News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance by billjings on Monday February 21, 2011 @06:37PM (#2247833)
We are way, way above the amount of money health care should cost.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:International_Comparison_-...

So as a matter of priority versus other spending outlays, we're way out of line.

Here's per capita GDP: http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=per+capita+GDP

Spitballing from these numbers, it looks like we spend about as much in absolute terms as Switzerland, with everyone else way, way far behind.

Here's another interesting graph, since I seem to be on a roll here:

http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/02/16/medicare-and-med...

The degree to which our government is in the red is in no small part a result of the degree to which we're invested in the health care money pit.

The amount of money that is going to health care should blow your mind. People go bankrupt every day due to health care expenses, and even if you don't go bankrupt your tax dollars are supporting this nonsense.

I was talking to a gentleman the other day who works for a medical hardware company. He said they had a radiation treatment device that costs one hundred million dollars. A tenth of a billion dollars for one machine! "Jeez," I said, "How long does it take to pay off such a thing?"

About a year.

There is, of course, a debate on how to fix health care. Is there really a debate on whether it's broken?

Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance by Groxx on Monday February 21, 2011 @06:44PM (#2247863)
Nope, I'm pretty sure everyone agrees it's broken. And just to re-clarify: I'm not claiming we're not paying too much. I agree with everything you've said. Just that $50-100/month is un-doably low regardless of brokenness.

I'll be reading through the links, I can always use more detailed info for future debates. Thanks!

edit for repliers: before stating that location X has 100 or less per month, how much do your taxes cost for this? That counts too, ya know.

Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance by cwp on Monday February 21, 2011 @07:08PM (#2247936)
No, it's not. I pay $120/month for a family of three, and get pretty good care for it.

I know that smug Canadians are a cliche in any discussion of health care, but we are an existence proof that acabal's expectations are totally reasonable.

Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance by Groxx on Monday February 21, 2011 @07:28PM (#2248012)
How much of that is subsidized by your taxes? That counts towards the final cost. Spreading it out doesn't make it less real.

edit: answered for you:

>In 2009, the government funded about 70% of Canadians' health care costs.

>Per capita expenditure in 2009: 3,895

$227 per month, per person, comes from the government, which gets its funding from your taxes. So you're paying $801/month for that plan (three people). Significantly less than many Americans, there's no debating that, but $120/month isn't anywhere near correct.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_care_in_Canada

Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance by billjings on Monday February 21, 2011 @08:35PM (#2248211)
Two points - one, is that odds are he's not paying $807/mo out of his taxes due to a progressive income tax. He's probably paying a good portion out of his taxes, but not $807/mo.

Point two - and this isn't a rebuttal of any kind against your claims, just an observation - that same graph shows that Canada spends a lower portion of government revenue on health care than we do. And we don't even have universal coverage!

Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance by Vivtek on Monday February 21, 2011 @08:54PM (#2248282)
The takeaway - you're actually paying for what should be your healthcare in your taxes as an American, but you're not actually getting the healthcare, because that would be socialism.
Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance by Groxx on Monday February 21, 2011 @09:07PM (#2248326)
>that would be socialism.

That is a massively incorrect statement, which pops up every time government-mandated healthcare debates appear, which I wish to squash ASAP: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socialism

Universal healthcare != socialism. Not even remotely. It's a political mud-slinging attempt to equate healthcare changes with the historical fear of the USSR that seems to have infected far more people than it should even have reached. Yes, fear the Reds, they'll lob bombs at you now that the cold war is over. They've just been waiting.

At the absolute closest would be if the government were to run all the healthcare directly (it's not - there are and will be many private healthcare markets), and then it would be a socialist action, not socialism (a socialist government).

To make matters worse for this use, any form of taxation can be described as a socialist action. That doesn't make any government that taxes its citizens a socialist government.

Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance by Vivtek on Monday February 21, 2011 @11:44PM (#2248780)
You've heard of irony, I take it?

