News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Meals on food delivery apps can be 90% more than if bough... by SN76477 on Thursday February 27, 2020 @09:18AM (#22433420)
Food delivery in its current form will be short-lived.

It is a 4 party system where the company controlling the money is the only one that wins.

Restaurants are asked to pay 30% of the ticket. The customer is asked to pay more than expected for their meal, a delivery fee, and a tip. For the customer, this can be nearly double for a simple $10 lunch.

The driver that has to deliver it gets stuck with fuel, automatic, and typically much less than $15 an hour. All of this is happening while Doordash has a 10billion dollar valuation.

Re:Meals on food delivery apps can be 90% more than if bough... by vector_spaces on Thursday February 27, 2020 @09:55AM (#22433749)
I do consulting work in the grocery business and serve as a point of contact for software and tech purchasing for a handful of retailers and producers.

Uber Eats has been calling me every year to sell their platform to some of the stores I work with.

Grocery product margins are about 30 percent in the happy case (specialty foods), usually much lower. Uber Eats wants 30 percent of the basket on each sale they make.

The last salesperson who called, after I gave him that context, suggested this would be a new revenue stream. I remarked that we would lose money on each sale. He clarified that Uber Eats would only take 30 percent of what we sold through their platform, not all of the sales made by the store (how generous of them). I thanked him for clarifying and said I understood that.

He then suggested to me that customers who buy from us on Uber Eats might do so only once, and make the rest of their purchases in store.

I asked him why they would do that, and he uncomfortably said a few words about how Uber is working on something for grocery stores and said they would try back later.

They have reached out to me about once a year since 2016, and pretty much every conversation goes the same, and their pricing is the same.

It's ridiculous to me how they don't bother to understand the customers they engage, and that they train their sales people to continue goad businesses into working with them even after they've made clear they would lose money. Either way, it's very clear to me that this model is indeed going to be short lived. It depends primarily on weaknesses in labor laws and operators being swayed by their bizarre sales pitches enough to act against their own bottom line. In any case I certainly won't be sad to see it crash and burn

Re:Meals on food delivery apps can be 90% more than if bough... by AgloeDreams on Thursday February 27, 2020 @10:11AM (#22433912)
What is bizzare about all of this is that I honestly do think that when Amazon figures Drone Delivery all out they will basically eat everyone alive in the food delivery business. They totally will automate the storage and picking systems, do it in warehouses (that also do normal delivery and act as Go/ Whole Foods distribution networks) and the Drone systems will be AI piloted possibly with human oversight. (one human, 10 drones, they may also use fleets to ease air clearance)

Once they solve all of this you chop distribution to the store, shelf stocking, checkout staffing, picker payment, driver payment, property and lease fees, the margin will be higher, the experience faster, the costs lower.

I bet Amazon will mass produce the drones at a rather low cost over time, maybe produce UWB tracking devices (like Apple's Tags will use) so you can be hand delivered products without the landing pad they currently use. It's a real infinite game and that's okay if it all takes 10+ years.

I'm not saying this is a good thing for mankind, but might be a reality.

Re:Meals on food delivery apps can be 90% more than if bough... by untog on Thursday February 27, 2020 @10:27PM (#22440264)
> when Amazon figures Drone Delivery all out

This feels similar to “when self driving cars are figured out”, i.e. a much bigger ask than it would first appear.

Re:Meals on food delivery apps can be 90% more than if bough... by AgloeDreams on Monday March 02, 2020 @10:42AM (#22465297)
Maybe, I actually agree on self driving cars.

But self driving cars are WAY harder than drone delivery. You have whole human elements to them. Drone delivery is 'exit, turn, go straight, don't hit objects, find target, drop item, repeat home', whereas we have already solved 'don't hit objects.' which absolutely can't be said about self driving cars.

Re:Meals on food delivery apps can be 90% more than if bough... by Fire-Dragon-DoL on Sunday March 01, 2020 @12:06AM (#22455224)
In italy we used to joke over how people will stsrt buying rifles to shoot down drones and get the packages...
Re:Meals on food delivery apps can be 90% more than if bough... by AgloeDreams on Monday March 02, 2020 @10:39AM (#22465262)
I mean you can do the same with a postal truck if you like too. It's going to be pretty easy to prosecute when someone shoots a camera-covered, GPS and cellular connected object.
Re:Meals on food delivery apps can be 90% more than if bough... by cdelb on Thursday February 27, 2020 @12:48PM (#22435656)
If you're up for a conversation - I would love to get your thoughts on a new product we've been working on. [email protected]
Re:Meals on food delivery apps can be 90% more than if bough... by anonsivalley652 on Thursday February 27, 2020 @09:28AM (#22433515)
And it's not a defensible business model because anyone can start such a company with very little expenses.

