(1) Comparison against all other cars in US (and across all states) just introduces lots of sampling bias. Teslas are like much more common in states like CA, than say Tennessee. Tennessee accounts for much more accidents in general than California and that adds up in overall stats, but not in Tesla stats.
(2) What kind of variation do we have in Tesla drivers vs other car drivers. As comment above mentions, Tesla drivers may be more responsible drivers.
(3) What accounts as accident? Minor collisions (fender benders) vs Major collisions. More specifically, I want to know, how does Autopilot react when it encounters something it has never seen before (like the crash in article). Humans can handle things pretty well IMO given they are not way beyond speed-limit, and all kind of random shit happens on road.
(4) Autopilot vs Manual Tesla stats is promising IMO. However, a little more information would be nice to have, like proportion of 1-billion miles logged as autopilot miles.
I agree that anyone who feels uncomfortable with Tesla's ADAS should simply turn it off. But don't you think it's unfair for the company to place an unfinished product in the hands of a consumer and pass off the risk-management responsibility to them? Tesla's cavalier attitude towards autonomous vehicle safety is concerning to me. They seem to adopt the "move fast and break things" approach, whereas teams like Waymo and Cruise are releasing things in a slower and more controlled manner. And not coincidentally, they've have far less accidents that way.
What’s immoral is that they allow people to turn this thing on and then play Candy Crush on their phone while the car does the driving, fully aware that this might lead to fatal accidents in some cases. Their marketing is misleading because they suggest that the system is safe and they don’t inform customers about the freak accidents that can happen when the system glitches (bad for sales). That’s not very ethical if you ask me.
You and I probably agree that this might be wishful thinking to expect some portion of the driving public to do so faithfully.
Perhaps additional technology can help better guarantee attention and participation on the part of the driver.
Then Tesla should be given it away, not charging extra for it. To do otherwise would be immoral.
Autopilot is standard in every single car Tesla sells now, for exactly this reason.
Here is the blog post on their website where they talk about making it standard: https://www.tesla.com/blog/update-our-vehicle-lineup
> I assumed you meant that they should include safety features for no extra cost, which they do
I could buy a car without it for 37500 and now I can't but I can now buy a car with it for 39500 and you would still consider this is no extra cost?
I must be misunderstanding what you are saying
There arguably is a moral problem selling a product with optional safety features that cost extra.
If tesla invented immortality fields within their vehicles, I have no doubt they would jack up the price, and that would be fine, because it’s now a much better car. To think otherwise would be silly.
I don't know where you get that idea from, when I'm out cycling it's generally the people in expensive cars that don't pay much attention.
Which is what it was designed for and which is a much easier problem to solve than inner-city driving.
Which IMO I feel like more self-driving companies should have focused on first to perfect their systems. We used feature phones before smartphones for a reason, hardware/software is best developed incrementally.
Accidents without AP's overreaching half-baked features meant to serve as a marketing gimmick, but with safety technology that's been iterated for almost 20 years like LKAS and AEB, and is now getting affordable, is what's interesting.
Now a Corolla, the most conservative car in the history of mainstream cars, can return you to your lane and warn you if it feels you're making too many mistakes due to being tired.
These features save lives when they work, and more importantly, do not kill you when they malfunction, and do not lull you into a false sense of safety nearly as actively as a system literally named "Autopilot".
AP could literally be the same system, not pretend that lane centering is so easy to do, be much more aggressive about disengaging like other manufacturers (see SuperCruise, which literally tracks your eyes to ensure focus is maintained), and be infinitely more palatable an experiment than it currently is
-
If it seems I'm being aggressively anti-AP here, it's because I didn't sign up to be a part of this beta, yet I have to drive on the road with these people.
I like that a bored developer can't push updates to the lane guidance in my cars. AP has had regressions that brought back deadly bugs.
I'll take a crusty system that was put through thousands of hours of testing then never "improved" again over that any day.
In Tesla's case, AutoPilot's lane keeping feature did not keep the car in the lane. Instead it drove the car into concrete at 71mph killing the driver. More over anti-collision feature did not stop the car from colliding with the concrete barrier. See where the issue lies?
Will you tell the people who faced safety issues with their Takata airbags to get rid of them? or the Toyota owners whose vehicles had unintended acceleration that they should rip out their accelerators?
Tesla’s Driver Fatality Rate is more than Triple that of Luxury Cars (and likely even higher)
https://medium.com/@MidwesternHedgi/teslas-driver-fatality-r...
Makes sense to investigate Tesla since it's always the same driver causing the accidents. It still makes sense even if this driver is safer than everyone else.
But at the same time, the kinds of people that get into accidents will be a different distribution.
How you drive factors a lot into how likely you are into getting in an accident, even allowing for the other drivers.
If the distribution becomes essentially random then you might actually have a higher chance of getting into an accident than before, if you were a very careful driver.
(Obviously those that benefit the most are the bad drivers since they'll no longer be bad)
Just remember that whenever you summarize a distribution into a single number like an average, you loose a lot of information in the process.
It shows Teslas have much fewer accidents than the average car, and that Teslas with autopilot enabled are substantially safe per mile than with autopilot disabled (25-50% more miles driven per accident).
The article says a Prius hit the same place as this Tesla the week before. But the NTSB isn't investigating Toyota.