News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by abvdasker on Monday February 03, 2020 @05:08PM (#22229806)
Normally I would say that investigating Google for antitrust violations would be a good idea, but I do not trust this administration and it's Justice Department to do it without having nefarious ulterior motives. It isn't hard to imagine what they may be: using the threat of a DOJ investigation to extort either money or political favors from the enormously powerful multinational technology conglomerate that is Google. The people who run the current administration have demonstrated countless times that they are not afraid to use the powers of the federal government for personal benefit and enrichment, so it has become impossible to trust any legal action they may undertake.
Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by Jerry2 on Monday February 03, 2020 @05:54PM (#22230279)
Previous administration had a rotating door with Google executives. It's as if Google was running the WH. This is how they managed to avoid all of the FTC investigations. [2][3][4]

This is usually what 3rd world type "banana republic" corruption looks like.

[1] https://theintercept.com/2016/04/22/googles-remarkably-close...

[2] https://www.wsj.com/articles/inside-the-u-s-antitrust-probe-...

[3] https://www.wsj.com/articles/google-avoided-ftc-probe-but-ot...

[4] http://graphics.wsj.com/google-ftc-report/

Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by natalyarostova on Monday February 03, 2020 @06:05PM (#22230372)
I was always under the impression though that it was Obama who was courting Google, rather than Google trying to court Obama. Although the end result is perhaps the same.
Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by slg on Monday February 03, 2020 @06:10PM (#22230408)
Regardless of the truth of your accusations or validity of the fears presented by OP, it constantly amazes me that so many people genuinely react to these stories with "the other side does it too". Someone else doing something wrong is not a justification for you also doing something wrong. It is the type of excuse you expect from an elementary school child.
Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by cookiecaper on Monday February 03, 2020 @06:26PM (#22230522)
It's relevant in this case because the premise of the first comment is that this administration is particularly and uniquely unqualified to perform an investigation. It's comparative by nature, and therefore information about the disposition and behavior of other administrations is the relevant basis to determine whether the initial proposition is applicable.
Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by abvdasker on Monday February 03, 2020 @06:57PM (#22230765)
I would like to clarify that my comment was actually not explicitly comparative in nature. It did not mention a past or future administration. It did not mention the administration of a different country. If you disagree, please quote the part of my comment that makes a comparison to, well, anything.

What bothers me about this line of thinking is its suggestion that because corruption is common, observers and interested parties should do nothing about it and remain uncritical towards abuses of power.

In particular, it discourages criticism in partisan ways: "Your politicians did it so our politicians should be able to do it. Everyone is corrupt so what are you complaining about?" When partisan ideology normalizes corruption all you end up with is more corruption.

Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by chottocharaii on Monday February 03, 2020 @07:06PM (#22230846)
‘Normally I would say A, but I do not trust X so I will say B’

Is an implicit comparison between X & an unstated Y

Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by slg on Monday February 03, 2020 @07:45PM (#22231113)
The comparison is implicit. However the definition of Y is not. Assuming that Y must represent Democrats just because X represents Republicans is viewing the world in a binary and unnecessarily partisan way. Y could just as easy be some neutral, nonpartisan, or completely imaginary option dreamt up solely for the sake of comparison.
Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by lingvist on Monday February 03, 2020 @07:10PM (#22230865)
I agree with the sentiment. The delivery suffers:

1. Linguistically speaking, humans tend to save energy. Every utterance is designed to provide new information, to describe what is different from the norm. Going on a rant on how this administration suffers of problems a, b, and c, weakly implies that other administrations suffer much less of problems a, b, and c. Otherwise it would be common knowledge that all administrations suffers of problems a, b, and c roughly in the same degree, and why bother wasting time repeating common knowledge?

2. Arguments that focus specifically on one administration, carefully avoiding anything that could be construed as a negative reflecting onto opposing party administrations, come across as partisan. It is the hallmark of the USA media environment that most what we hear in the political news is technically true, but carefully curated to further one of the major two narratives. Also known as "information bubble". "Democrats: saviors, Republicans: evil" OR "Democrats: corrupt, Republicans: straightshooters".