I remember using waitersonwheels.com in the mid 90's and it wasn't any better than what's available now. Also, I know waiter.com has been around a long time and makes very good money. Perhaps the SF Bay Area is a unicorn where there are so many people with disposable income that their time is worth more than overpaying for things that it can sustain many delivery services? I don't think the business model would work in rural Michigan but it would work anywhere with high property values and/or high incomes.

Re:Meals on food delivery apps can be 90% more than if bough... by jfengel on Thursday February 27, 2020 @10:04AM (#22433850)
You can start such a company, but there's an overhead in getting on the minds of users and restaurant owners.

Users don't want to have to keep multiple apps on their phone, or remember that the local Olive Garden uses OnlineFood but that the Greek place uses FoodNGo. We can have them order through the restaurant's web site and let them make the decision, but they're going to get frustrated if the drivers are fragmented across the different services. If every driver has every app, then it's really just adding overhead.

All people and restaurants want is somebody to get the food from point A to point B, without a lot of differentiation. Much like ride share services replacing taxis: people don't really care what they get, and multiple taxi services don't provide useful differentiators. I really think that taxis might have survived better if they had come together to develop an app instead of letting somebody else take that space.

As for prices... people are willing to pay to save time. If they really wanted to save money, they'd cook. People go to restaurants so they don't have to cook, but they still pay the time to go and sit and wait. Faced with a choice of $20 Olive Garden + $20 delivery fee, and wait at home playing video games, or $40 at the steakhouse sitting at a table waiting for their food, it might be a tossup. Lots of people do that today. If all they wanted was calories, they'd spent $5 at McDs.

Re:Meals on food delivery apps can be 90% more than if bough... by matthewowen on Thursday February 27, 2020 @10:23AM (#22434023)
> they're going to get frustrated if the drivers are fragmented across the different services

Why would consumers care about this? For decades (centuries even!) restaurants managed to make delivery work with their own delivery people. And admittedly pooling delivery people is effective for restaurants that don't do a lot of delivery volume, but there's still really a lot of room for fragmentation.

> All people and restaurants want is somebody to get the food from point A to point B, without a lot of differentiation

Here's the thing though: there's a lot of differentiation! In my experience, delivery that's managed by restaurants tends to be orders of magnitude better than from the apps. The app delivery services bundle a bunch of deliveries together in such a way that your food sits around at the restaurant, then goes all over the city, then eventually reaches you an hour after it was made. This kind of thing rarely happens for me when restaurants manage delivery themselves.

> People go to restaurants so they don't have to cook, but they still pay the time to go and sit and wait

I mean... some people go to restaurants for this reason, I suppose, especially at the low-end of the market. But it's really hard for me to believe this is the primary reason people go to restaurants. If it were, you'd expect restaurants to be quite different.

Re:Meals on food delivery apps can be 90% more than if bough... by jfengel on Thursday February 27, 2020 @11:37AM (#22434796)
I was unclear: I meant that the restauranteurs would become frustrated if they had to search over multiple apps to find one with an available driver.
Re:Meals on food delivery apps can be 90% more than if bough... by fjp on Thursday February 27, 2020 @10:58AM (#22434360)
I'm mid-20s and everyone I know has like 6 food delivery apps on their phone.

I'm somewhat of minimalist with trying to keep a low number of apps on my phone but whenever I see my friends phones they have hundreds of apps

Re:Meals on food delivery apps can be 90% more than if bough... by ghaff on Thursday February 27, 2020 @09:56AM (#22433761)
In general, food delivery doesn't work well well in rural areas. Where I live is more ex-urban than rural and I'm just 40 miles from a major city and almost next door to a couple minor cities. But I have very few delivery options.

I apparently have a few more these days through a couple of the online delivery apps although I haven't used them yet.

Re:Meals on food delivery apps can be 90% more than if bough... by sjg007 on Thursday February 27, 2020 @04:23PM (#22438065)
I find pizza shows up reliably! We have 5 pizza delivery options and only 2 stop lights in town.
Re:Meals on food delivery apps can be 90% more than if bough... by tmpz22 on Thursday February 27, 2020 @10:56AM (#22434340)
As a former power user in SF I have to agree. Prices have doubled and quality has plummeted. Riders are making deliveries with other apps while they are “supposed” to be delivering mine (can’t blame them). Food is always cold and items are constantly missing. Aggressive tipping and feedback modals (especially for Postmates) are a big turn off - I always tried to tip generously in cash but they tried to force tips through the app for unscrupulous reasons.

The whole thing is just absurd. $25 for a cold $8 hamburger?

