Someone else wrote my favorite answer: "Basically, the way to think of it is not that light is the fastest thing, but rather that there is a speed, c, which the geometry of space and time demands is the fastest possible speed.
One can also work out that anything without mass must travel at this fastest possible speed c. Light is one of those things, therefore light travels at c. It's only an accident of history that we call c "the speed of light": that's the context we discovered c's existence in.
As for why it's the speed it is, well, it's the speed in our universe. It's actually much more natural to say c=1 and all speeds are then unitless numbers between 0 and 1. From this point of view c is 300 Mm/s because of how we chose to define the meter and the second." http://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/fjwkh/why_exactl...
> The meter is the length of the path travelled by light in vacuum during a time interval of 1/299 792 458 of a second.
So I guess that means a meter is 30.66331898849836976219 cesium-133 transition periods.
Hope you can help me with a couple: why is there even a limit? how do we know there is an insuperable barrier nothing can cross for sure?
We have models that describe the world very well, but those models are never the whole truth (and even it were, we couldn't be sure of it).
Special and General Relativity are experimentally very well tested, and these theories predict that a particle that has a speed < c can never acquire a speed > c. There are solutions for speeds larger than c, but those solutions are quite weird, and can't interact with "normal" particles.
But the mere scientific approach of observing facts, modeling and verifying means that one can never be sure that something can't be - only in the limits of the models can we be sure that a thing can't be.
The only reasonable answer to the original question is: we don't know. The whole schizofrenic theory of something that can be waves and particles doesn't make sense right now but that's the best we can come up with. Nothing can go faster than light because our equations tell us so but we don't know the mechanisms, exactly as we don't know what is creating gravity, for instance. Physics is full of deep mysteries still.
Have you ever read the book QED? It's Feynman's best effort to explain Quantum Electrodynamics to a layman. In the book, he takes a genuine question about the nature of things (how does light work?) and answers it by "bringing up paper and arrows!" (I encourage you to read the book to see what I mean). Feynman disliked "explaining" nature with inaccurate and irresponsible metaphors. But arrows are the way it really is!
Bringing in arrows where they don't belong, or in the magnet case "rubber bands", is cheating the asker. I'm not familiar enough with GR to know if arrows are a useful representation like they are with complex amplitudes.
On a margin note, the best book I've read about explaining modern physics to the layman is this: http://www.amazon.com/Evolution-Physics-Albert-Einstein/dp/0...
* My understanding before: light has a constant speed and nothing can exceed that speed, but up until that limit everything can travel at a variety of speeds.
* My understanding after: everything travels through space-time at a constant speed. Light is "special" only in that it travels exclusively through space and not at all through time.
C and pi are similar also: c would be different, if the universe's geometry where scaled differently, even if meters and seconds were unchanged in transition to the alternate universe (assuming one can formalize what I am saying in a sensible way). Likewise, pi (circumference divided by diameter) would take a different value (or not even be a constant) in an alternate (non-Euclidean) geometry (assuming that a circle could still be defined there, which is more obviously possible than the c/spacetime hypothetical)
> For right now, if you just believe that four-velocities can never stretch or shrink because that's just the way it is
In other words, nothing can go faster than the speed of light because that's the way it is? The author needs to explain why the magnitude of this four-velocity vector is the speed of light! I was hooked after the first few paragraphs, but then felt like it dead-ended in a circular argument.