Of course I don't think it's socialism - but everybody around me in Indiana damn well thinks so. Not that they know what socialism is, mind you - but they know it's really Evil, and it's something liberal people on the East Coast force down our throats in order to pay for all the welfare queens in the cities.... ah, hell, there's that pounding in my temple again.

Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance by Groxx on Monday February 21, 2011 @11:57PM (#2248814)
I catch it now. And may I say thank you? :) I've just met far too many otherwise-apparently-competent people that actually believe it. And a bajillion tea-partiers.

Thanks for the catch, everyone-else, my bad!

Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance by hoprocker on Monday February 21, 2011 @10:42PM (#2248612)
Oh yeah -- the fear-mongering against "Obamacare" has definitely pulled heavily from imagery surrounding breadlines and gulags. But I imagine vivtek's comment was a sarcastic jab at the acceptance of pouring money into the health care industry w/o getting a commensurate benefit out of it. (Correct me if I'm wrong.)
Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance by joe_the_user on Monday February 21, 2011 @10:59PM (#2248661)
I think the parent meant "pundits would say 'that would be socialism'".

I think most here know nationalize health isn't socialism.

Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance by s3graham on Monday February 21, 2011 @09:28PM (#2248407)
There is also corporate tax, and personal tax is assessed at graduated rates depending on income. If their income is low, say ~60k split between husband and wife, they would pay roughly ~0 for health care.
Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance by Groxx on Monday February 21, 2011 @09:36PM (#2248433)
Corporate taxes come out of paychecks. Unless all that is refunded if that's their income, then they're still paying something for it in addition to their direct monthly bill.

It can be carried further: money they get refunded comes out of other areas' funding, as the difference gets made up somehow. Their property taxes go up, the cost of food goes up because others are carrying a heavier burden, jobs across the board pay less / hire fewer, everything always costs something, even refunds. Less in some situations, but not zero. And we're still not reaching $50-$100.

Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance by s3graham on Monday February 21, 2011 @10:56PM (#2248655)
But by the "whole system" argument you're making, health care could easily have a negative cost.

Let's hypothesize that all the engineers working in SV get an AIDS-like illness caused by spending too much time on news.yc.

If there was a health care solution that would make sure that all the employees of Google, Intel, HP, etc. continued to function as usual by caring for those engineers, then even an extremely high up-front cost for that care would result in a net-win for the budget/economy/country.

Of course, that's silly as it won't happen to that extreme. But, I don't think the downward-spiral of more-cuts-here-and-there that you describe is the only possible outcome. A positive virtuous-cycle of increased wealth production is also possible.

Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance by wtallis on Tuesday February 22, 2011 @02:26AM (#2249118)
Before that positive outcome can have a chance of happening, we have to get rid of the obscenely expensive hopeless palliative end-of-life care (cue teabaggers screaming about "death panels"), and make basic healthcare universally available.

The only ways that increased healthcare spending can increase productivity are through effective preventive measures and corrective treatments that return the patient to sufficient health to be productive, but that's not where our super-high healthcare costs come from.

They come from the consequences of delayed care (eg. using only emergency rooms when you're uninsured, necessitating more risky treatments for more advanced problems, which means higher malpractice premiums) and from end-of-life care.

Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance by jbri on Monday February 21, 2011 @09:42PM (#2248450)
And breaking a window stimulates the economy because it means the window-fitter gets more business.
Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance by Groxx on Monday February 21, 2011 @10:32PM (#2248575)
I don't see how it's possible to have a cost of less than $50-100/month for healthcare. And all forms of cost have to be accounted for - direct + taxes being by far the easiest to measure, but when people start claiming that it "costs nothing" they're ignoring the bigger picture of the economy as a whole. Especially when $60k/year is your bottom margin - that includes a lot of people => a lot of drain on the rest if it doesn't come from them.

Nice reply, btw :)

Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance by jbri on Monday February 21, 2011 @10:39PM (#2248592)
The issue, I think, is that government spending is really in a different boat to private expenditure when it comes to the effect on the economy. Trying to model it as "you spend $X in taxes to pay for that healthcare" is a drastic oversimplification.