If we truly are to move past partisan criticism, it is on us to fairly depict deplorable behavior on both side of the aisle, regardless of our own political leanings. Otherwise, we risk engaging in the usual half-blind partisan discourse that is tearing this country apart.

Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by Teknoman117 on Monday February 03, 2020 @07:07PM (#22230849)
I would argue there is some nuance to this - justifying your favorite politician(s) behavior by claiming the other side does it as well is an excuse you'd expect from a child.

However, when you claim that your own party is the bastion of righteousness and the only possible solution because the other party does bad things that you do as well, it undermines your argument.

Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by izacus on Monday February 03, 2020 @06:18PM (#22230466)
That's because having the rule of law in the modern world usually means that you're playing by the same rule book. If you allow one powerful player to do things the other can't, that's simply corruption. And our ex-socialist states have proven that that's fundamentally damaging to the country.

People fundamentally want government that's fair.

Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by notSupplied on Monday February 03, 2020 @08:09PM (#22231283)
Anti-trust hasn't changed much legislatively in the past few decades. While the laws haven’t changed much on paper, what’s changed is simply the level of enforcement. We still have the same laws that barred IBM from dominating personal computers (creating the opening for Microsoft) but we simply don’t pursue as much enforcement.

One problem with diminishing enforcement is that whenever you DO pursue enforcement action, it will inevitably look extremely political.

Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by AaronFriel on Monday February 03, 2020 @06:30PM (#22230557)
Corruption on "both sides" however is not fair, that's just more corruption. So the whataboutism present in the reply isn't an answer to a question about whether the current DOJ and Administration will act properly.
Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by eanzenberg on Monday February 03, 2020 @06:47PM (#22230686)
However, allowing corruption from only 1 side is vastly unfair especially through the lens of public perception.
Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by monoideism on Monday February 03, 2020 @07:05PM (#22230832)
I can't believe this is even up for discussion on HN.

Corruption is bad, period. There's no "someone else did it" get-out-of-jail card.

Also, why didn't we hear all these accusations of corruption against Obama during this presidency? I heard tons about Benghazi, and Fast and Furious, both of which were epic screw-ups that deserved a strong response, but nothing about this supposed corruption. I find it hard to believe that the GOP Congress was willing to let a little corruption go during the Obama presidency.

Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Monday February 03, 2020 @07:38PM (#22231070)
I am willing to agree. Corruption is bad for the population at large.

I even agree with the assessment that GOP during Obama years would certainly cry foul if there was even a perception of inapproriety. Frankly, it kinda was their job to be a check ( though I would argue that they failed then as well ).

There is a but coming. But, Obama had a decent team, which kept unapproved leaks from surfacing, had a cover from friendly media so even if there was something there, it was tightly held under wraps.

Now compare it to current administration where everyone is out to leverage their current position for something better in the future ( book deal, friendly energy company or just extra business for your daughter ).

I guess what I am saying is, Obama, HRC, Biden et al are just waaaaay better at covering their tracks.

Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by AaronFriel on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @01:50PM (#22239427)
The allegation was all out in the open then! The ouster of a Ukrainian Prosecutor General, the appointment of his son to a board of a Ukrainian company, all of it was public knowledge then!
Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by aguyfromnb on Monday February 03, 2020 @07:01PM (#22230789)
>so many people genuinely react to these stories with "the other side does it too".

As an outsider (I'm Canadian), it seems to me that the left-wing of America invented "whataboutism" because their hypocrisy is off the charts.

>It is the type of excuse you expect from an elementary school child.

The idea that you criticize someone for something you yourself are doing is something I'd expect of a child.

Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by monoideism on Monday February 03, 2020 @07:06PM (#22230841)
Who is "you yourself" in this analogy? The Obama administration?
Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by aguyfromnb on Monday February 03, 2020 @07:10PM (#22230864)
>Who is "you yourself" in this analogy?

Anyone crying "that's whataboutism!" in the face of their blatant hypocrisy.

