News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla remotely removed autopilot features from used Tesla... by muzika on Friday February 07, 2020 @02:40AM (#22263945)
This is absurd. It’s theft, plain and simple. Tesla wants to habe each owner of the car pay the $7,000 software update option, yet when someone pays for it, they refuse to transfer the license to the buyer’s next car.
Re:Tesla remotely removed autopilot features from used Tesla... by londons_explore on Friday February 07, 2020 @03:34AM (#22264177)
I'm not sure this is the case here.

I think they're implying the original owner may not have paid for autopilot, and perhaps had it activated through illicit means, like persuading an employee to tweak a database.

Re:Tesla remotely removed autopilot features from used Tesla... by Swenrekcah on Friday February 07, 2020 @04:00AM (#22264286)
Be that as it may, in the meantime the car returned to Tesla's ownership who then advertised it as having those options. They need to reactivate it for this car (forever), apologize for the misunderstanding and then case is closed.
Re:Tesla remotely removed autopilot features from used Tesla... by kjksf on Friday February 07, 2020 @05:25AM (#22264683)
> who then advertised it as having those options

That's what the dealer claims.

Tesla claims this feature was never bought for this car.

You can choose to believe one party or the other, but don't present that belief as a fact.

Re:Tesla remotely removed autopilot features from used Tesla... by Swenrekcah on Friday February 07, 2020 @06:09AM (#22264902)
Well I did read the article and it has what seems to be a sales sheet for the car from the auction, on which you can see those features listed.

It is a bit confusing that some are marked included and some have a price tag, but if you add up all the price tags you get the advertised price, so I think it's reasonable to assume that everything listed there is included in the purchase.

There are also screenshots, supposedly from the car, showing that the car has those features activated.

Now, I'm not going to independently verify the claims the article makes and I'm for now assuming it's presenting the case in a fairly unbiased way.

It seems to me then that Tesla's position is that since the activation was done without payment and their knowledge (again, I believe the article for now), then they have the right to deactivate it.

And I would agree with them if anyone other than Tesla themselves had sold the car at the auction. But they did, they said the features were there and they have the authority to add them, so they should. They didn't verify the car properly before selling and that's on them.

Re:Tesla remotely removed autopilot features from used Tesla... by TheGrumpyBrit on Friday February 07, 2020 @11:13AM (#22267389)
The fact that this was a lemon law buyback suggests to me that the original owner did pay for the feature, but then got a full refund. Tesla intended to restore it to standard features but accidentally sold it on before doing so, and in doing so asserted that it still included that feature.

Legally, I think that leaves them in the same position as if they'd intended to remove the premium interior but sold it on before doing so - tough.

Re:Tesla remotely removed autopilot features from used Tesla... by Forgivenessizer on Friday February 07, 2020 @05:15AM (#22264632)
Even funnier, if you, say, get cancer and die, and you leave your girlfriend your car, she can't have autopilot without ponying up again, even if you lived with each other for decades.
Re:Tesla remotely removed autopilot features from used Tesla... by madaxe_again on Friday February 07, 2020 @03:58AM (#22264275)
If I have a computer with a big pile of really expensive software on it licensed to me, and I sell you that piece of hardware, without formatting the disks, does that mean I’ve sold you those licenses?

I think any reasonable take here is “no, you did not”.

A Tesla is a computer that just happens to have wheels.

In this case, it sounds like someone bought a second hand computer that happened to have an unlicensed installation of some software, and the license was revoked. Perhaps the car was ex-demo before the owner who auctioned it off did so.

Now, there’s a separate question around the communications over this, and the dealer/end customer being mis-sold, and they’ve stumbled there, but this is more of a gap between expectations (it’s a car!) vs reality (it’s a computer).

Re:Tesla remotely removed autopilot features from used Tesla... by micheljansen on Friday February 07, 2020 @04:34AM (#22264452)
That's really not how it is sold.

If you want to stick with the computer metaphor, it's like Tesla sold you a computer with some paid-for firmware options enabled, tied to that device, that cannot be transferred to any other device, then pulls them post-resale.

Tesla needs to pick: either it's software licensed to you as a person and therefore transferrable to another car, or it's software tied to a specific car and therefore transferrable to another person.

Re:Tesla remotely removed autopilot features from used Tesla... by martin8412 on Friday February 07, 2020 @04:35AM (#22264462)
I would say this is very similar to Cisco saying that the IOS license for their switches is non-transferable. You go buy a switch on eBay, and you'll have to pay a license fee to Cisco.

Mind you that this is not legal in Europe. Licenses are transferable regardless of what American corporations say.

Re:Tesla remotely removed autopilot features from used Tesla... by Nursie on Friday February 07, 2020 @04:22AM (#22264394)
If the computer is specialised to the extent that the software is only useful on that one computer, and you have no ongoing use for the software without the computer, and perhaps you even advertised the software license as part of your sale...

Hell yes you transferred that license.

Re:Tesla remotely removed autopilot features from used Tesla... by brailsafe on Friday February 07, 2020 @04:24AM (#22264402)
I think this analogy depends entirely on communication and your ability to defend what you think of as your property. Applying the reverse logic, is it theft if the person uses that software that you sold them access to?

As far as I'm concerned, someone's property is what they can defend as their property. If someone has access to a license that you didn't intend to sell them, but also doesn't impair your ability to use it, then you now both have that property.

Otherwise, if you clearly communicate that it's part of the deal, but then keep a backdoor in, and remove the software from the person's new computer, that's theft.

The only way I'd argue that the software would remain yours after the transaction and when you forgot to exclude it, is if you maintained access to it somehow. Whether the person keeps it or not is up to their goodwill or ability to use the licenses. In the old days, if a computer came with a Photoshop license on it, it's yours.

Re:Tesla remotely removed autopilot features from used Tesla... by mgoetzke on Friday February 07, 2020 @04:34AM (#22264446)
it seems in this case the expensive software was never licensed to begin with. It was on the PC by accident so to speak.

Its like buying a PC with an internet activated piece of software which is later deactivated remotely because the software detected it was never licensed.

BUT Tesla and others in the chain should not have listed it as an extra and those are now required to make this right. This could mean accept the return of this product, or leave the feature activated

Re:Tesla remotely removed autopilot features from used Tesla... by _Microft on Friday February 07, 2020 @04:28AM (#22264421)
Could Tesla owners really keep the FSD 'license' when selling a car and use it with their next Tesla? I have never read about anything like that. I thought the features were tied to the car, not to the owner.
Re:Tesla remotely removed autopilot features from used Tesla... by notyourday on Friday February 07, 2020 @07:10AM (#22265223)
Tesla may want to claim it is a computer with wheels but the state disagrees -- you don't have to register a computer but you have to register a car
Re:Tesla remotely removed autopilot features from used Tesla... by overgard on Friday February 07, 2020 @10:54AM (#22267154)
If you believe that, then Teslas have zero resale value. Unless they state that they will honor their agreements I wouldn't dream of buying one