News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by soygul on Monday February 17, 2020 @09:54AM (#22348029)
Article praises Tesla's custom AI chip. It is something many criticize as a waste of development resources, while they could have used off-the-shelf components for the same task.

Tesla's real advantage is their battery production. No one else can compete with them on battery price or production volume at a similar quality: https://www.cnbc.com/2020/02/10/teslas-competitors-play-catc...

Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by onepremise on Monday February 17, 2020 @10:22AM (#22348266)
> they could have used off-the-shelf components for the same task.

They did use off-the-shelf components. They performed poorly and they resulted to developing a custom die with the right components to handle the task of computer vision. They explicitly stated this in multiple interviews. The off-the-shelf solution was crap.

Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by soygul on Monday February 17, 2020 @10:31AM (#22348351)
AI/ML components change rapidly. What happens if they decide to use an entirely different approach. They develop a new chip? Still seems excessive to develop custom chips for unfinished/experimental tech like self-driving: https://www.theverge.com/2019/4/24/18514308/tesla-full-self-...
Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by onepremise on Monday February 17, 2020 @01:53PM (#22349658)
Point is they are doing it. Tesla does it. Apple does it. Microsoft does it. They are all developing their on hardware, and it's paying off, especially in Apple's and Tesla's use case. Research and development is the cornerstone of new innovation. Who cares if it's new tech. Not sure what you mean by "unfinished". They have a product that works. It's new and could use improvements, but Point is, they are doing it and winning. We can't sit around and wait for Ford and GMC, but these guys are being ran by dinosaurs. Stuck in the stone age, waiting for ICE to make a comeback. Here's the crutch of it all, ICE is pretty much out, with the old waterfall model, dead, old tech, EV is far more simple and a heck of a lot better. This whole ICE mentality where you release a car and it's "complete", has to go. This is why we have 'recalls'. Your car should continue to receive updates and improve as you drive it off the lot. Security updates are necessary, UI updates are necessary, performance and economy updates are necessary.
Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by justapassenger on Tuesday February 18, 2020 @11:35PM (#22363063)
> This is why we have 'recalls'. Your car should continue to receive updates and improve as you drive it off the lot. Security updates are necessary, UI updates are necessary, performance and economy updates are necessary.

Did you ever try to rollout change to millions of units of anything, with individual owners of each item, operating in vastly different environments and with additional modifications from those owners?

Rolling updates is A HUGE issue, if you need reliability. It’s not a random app. It’s, for majority of the people, second most expensive purchase in their live (only behind a house). Messing up with that is very very risky.

Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by marvin on Monday February 17, 2020 @11:11AM (#22348644)
This is less of a risk than it might appear. To be sure, it would be expensive to replace the computer part of the entire installed fleet. But the (potentially) full self-driving option is very richly priced, and sells with an incremental margin of 100% when component replacements are excluded. The sensor & computer package are included with all production cars, regardless of whether the FSD option is purchased.

Additionally, Tesla still grows their sales and customer base exponentially. This means that most significant changes in strategy during the production ramp-up will require (in the form of deprecation of now-obsolete production resources) only a small fraction of the investments required to achieve their full, steady-state production capacity.

The same argument holds for the potential case of major changes in battery technology. (Replacements of current fleet excluded, which would not happen for batteries). If Tesla's current battery technology is obsolete in 5-10 years, that's not a very big deal as their sales are expected to be a multiple of today's by then, and the new technology would be phased in during the expected production ramp. (If Tesla fails to grow by a multiple of today's sales, they have largely failed).

Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by Retric on Monday February 17, 2020 @10:38AM (#22348399)
Once you cross the 1+ million chip threshold, custom chips stop being such a big deal.
Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by AtlasBarfed on Monday February 17, 2020 @02:11PM (#22349807)
Based on their AI chip presentation, the important thing is that they have a software/hardware integrated design relationship. Your comment assumes they do this once and never again.

I seriously doubt Tesla is not actively improving the chip, and if they need a fundamentally new software approach, then they have the process/iteration loop established.

Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by rrss on Monday February 17, 2020 @10:41AM (#22348416)
If it was so bad, why did tesla claim for years that all their cars were shipping with sufficient onboard capability for eventual "full self driving?"
Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by jsight on Monday February 17, 2020 @12:10PM (#22349025)
They didn't. They had been saying for years that it would require a computer upgrade that could be done with a service visit, and that the service visit would be free for people who purchased the "FSD" option.
Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by rrss on Monday February 17, 2020 @04:39PM (#22351082)
They absolutely did, and then changed the story when they announced they were building HW3.

