with a public defender might be better than private but going to court under these specific circumstances?
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by closeparen on Saturday March 07, 2020 @03:31PM (#22513832)
I think the typical concern is that caseload usually doesn't permit a public defender to mount a defense, only to negotiate a plea agreement. Those connections will be useful in negotiation. But you are probably not getting evidence thrown out, private investigators, expert witnesses, etc.
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by 6gvONxR4sf7o on Saturday March 07, 2020 @08:39PM (#22515685)
>There are a lot of bad private lawyers out there, and it's hard for most people to tell them apart from the good ones.

Is that not the case for public defenders too?

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by samstave on Saturday March 07, 2020 @01:56PM (#22513287)
Obviously - people with money have far better connections.
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by tingletech on Saturday March 07, 2020 @02:47PM (#22513589)
if you have money, is a public defender even an option?
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by sneak on Saturday March 07, 2020 @10:38AM (#22512053)
It's worse. They can blow up your infant children with explosives because they got the wrong house, and suffer no consequences:

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/ex-georgia-deputy-acqui...

Policing in the US is entirely out of control.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by HarryHirsch on Saturday March 07, 2020 @11:32AM (#22512398)
US police can rape women on the job and walk with a suspended sentence: https://www.elpasotimes.com/story/news/crime/2020/01/31/-/46...

That shapes the culture. It's kind of anti-Spiderman. With great powers comes no responsibility at all.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by xyzal on Saturday March 07, 2020 @10:50AM (#22512129)
As an Eastern European with some experience with autocratic government I quite look up to the U.S. as to a champion of democratic culture, but among two major things that baffle me (healthcare being the other) is why there is such a high cost associated with litigation even for the innocent party. In continental Europe, the "loser pays" principle seems to hold quite well, while also having the benefit of discouraging people from frivolous lawsuits.
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by Hamuko on Saturday March 07, 2020 @11:04AM (#22512202)
>In continental Europe, the "loser pays" principle seems to hold quite well

It apparently holds in every western democracy except for the United States of America.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English_rule_(attorney%27s_fee...

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by briandear on Saturday March 07, 2020 @12:18PM (#22512679)
Imagine suing General Motors because of a faulty car. General Motors hires an army of experts and the best attorneys. In the event of loser pays, the apparent victim is now on the hook for perhaps a million dollars. That would shut down all legitimate product liability lawsuits in an instant.
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by samatman on Saturday March 07, 2020 @04:31PM (#22514249)
There is a game-theoretic optimal solution to this:

The loser must pay up to the amount they themselves spent on prosecuting the case, but no more.

So General Motors would have to pay the full cost of the plaintiff's litigation if they lost, while the plaintiff would have to pay their costs, plus an equivalent amount to GM.

This is of course independent of compensation and damages awarded.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by tgsovlerkhgsel on Saturday March 07, 2020 @06:46PM (#22515093)
Which is why there is a definition of reasonable costs, and that's what you get reimbursed.

And if that is a million dollars, in that case: Should someone be able to cause a million dollars' worth of damage with a frivolous lawsuit without being liable for it?

Patent trolls are one of the things that would work significantly less well in a loser-pays scenario.

Or to turn your example around: If the car hasn't killed me and I just want my money back, should I be forced to just eat the loss because even if I win, the legal costs will be higher?

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by imtringued on Sunday March 08, 2020 @01:49PM (#22519378)
>Patent trolls are one of the things that would work significantly less well in a loser-pays scenario.

I'm not sure how that would matter. The patent troll sues 100 companies. Has to pay the legal fees for the 100 processes because all of them have been initiated by the patent troll. The patent troll wins 30 cases.

In the American system the patent troll already included the legal fees in his calculations and optimized them for profit but the victims are always stuck with legal fees even if they win. The patent troll basically causes a minimum amount of damage regardless of the outcome. The legal fees are often close to $0 for the patent troll because merely the act of receiving a letter from a lawyer scares startups into paying the settlement fees. Losing a month or two can be devastating for a young company but they can easily recover from losing $20k if it means that they can run their business with no distractions.

In the loser pays scenario the patent troll's legal fees would be completely unpredictable in the 70 cases. Losing 70 times might result in bankruptcy of the patent troll and the majority of victims would not be burdened by legal fees.

