News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitter is suspending pro-Bloomberg accounts, citing ‘pla... by nneonneo on Saturday February 22, 2020 @08:52AM (#22390997)
The more I look at platforms like Twitter and Facebook, the more I start liking the WeChat “anti-viral” timeline concept. Posts on your WeChat timeline show only likes from your friends. This applies even on posts from other people - you can only see likes on those posts from your friends, not any of that person’s friends. Boom - no more platform manipulation, since everything on your timeline is 100% driven by your friends.

Unfortunately the Chinese government can and will censor posts on these feeds, which is made super easy by how slow things usually spread on that platform - but that’s a different issue entirely. I’m not advocating literally switching to WeChat - just that the concept feels at once far more “social” and rather less prone to certain kinds of manipulation.

Re:Twitter is suspending pro-Bloomberg accounts, citing ‘pla... by geofft on Saturday February 22, 2020 @09:38AM (#22391241)
Does WeChat have an equivalent to "Trending"? Part of the strategy of campaigns like this one is to get something globally trending, and Twitter seems to like the idea of global (or even local) trends existing. It'd be interesting to have a per-user concept of "Trending," scoped to just the people you follow, but I suspect Twitter wouldn't like it because it's harder to onboard new users and get them engaged.

The other part of campaigns like this is replying to major accounts to push something, so you'd have to have your "anti-viral" timeline hide replies that weren't endorsed by people you don't follow. That is, if friend A retweeted something by a famous politician, and a thousand people replied including none of your friends, and friend B liked one of those replies, only that one reply would show up for you if you looked at the tweet. Again, I suspect this is bad for engagement (so I'm wondering if WeChat actually does this?).

Re:Twitter is suspending pro-Bloomberg accounts, citing ‘pla... by physicles on Saturday February 22, 2020 @10:58AM (#22391615)
Wechat doesn’t have trending. Trending is literally the opposite of something you want if your #1 fear is bad news about the government going viral.

The closest thing to trending is that you notice that a bunch of your friends are all posting about similar stuff. Like when Li Wenliang, the whistleblower-doctor in Wuhan, died, or when everyone bored at home in quarantine was posting photos of brooms balanced to stand on end.

Re:Twitter is suspending pro-Bloomberg accounts, citing ‘pla... by science4sail on Saturday February 22, 2020 @10:32AM (#22391475)
In my recollection, Tencent (WeChat's owner) derives a lot of their revenue from microtransactions, so engagement in the core app isn't as big a deal for them.
Re:Twitter is suspending pro-Bloomberg accounts, citing ‘pla... by Jommi on Saturday February 22, 2020 @11:35AM (#22391841)
I think it's not giving the whole picture of paint WeChat/tencent as a normal company trying to make profit. They are providing a national service, it doesn't need to be profitable.
Re:Twitter is suspending pro-Bloomberg accounts, citing ‘pla... by vtange on Saturday February 22, 2020 @11:16AM (#22391718)
This sounds like it will fall into the same "echo-chamber" problem platforms like Youtube fell into. Note that with the social-credit system, you are docked points if you are friends with the "wrong" people. Thus, you naturally friend with people with similar interests. I don't think they designed it with "anti-viral" as a motive, but instead as a way to weed out and isolate people with contrarian thoughts.
Re:Twitter is suspending pro-Bloomberg accounts, citing ‘pla... by 101404 on Saturday February 22, 2020 @11:40AM (#22391876)
When I lived in China 10+ years ago, the West would criticize the Chinese government for limiting the spread of "opinions" on social media. Today, in the West, we call that "fake news", and limit its spread too.

Give it another 10 years and, at least here in Europe, we will have the first countries copying the "social points" system China is currently rolling out.

Not sure what to do about it.

Re:Twitter is suspending pro-Bloomberg accounts, citing ‘pla... by dntbnmpls on Saturday February 22, 2020 @07:47PM (#22394362)
We, along with Europe, had "social points" system for a long time. If you smoked weed, were associated with communist/socialist circles, etc, you were or could be barred from certain jobs (public and private), banks, voting, etc. The idea that it's bad when china does it is just hypocrisy or borderline jealousy.

> Today, in the West, we call that "fake news", and limit its spread too.

We say/use "civility" or "western values" to censor, attack, etc. The chinese use "harmony", "chinese characteristics", etc to censor, attack, etc.

We shame the chinese and demand they treat muslims better while killing millions of muslims and destroying a few muslim countries. The chinese shame the west and demand we treat muslims better while interning millions of muslims.

Too bad hypocrisy isn't a currency or we'd all be rich and living large.

Re:Twitter is suspending pro-Bloomberg accounts, citing ‘pla... by shadowprofile77 on Sunday February 23, 2020 @05:34AM (#22396181)
Your false equivalence here is absurdly full of shit on both points.

The highly decentralized, mostly non-computerized western social shaming that existed for decades for certain social beliefs and practices, which to some extent still exists in certain limited contexts was in no meaningful way comparable to a systematic, almost entirely centralized government-directed formal social credit scoring system that dictates one's "worthiness" and so many aspects of their social life, economic life and literal freedom to move around based on what political opinions they publish, who they're friends with, what things they read, share on social media or even what things they buy. Comparing the two is ridiculous. It's either blatantly blind or you're trolling for some other reason. No western state has anything like this. No notable number of people in the west are literally ruined economically or banned from travel, or the victims of their friends being nudged by the government into abandoning them because they posted something against Trump, or against Obama or in any other context. Very public, very open debate and protest against numerous government policies is still very much alive and well in the west. In China this is blatantly not the case.

Re:Twitter is suspending pro-Bloomberg accounts, citing ‘pla... by dntbnmpls on Sunday February 23, 2020 @06:00PM (#22400152)
> Your false equivalence here is absurdly full of shit on both points.

