I’d say do like bill gates and put the billions directly into worthwhile causes instead instead of suggesting the trickle down will be unquantified but amazing.
There is likely an optimal ratio of spending between humanitarian causes and existential risks. What is it? Is this ratio, and others that have the potential for shaping the future of humanity, openly discussed somewhere?
If so, where?
One more immediate benefit is that the ability to refuel on Mars is identical to the ability to take CO2 out of the air and turn it into (un)natural gas.
Doesn’t do much for bigotry or inequality though.
Many people also like having bigger goals to strive for, and this one might cause less conflict than those wanting to reorganize society in whatever direction.
At the same time I also hardly see it hurting us. The cash is certainly better spend that way than putting another few billions into entertainment, cosmetics or the likes.
But yes, the direct impact on your own backyard will be limited, if that is all you care about.
> this one might cause less conflict than those wanting to reorganize society in whatever direction.
Is that the "go to North Korea/Chile/Somalia" argument on steroids?
Hardly anyone who suggests that the racists move to Somalia believes that the racists, after doing so, should be free to take over the place and rule over, displace or genocide the Somalis. Conversely, if this offer were actually on the table, I'm sure plenty of racists would step up to take it.
Not that I have any reason to believe racists can be convinced to go away no matter where or how appealing the destination is. If anything, I would expect the contrary.
And I’ve yet to see racist ideology that says “OK guys, we got some invaders here, time to pack and look for a new place for us, they won”.
What would benefit our species is drastically reworking the economy to stop the massive waste and production of greenhouse gasses (which Musk may have slightly improved with Tesla, credit where credit is due).
Also, putting more economic and political power in the hands of the many instead of concentrating it all in afew hundreds or thousands of people would go a much longer way towards improving our species than some 'colony' on Mars.
Spreading across n>1 planets would literally move our species up on the Kardashev scale. Achieving that is one of the very few things anyone is doing on this planet, which is fundamentally beneficial to our species.
> Also, putting more economic and political power in the hands of the many instead of concentrating it all in afew hundreds or thousands of people would go a much longer way towards improving our species.
“The best argument against Democracy is a five-minute conversation with the average voter.” - Winston Churchill.
I'm not defending the actions of most of those wealthy individuals, but handing the reigns of power to the masses is a historically proven recipe for failure. Moreso now than ever with the advent of ML driven voter manipulation.
And singling out Musk is laughable. Musk and Gates are perhaps the only two that aren't cartoon level evil villains. I don't understand how anyone could possibly be shitting on Musk for his Mars vision, even if it's folly, when all the other people with comparable wealth are too busy rigging elections, fucking up the poor, and destroying our natural resources.
And democracy, even as limited as it is today, has been the only system which has brought any amount of peace around here.
And I'm not attacking Musk specifically, he is just very visible, and happens to be the subject of this article. But I do not believe anyone is worth a billion dollars in their own merits, even if Musk is perhaps not the worst one.
Okay. And we're embarking on a mission that would achieve an 'essentially sci-fi' objective. With the funding of a billionaire that you chose to shit on over the rest, that instead embark on.... Sex crimes? Petty regional politics? Rent seeking? Expanding their empires? Setting their offspring up to follow in their steps?
I don't follow.
To me, a Mars mission is going to be as impactful to the vast majority of humankind as a fraction of how important the discovery of the Americas was the peasantry of Europe (since the Americas were at least immediately habitable). It would be little comfort to know that there is a little colony on Mars, completely dependent on Earth exports while the Earth itself is declining around us. If we don't solve the climate crisis on Earth, there will be no Mars colony, not in th curent world, I hope this much is clear.
Those two things alone will massively help the planet.
The Kardashev Scale is just a scale, like the Richter Scale. It's not sci-fi, though there being aliens at higher levels on that scale is.
I think a discussion of other billionaires is on topic considering the OP's message.
The typical moral justification is that the Earth may be threatened and so it would be prudent to have some humans somewhere else in the solar system.
Well the number one threat to Earth is an impact event. If we can hypothesize a rapidly growing lift capacity, why not use that mass budget to develop a solar-system-wide system for detecting and if necessary altering the trajectory of potential impacting objects? It would be WAY better to protect the Earth than any other backup plan.
The other big threat to the Earth would be a fast gamma ray burst but that would very likely get Mars and any other human colony as well.
The reality is that people want to go to Mars for the same reason people want to go climb mountains: because it is there. Our economic system provides a very few people with the resources to pursue those dreams. Whether that takes away from everyone else depends on how you think about the economy—to what extent you believe it is zero-sum.
Personally I think we should go to Mars for the simple purpose of going—I like exploration and climbing mountains too—but not fool ourselves about establishing a new human society there. To me it’s like say let’s establish a new human society on the summit of Everest. Which would be way easier than doing so on Mars, by the way!
Detection is a solved problem.
Altering the trajectory of an asteroid requires a large amount of lifting capacity to be available on relatively short notice. That is, it has to already exist when the crisis is identified.
Congratulations. You've identified a positive externality of Starship.
So having a steady traffic in commercial heavy lift could be a positive externality as well, for whoever wants to find a close-call asteroid that has been recently marked as 100% safe and give it a little nudge.