This sub thread is making the assumption that the innocent legal entities (= person or company) are on the losing end but if patent trolls had to be 100% sure that their patents are valid then there would be significantly fewer of them. For the few patent trolls that remain you can't argue that they shouldn't have the right to protect their patents. The patent system might be broken but if you can't enforce patents in valid situations then why even bother with the system?

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by edmundsauto on Saturday March 07, 2020 @09:30PM (#22515928)
What GM argues is reasonable could be many millions of dollars -- they could be liable for hundreds of millions of dollars depending on the severity. A judge isn't going to make them work with just 2 associates.

Your first question ("Should someone be able to...") is a false dichotomy. The real question is whether we show a preference for being able to sue easily, versus adding more downside.

In America, consumer protection is done through lawsuits, especially since the current leadership is underfunding these groups. In general, companies have less approvals before launching a product under the assumption that negligence will cost them a ton of money in class action. That is why class action amounts can be so high - it's the dis-incentive for cutting corners.

Yes, patent trolls are an issue. I think there are better ways to reduce that impact (such as a sensible patent system) without harming consumers.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by Hamuko on Saturday March 07, 2020 @01:42PM (#22513204)
Well, that's assuming that legitimate product liability lawsuits lose in the court.
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by ip26 on Saturday March 07, 2020 @02:13PM (#22513387)
Just because you are right doesn't guarantee you'll win. You feeling lucky?
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by int_19h on Saturday March 07, 2020 @07:40PM (#22515388)
With our existing system, you have to ask the same question every time you sue anybody, or do something that might cause somebody else to sue you, because you can get financially ruined even if you win.
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by huntie on Saturday March 07, 2020 @12:19PM (#22512694)
The problem with the English Rule is that it protects the rich.
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by Fnoord on Saturday March 07, 2020 @01:13PM (#22513021)
No, it does not, its exactly the other way around. English Rule protects the innocent, who did not commit a crime, as they'll eventually win the case.

American Rule protects the rich (and those in power, such as police, public prosecutor, etc), as it allows them to bully the poor who can't afford a lawyer, or lose so much money that their interests are harmed. A clear example of that is patent trolls.

The rich can afford in either system, but the poor can only afford in English Rule. It should not be about poor vs rich but about truth (ie. guilty vs innocent).

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by alistairSH on Saturday March 07, 2020 @02:35PM (#22513508)
How does loser-pays protect the poor? As noted above, unless you have significant resources, bringing suit against a large corporate entity is extremely risky, as you could get stuck paying for their army of lawyers, paralegals, and investigators.

In the US system, a poor person can bring suit, using a lawyer working on contingency, and not fear for being stuck should they lose.

Your argument seems to hinge on the "correct" party always winning, but that's far from the case.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by tgsovlerkhgsel on Saturday March 07, 2020 @06:48PM (#22515107)
With loser pays, bringing a suit is risky (with the risk depending on the risk of losing the suit).

With the US system, there is no way to get justice in many cases, even when you're obviously right, because the (non-recoverable) legal costs exceed the amount by which you have been wronged (and the opponent knows that).

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by xyzal on Saturday March 07, 2020 @03:03PM (#22513679)
This is IMO part of the problem with common law: the judge rarely inquires into matters before them, instead relying on arguments presented by lawyers, so the party which can afford better lawyers tends to win.

In continental law, judges role is more like an investigator; his/hers role is to establish the facts of the case and to apply the provisions of the code. They are the ones questioning witnesses.

See also: https://onlinelaw.wustl.edu/blog/common-law-vs-civil-law/

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by Fnoord on Saturday March 07, 2020 @02:56PM (#22513647)
If you can't afford an attorney, you can get one appointed, it is like that in every system AFAIK.

> Your argument seems to hinge on the "correct" party always winning, but that's far from the case.

Of course it does.

If the correct party does not usually win (with a few exceptions, being rounding errors) then your legal system, and democracy, is indeed very much broken.

If the police bust someone for murder, and this person gets sued, gets a fair trial, and gets incarcerated in jail for murder we, civilians/voters, must be able to assume that the system worked correctly. If this is not the case, if it is "normal" (too high percentage) innocent people get behind bars, that is a high priority problem. There's always going to be false positives, sure, but in general we must be able to assume one is a true positive.

Now, in English law the poor could sue, and win, if they're in the right. In American law, they can't afford a lawsuit. If they get sued for whatever, they'll be more likely to settle, without being on the good end of the stick. I can only define that as class justice.

