News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by Gustomaximus on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @07:53AM (#22364989)
I don't care how certified these planes are down the track, I never want to set foot on a 737 Max and generally any new Boeing that doesn't have a solid air history. Trust with these guys is totally blown.
Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by kitd on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @09:06AM (#22365483)
I understand the sentiment but there may well be a reporting bias going on.

Boeing are in the news anyway, which in turn makes other Boeing problems more likely to make the news, both in the number of blogs written, and the likelihood they get shared here.

Or alternatively, it really needs a report that demonstrates that eg Airbus have no similar foreign object problems for one's understanding to be more informed.

A Boeing-only story by itself is an incomplete picture.

Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by txcwpalpha on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @09:27AM (#22365648)
It’s not even just reporting bias, there are other biases involved as well. It’s entirely possible that other airplane types have high rates of FOD in the fuel tanks but they go unnoticed because those other planes aren’t under nearly as much scrutiny as the post-crash MAX.

If there’s a systemic problem that involves issues manufacturing a plane, it’s highly unlikely that it only involves one single type of plane.

Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by onion2k on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @09:53AM (#22365917)
I'd rather fly on a plane that from a manufacturer whose planes might have foreign objects in the fuel tanks than a manufacturer whose planes definitely do have foreign objects in the fuel tanks.

If there’s a systemic problem that involves issues manufacturing a plane, it’s highly unlikely that it only involves one single type of plane.

There isn't though. Evidence for that is Boeing itself - for decades they made excellent planes that had very few problems. The 747 was the safest and most popular plane in the world for years. Boeing have made more than 1000 of them and there have been very few crashes, and most of those have been pilot error or external factors.

Something at Boeing has changed, and that has made some of their newer planes less safe. That tells you nothing about other manufacturers.

Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by txcwpalpha on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @10:30AM (#22366305)
Suit yourself, but I’d rather fly on a plane that had problems found, scrutinized, and fixed rather than a plane that may or may not have problems but nobody actually knows because they weren’t pressured to look hard enough.

Re: other manufacturers, if the regulatory environment is one in which Boeing can get by with cutting corners, that means it’s an environment in which other manufacturers can cut corners as well. That, combined with the inherent characteristic of for-profit companies doing what they do, I have no reason to believe that Airbus et al are not doing the same. Hell, the first A320 was infamous for a software issue causing it to crash, too, complete with regulators and Airbus involved in controversy afterwards for trying to alter the results of the investigation.

Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by jacquesm on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @10:26AM (#22366255)
> Something at Boeing has changed

MD merger.

This is a good article with some background on why people think that may be the case:

https://qz.com/1776080/how-the-mcdonnell-douglas-boeing-merg...

Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by pintxo on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @01:43PM (#22368613)
Wow, top right of the picture, they have actually parked some planes in the parking lot (for cars).
Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by btgeekboy on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @04:33PM (#22370329)
Yes, that’s at BFI. Before production was halted, Boeing kept building planes for months and months. They’ve stuck MAXes all over the Pacific Northwest in what feels like any available space connected to a runway.
Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by sgent on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @11:58AM (#22367386)
Your correct of course. The 767 refueling plane has been on hold for almost a year since the Air Force kept finding random parts strewn all over the plane.

Many airlines will not accept the 787 built on the east coast until they are flown to Seattle to be inspected there first.

Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by hinkley on Saturday February 22, 2020 @11:53PM (#22395220)
Really saving a lot of money on those non-union jobs, huh.
Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by octodog on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @09:53AM (#22365916)
Even if this is a systemic problem is doesn't change the underlying logic involved. It's unknown whether other models have this (or similar) issues, so you are still better off avoiding the model you know has a risk/default.
Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by txcwpalpha on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @10:32AM (#22366323)
You’re missing the other half of your logic though, which is that due to knowing that this plane has an issue, you also know that the issue will be resolved, so you actually know that this plane does not have the issue. For other planes, as you said, it is unknown if they have the issue or not. I’d rather fly on the plane that I know for sure has had the issue addressed.
Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by lagadu on Sunday February 23, 2020 @08:28AM (#22396731)
But we also know that this plane was poorly designed and the design process followed a path that completely disregarded safety.

