Re:Eiffel programming language
by magoghm on Sunday February 09, 2020 @09:09AM
(#22282160)
Actually, Bertrand Meyer (the creator of the Eiffel Programming Language) has always emphasized that the object oriented origin of Eiffel comes from Simula 67 and not from Smalltalk.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Yeah, according to his book OOP is mostly about inheritance (Java/c++ style OOP) rather than message passing or objects . Eiffel even support multiple inheritance.
Smalltalk supports multiple inheritance via traits, added to post Smalltalk-80 systems.
iirc Added to Pharo. Not added to the commercial Smalltalk implementations.
Do you know different?
Just by reading papers, so I might be wrong here regarding adoption among them.
My last commercial Smalltalk was Smalltalk/V, just before Java got released, so not much I can state here.
I think it was added originally in Squeak[0], Pharo got it from there.
It isn't obvious to me that Squeak classes have been re-organised to actually use traits?
Where-as for some reason I seem to imagine Pharo classes have been re-organized to use traits?
Except that Simula allows free functions and Eiffel does not, while Eiffel also supports metaclasses and Simula does not, additionally using MELT feels like having a Smalltalk image, so it is a bit strange his point of view.
Any details why he thinks that way?
If I had to guess, probably the staticness, which is what people usually mean when they make that Simula/Smalltalk distinction.