There are limits to the claims, btw [1] [2]. Also, the amounts have to be reasonable.

Also, I believe @xyzal is correct in describing the difference between civil and common law. The problem you described is much less of a problem in civil law.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Costs_in_English_law#Exception...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Costs_in_English_law#Who_can_c...?

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by alistairSH on Saturday March 07, 2020 @03:45PM (#22513907)
If you can't afford an attorney, you can get one appointed,

In the US, that only applies to indigent defendants in criminal cases. It does not apply to anybody with any semblance of financial stability and does not apply to anybody in civil cases.

Is it different abroad?

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by imtringued on Sunday March 08, 2020 @01:55PM (#22519422)
An innocent poor person doesn't bring up a suit against a large corporate entity. Why? Because only defendants can be innocent or guilty.

This focus on small people suing big corporations is absolutely insane.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by perl4ever on Saturday March 07, 2020 @09:14PM (#22515858)
I used to work in litigation support and something that stuck in my mind was an article some years ago in a trade magazine about how a new trend in venture capital from the UK was funding American lawsuits.

I always think of that when someone is sneering at the American legal system or blaming Americans for everything they interact with globally.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by srtjstjsj on Saturday March 07, 2020 @10:38PM (#22516193)
> as they'll eventually win the case.

Citation needed.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by asdfman123 on Saturday March 07, 2020 @04:23PM (#22514185)
> In continental Europe, the "loser pays" principle seems to hold quite well, while also having the benefit of discouraging people from frivolous lawsuits.

You'd think the people who came up with it had never played Scrabble, where you lose a turn for a false dictionary challenge.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by notRobot on Saturday March 07, 2020 @10:59AM (#22512181)
> I quite look up to the U.S. as to a champion of democratic culture

It really isn't. Look towards Scandinavian countries for that.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by Legogris on Saturday March 07, 2020 @11:07AM (#22512219)
Scandinavian here. Keep looking.
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by gruez on Saturday March 07, 2020 @11:18AM (#22512308)
What are the ills there?
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by notlukesky on Saturday March 07, 2020 @10:17PM (#22516109)
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by srtjstjsj on Saturday March 07, 2020 @10:39PM (#22516197)
> The United Nations’ ruling that Sweden violated the global torture ban

which has nothing to do with democracy.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by oska on Saturday March 07, 2020 @10:08PM (#22516077)
Switzerland probably remains the champion.
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by Hamuko on Saturday March 07, 2020 @11:04AM (#22512203)
Or Finland.
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by danlugo92 on Saturday March 07, 2020 @12:40PM (#22512826)
One of those went cashless... do I need to say more?
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by lostlogin on Saturday March 07, 2020 @01:20PM (#22513060)
Yes.
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by ta1234567890 on Saturday March 07, 2020 @11:16AM (#22512297)
And this applies to the whole justice system, regardless if it's a criminal or civil issue.

In civil cases this is used as leverage by wealthy people. The wealthy can sustain a legal battle for as long as they want. They know that if their opponent isn't as wealthy, they'll be forced to settle, even for an unreasonable amount, just because they won't be able to afford defending themselves properly.

For reference, a decent civil attorney in a major city in California will charge $250-500/hour, which ends up being around $5k/month to defend pretty much any civil lawsuit. A lawsuit that goes to trial will take 18-24 months, so you'll end up paying $90-120k just in legal fees. There will also be $10-20k in additional court fees and other expenses, not to mention your time.

At the end of the day, if you defend a civil lawsuit and you flawlessly "win" the case, after about 2 years of manufactured stress, you'll be down $100-150k.

That's what it costs to prove you are innocent and walk away "free" (free to be sued again).

Btw, in civil cases, if you cannot afford a lawyer, the system won't appoint one for you, you will have to defend yourself (which judges and lawyers hate, and will very much play against you in court).

Also, even if you can represent yourself, the court fees won't necessarily be waived ($2-3k), and you'll have to fund your own discovery (which can be insanely expensive, depending on the case).

