News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Climate Change Did Influence Australia’s Unprecedented Bu... by jamil7 on Thursday March 05, 2020 @06:55AM (#22492799)
Australians have continuously voted for parties who have a track record of either dismissing or doing nothing about climate change. The currently elected party in particular. It's extremely sad to watch all this unfold in my home country from abroad but at the same time I'm not sure how you can argue with what the general public are voting for.
Re:Climate Change Did Influence Australia’s Unprecedented Bu... by perfunctory on Thursday March 05, 2020 @06:59AM (#22492826)
> I'm not sure how you can argue with what the general public are voting for.

You can absolutely argue against the general public. General public once voted for the segregation law.

Re:Climate Change Did Influence Australia’s Unprecedented Bu... by jamil7 on Thursday March 05, 2020 @07:02AM (#22492840)
Good point
Re:Climate Change Did Influence Australia’s Unprecedented Bu... by adrianN on Thursday March 05, 2020 @07:02AM (#22492839)
The general public votes for anyone supported by the press. Thank Murdoch for the past few governments.
Re:Climate Change Did Influence Australia’s Unprecedented Bu... by SiempreViernes on Thursday March 05, 2020 @07:27AM (#22492963)
The connection is not that direct, the media is influential but not the primary factor. Advertising isn't magic after all.
Re:Climate Change Did Influence Australia’s Unprecedented Bu... by tialaramex on Thursday March 05, 2020 @07:44AM (#22493044)
The Americans are currently getting a worked example of how a billionaire spending their money on advertising can ensure voters know who they are but those voters might still say "Oh that guy, he's fucking awful, No".
Re:Climate Change Did Influence Australia’s Unprecedented Bu... by JauntyHatAngle on Thursday March 05, 2020 @06:32PM (#22499555)
That is a different example though. Bloomberg is spending money on himself and is an obvious outlier.

The media/coorps in most cases of lobbying/bias are not batting for themselves directly, they're batting for their own interests in (somewhat) more subtle ways and/or supporting a candidate who aligns with their own interests.

Murdoch in Australia owns 70% of the press, and in a mostly ignorant society, that leads to the narrative being highly skewed for many decades.

Re:Climate Change Did Influence Australia’s Unprecedented Bu... by JauntyHatAngle on Thursday March 05, 2020 @07:06AM (#22492858)
Popular opinion held by non-experts on topics where objective fact from experts exists, is the way to argue it.

Also, statistically Australians believe in climate change. They're just not voting on that issue in elections over others.

I could go into media bias/propaganda in Australia, but that is off topic, but the pertinent part is that Australians are (in my opinion) ill informed on many subjects, especially ones where experts should be listened to, and not media mouthpieces.

Re:Climate Change Did Influence Australia’s Unprecedented Bu... by patrickaljord on Thursday March 05, 2020 @07:04AM (#22492850)
There is nothing Australia could have done on its own to curb climate change. Even if we removed every single human and factory from the country it wouldn't have influenced climate change one bit. Now I know "we need to start somewhere", but this somewhere needs to be the biggest polluters not Australia. The best thing Australia could have done is to decrease their consumptions of goods manufactured by these big polluters by imposing heavy tariffs maybe, although this could have triggered a local industry to build this tariffed stuff which could have only been stopped by imposing very heavy taxation on those local industries, I don't think any politicians would like to commit political suicide though.
Re:Climate Change Did Influence Australia’s Unprecedented Bu... by rypskar on Thursday March 05, 2020 @07:14AM (#22492900)
This is only a variant of the old "that big group of peoples are much larger than our group, so they need to change first". The others are always larger, so easy to accuse. Total for a country is maybe not the best metric to use. Per person emissions shows much more than total for a group of peoples called a country. Of course the largest polluter both by country and per person need to change the most, but the total pollution is the total of what you, me, and everyone else pollute
Re:Climate Change Did Influence Australia’s Unprecedented Bu... by reitzensteinm on Thursday March 05, 2020 @07:29AM (#22492974)
Yes, and it's scary how often this broken thinking pops up here.

Here's a quick quiz: China decides to split in two. Can each half now by rights pollute twice as much as it was before? Does the EU count as one large mega polluter or a bunch of small conscientious countries? Should we cap an Indian's emissions at 1/50th of those of an Australian, or use their economic development as an excuse to do whatever we want?

