News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:LA’s new trains have not lessened the time spent stuck in... by Eric_WVGG on Friday February 07, 2020 @03:27PM (#22270539)
I lived in Austin just before the advent of Lyft and Uber, and was thus stuck using the bus from time to time. I found the bus service in Austin to be unusually slow by US standards due to the abnormal number of wheelchair users.

why oh why doesn't that city have light rail…

Re:LA’s new trains have not lessened the time spent stuck in... by supernova87a on Friday February 07, 2020 @04:36PM (#22271235)
This is a real problem, and hard to raise without coming off (or being accused) as an insensitive clod.

The number of handicapped and mentally ill / incapacitated users who take public transport is a really big problem when combined with a system's stated need to serve everyone equally.

They take up stopping time, slow the bus down, antagonize other riders, which leads to people not wanting to take the bus, making it seen more and more a transport mode of the dysfunctional. Then depriving it of funding, and into a spiral of decline. On a train or bus, you can't allow 1 person to delay 50 or 200 by multiple minutes during every ride.

People who take public transport (the poor, those with no alternative) are the very people whose time is precious and wasting it with delays is really irresponsible.

There needs to be a way to handle the outlier cases who slow the system down, to maintain confidence and reliability of the system for the bulk majority of passengers.

Re:LA’s new trains have not lessened the time spent stuck in... by pasttense01 on Saturday February 08, 2020 @01:52AM (#22274397)
Well there is: a separate system for the disabled. It's better for the average user--it speeds up the system. It's better for the disabled--the handicapped van comes directly to their house to pick them up and takes them directly to their destination.
[dead]
Re:LA’s new trains have not lessened the time spent stuck in... by dang on Saturday February 08, 2020 @02:24AM (#22274491)
Since you've done nothing but break the site guidelines since the last time we asked you to stop, it seems clear that you don't want to use HN as intended, so I've banned the account.

Even if you're right on the underlying issue, being this much of an asshole on HN poisons what little community we actually have here, and that is more important. If you change your mind and decide you want to use the site in the intended spirit—e.g. with respect for others, even when they're wrong—you're welcome to email [email protected].

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:LA’s new trains have not lessened the time spent stuck in... by Eric_WVGG on Friday February 07, 2020 @10:33PM (#22273636)
You know, I spent several minutes on that comment trying to figure out how to talk about this diplomatically, eventually just gave up and tried to talk simply.

What I wish I had added was, "this is fine, it's worth it, my convenience is not actually important." So, sorry about that.

Re:LA’s new trains have not lessened the time spent stuck in... by supernova87a on Friday February 07, 2020 @07:28PM (#22272702)
"Ableist"? Go off back to your ridiculous PC college fantasy world and leave the solving of real problems to people who want to actually make things better.
Re:LA’s new trains have not lessened the time spent stuck in... by dang on Saturday February 08, 2020 @02:29AM (#22274505)
Breaking the site guidelines like this is not ok here, regardless of whether another user broke them. We've had to warn you about this in the past. Continuing to post like this will get you banned, so please don't.

Edit: it also looks like you've been using HN primarily for ideological battle. That's not ok, because it destroys what this site is supposed to be for (curiosity and thoughtful conversation). We ban such accounts, so please stop.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:LA’s new trains have not lessened the time spent stuck in... by supernova87a on Saturday February 08, 2020 @02:45AM (#22274564)
Your edit -- is this a cut and paste admonition that you send to anyone? I think if you look at my previous contributions, they are far from "ideological" and in fact contribute a lot of information. In a previous moderation, you took the position that pointing out the flaws in someone's argument was a personal attack. That is a concerning use of moderation discretion. On this above post, I concede that I was not being respectful to the person who was being so snarky and angry to begin with.
Re:LA’s new trains have not lessened the time spent stuck in... by dang on Saturday February 08, 2020 @11:43AM (#22276648)
I certainly post this sort of moderation comment to anyone who I see breaking the rules, but I try not to copy and paste them. Inevitably they are pretty repetitive though.

