I also like the consistency of windows forms. This is awesome for administrative and business users, who just want to get their work done. There are no UI surprises. But your tool will look like an ugly duck, if it is used in an environment with shiny Web and WPF applications.
For this reason alone, we had to make a split between forms and WPF applications. Windows Forms for administrative UI, WPF for end users. (By the way: I recommend outsourcing the design part to another company specialized in WPF design. Designing nice WPF UI is a black art.)
There's also the fact that Microsoft calls forms legacy tech, but I'm not yet too concerned. I would be more concerned to rewrite all WPF application with the next shiny framework coming around...
https://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=metro+styling+for+winf...
Styling WinForms to look the way you want is certainly possible, but I would agree that it's even more of a black art than designing a WPF UI.