The planet doesn't care about whatever imaginary lines we draw on a map. Per capita is all that matters and Australia is doing very poorly.

Re:Climate Change Did Influence Australia’s Unprecedented Bu... by simonh on Thursday March 05, 2020 @07:23AM (#22492938)
Every country has to pull their weight. All of them. No excuses.

You're probably right that events like this weren't avoidable even if drastic measures had been taken a decade ago. Maybe the effects could have been reduced, or the likelihood minimised but not eliminated. That doesn't matter though. What matters is what we do now, that we and politicians take this issue seriously and do what we can to address it.

Re:Climate Change Did Influence Australia’s Unprecedented Bu... by imtringued on Thursday March 05, 2020 @07:26AM (#22492961)
Everyone says that, even the Americans who are second place. If the Chinese had a scapegoat they would blame someone else too.
Re:Climate Change Did Influence Australia’s Unprecedented Bu... by jamil7 on Thursday March 05, 2020 @07:09AM (#22492878)
I agree Australia could not have prevented it on their own but given a clear, devestating example of the possible effects of climate change both parties shrug it off.
Re:Climate Change Did Influence Australia’s Unprecedented Bu... by tomlock on Thursday March 05, 2020 @07:08AM (#22492870)
Australia is the largest coal exporter in the world.
Re:Climate Change Did Influence Australia’s Unprecedented Bu... by tomhoward on Thursday March 05, 2020 @08:38AM (#22493383)
...to countries [1] who need it for their societies and economies to function and grow.

Is the argument that the noble thing to do would be to refuse to sell the coal, and force these countries to use more expensive forms of energy, regardless of whether it keeps more of their people in poverty for longer?

It's an easy thing to say for those of us already living in first world countries with access to all the modern comforts.

And sure, Japan and Korea are not poor countries, but they are populous, resource-poor countries with huge manufacturing industries (producing some of the world's most fuel-efficient cars, no less), so they have to import their energy from somewhere.

[1] Major importers of Australian metallurgical coal are India, Japan and China. Major importers of Australian thermal coal are Japan, China, South Korea and Taiwan https://www.ga.gov.au/scientific-topics/minerals/mineral-res...

Re:Climate Change Did Influence Australia’s Unprecedented Bu... by tomlock on Thursday March 05, 2020 @09:01AM (#22493523)
If you excluded metallurgical coal from our exports, we'd still be the largest exporter of coal in the world.
Re:Climate Change Did Influence Australia’s Unprecedented Bu... by tomhoward on Thursday March 05, 2020 @09:17AM (#22493640)
How is that a refutation of anything I wrote?

The coal is still important for the economic wellbeing and personal welfare of the people in those countries, whether it's used for power generation or materials production.

Re:Climate Change Did Influence Australia’s Unprecedented Bu... by tomlock on Thursday March 05, 2020 @11:41AM (#22495170)
Keeping global warming under control is important for the economic wellbeing and personal welfare of the people in those countries.
Re:Climate Change Did Influence Australia’s Unprecedented Bu... by tomhoward on Friday March 06, 2020 @03:10AM (#22501812)
Notice how easy and noble-seeming it is to say that, compared to saying "I believe we should force more people in developing countries to stay in poverty for longer", even though they amount to the same thing?

Please understand, I'm with you that climate change is important to mitigate; I lived through the bushfires and smoke haze this Australian summer, and I worry about the prospect of that being a more normal part of our future.

I'm also expecting a child and have concerns for their future, as well the broader effects of climate change and environmental damage on humanity and nature everywhere.

But I know that it will take more than scapegoating Australian politicians (funny how it's the conservative politicians that get attacked over this, even though their coal export policies aren't substantially different from Labor's) to fix the problem, when the whole reason for the demand for coal is that people in the developing world just want, quite reasonably, a standard of living approaching what we in the west take for granted.

If these discussions involved sensible ideas about how developing countries could modernise their economies without fossil fuels, or acknowledged that large-scale carbon capture will have to be part of a comprehensive climate change solution, then I might be able to start taking them seriously.

But I guess that kind of discussion doesn't deliver the quick hit of sanctimony that so many people seem to crave.