It always feels like the other person started it and did worse, which is why you need to follow the site guidelines regardless of what the other person does. I don't mean 'you' personally, of course. We all do.

I didn't read your account history closely, so it's possible it wasn't primarily ideological. But to stay on the right site of the guidelines, make sure that you're using this site for intellectual curiosity, not arguing with political enemies. That's important, and when people do that as intended, their comments take on a different quality that is more conducive to curious, thoughtful conversation.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:LA’s new trains have not lessened the time spent stuck in... by alex_c on Friday February 07, 2020 @05:39PM (#22271902)
Toronto handles this in part with a separate fleet of buses for wheelchair users. It’s effectively a taxi service with the same cost as a bus fare. It’s not perfect, it has to be booked in advance and times / availability can be unpredictable, but it is there.

http://www.ttc.ca/WheelTrans/index.jsp

All regular buses are still wheelchair accessible, but in practice I cannot remember the last time I saw a wheelchair user on a bus.

Re:LA’s new trains have not lessened the time spent stuck in... by the_common_man on Friday February 07, 2020 @04:24PM (#22271114)
Buses in bay area and in SF take forever as well
Re:LA’s new trains have not lessened the time spent stuck in... by krn1p4n1c on Friday February 07, 2020 @03:58PM (#22270856)
It does, if you're going from Leander/Cedar Park to downtown it's useful. It takes about the same amount of time as driving in rush-hour, but without the bs.

Texas generally sees public-transport as something for poor people and the state is full of armchair libertarians..

Re:LA’s new trains have not lessened the time spent stuck in... by dkarl on Friday February 07, 2020 @04:33PM (#22271203)
Yep, that's almost the only scenario it covers, along with commuting from east Austin to the Domain.

I was at a lecture recently about the things cities do right and wrong when planning public transit, and the speaker used Austin's rail system to illustrate what happens when cities route public transit around political opposition. The political opposition is typically strongest exactly where transit is most valuable, and Austin's Red Line is the perfect example: it barely sticks its nose into one side of downtown and then manages to dodge the capitol area, the university, and the dense residential neighborhoods of north Austin. Even the station that seems intended to serve the Domain is actually a ten minute walk from it, twenty minutes to most of the shops and restaurants.

Re:LA’s new trains have not lessened the time spent stuck in... by NathanKP on Friday February 07, 2020 @04:47PM (#22271339)
I mean its not like they really had much of a choice for the route. They didn't build new tracks, just reused old existing tracks and built stations along the way.

I lived in Austin when they were voting to build the rail line and there was so much opposition that they never would have been able to get funding for any serious development of new tracks. There was a proposal for a while to run trains up Mopac, along the train line in the middle of the highway there, but apparently that wasn't possible because there is too much freight traffic on that line.

> The political opposition is typically strongest exactly where transit is most valuable

That actually wasn't the case either. The original proposal was for a roughly $2 billion project, and while it had lots of support in the central city the suburbs voted against it.

In the end they got the proposal passed, but with a drastically reduced budget, and were only able to spend about $100 million to build a rail system. So they just slapped together the red line on existing rail tracks

Re:LA’s new trains have not lessened the time spent stuck in... by dkarl on Friday February 07, 2020 @05:00PM (#22271478)
They could have found the money if people weren’t opposed to the route the money would have enabled. The university was very strongly opposed, NIMBY residents in north Austin were opposed to having nearby transit, and lots of people who owned or rented commercial land along the route were opposed because businesses would lose a lot of business during construction. Many of the people who were opposed found cost to be a convenient grounds for opposition, and the cheaper alternative happened to conveniently coincide with making the least number of people upset.
Re:LA’s new trains have not lessened the time spent stuck in... by NathanKP on Friday February 07, 2020 @05:12PM (#22271627)
Haha yeah, I rememeber the NIMBY's in North Austin. I was living out near the Domain area back then, so I was glad to at least get the Kramar station. Honestly the biggest shame is still no rail line out to Austin Bergstrom.