Have you ever read the book QED? It's Feynman's best effort to explain Quantum Electrodynamics to a layman. In the book, he takes a genuine question about the nature of things (how does light work?) and answers it by "bringing up paper and arrows!" (I encourage you to read the book to see what I mean). Feynman disliked "explaining" nature with inaccurate and irresponsible metaphors. But arrows are the way it really is!
Bringing in arrows where they don't belong, or in the magnet case "rubber bands", is cheating the asker. I'm not familiar enough with GR to know if arrows are a useful representation like they are with complex amplitudes.
On a margin note, the best book I've read about explaining modern physics to the layman is this: http://www.amazon.com/Evolution-Physics-Albert-Einstein/dp/0...
The only reasonable answer to the original question is: we don't know. The whole schizofrenic theory of something that can be waves and particles doesn't make sense right now but that's the best we can come up with. Nothing can go faster than light because our equations tell us so but we don't know the mechanisms, exactly as we don't know what is creating gravity, for instance. Physics is full of deep mysteries still.