Re:Climate Change Did Influence Australia’s Unprecedented Bu... by tomlock on Friday March 06, 2020 @04:51AM (#22502305)
We can alleviate poverty without coal.
Re:Climate Change Did Influence Australia’s Unprecedented Bu... by tomhoward on Friday March 06, 2020 @08:21AM (#22503307)
I want to believe that too! And I'd be delighted to see evidence that it's possible and details of how it can happen.

These one-line drive-by assertions without any details don't inspire confidence.

Re:Climate Change Did Influence Australia’s Unprecedented Bu... by tomlock on Friday March 06, 2020 @09:24AM (#22503759)
There's no evidence to suggest that we can't alleviate poverty without coal. We can alleviate poverty any number of ways. Your hyperbolic and emotional assertions about the need for Australia to continue selling coal don't inspire confidence.
Re:Climate Change Did Influence Australia’s Unprecedented Bu... by tomhoward on Friday March 06, 2020 @07:48PM (#22508848)
This gambit of replying with a flipped-around copy of the parent comment might feel clever but just indicates that you’re more interested in cheap point-scoring than earnestly confronting the entirety of the topic. Hacker News is not the place for crappy discourse like that.

There is ample evidence that it can’t be done yet, given that governments and private companies addressing the biggest populations/markets in the world have had many years and every incentive to do it but so far have been unable to. Despite huge investments in renewables, nuclear and gas, they still need lots of coal for the foreseeable future.

Here's a 2015 article from MIT Technology Review that explores the issue in depth: http://archive.is/SXXHl

Re:Climate Change Did Influence Australia’s Unprecedented Bu... by tomlock on Saturday March 07, 2020 @02:58AM (#22510462)
Across the world, the percentage of fossil fuels used to generate power is dropping. This trend seems likely to continue, and Australians can accelerate it with our economic power. Coal is not required to alleviate poverty. Saying coal is required to alleviate poverty is a hyberbolic and emotional statement.
Re:Climate Change Did Influence Australia’s Unprecedented Bu... by tomhoward on Sunday March 08, 2020 @11:10PM (#22522650)
I’ve shared, without emotion, evidence and analysis of the topic, and you keep replying with what you wish to be true but with no backing data.

The countries that are moving away from coal are replacing it with natural gas, nuclear or imported energy/materials. Renewables in some cases but only where the country is endowed with natural energy resources and/or is already rich enough to do so. There are valid reasons why this is not immediately possible for India and China if they are to continue developing.

All of this would easy for you to find out if you cared to properly understand it and engage in constructive discussion.

Re:Climate Change Did Influence Australia’s Unprecedented Bu... by tomlock on Monday March 09, 2020 @03:56PM (#22529114)
> The countries that are moving away from coal are replacing it with natural gas, nuclear or imported energy/materials. Renewables in some cases but only where the country is endowed with natural energy resources and/or is already rich enough to do so. There are valid reasons why this is not immediately possible for India and China if they are to continue developing.

Incorrect. This isn't even true if you're talking about Australian states, let alone countries.

Re:Climate Change Did Influence Australia’s Unprecedented Bu... by tomhoward on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @12:09AM (#22532652)
Sure, let's look at Australian states then.

South Australia uses just over 50% renewables [1], thanks to being endowed with natural solar, wind and geothermal resources, but still operates 15 natural gas power stations [2] - exactly as I said in the part of my comment that you chose to quote.

Tasmania uses 93% renewables [1] thanks to being endowed with natural hydro and wind resources, but still runs three natural gas power plants [3] - exactly as I said in the part of my comment that you chose to quote.

Both states are in a first-world, already-rich and already-developed country, also as per the part of my comment you quoted. And they both have tiny populations.

These conditions obviously don't apply throughout India and China. Yes they both use plenty of renewables and continue to expand their renewables investments. And they both use some natural gas but can't use much as they don't have large local gas reserves [4] (particularly relative to their population sizes), and it's costly to ship/pipe in. So, coal it is, however much you and I might wish it to be different.

If you have any independent evidence to demonstrate otherwise, I'm keen to learn, so I encourage you to share it.

[1] https://www.climatecouncil.org.au/south-australia-hits-50-as...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_power_stations_in_Sout...

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_power_stations_in_Tasm...

[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_natural_g...

Re:Climate Change Did Influence Australia’s Unprecedented Bu... by tomlock on Tuesday March 10, 2020 @01:55AM (#22533116)
Every country is endowed with enough natural renewable resources to service their own needs.