I'm not talking about justifying corruption because the other guys do it. But I am talking about things like holding up bills, or filibusters, or whipping the vote, or leaking information, or any other of a multitude of things that one party always seems to lose their mind when it happens like it's never happened before.

One party uses something as a political strategy one year, then the next year cries foul like the Union is coming undone when the other side does the same thing. It's stupid.

Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by izacus on Monday February 03, 2020 @06:02PM (#22230354)
And now those were replaced with Trump taking pictures inside Apple plant with Tim Cook [1]. It seems that the game stayed the same, except that now another ultra-rich corp seems to be buying favor from the government.

It seems that pretty much all of the FAANG corps would require serious invesigation into their walled garden and anti-competitive practices to allow for smaller players to again enter the market and compete. Having a single search provider is extremely dangerous. As dangerous as having an OS where no 3rd party browsers can exist and no software without Tim's approval can run.

Edit: downvoters, mind explaining the reasoning?

[1]: https://www.forbes.com/sites/williamjeakle/2019/11/25/how-ap...

Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by throwaway13337 on Monday February 03, 2020 @05:24PM (#22229971)
Making this another polar political discussion would be shameful and unproductive for hacker news.
Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by rahuldottech on Monday February 03, 2020 @05:25PM (#22229984)
Tech and politics cannot always be separated. This appears to be one of those cases.
Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by dang on Monday February 03, 2020 @07:30PM (#22231009)
For sure they can't—but discussions don't need to degenerate into predictable partisan sniping. That stuff is always the same, so though it may be intense and exciting (to some), it's not intellectually interesting.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by creddit on Monday February 03, 2020 @05:25PM (#22229990)
This is an inherently political topic.
Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by AnimalMuppet on Monday February 03, 2020 @05:47PM (#22230207)
It is. The interesting part of the politics, though, is not how it intersects with the current president. There are much more interesting topics: Should Google be under investigation? For antitrust, I presume (and the article mentions), but anything else? What's the relation between the state AGs and the US DOJ in this?
Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by adrianmonk on Monday February 03, 2020 @06:22PM (#22230496)
It's even less hard to imagine when you consider Trump's own words from 2018:

> Google & others are suppressing voices of Conservatives and hiding information and news that is good. They are controlling what we can & cannot see. This is a very serious situation-will be addressed!

https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/10344562811202068...

Trump promised he'd take action against Google. Now action is being taken against Google. Maybe there's no connection, but Trump has given everyone a very good reason to suspect that there might be one.

Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by cookiecaper on Monday February 03, 2020 @06:33PM (#22230576)
Do we really trust that a politician who finds them helpful is not going to overlook certain misconduct that is politically beneficial (e.g., suppressing the statements of their major opponents)?

It's certainly not a forgone conclusion that investigations led by "friendlier" administrations are necessarily fairer. I doubt there's any way to have a purely unbiased investigation into an entity as prominent and influential as Google.

Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by newnewpdro on Monday February 03, 2020 @05:45PM (#22230190)
I don't think the threats of regulatory capture are unique to this administration.
Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by dariusm5 on Monday February 03, 2020 @05:24PM (#22229974)
Previous administrations have clearly abused their power with the DOJ, just look at how DACA was passed. Just because the large media outlets did PR for previous administrations or you agreed with their politics doesn't mean that abuses did not occur.
Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by tzs on Monday February 03, 2020 @05:33PM (#22230073)
DACA was a Presidential memorandum. What DOJ connection are you referring to?
Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by herbstein on Monday February 03, 2020 @06:03PM (#22230356)
Other comments have explained why DACA isn't an example of DOJ overreach. I'd like to take a magnifying glass to the underlying reason to bringing up DACA in this context.

It's an Obama-era policy that has been shown to have wide, bi-partisan support across the country. Bringing it up here is a means to say "Look, Obama also did bad stuff. You can't call Trump out on his bad stuff" which is an asinine way to frame anything.

It reminds me of an old conservative response to progressive/leftist ideas about American foreign policy.