You're saying that the best way for a company to get your business is to make a deathtrap and after it kills a bunch of people they'll fix a few of the glaring problems versus just making a good plane in the first place.

Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by gentleman11 on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @01:10PM (#22368231)
So that’s the question: how unusual is this? How severe?
Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by SimplyUnknown on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @07:56AM (#22365015)
I'm totally with you, but how do you prevent it? Usually you only know what type of plane you fly with after buying tickets. A solution might be to only buy tickets from operators that don't have with 737 MAX planes but this group might be getting smaller over long time.
Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by londons_explore on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @08:21AM (#22365163)
Nearly all routes are flown with a specific type of plane always. Just use FlightRadar24 to see for that specific flight what usually does that route.

Thats only a 90% guarantee, since plane types are reshuffled during disruption sometimes.

Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by tluyben2 on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @08:49AM (#22365359)
I pick airlines that have (almost) no Boeings and that I can call before booking to see if it's an Airbus. I have done that for many years before the 737 Max issues. I simply find them annoying (very noisy) to fly with, but I definitely try to avoid. Some times I find myself in a Boeing on short flights when suddenly another airline provides the plane and it may be bad luck or damaged hearing or whatever; every flight I get into (and I fly a lot) with a Boeing, the noise is horrible.
Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by mmcconnell1618 on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @09:53AM (#22365912)
Shortly after the crash of Air France 447 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_France_Flight_447#Sidestic...) many people wouldn't fly on an Airbus plane due to perceived fly-by-wire/software issues. Boeing and Airbus are the duopoly of commercial aviation and each has had issues over the years. However, commercial aviation as a whole is an incredibly safe way to travel long distances.
Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by Reason077 on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @09:47AM (#22365849)
Have you tried noise cancelling headphones? They make a huge difference to comfort on noisy flights.
Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by tluyben2 on Saturday February 22, 2020 @05:11AM (#22390241)
I have yes and they work, however, when I fall asleep, I end up laying on them and they kind of break...
Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by avh02 on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @09:06AM (#22365478)
my experience with A350 vs 787 (both Qatar) is that the A350's are some of quietest planes I've flown.
Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by tluyben2 on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @09:10AM (#22365514)
Must be me for sure; Qatar as well; did not sleep at all as there was a high pitch whining the stewardess said ‘you get used to’; nothing at all in the 350 or 380.
Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by vrsfvwae5tbh on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @09:30AM (#22365674)
Got bumped from a A350 to a 777 for an upcoming long haul when Cathay Pacfic changed their schedules due to COVID-19. Blegh.
Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by MaupitiBlue on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @10:08AM (#22366065)
The 777 is the safest of them all, isn’t it?
Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by iso947 on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @08:27AM (#22365209)
This is an example of where “vote with your dollar” and “invisible hand of the market” falls down, and why we need strong regulations.
Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by emiliobumachar on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @08:32AM (#22365258)
Airliners are very much regulated already. If you want to set a personal standard above and beyond the regulation, there might not be a market for you. Supposing it could be worked out, do you plan to review the safety record of all your potential rides, or just go by headlines?
Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by mfer on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @08:52AM (#22365392)
The issue many people will have on hn is that the design flaws (not just software issues) have been discussed at length along with mismanagement that has shown little to no regard for design flaws. This has eroded trust in Boeings ability to make a new plane.

Time without incidents will be needed to earn many of our trusts back.

You talk of the regulation but posts on HN have shown how the regulators have failed and even why it's happened.

Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by bluGill on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @09:20AM (#22365602)
How do you know Airbus' software is better than Boeing? Maybe Boeing is overall better, but bad luck caught them? Maybe Boeing has learned a lesson and while their past software was bad they have spend the last year making significant changes and all future airplanes will be much better?
Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by jsight on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @10:17AM (#22366167)
You are getting downvoted, but your points are fair. It wasn't that long ago that people criticized Airbus for some surprisingly similar reasons.
Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by admax88q on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @10:24AM (#22366231)
Sure we can imagine a scenario where Boeing is still the best choice. But if we actually want to make the best decision possible with the information available at this point in time add probabilities to your cases.

Who is more likely to have quality control issues? The company that has had more planes crash or the company that has had fewer planes crash?

Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by cultus on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @01:36PM (#22368514)
They clearly aren't regulated sufficiently. The lack of FAA oversight is what allowed the whole 737 Max fiasco to happen in the first place.
Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by refurb on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @12:57PM (#22368081)
I think the "vote with your dollar" is already working. How many 737 MAX contracts have been cancelled?
Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by iso947 on Thursday February 20, 2020 @06:28AM (#22374311)
Cancelled because the planes aren’t available.

Meanwhile companies like IaG are buying more 737-Max, knowing full well their customers will base their purchase on the cheapest hit on skyscanner.

Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by ropiwqefjnpoa on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @08:59AM (#22365435)
Regulation can't help when management is willing to sacrifice safety for profits. Ultimately, the penalties for violating those regulations and loss of customers could kill Boeing, but lives have already been lost.
Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by MaupitiBlue on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @10:11AM (#22366105)
Except that didn’t happen with the Max. The engineers thought MCAS was safe. Nobody in management told the engineers to design MCAS do be dependent on a single sensor with no sanity check and nearly physically impossible to override.
Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by rburhum on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @08:58AM (#22365427)
when you buy a ticket from the airline, it shows you what kind of plane it is.
Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by mnm1 on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @09:36AM (#22365731)
Look it up on kayak or the airline's website if booking directly. The info is available before booking.
Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by rsynnott on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @08:39AM (#22365288)
Assuming it's a major route, there are probably carriers with Boeing-less fleets on it.
Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by HorkHunter on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @08:42AM (#22365312)
Assuming Airlines are/will be racing to operate/purchase 737 MAX?
Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by tus88 on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @08:02AM (#22365047)
Or larger.
Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by SimplyUnknown on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @08:10AM (#22365096)
Sure, but you never know which way it will go but this is assuming the 737 MAX gets recertified by the FAA and operators are going to buy them because it is cost-effective or whatever. This means that the group that doesn't have a 737 MAX is going to be smaller and therefore harder/way more expensive to avoid.
Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by sascha_sl on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @08:21AM (#22365170)
It's not much different than the NEO, the pitch was that you will not have to send your pilots back to training because "it's just a 737". Since it clearly is not just a 737 the NEO (which is also a variant, but one that didn't inherently change the aerodynamics of the plane) now has the advantage, not just because reputation.
Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by tyfon on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @10:29AM (#22366286)
I completely agree, I'm never setting my feet on a new Boing again. The certification they receive is mostly done by themselves anyway.

I might have been lenient if it was one issue but it issue after issue and it's not just design of the plane, it seems the whole company is rotten to the core.

Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by ars on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @11:04AM (#22366699)
It's the other way around for me. These planes, and Boeing, are under so much scrutiny I doubt that there will be any other plane in the world that will match it for safety.

I also noticed that the last several issues reported were all reported by Boeing and not by the FAA. I like that as well.

Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by glofish on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @12:47PM (#22367950)
If anything the exact opposite is true.

These planes are vetted so closely and strictly that will probably make them the safest plane in existence.

How many Airbus have messed up wiring or have debris in the fuel tank? None? Do you know why? Because nobody is looking at them with a magnifying glass.

Re:Boeing finds debris left in new 737 MAXes, now in storage by jojo2000 on Wednesday February 19, 2020 @03:07PM (#22369487)
That's absolutely not true regarding the wiring constraints. There have been projects going on for years to sort that problem out.