If you instead look at all government spending as economic stimulus, and all taxation as a factor in inflation management, you get quite a different picture.

Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance by cwp on Tuesday February 22, 2011 @03:40PM (#2251465)
So my taxes count, but acabal's don't?
Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance by nerfhammer on Monday February 21, 2011 @07:12PM (#2247948)
Check out how much private insurance costs in Australia:

http://www.privatehealth.gov.au/dynamic/healthfundlist.aspx

Most plans are around A$100/month or less

Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance by netcan on Monday February 21, 2011 @08:49PM (#2248262)
Australian private health insurance isn't necessarily a good comparison for two reasons.

First, it's a complimentary insurance meaning that it's for extras that people otherwise pay out of pocket or go without like dental, private hospital rooms, etc. It doesn't cover the really expensive unpredictable things like major surgery, cancer treatment. The basics (eg GP visits) and the big expenses are covered by medicare.

Second, it is subsidized from both ends. The insurance companies get paid by the commonwealth and the expense is mostly tax deductible.

You really can't use the cost to us as a measure of what it costs to run.

Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance by nerfhammer on Tuesday February 22, 2011 @12:39AM (#2248911)
I also looked at insurance intended for non-Australians living in Australia (not covered at all by national insurance) and found prices to be pretty much the same
Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance by netcan on Tuesday February 22, 2011 @09:31AM (#2249940)
From Wikipedia the total annual cost of medicare (the australian national insurer) is about $18.3b, $900 - $1000 per person living in Australia.

The graphs comparing total healthcare spending of various countries put Australia's at close to $3500 per capita, so medicare must only be part of the total.

There are some funds going into health in one off ways like states funding hospitals, donations, people paying above medicare rebate amounts (usually about 30% more for GPs in my experience). There's drugs, some of which are subsidized. Then of course there's private insurance which a substantial portion of people have.

I had private insurance for foreign students for a few years. From what I understood it's basically a tax administered by an insurance agency.

Basically it's complicated and subsidized in all sorts of ways. It's like that in The States too. You can't just look at a doctor's bill or insurance premium in one place and assume that it's representing cost in some meaningful way.

Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance by bodhi on Tuesday February 22, 2011 @07:10AM (#2249625)
You may or may not know, but non-Australians living in Australia are covered by Medicare (depending on your visa type), so that could explain the similar pricing.
Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance by nerfhammer on Tuesday February 22, 2011 @11:56AM (#2250444)
It's dependent on your nationality and whether your nation has a reciprocal health coverage agreement with Australia, which many EU countries do but most countries do not (including the US of course).
Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance by narcissus on Tuesday February 22, 2011 @07:39AM (#2249696)
One other interesting thing about private health insurance in Australia is that once you reach a certain income threshold, if you do not have any extra private health insurance, your income tax rate goes up a percent or two.

That wasn't intended to argue the point either way, though, I was just saying :)

Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance by Dylanlacey on Monday February 21, 2011 @07:52PM (#2248084)
Thanks, you saved me from having to do this myself.

$70, Basic hospital, extras like dental work and optical ($300 / yr... Two new pairs of glasses, effectively, or the year's supply of contact lenses), private rooms.

Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance by rhizome on Monday February 21, 2011 @09:16PM (#2248365)
It depends on whether anything is done about the racket going on between insurers, pharma, and healthcare providers. These are the people who blame each other for rising costs and likely a free market mentality is to blame. It's a circular argument in the US, which needs to be broken.
Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance by edruk01 on Monday February 21, 2011 @06:59PM (#2247913)
I'm astounded that something that expensive can find a market. Out of curiosity, do you know what it is ?
Re:Money Won’t Buy You Health Insurance by billjings on Monday February 21, 2011 @08:22PM (#2248188)
I don't know specifically, but it is a radiation device for the treatment of cancer. So my word is hearsay in this case - I'll have to get some better information for you. However, if you ran such a machine 30 times a day every day all year, $10k a pop, you'd hit $100m in a year. $10k for a treatment isn't unheard of for cancer treatment.