> All Tesla Cars Being Produced Now Have Full Self-Driving Hardware

> Oct 19, 2016

> To make sense of all of this data, a new onboard computer with more than 40 times the computing power of the previous generation runs the new Tesla-developed neural net for vision, sonar and radar processing software

^ this refers to the nvidia thing 'onepremise says was too bad for the job.

https://www.tesla.com/blog/all-tesla-cars-being-produced-now...

https://www.theverge.com/2016/10/19/13340938/tesla-autopilot...

Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by jsight on Monday February 17, 2020 @07:14PM (#22352251)
It is a fair point that they didn't say it on day 1. Having said that, they've been talking about the potential for computer upgrades since at least 2017: https://www.theverge.com/2017/8/9/16119746/tesla-self-drivin...

I don't have time to dig it all up, but they were talking about the potential for computer upgrades as far back as 2016 as well: https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/789008557341454336 (though not for pre-2016 vehicles).

I can see where people who don't follow the company closely wouldn't have been aware of this, though. And, obviously there have been plenty of false and misleading statements made in this area.

Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by rthomas6 on Monday February 17, 2020 @10:30AM (#22348333)
What was wrong with using FPGAs?
Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by cdumler on Monday February 17, 2020 @10:44AM (#22348446)
Power and capability. Custom silicon means they can build the chip with all of the chip's surface being used for things their software needs (ie. extra surface for parallel computing and zero surface for unneeded features). They can also tune the chip with ops/watt in mind. Nvidia has touted their A.I. chips being x10 more powerful, but they also took twice the power to do it [1]. For an electric vehicle that lives on only the charge stored in its batteries, you want to use exactly as much power as you need to get the job done and no more.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19732974

Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by rebelde on Monday February 17, 2020 @10:18AM (#22348240)
Oh, the article gives numbers!

Tesla: $158/kWh Competitors: "more than" $200/kWh

Model 3 SR+ has a 54 kWh battery.

Tesla advantage = (200 - 158) * 54 = $2268 per car.

Yes, an advantage today, but not too bad.

Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by clouddrover on Monday February 17, 2020 @10:49AM (#22348485)
Volkswagen is paying less than $100 per kWh for their MEB cars:

https://www.nytimes.com/2019/09/08/business/volkswagen-trade...

Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by matahwoosh on Monday February 17, 2020 @05:10PM (#22351331)
I don't know if it's true. People tend to conflate the price for cells with those of modules and entire battery packs. IIRC, the holy grail is < $100/kWh for a battery pack.
Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by SEJeff on Monday February 17, 2020 @10:34AM (#22348369)
The Maxwell Technologies battery technology is allegedly 10x cheaper to manufacture due to no oven or liquids and as a result, and also lighter. Elon says the "holy grail" of batteries is being able to develop an automotive grade battery at <= $100/kWh. The Maxwell tech looks to be below that, but we'll find out specifics on the upcoming Battery Investor day.
Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by AndrewDucker on Monday February 17, 2020 @11:00AM (#22348555)
Fingers crossed that the rumours are accurate. There are a lot of "coming soon" battery improvements that aren't nearly as impressive when (if) they finally arrive. Be lovely for one to actually live up to them.
Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by SEJeff on Monday February 17, 2020 @11:24AM (#22348739)
For the Tesla Semi and Cybertruck to not be huge loss leaders for Tesla, they have to have made a fundamental breakthrough in battery cost. I'm anxious to see what they come up with.
Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by smileysteve on Monday February 17, 2020 @11:07AM (#22348619)
Just the super capacitor allows for much better durability of all battery technology, especially in normal driving conditions.
Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by SEJeff on Monday February 17, 2020 @11:23AM (#22348733)
Maxwell made ultracapacitors not supercapacitors. Elon has stated that those weren't useful at all for Tesla, but their dry battery electrode manufacturing process stands to be the holy grail. This is what I was referring to.
Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by Vesuvium on Monday February 17, 2020 @10:24AM (#22348292)
Sounds like a lot of money for such a competitive market
Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by H8crilA on Monday February 17, 2020 @11:37AM (#22348812)
Yeah it is a lot for this market. VW makes around €500 per car, on average.

But even that kind of a margin benefit may not justify the current valuation...

Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by DarmokJalad1701 on Monday February 17, 2020 @10:05AM (#22348137)
Is it though? When they started development, there was no such chip specialized for NN tasks. NVIDIA chips are more general purpose and uses a lot more power. The FSD chip has an instruction set of around 18 instructions and is highly specialized.
Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by taylodl on Monday February 17, 2020 @02:06PM (#22349761)
I would argue this is Tesla's real business - battery production. I don't believe they intend to stay in the auto market forever. They're in the market to create demand for quality electric cars, goad the traditional auto makers into making them, and then selling those traditional auto makers the batteries they need to make them work well. I believe that is Tesla's long-term business plan.
Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by matahwoosh on Monday February 17, 2020 @05:07PM (#22351305)
Batteries are a commodity, so I doubt Tesla would want to reduce themselves to an OEM and shrink their margins. Their energy business might eventually be bigger than their automotive one, but either way I think they will continue selling vertically integrated products.
Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by rjsw on Monday February 17, 2020 @05:30PM (#22351521)
Cars are a commodity, the real money is in providing the finance for them.
Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by erikpukinskis on Tuesday February 18, 2020 @04:57AM (#22354753)
Batteries with 20% more watt hours for the weight than the rest of the market are certainly not a commodity.
Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by pests on Monday February 17, 2020 @08:22PM (#22352609)
Are batteries a commodity or are we just assuming that?
Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by NotSammyHagar on Tuesday February 18, 2020 @01:15AM (#22353888)
batteries are absolutely not a commodity at this time. every other manufacturer is held back by not enough battery capacity. Even the biggest companies are held back.
Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by ianai on Tuesday February 18, 2020 @05:41AM (#22354975)
Yeah, until batteries are traded the same way actual commodities are they are not commodities. A good way to tell whether something is a commodity or not is whether there are strong brands in the space. I can’t go onto a major exchange and speculatively trade lithium battery cells.
Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by wil421 on Monday February 17, 2020 @10:03AM (#22348119)
Battery production seems like a problem that can be solved right now with money. VW and Toyota could partner with a 3rd party (like Tesla and Panasonic) and build factories.

Custom silicon seems like a much harder problem for VM/Toyota. Unless a supplier can build something for them I don’t see either company innovating like Tesla. Basically Tesla’s secret sauce is the Tech not the EV components.

Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by SEJeff on Monday February 17, 2020 @10:36AM (#22348384)
It isn't just production, but is also the chemistry. Tesla has the lowest amount of cobalt and nickel in their batteries of any battery manufacturer in the world. It makes their batteries cheaper, but also use less rare earth minerals (which are difficult to get ahold of at their scales). Tesla isn't sharing their chemistry, which is demonstrably better than anything LG Chem or Samsung, etc has been able to come up with. As a result, their batteries are actually better.

You can scale up manufacturing of inferior batteries, but you still will have an inferior product.

Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by kenhwang on Monday February 17, 2020 @05:02PM (#22351263)
No one _wants_ Tesla's chemistry. Tesla is the only automaker using the NCA chemistry. Sure, they're improving NCA quite admirably, but every other automaker would rather use and develop NMC.

Traditional automakers would rather have batteries that don't easily overheat or catch fire when damaged (NMC) than cheaper batteries (NCA).

Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by NotSammyHagar on Tuesday February 18, 2020 @01:19AM (#22353901)
tesla has proven by time that their batteries are excellent, last longer than competitors and have superior battery heating, cooling, and safety systems. Any car can catch on fire (they are all designed and built by humans).

It's just one example, but here is a new porsche ev that caught fire https://electrek.co/2020/02/17/porsche-taycan-fire-burning-g.... Does porsche use nmc batteries? What is the problem with nca, where from experience the overall product is superior to all comers?

Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by MagnumOpus on Monday February 17, 2020 @11:43AM (#22348860)
> Tesla isn't sharing their chemistry

Isn't it Panasonic that manufactures the batteries and sells them to Tesla? Can't they sell the same batteries to everyone else too?

Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by SEJeff on Monday February 17, 2020 @11:51AM (#22348914)
Tesla develops the chemistry and has Panasonic manufacture the cells. Tesla builds the battery packs from Panasonic cells.

The intellectual property for the chemistry is 100% Tesla’s and can not be reused by Panasonic for other manufacturers. In places where Panasonic builds batteries for other manufacturers, they use more traditional chemistry that includes more rare earth metals. Tesla’s chemistry is patented and can’t be duplicated. It is one of their several “moats”.

Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by AtlasBarfed on Monday February 17, 2020 @02:17PM (#22349863)
And right now Tesla / Panasonic is maxed out in their battery production (still a scale that all other manufacturers fundamentally don't have the ability to do, much less profitably).

If/when Tesla increases battery production beyond its storage and car/semi lines of business, they will probably acquire/merge other car companies on the cheap.

The only thing that can eliminate Tesla's advantage is a catch-up solid battery tech that everyone has access to, and even then Tesla will have lots of infrastructure advantages.

Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by SEJeff on Monday February 17, 2020 @07:04PM (#22352182)
That’s not true. Panasonic disagreed with you in their latest earnings call. They’re ramping up for more production. I think Elon has stated they can ramp up 30-50% with the existing space.
Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by clouddrover on Monday February 17, 2020 @04:25PM (#22350928)
Volkswagen is paying less than $100 per kWh for the batteries in their MEB cars. The mid-range Volkswagen ID.3 achieves slightly greater range at a lower price point than a Tesla Model 3 Standard Range Plus.