Then if you are defending as a corporation (llc, c corp, etc), you must have a lawyer. So basically if someone knows that your company cannot afford to hire a lawyer, they can sue you and force you to pay up or go bankrupt - then during bankruptcy they can keep going after you personally, and even after bankruptcy they can sue you again.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by indymike on Saturday March 07, 2020 @11:49AM (#22512493)
In civil cases this is used as leverage by wealthy people. The wealthy can sustain a legal battle for as long as they want. They know that if their opponent isn't as wealthy, they'll be forced to settle, even for an unreasonable amount, just because they won't be able to afford defending themselves properly.

Hmm. Every civil case I've been involved with was decided not by relative wealth, but by the strength of the case. In every case, the less wealthy party won, and the wealthy party got stuck with legal fees. In many cases, the less wealthy person was represented by a lawyer who was paid mostly on contingency.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by ta1234567890 on Saturday March 07, 2020 @12:43PM (#22512841)
If both parties have enough money to litigate, the relative wealth might not matter as much.

But if one of the parties cannot afford to litigate, they are screwed.

Considering that 40% of Americans can't even afford a $400 unexpected expense[0], it means most people are extremely vulnerable to legal liability, as they would barely be able to afford maybe 1 hour of consulting with a lawyer.

My guess is that you've mostly dealt with people and companies that had the money to go through the legal system. Most people don't.

Also, in my experience, it is very (extremely?) rare to find a lawyer that will work on a contingency basis, especially on short notice. So unless you know it's coming, and you've already spent the time to interview a bunch of lawyers (most of which are not even going to give you the time of day without having an open case) ahead of time, then you'll most likely be out of luck when you get served and have 30 days to respond (and if you don't respond they get a default judgement against you).

You just can't deny that the (American) legal system is, in practice, based on money and resources, rather than on justice and fairness.

0: https://abcnews.go.com/US/10-americans-struggle-cover-400-em...

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by perl4ever on Saturday March 07, 2020 @09:30PM (#22515929)
"Considering that 40% of Americans can't even afford a $400 unexpected expense"

That's based on the idea that people who put a random $400 expense on a credit card that they pay off next month "can't afford" it.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by indymike on Saturday March 07, 2020 @01:22PM (#22513077)
Stereotypes are horrible and often used as an substitute for reason. Lawyers will take a solid case on contingency especially against "deep pockets". People have families and friends. People can change their spending habits. Courts exist to bring disputes to a just resolution. The whole meme that justice is only for the rich and average people can't fend for themselves is intellectually lazy and relies on generalization.
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by ta1234567890 on Saturday March 07, 2020 @01:48PM (#22513243)
Well, my personal experience is in direct opposition to what you are exposing here.

I've been dealing with a vindictive plaintiff for a few years now.

No lawyer will take a case on a contingency basis, especially against a plaintiff with "deep pockets", if there's no money to be made (which is usually the case when you are on the defending side).

Let me illustrate, let's say a company gets a loan from a creditor, then the company fails to pay, the creditor sues, the company doesn't have the money to pay.

At this point lawyers see that there's no money to be made and will rarely touch the case. The defendant is out of luck and will most likely have to file for bankruptcy (which at the minimum will cost $10-15k in legal fees, so it might not even be an option).

As long as the creditor wants to keep spending money, they can keep going after the company, its founders and directors. Most lawyers will say that it doesn't make sense because the creditor is very unlikely to recover anything. But if the creditor still wants to spend the money, the defendants will be forced to keep paying to defend themselves for as long as the creditor attacks them, even if they didn't do anything wrong or ilegal and they prevail in the end.

So most lawyers will recommend to settle and pay the creditor, because you'll have to spend about $100k defending yourself anyway, hence you might as well pay that in a settlement and not go through trial. Lawyers will also note that 90%+ of cases settle. In the end the company officials/founders might unfairly pay a bunch of money to someone, just so they can get rid of them.

Then, even after the defendants pay, everyone might have lost a bunch of money and not found any justice whatsoever.

Now, regardless of the example above. It costs about $5k to file a lawsuit and about $50-150k to go through with it. How many people have the means to pay for that? I'd say very few.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by perl4ever on Saturday March 07, 2020 @09:26PM (#22515903)
People can be awful, I learned that at my first customer service job.

However, from 40,000 feet, one might listen to your story and think, ok, you took money from someone and didn't give it back, and now you're being inconvenienced and harassed, and this is supposed to be a major societal problem? What about people that get sent to prison for stealing the same or less money? Or a candy bar?

