News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla remotely removed autopilot features from used Tesla... by gumby on Friday February 07, 2020 @06:44AM (#22265084)
You have misinterpreted what the article documents:

> In this case, the car was sold back to Tesla, a dealer bought it from Tesla and sold it to someone. Tesla determined that the car was configured with FSD even though the user never paid for it.

The dealer purchased the car from the manufacturer and the window sticker (required by law to be provided by the manufacturer to prevent dealer fraud) listed the “FSD” feature as included with the device. The purchaser bought it with the understanding that that list of features was correct. The dealer had no say in the matter either way.

You don’t have to take my word for this: the Monroney sticker is actually in the linked article.

Legally this is unambiguously fraud by the manufacturer.

Re:Tesla remotely removed autopilot features from used Tesla... by flyingfences on Friday February 07, 2020 @08:56AM (#22265928)
I agree with your analysis - the beuyer did pay for the feature, but there is one detail you got wrong: a manufacturer Monroney is only required for new cars.
Re:Tesla remotely removed autopilot features from used Tesla... by ddalex on Friday February 07, 2020 @09:52AM (#22266476)
But Tesla sold the car to the dealer as a NEW car, slightly defective, hence the sticker.

The customer needs to go to the dealership and get their money back, and the dealership needs to go to Tesla and get their own money back

Re:Tesla remotely removed autopilot features from used Tesla... by rootusrootus on Friday February 07, 2020 @02:40PM (#22269959)
Unless I am woefully misinformed, Tesla is absolutely 100% not allowed to sell a lemon buyback as a new car. It's a used car, and on top of that it has to be disclosed as a lemon buyback.
Re:Tesla remotely removed autopilot features from used Tesla... by TheGrumpyBrit on Friday February 07, 2020 @10:52AM (#22267131)
I'm not familiar with US laws around these stickers, but that doesn't sound like a get out for Tesla. Not being legally required to provide a sticker doesn't (or shouldn't) change the fact that, if the manufacturer provides a sticker anyway, it must be accurate.
Re:Tesla remotely removed autopilot features from used Tesla... by rootusrootus on Friday February 07, 2020 @02:41PM (#22269982)
Agreed. It may not have the slam-dunk legal authority that a monroney sticker on a new car would have, but it is still documentation that shows features and a VIN, and including it in the car is tantamount to claiming that the car has these specifications. It was foolish of Tesla to include it.
Re:Tesla remotely removed autopilot features from used Tesla... by gumby on Friday February 07, 2020 @05:29PM (#22271819)
> It was foolish of Tesla to include it

I think it was correct for Tesla to include it and I think their policy of non-transferable licenses is exploitative. Not legal in the EU but they can get away with that crap in the USA.