There are more perverse options with housing, childcare and income benefits being removed which I believe can lead to a negative income.
In the US the Benefit Cliff is real:
"There is this issue of the benefits cliffs, where some programs are designed so just a very marginal increase in earnings can result in a loss of a very important benefit. And a lot of states, unfortunately, have structured their childcare subsidies programs that way," explains Skinner.
"Typically, pay rises, income rises, but at some point you lose eligibility for a subsidies all together and it's an abrupt reduction in that family's resources," Skinner says.
https://www.theguardian.com/money/2014/jul/20/benefits-cliff...
Strangely, a lot of people don't understand this at all.
Why it comes up in these discussions as something meaningful always confuses me. To me its akin to explaining to someone that squirrels are not harmful to humans and we should not walk around terrified of them and having someone come by and say "but actually, they could have rabies...." I mean, you aren't wrong, but you are essentially spreading misinformation by implying that this is common instead of exceedingly rare and something people should be wary of as they walk down the street every day. Its the exact type of misinformation that politicians use to make disingenuous arguments to steer people into supporting their policies, and the HN crowd should be above that IMHO.
The OP was describing the same thing as you. People don't understand marginal tax brackets and do silly things like not want raises for tax reasons.
It's in Dutch, but the most important columns are the first (gross income), the second to last (net income, including benefits) and the last (effective tax rate on the 1000 gross income increase).
Note the last column tells us that making 1000 gross extra will increase your net income about 100 between 32K and 31K gross income. Going from 31K to 32K will even make you lose money.
It's never disadvantageous except when it is? That sound like the classic anchorman citation: 60% of the time, it works every time
Sure your tax bracket won't directly means less returns, but switching from a tax bracket to another may means having access to less benefits, which may means a higher effective tax rates.
> It's never disadvantageous to make more money (except if you're on government benefits as mentioned, where there are some weird effects).
is essentially equivalent to:
> If you're not on government benefits, where there are some weird effects, then it is never disadvantageous to make more money.
But if the wording was done the second way, you probably wouldn't have had a problem with it.
This is why I would have less problem with the second one. I would still precise that some of theses benefits aren't really a choice, they are tax break that just happens to be offered because of your income, so sure if you already went beyond that income, you aren't on that government benefit... but at one point you weren't beyond that income and you did made less money once you went beyond.
These are different phenomena, generally affecting different people. While (a hypothetical I) could certainly lose out his social security medicaid by going from $0 income to non-0$ income, I'm not the person worried about going from the <80k$ bracket to the >80k$ bracket.
IME, the people who worry about making more money and moving into a new tax bracket are not people who are eligible for any meaningful subsidies to begin with.
Most important part of that picture: "The single mom is better off earning gross income of $29,000 with $57,327 in net income & benefits than to earn gross income of $69,000 with net income & benefits of $57,045."
I considered going into financial advisement once, in the distant past. A family friend was in the field, and took me in for a round of advice. He was quite open that it was eat-what-you-kill, with a serious focus on people with impaired judgement (e.g., elderly), because that was the only way to make up the bulk of your revenue. He said that he hadn't had a peaceful night's sleep since he'd started, due to the guilt of day-to-day work.
(Although, admittedly, mutual fund MERs have dropped substantially with the rise of low-cost ETFs...)
If you want to give it another shot, this article and video from Vox is pretty good:
* https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2019/1/7/18171975/ta...
is that not a real thing where you live?
It's actually terrifying to me how little understanding the average person has of finance.
TFSAs can be created to hold ETFs, Mutual Funds and other types of investments. I can contribute $6k for 2020, and the total I can hold in TFSA is $69,500. I can contribute more annually as long as my total is under $69.5k.
With a raise, I can accelerate my contributions and continue to enjoy tax-free gains on it. My personal average income tax rate might go up, but that's offset to an extent by whatever returns I'm making through my portfolio.
> I can contribute $6k for 2020, and the total I can hold in TFSA is $69,500
As of 2020, the total you can contribute into a TFSA over your lifetime is $69500. But it's not a limit of what can exist in your account. Gains you make in the account do not count toward your limit.
It has absolutely nothing to do with your contribution to retirement accounts. You can invest more and contribute more to your tax free retirement accounts with a higher salary (up to a point) but even if you didn't, that wouldn't make a difference.
I'm responding with respect to the OP's comment about beign bumped into a higher marginal tax bracket. Just because you are, doesn't mean you'll automatically end up with less discretionary income.
Candidate X wants to tax you 60%!
https://twitter.com/charliekirk11/status/1231005642413858816
"Facts:
Bernie wants a $15 minimum wage
That would mean a gross salary of $31,200 for a 40 hr. work week
But he wants to tax anyone making above $29,000 a year 52%
That would make gross salary $14,976—$288/week
$288 divided by a 40 hour work week—$7.20/hour
Socialism Sucks."
I have a couple friends right now that do not want wage raises because "it will knock them into the next tax bracket". Believe me, I've tried to explain how the simple concept of income and taxes work.
I trusted my financial advisor years ago when I started my career. It took me a couple years to realize I was the product, not his client with his best interest in mind. Strangers, especially from more disciplined subs and without skin in the (your own) game, have been more valuable many, many times over.
Everyone who takes what is said literally and in verbatim would be a fool. Validate what is said as it applies within your own context.