To be sure, I can imagine being in the same place, and I can imagine dealing with a crazy/obsessive litigant and being very unhappy about it. But if it were me, I wouldn't expect people to sympathize or agree that it's a problem with society.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by ta1234567890 on Sunday March 08, 2020 @12:59AM (#22516577)
The problem with society is not that people can be sued for a loan.

The problem with the legal system is that if you get sued, for pretty much anything, you'll need to spend several thousands of dollars, regardless if you are actually liable or not.

And if you want to sue someone, it will cost you several thousand too.

40% of people in the US cannot afford a $400 unexpected expense. That means that a huge portion of the population, is extremely susceptible to any legal issues, as they won't be able to properly use the legal system to fairly represent them and seek proper justice/relief. Ie. If those people get sued, they'll most likely not be able to afford defending the lawsuit - or if someone did something to them, they won't have the money to sue them.

A proper legal system should not discriminate by level of wealth and should represent everyone equally.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by perl4ever on Monday March 09, 2020 @06:20PM (#22530515)
"40% of people in the US cannot afford a $400 unexpected expense"

It's my understanding that is a bullshit statistic as I said in another comment. I can't afford an unexpected expense of $400 right now, in the sense that if I really have to pay that bill immediately, I'm going to put it on a credit card. That doesn't make me financially strained.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by gamblor956 on Saturday March 07, 2020 @12:16PM (#22512663)
This is literally the exact opposite of my past experience as a trial lawyer.

The strength of the parties cases matters 10000x more than the amount of money they had. In fact, excessive spending was usually associated with worsened outcomes for the spending party.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by ta1234567890 on Saturday March 07, 2020 @12:37PM (#22512807)
You are right, if the defending party has enough money to defend, then the case will mostly be decided on the abilities/experience of the lawyers and the merits of each side.

But what happens when the defendant just simply doesn't have the money to defend themselves in court?

Have you represented a client in court for free for 2 years and paid for their court fees and discovery?

You've also probably dealt mostly with relatively rational people in good faith. But when you have someone who's very vindictive or irrational, acting in bad faith and with a lot of money, it can be terrifying to be on the receiving end, and you can feel absolutely hopeless if you don't have the knowledge or money to defend.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by imtringued on Sunday March 08, 2020 @02:05PM (#22519497)
That's an interesting argument. In the "loser pays" system lawyers are encouraged to take on cases even if the defendant can't afford the legal fees. From the perspective of a lawyer an innocent defendant is basically a cash cow.
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by srtjstjsj on Saturday March 07, 2020 @10:41PM (#22516207)
Can you share your data? Are you sure of the direction of causality, unbiased conditioning, and magnitude of impact? If I were really wrong, I'd want to spend a lot of money so soften my outcomes, even if the result is still worse than if I weren't wrong. You need to condition on guilt before comparing outcomes.
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by gamblor956 on Sunday March 08, 2020 @06:26PM (#22521055)
My data is actual real world experience.

There are studies out there confirming my experience but as I don't currently have access to a law library you'll have to look them up on your own.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by barrkel on Saturday March 07, 2020 @10:38AM (#22512052)
There's also the fact that the courts are driven by narratives; the prosecution just needs a credible story to tell, and doesn't have much of an incentive to find out the truth - it's up to the defense to tell the counter-narrative.

Over time, as more tools become available to find people with precise overlaps with a crime, the stronger the narrative is for innocent people (as well as the guilty). IMO a more inquisitorial approach which tests the counterfactual of each evidentiary point rather than relying solely on defense ought to hold up better in the future.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by hedora on Saturday March 07, 2020 @11:28AM (#22512380)
I doubt better surveillance tools will lead to more accurate prosecutions unless individuals also have direct access to the tools.

Police and prosecutors in the US are notorious for leaving out evidence that exonerates the accused, even though they are supposedly required to provide the defense with all evidence relevant to the case.

Also, well-connected victims’ cases are investigated much more carefully than normal victims.

For instance, some SFO luggage handlers were stealing stuff from bags. People repeatedly reported them to the police, but nothing happened until they stole from a retired cop. An investigation was launched and they were arrested the next week.

Similarly (based on personal experience with multiple incidents in multiple cities with multiple victims), they normally won’t bother to pull location database records for successful burglaries, even if they have exact timestamps of the incident (up to and including video), even in remote areas in the middle of the night involving literal truckloads of loot (where the location records would be a slam dunk, and the evidence would take a while to dispose of).