The supposed battery advantage isn't really there. So hopefully the Maxwell stuff is better.

Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by aguyfromnb on Monday February 17, 2020 @10:17AM (#22348229)
>Custom silicon seems like a much harder problem for VM/Toyota

What evidence is there that custom silicon has any advantage in the self-driving race, let alone in cost competitiveness?

Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by Slartie on Monday February 17, 2020 @02:05PM (#22349751)
None. And this is exactly the problem: Tesla might have a nice piece of silicon there, but that doesn't solve the problem of still being far, far away from having a working algorithm for level 5 self driving. They have a supercomputer in their cars, but can only run minesweeper on it, so to speak.

Their hardware (maybe, at best) solves one of the easy pieces of the self-driving puzzle. It doesn't get them any closer to solving the hard parts. But it sure helps from a marketing perspective, which is kind of important if you want to continue selling a $6000 feature that essentially is just a promise for the future and thus requires buyers to "believe".

Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by nix0n on Monday February 17, 2020 @10:31AM (#22348347)
> Custom silicon seems like a much harder problem for VM/Toyota

Nvidia built a custom chip for Nintendo, I'm sure they would build one for Toyota or VW.

Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by kcb on Monday February 17, 2020 @05:58PM (#22351744)
The switch chip is an off the shelf Tegra X1.
Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by lyime on Monday February 17, 2020 @10:07AM (#22348151)
It’s both.

Continued improvements to battery tech will bring the costs down for Tesla which is important for them to do if they want to succeed.

Custom hardware and software will also give them cost advantage and help them in the long term.

Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by samirm on Monday February 17, 2020 @10:04AM (#22348133)
Both problems could be solved with money, but according to the article it seems the giants are refusing to move due to historical relationships (which tesla does not have).
Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by cma on Monday February 17, 2020 @10:10AM (#22348176)
> Unless a supplier can build something for them I don’t see either company innovating like Tesla.

Mobileye?

Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by NotSammyHagar on Tuesday February 18, 2020 @01:20AM (#22353903)
tesla used mobileye early, then intel bought mobileye so t doesn't use them anymore
Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by rasz on Tuesday February 18, 2020 @12:06PM (#22357572)
Tesla doesnt use mobileye after their unauthorized firmware modifications cut drivers head. Mobileye was the party backing out of the deal.

https://www.wsj.com/articles/mobileye-ends-partnership-with-...

" Mobileye NV said it would no longer provide its computer chips and algorithms to Tesla after a current contract ends due to disagreements about how the technology was deployed. Mobileye provides core technology for Tesla’s Autopilot system, which allows cars to drive themselves in limited conditions."

Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by AtlasBarfed on Monday February 17, 2020 @02:10PM (#22349789)
Off the shelf parts can beat a custom ASIC? That is news to me.

Remember this isn't about the power of the ASIC processing, it is about minimizing the power consumption of the chip so the EV range is affected as little as possible.

Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by aguyfromnb on Monday February 17, 2020 @10:09AM (#22348174)
>Tesla's real advantage is their battery production

Battery pack production. Tesla purchases batteries from Panasonic and LG (and thus is susceptible to that supply).

Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by soygul on Monday February 17, 2020 @10:25AM (#22348294)
They also produce the cells (though it might be Panasonic's tech): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giga_Nevada

> the production rate of battery cells in the Gigafactory had reached 3.5 million '2170' cells per day.

Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by mmaurizi on Monday February 17, 2020 @11:08AM (#22348624)
The gigafactory is a joint venture with Panasonic. There is literally a line on the floor that denotes the Tesla side and the Panasonic side.
Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by AtlasBarfed on Monday February 17, 2020 @02:17PM (#22349869)
Tesla will make their own cells soon.
Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by NotSammyHagar on Tuesday February 18, 2020 @01:13AM (#22353880)
plus superchargers, engine efficiency, not being held back by supporting legacy car service (aka dealer profit center), no dealers, billions more miles to train their ml models on self driving, customer satisfaction
Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by hef19898 on Monday February 17, 2020 @10:36AM (#22348382)
Isn't Tesla getting batteries from Panasonic? because I had the impression tesla has now a scale advantage.
Re:Tesla teardown finds electronics 6 years ahead of Toyota ... by soygul on Monday February 17, 2020 @10:40AM (#22348408)
Gigafactor is also producing the battery cells (though it might be Panasonic's tech) as well as the packs: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giga_Nevada

> the production rate of battery cells in the Gigafactory had reached 3.5 million '2170' cells per day.