Ah "false equivalence". It gets me every time because at this point it's so obvious. A talking point by people who don't know what it means.

> The highly decentralized, mostly non-computerized western social shaming that existed for decades for certain social beliefs and practices

Highly decentralized? FBI background checks are decentralized? Credit checks are highly decentralized? If you think "the west" is decentralized, you really have bought into the propaganda hard. Let me guess you think "the west" is individualistic while the east is "collectivist".

> No notable number of people in the west are literally ruined economically or banned from travel, or the victims of their friends being nudged by the government into abandoning them because they posted something against Trump, or against Obama or in any other context.

And notable number of people in china have been? Or is it just parroting propaganda you just choose to believe in.

> Comparing the two is ridiculous.

Only to people with an agenda.

> It's either blatantly blind or you're trolling for some other reason.

This is called a false dichotomy with a dash of ad hominem.

> In China this is blatantly not the case.

The hong kong protests don't happen? How come there are so many protests in china?

https://www.economist.com/china/2018/10/04/why-protests-are-...

Just because they aren't identical doesn't mean they aren't comparable. Just because one is bad doesn't mean the other is good. You can cherrypick nonsense to fit an agenda or just look at the obvious objectively.

Re:Twitter is suspending pro-Bloomberg accounts, citing ‘pla... by shadowprofile77 on Tuesday February 25, 2020 @07:31AM (#22412605)
If you can't plainly see the difference between the west's flawed but essentially democratic and mostly liberal systems of government, media rules and management of free expression (even if they sometimes veer into the authoritarian in an ad-hoc, sporadic way) and the overtly authoritarian, systematically repressive systems of social and political control that exist in the Chinese state, then there's no debating your nonsense. Spare me the claims of it all being anti-China propaganda too. The CCP is quite blatant about what it does and numerous creditable NGOs and media sources have reported on these subjects extensively.
Re:Twitter is suspending pro-Bloomberg accounts, citing ‘pla... by physicles on Saturday February 22, 2020 @11:14AM (#22391705)
I’ve been living in China for 7 years and I really like Wechat, aside from the censorship and privacy concerns aside. It’s basically WhatsApp with a dumb timeline — literally the algorithm is “show me everything my friends have posted, in chronological order”. It’s wonderful.

That’s probably possible for two reasons. First, the app’s principal designer maintains Steve Jobs-level creative control on the product. Second, as a sibling pointed out, Wechat primarily makes money from other stuff besides posts going viral﹡.

There’s not even a “repost” feature. You literally have to open the article, copy the URL, and create an entirely new post on your timeline. It cuts down on low effort sharing (of course, if you’re the government, you like this because it also slows the spread of so-called “improper information”)

Facebook died for me when it became possible for me to see Nazis arguing in the comments of an article my grandma posted. I mean what the fuck, how did we ever get there.

﹡ which unfortunately involves vacuuming up as much data about every aspect of everyone’s life as possible. It’s impossible to understate how pervasive Wechat is: if you only have this app and no other, you can still live very comfortably here.

Re:Twitter is suspending pro-Bloomberg accounts, citing ‘pla... by mensetmanusman on Saturday February 22, 2020 @01:25PM (#22392449)
Until you disagree with censors, then you are cast aside.
Re:Twitter is suspending pro-Bloomberg accounts, citing ‘pla... by chillacy on Saturday February 22, 2020 @02:14PM (#22392719)
Yes that’s the whole point as the poster pointed out. The Nazis arguing on the grandma’s post would also disagree with the censors too —it’s not a matter of censorship vs none, is a matter of what is considered worthy of censorship in China vs here.
Re:Twitter is suspending pro-Bloomberg accounts, citing ‘pla... by JD557 on Saturday February 22, 2020 @09:09AM (#22391088)
That looks like a cool model, but isn't that pretty close to what Twitter does (at least if you use TweetDeck instead of the twitter webpage/app)?

I only see:

- Things posted by who I follow

- Things retweeted by who I follow

- Things liked by who I follow (I think I don't actually see this in TweetDeck)

Re:Twitter is suspending pro-Bloomberg accounts, citing ‘pla... by bathtub365 on Saturday February 22, 2020 @09:23AM (#22391164)
It sounds like even the like count on posts is scoped to likes that come from your friends. So if a post has 1000 likes globally but was only liked by 10 of your friends the like count would be 10.
Re:Twitter is suspending pro-Bloomberg accounts, citing ‘pla... by _bxg1 on Saturday February 22, 2020 @03:30PM (#22393144)
This is why I've started using regular group chats more and more to keep in touch with people
Re:Twitter is suspending pro-Bloomberg accounts, citing ‘pla... by asdff on Saturday February 22, 2020 @01:31PM (#22392481)
Sounds like facebook before boomers joined
Re:Twitter is suspending pro-Bloomberg accounts, citing ‘pla... by chance_state on Saturday February 22, 2020 @09:58AM (#22391312)
I don't think we should extol the virtues of features that were literally designed to improve censorship.
Re:Twitter is suspending pro-Bloomberg accounts, citing ‘pla... by physicles on Saturday February 22, 2020 @11:20AM (#22391745)
That maybe have been their original purpose — who can say — but I also appreciate that this model tends to separate social from news.

I personally prefer a model that makes it impossible for me to see Nazis arguing about an article posted by my grandma.

Re:Twitter is suspending pro-Bloomberg accounts, citing ‘pla... by jamiek88 on Saturday February 22, 2020 @07:46PM (#22394353)
You know its the old boiling frog trope - until you pointed that out

> this model tends to separate social from news.

i hadn't realised how much the two had become intertwined. FB, twitter etc all started off as interacting with your friends then drifted very far from that.

They should be separate.