Weaponizing smallpox and distributing it in major airports is the lower bound of effort. Anything that exceeds this is not worth worrying about.
It would be a massive drain on the economy that chose to maintain it, there's no guarantee it would actually work when the time came, and it wouldn't benefit from improvements in design over time.
Being profitable, Starship has none of these limitations.
Challenged— that’s the number one natural threat to (human civilization on) Earth. Or maybe the number one threat assuming we survive the next thousand years.
The number one threat at this moment is deliberate annihilation of the ecosphere by a very small number of insane humans.
The number two threat is negligent annihilation of the ecosphere by a plurality of merely shortsighted humans.
Not only is a Mars colony uniquely susceptible to these existential risks, the process of building one could plausibly make them worse.
Space folks like to talk a lot about how the technology you use to survive in space is technology you can use to live better on Earth. They don’t like to talk about how the technology you use to get to space is the same technology you use to murder human civilization anywhere it hides.
I wonder why.
Then there is the huge gain in perspective. Even if the direct utility of all the space missions might not be large, looking onto our planet has given us a clear perspective. That we shouldn't waste this precious place.
Finally, not at least trying to go to Mars and beyond would have a negative impact on the long-time development of the species. We either eventually leave this planet or eventually will be consumed by the expanding sun. Sure, there is plenty of time till then and I hope there are others why try to make humankind eventually an interstellar species. But if we don't even try, because it is "stupid and wasteful", we already have lost.
And I am sure, even if the colony on Mars might not do anything useful in the short term, just having space launch capability available as the article describes, will find many other beneficial uses.
Of course it makes more sense to colonize at least one other planet in our solar system first to learn on a smaller scale with lower stakes. But waiting for entirely new physics is unessesary.
https://io9.gizmodo.com/how-self-replicating-spacecraft-coul...
https://www.open.edu/openlearn/science-maths-technology/scie...
What's this mania you have of disseminating yourself? Even if you build ships that carry human genes sequences and send them on a million years trip, who is going to benefit? The sequences you sent?
Life. It's what living beings do. If some group of living beings stop doing it, there are fewer of them, later.
I’m told there was a book on this exact topic. I’ve never read it, because other people tell me it’s now wildly out of date.
We could also colonize objects in the Oort Cloud, just gradually hopping outward from rock to rock, with fusion to power our little colonies, ultimately reaching interstellar distances. It'd be a little slower, but it'd happen without any special effort.
It's worth pointing out that, had Elon Musk not dedicated 17 years of his life to building those very resources, they likely wouldn't now be available to anyone at all.
> The Gobi had a long history of human habitation, mostly by nomadic peoples. By the early 20th century, the region was under the nominal control of Manchu-China, and inhabited mostly by Mongols, Uyghurs, and Kazakhs.
To put it another way, myself and Bezos are not equally free to spend Apollo mission money on solving problems.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simpson%27s_paradox
https://ourworldindata.org/uploads/2013/12/Global-inequality...
https://www.mckinsey.com/~/media/McKinsey/Industries/Public%...
Add it to the long list of things Blade Runner got so right about the future.
I stopped reading this article because in all the rocket talk, nowhere did it acknowledge just how completely inhospitable Mars will be once you finally get it there. Every single aspect of the planet is not conducive to life. I don’t doubt that one day extremely rich people will (very far in the future, far past Elon Musk’s lifespan) live there and the toil of humans here will fund the exotic ways they deal with the massive radiation there etc. Just so they can not be around the poor serfs back on the planet custom made for life.
Here's his article about radiation on Mars:
https://caseyhandmer.wordpress.com/2019/10/20/omg-space-is-f...
And here, on terraforming Mars:
https://caseyhandmer.wordpress.com/2018/08/05/atmospheres-an...
And on the immense infrastructure we'd need for a sustainable colony:
https://caseyhandmer.wordpress.com/2020/01/20/what-would-it-...
And you really legitimately think that they did not know about this piece of information from the children's book about space? They don't mention it because it is so ubiquitous and common sense that they assume everyone knows it, not because they managed to "miss the memo" about Mars. The idea is that we terraform Mars with technology to make it liveable, not that we just go there and try to build a hut from dirt and call it a day.
On the other hand, I admire Musk for being a great engineer and businessman with the dreams of a teenager; even if the idea of thriving colonies on Mars is a cheap fantasy, I understand that you need to set yourself exciting goals to drive your ambition.
Once a human society learns how to thrive on a single colony there is no reason it could not spread across the planet.
You are right of course that interplanetary colonization is completely different thing from the European colonization of Americas.
But it's quite silly to think it is childish. The thing is, we don't know what it would be like.
So you could be proven right ("what a silly idea this was, let's go home") or you could be proven wrong (it turns out humans can thrive elsewhere and we become an interplanetary species).
Not only will colonizing Mars never work, there’s no reason at all to want to. What a dead, barren place.
And in the meantime back down to earth people are really starting to care about inequality. Meanwhile billionaires pour resources into childish flights of fancy when the world is literally burning.
Ugh. I really think billionaires have a place in our society but these sorts of projects make me understand why others question whether some people should have such huge control of resources.
No one is even visiting Mars, let alone colonizing it.