Re:Meals on food delivery apps can be 90% more than if bough... by deminature on Thursday February 27, 2020 @10:45AM (#22434239)
Suggesting this model is short-lived is ignoring history. Grubhub has been running this model in the US since 1999 (originally as Seamless in NYC) [1]. It's very unlikely that its going anywhere.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grubhub

Re:Meals on food delivery apps can be 90% more than if bough... by AlexandrB on Thursday February 27, 2020 @09:25AM (#22433493)
> Restaurants are asked to pay 30% of the ticket.

I was not aware of that. I can see the logic (“we’re providing a service for your business”, etc.) but it feels like double dipping. Especially since it seems as though that cost is passed straight onto the customer anyhow.

Re:Meals on food delivery apps can be 90% more than if bough... by gallamine on Thursday February 27, 2020 @09:53AM (#22433724)
The reasoning is that restaurants are using this money for advertising - either they pay to mail out fliers or they pay for listing in the online aggregator. It's a very similar model to paid ads in search engines.
Re:Meals on food delivery apps can be 90% more than if bough... by Jommi on Thursday February 27, 2020 @12:52PM (#22435719)
It is doubledipping. But the phrase. "your margin is my opportunity" should ring true here meaning that soon a competitor should show up that goes by list price. It already happens in Europe with the Finnish company Wolt AFAIK.
Re:Meals on food delivery apps can be 90% more than if bough... by pcurve on Thursday February 27, 2020 @09:41AM (#22433618)
Compared to South Korea, the company's take is insane. SK's minimum wage is $7+ and it's not unusual for delivery person to make $3000+/month. Customers pay reasonable fee of a few dollars and no tip.
Re:Meals on food delivery apps can be 90% more than if bough... by JCharante on Thursday February 27, 2020 @10:01AM (#22433810)
And in Vietnam, Grab drivers can make the same as young professionals, leading some to start deliverying food or chauffering people around full time after graduating from post-secondary education. (~$600/mo, less than $1/hour from working at a cafe is normal).
Re:Meals on food delivery apps can be 90% more than if bough... by bluetidepro on Thursday February 27, 2020 @10:37AM (#22434158)
I think you under estimate how many people are lazy and willing to eat all those costs to not leave their house, and have the food delivered right to their door. Even more so in big cities where most of the population doesn't have a car.
Re:Meals on food delivery apps can be 90% more than if bough... by walrus01 on Thursday February 27, 2020 @09:22AM (#22433464)
Food delivery by car should actually be way more expensive than it is, if you consider the standard IRS mileage reimbursement rate for driving.
Re:Meals on food delivery apps can be 90% more than if bough... by michaelt on Thursday February 27, 2020 @10:36AM (#22434146)
In my country, business mileage rates are based on the depreciation of a car that is quite nice, and quite new. The kind of car a professional salesperson might drive to visit clients.

For a delivery driver to show up in a BMW would be... very unusual.

Re:Meals on food delivery apps can be 90% more than if bough... by hansvm on Thursday February 27, 2020 @02:02PM (#22436575)
I delivered pizza for a couple years before getting my life together, and I can definitely confirm that vehicle costs can be much lower than the IRS standard mileage deduction. I averaged $0.16/mi in insurance, depreciation, repairs, maintenance, tires, gas, washes, and every other cost put together. You can't pull that off as an Uber driver because you need to make a good impression, but food delivery costs can be pretty low.
Re:Meals on food delivery apps can be 90% more than if bough... by morrbo on Thursday February 27, 2020 @09:33AM (#22433553)
Don't forget the "service charge" (different to a tip, akin to Ticketmaster) I've started seeing on deliveroo in the UK
Re:Meals on food delivery apps can be 90% more than if bough... by Symbiote on Thursday February 27, 2020 @10:25AM (#22434047)
Presumably that's because it's not common to tip the delivery driver in the UK -- and if there is a tip, it's a token £1 or so.
Re:Meals on food delivery apps can be 90% more than if bough... by mantap on Thursday February 27, 2020 @09:33AM (#22433554)
The business model is strong and is hugely successful in Asia. But the fees will decrease with competitive pressure.
Re:Meals on food delivery apps can be 90% more than if bough... by 9nGQluzmnq3M on Thursday February 27, 2020 @09:42AM (#22433626)
That's because food is cheap, wages are low and cities are dense enough to cover by motorbike, PMD (hoverboards etc) or even bicycle.
Re:Meals on food delivery apps can be 90% more than if bough... by mantap on Thursday February 27, 2020 @10:55PM (#22440406)
The food is cheap but not necessarily cheaper after adjusting for income because, as you said, wages are low.
Re:Meals on food delivery apps can be 90% more than if bough... by aabbcc1241 on Friday February 28, 2020 @07:59PM (#22447864)
Can we improve the situation? Well known "platform app" are evil, while non-evil alternative feel tough to reach the critical mass, because they don't have as much budget to promote.