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by ta1234567890 on Saturday March 07, 2020 @02:13PM (#22513388)
It also happens with taxes.

Tax agencies target people and companies that don't have the means to defend themselves, because then they can collect on them. Whereas they usually stay away from wealthy/legally savvy individuals/companies, because the cost/benefit of going after them is not worth it.

A few years ago there was a big push in California to go after food trucks. They were the perfect target, small businesses run by individuals or families with few resources or legal sophistication. At some point the media got involved, as well as some advocacy groups. The issue ended with the BOE (California's tax agency), changing the way food trucks had to calculate, report and collect their sales tax. However, many non-wealthy food truck owners ended up with very unfair personal tax liabilities in the thousands of dollars, which they might still be paying today.

I was involved in defending one of these food trucks and putting together their case. They were being assed $60k in taxes and being proposed a payment plan that would have meant them paying a total of around $100k over the course of 10 years. In the end the liability was reassessed to $0. At the beginning of the dispute, every accountant and tax lawyer consulted said the tax liability was unavoidable. Tax agencies are scary.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by pragmaticalien8 on Saturday March 07, 2020 @11:04AM (#22512200)
I would also add: Immediate judgement by people online who read headlines and make up their minds. The media will never report on dropped charges as much as they do an arrest. Stigma will live on via Google search forever, because you know "Free speech" and all.
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by HarryHirsch on Saturday March 07, 2020 @11:23AM (#22512342)
The media will never report on dropped charges as much as they do an arrest.

They will do that from time to time, if you are wealthy and well-connected enough. We had a case like that at my institution, an attempted rape. Don't rely on the government for protection, arm up.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by EarthIsHome on Saturday March 07, 2020 @10:17AM (#22511909)
It's because our justice system is an instrument of the wealthy. It works for them with little friction, and it doesn't work for most people without disrupting our lives, or even ruining them (e.g. bails and bonds that most people can't afford to pay).
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by flyGuyOnTheSly on Saturday March 07, 2020 @10:56AM (#22512162)
>The whole situation is asymmetric given that investigators, courts, and prosecution don't have to spend personal funds to conduct investigations and try people in court.

It's worse than that.

Litigation is literally what puts bread on their tables.

They are rewarded financially for inconveniencing the layperson and making them jump through the hoops they have built.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by syshum on Saturday March 07, 2020 @09:47PM (#22516000)
One of the ways people have tried to solve this is with legislation that requires the public defenders office to be funded at the same level as the Prosecutors office.

it will not eliminate the inequality, for sure, but it would be a step in the right direction and in some area's the public defenders get less than a dime for ever dollar the Prosecutors office receives in public funding

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by fluidcruft on Saturday March 07, 2020 @12:00PM (#22512556)
If companies want to collect and amass surveillance data for profit, they should be the ones providing compensation for abuses their data hording enables.
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by HenryBemis on Saturday March 07, 2020 @04:06PM (#22514056)
> don't have to spend personal funds

No, they spend taxpayers funds!

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by billfruit on Saturday March 07, 2020 @11:16AM (#22512302)
May be some kind of insurance product to protect and cover costs in such no-fault cases should cover it.
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by jeffdavis on Saturday March 07, 2020 @10:51AM (#22512135)
In theory, this is why there are stages with increasingly-high standards. Hearings, grand juries, etc.

In practice it doesn't always hold up very well.

Do you have an alternative suggestion? Would the government always pay for the entire defense? Or reimburse if the accused is acquitted?

This is also why gun violence restraining orders are bad. Large costs to the defendent with no standards or hearing or even an accusation of a crime.

Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by runarberg on Saturday March 07, 2020 @11:23AM (#22512343)
In most democracies if you loose a court case you have to pay all the legal fees, plus damages and reimbursements to the other party. This holds true in criminal or personal cases, and even when the loosing party is the government or the police.
Re:Google tracking a bike ride past a burglarized home made ... by luckylion on Saturday March 07, 2020 @01:50PM (#22513254)
> you have to pay all the legal fees

"Reasonable fees". If You sue me, I win and my lawyer sends me a bill for a billion euros that I pass on to you, no judge will consider that valid.

As for damages and reimbursements: hardly. If you arrest a highly paid consultant and keep him in jail during his trial, he's not getting paid his hourly fee * 24 * days in jail.