End user has the same control as over any feature of the car.
If you buy Tesla and then buy FSD and then sell that car to someone else, FSD stays with the car. It would be absurd if it worked any other way.
In this case, the car was sold back to Tesla, a dealer bought it from Tesla and sold it to someone. Tesla determined that the car was configured with FSD even though the user never paid for it.
Now it's a he said / she said situation.
The user got screwed because he lost FSD that he thought he had.
The question is: was he screwed by the dealer (who mis-represented availability of FSD) or was he screwed by Tesla (who mis-represented availability of FSD to the dealer). Or maybe the dealer misunderstood.
Either way, this should be straightforward to resolve.
The buyer should be made whole by the dealer, because dealer sold the car.
The dealer should be made whole by Tesla (if Tesla indeed misrepresented the car).
All parties have relevant documents so it should be clear who's responsible for what.
> In this case, the car was sold back to Tesla, a dealer bought it from Tesla and sold it to someone. Tesla determined that the car was configured with FSD even though the user never paid for it.
The dealer purchased the car from the manufacturer and the window sticker (required by law to be provided by the manufacturer to prevent dealer fraud) listed the “FSD” feature as included with the device. The purchaser bought it with the understanding that that list of features was correct. The dealer had no say in the matter either way.
You don’t have to take my word for this: the Monroney sticker is actually in the linked article.
Legally this is unambiguously fraud by the manufacturer.
The customer needs to go to the dealership and get their money back, and the dealership needs to go to Tesla and get their own money back
I think it was correct for Tesla to include it and I think their policy of non-transferable licenses is exploitative. Not legal in the EU but they can get away with that crap in the USA.
People are having FSD disappear from their cars and having to produce invoices showing they bought it in order to have it restored. How do you do that when you bought it used?
https://teslamotorsclub.com/tmc/threads/lost-fsd-earlier-thi...
Versus buying a dumb car and never getting upgrades?
I'll take the "risk" to get sentry/dog/camping mode as free updates vs having to buy a new car every time I want a new feature.
Next day in the morning I tried to start it up and it actually worked again. The display just shortly displayed 'update complete'. Made me laugh. I believe the error was related to the battery being low while it was really cold outside and the update notification was unrelated. But I guess you could call that "camping mode".
Still left me with an appreciation for my old car, which is too old and stupid to receive updates and is really dependable without me treating it that well.
Funny anecdote but imagine someone with mobility issues getting stuck in the same situation.
My car is so dumb that it doesn't brick itself when I change the suspension or put a bigger turbo on it. Though it might send a piston into orbit.
You don't need to be nannied by your car.
Further, it takes a naive level of trust to be okay with an "essential", non-subscription item depending on the benevolent existence of a 3rd party. Be it vehicles, machinery, firearms, combine harvesters or front door lock.
The chance of winning camping mode is not worth the risk of losing autopilot, for most people.
The entire "Autopilot" feature is technical ability driven by marketing to pump more money out of their car sales. Good business for Tesla, but a shitty thing to do to consumers to treat autopilot as an owner-dependent feature and not as a feature that could be handed off. That's one of the biggest negatives to having cars that can innately phone home to the manufacturer - it gives Tesla the power to giveth and taketh away at their discretion, and leave the car and consumer S.O.L.