Leftist: "... and that's why the current administration should be considered as war criminals" Conservative: "By that logic every administration since World War 2 were war criminals" Leftist: "Yes"

Whether or not the argument posed by the above comment is even valid is, for the purposes of this comment, irrelevant. What is more interesting is knowing why the supposed crimes/overreach of the Obama administration excuses the overreaches of the Trump administration.

Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by zweep on Monday February 03, 2020 @06:06PM (#22230385)
But in your war criminals dialogue, the “Yes” from the leftist provides cover to compress all administrations on the dimension of war crimes, dismissing LBJ/Nixon/GWB by saying “Carter was a war criminal too.”
Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by BubRoss on Monday February 03, 2020 @05:28PM (#22230015)
He didn't say previous abuses didn't occur, he said he doesn't trust this administration to not have ulterior selfish political motives.

Edit: Also, poor form or not, I see the same patterns here as I do on threads about china and the people that took over bitcoin - votes up in increments, then all comments are downvoted multiple times in batches. That and lots of whataboutism.

Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by ngold on Monday February 03, 2020 @05:35PM (#22230090)
The classic "But what about...look over there...this is normal...nothing to see here...move along now. "
Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by BubRoss on Monday February 03, 2020 @05:48PM (#22230227)
Yes, that's whataboutism and what I was replying to. Instead of saying why the current administration can be trusted to not have ulterior motives, someone says 'other people also abused their position'. This isn't about comparison, it's about the motives of this move.
Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by 3fe9a03ccd14ca5 on Monday February 03, 2020 @05:43PM (#22230169)
I think I feel the opposite. To me, Barr (and Durham) represent really good news for legal reform in the FISA courts. The fact that these courts, non-adversarial by design, can spy the way they have is really troubling, let alone on an incoming and present administration. I hope there's strong reform here. Transparency is the only way forward.

When secret FISA courts were first introduced, I'm sure many people wondered how long it would take before they're used illegally, for political purposes...

I guess it's just the sign of the times that two people, probably relatively similar in most regards, can have precisely opposite feelings.

Re:Justice Department meeting state AG offices Tuesday to di... by AaronFriel on Monday February 03, 2020 @06:39PM (#22230627)
Your belief about Barr is fundamentally incompatible with Barr's belief about Barr. The real Attorney General, in words and in deeds, favors a unitary executive who, by dint of national security argument, has almost unlimited power including the ability to spy on anyone they please.

While you may believe he is taking on the FISA court, and there are abuses there to fix, by Barr's own admission he doesn't seem to think there are any restraints on an Executive's power in the realms of national security or foreign policy. It seems to me the motivation around FISA is strongly motivated not by sincere belief in the limitations of executive authority, but because of a sense that they (read: the President) were wronged.

When Attorney General William Barr spoke to the Federalist Society in a memorial lecture just a few months ago[1] he lamented the transparency Congress has forced upon the Executive, "There is no FOIA for Congress or the Courts. Yet Congress has happily created a regime that allows the public to seek whatever documents it wants from the Executive Branch at the same time that individual congressional committees spend their days trying to publicize the Executive’s internal decisional process. That process cannot function properly if it is public, nor is it productive to have our government devoting enormous resources to squabbling about what becomes public and when, rather than doing the work of the people."

Barr then attacked the judicial branch directly, claiming they are "encroaching on Executive responsibilities in a way that has substantially undercut the functioning of the Presidency" and in particular, those darned judges keep finding that they can review the acts of the Executive! Isn't that frustrating?

He writes in such an example: "Courts are now willing, under the banner of judicial review, to substitute their judgment for the President’s on matters that only a few decades ago would have been unimaginable – such as matters involving national security or foreign affairs.

"The Travel Ban case is a good example. There the President made a decision under an explicit legislative grant of authority, as well has his Constitutional national security role, to temporarily suspend entry to aliens coming from a half dozen countries pending adoption of more effective vetting processes."

Do you think that a surveillance state reformed by Barr would really rein in the courts, or simply remove them from the picture?

[1] - https://www.justice.gov/opa/speech/attorney-general-william-...