News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hard negotiations: why a softer approach yields better ou... by lbj on Monday February 03, 2020 @03:24AM (#22222406)
This matches my experience perfectly, both in salary and contract negotiations. You get a long way with smile and a focus on the core: We both want to do something together.

> We don't allow you to work on your own projects while working for us

"Completely unacceptable. Im a free soul and I demand my freedom!"

Compared to

> We don't allow you to work on your own projects while working for us

"I perfectly understand, no need to invite competition or leak ideas, however in my experience you'll actually benefit from XYZ and I'd be happy to ..."

My intuition is, that as long as the talk is progressing in a pleasant manner, you're inching towards your goal.

Re:Hard negotiations: why a softer approach yields better ou... by Normal_gaussian on Monday February 03, 2020 @04:04AM (#22222578)
Unless they use your easy going cooperativeness to run you in circles, endlessly delaying something they don't want to happen. Or constantly delivering only a token amount of their side of any compromise deal to cause re-compromises etc.

Sometimes soft negotiations have to turn to hard negotiations. In fact, I would argue that the potential to turn into a hard negotiation - but not yet being such - is a key factor in making soft negotiations work.

Re:Hard negotiations: why a softer approach yields better ou... by Madmallard on Monday February 03, 2020 @04:18AM (#22222644)
In my experience if it's not a point they are actually flexible on they will 100% do this no matter how charismatic you try to be.
Re:Hard negotiations: why a softer approach yields better ou... by chasd00 on Monday February 03, 2020 @08:45AM (#22224047)
very true, being nice gets you very far but it can also lead to you turning into a doormat. The trick is seeing it coming and changing the discussion appropriately. I had a boss that was an expert at this, he was all smiles and sunshine with vendors until they started to take advantage. At that point, they found they were negotiating with a calculator on the sum of 2+2.
Re:Hard negotiations: why a softer approach yields better ou... by jacobush on Monday February 03, 2020 @04:24AM (#22222668)
Speak softly and carry a big stick.
Re:Hard negotiations: why a softer approach yields better ou... by theelous3 on Monday February 03, 2020 @04:59AM (#22222836)
Sure, but in employment post salary negotiation your only (or at least biggest) big stick is leaving. For many people that's a... double edged stick, to stretch the analogy.

There's not many sticks to emolpy unless you're unionised or otherwise have strong networking in the company.

Re:Hard negotiations: why a softer approach yields better ou... by TheBobinator on Monday February 03, 2020 @07:36AM (#22223584)
I've seen sales guys intentionally leak information to the competititon in order to try to push a company they were working for out of business so they could get out of their non-compete contract and go after more lucrative employment at a competitor. I've also seen them sabotage a company just out of spite.

Your biggest stick is actually flipping the table and doing something that seriously damages the company or puts it out of business. Comitting actual crimes like embezzlement, theft, or damaging company equipment for which you are not caught are also great sticks.

Of course, nobody likes to talk about that, they find it too high minded, but all to often that is what goes on behind closed doors. The root cause of it is a mal-formed, unfair compensation policy.

Classic example is Small business Sole Proprietorships where the ownership passes their purchases through the company and plays accounting games to hide profitability from their staff. The staff are always told "work harder to make the profits go up we'll reward you", nobody gets to see the balance sheet so the profit number they are given is fundementally hidden and there's no end of excuses as to why the business can't pay those market wages or big bonuses. Then one day the ownership sells, new ownership cleans house, and we repeat.

They'll negotiate just fine, make verbal promises, but at the end of the day there's a scam going on.

And when people feel scammed, then they do the aboved illegal\immoral crap and make the place a totally messed up place to work.

Re:Hard negotiations: why a softer approach yields better ou... by eru on Monday February 03, 2020 @07:05AM (#22223452)
Well, the company doesn't really have that many sticks either, once you are in.

They can fire you, and they can delay advancement.

(Btw, you have an implicit stick about not working with as much motivation.)

Re:Hard negotiations: why a softer approach yields better ou... by gowld on Monday February 03, 2020 @08:01AM (#22223728)
This is something employers are terrible at understanding. Employees in professional roles have tremendous ability to waste employer resources or underdeliver value. Nickel-and-diming employees is self-destructive, unless the employer is excellent at hiring desperate weak-willed employees... like naive college students and people pinned under H1B.
Re:Hard negotiations: why a softer approach yields better ou... by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Monday February 03, 2020 @08:37AM (#22223997)
I am not sure that is true. My most recent conversation with my boss' boss made it clear that he was concerned them not meeting my needs money-wise would result lower motivation. He made a whole speech about bringing his best every day and we were not there to discuss motivation.

Management is well aware of what might happen. Financial incentives, however, are aligned with keeping costs as low as possible. And you are seen as cost. Even when you bring money in.

That means unless you have an offer on the table, ability to waste time is a secondary consideration.

For the record, I agree about the ability to waste time. I don't agree with assessment that management does not get it. They just act in their own short term interest.

Re:Hard negotiations: why a softer approach yields better ou... by eru on Monday February 03, 2020 @08:30AM (#22223952)
Re:Hard negotiations: why a softer approach yields better ou... by theelous3 on Wednesday February 05, 2020 @06:26AM (#22245858)
> not working with as much motivation

That's the equivalent of hitting myself and my employer, just hitting them a little harder.

If I'm lazing around, I'm bored and not progressing as a developer. I don't know if you've ever had a job where you do nothing or very little, but it's torture. Plus, you run the risk of getting sticked right back for underperforming.

Re:Hard negotiations: why a softer approach yields better ou... by ReptileMan on Monday February 03, 2020 @05:09AM (#22222879)
Timing is critical. If you are crucial to a project and threaten to leave while deadline looms and cost the company couple of million - then they will be flexible.
Re:Hard negotiations: why a softer approach yields better ou... by ChuckNorris89 on Monday February 03, 2020 @05:33AM (#22222981)
Be careful with that though as it will only work once and you might not last long there after that.

While the company might give you what you ask for this one time, they will feel blackmalied and will see you as a flight risk, ready to leave for greener pastures at any moment anyway, so they'll prepare themselves by restricting your access to promotions, trainings and critical work so you don't pull that stunt again and slowly reduce its dependency on you and you could soon find yourself training your future replacements. It's all 101 in the HR handbook.

Try it, but only as long as you always have an exit planned.

Re:Hard negotiations: why a softer approach yields better ou... by plapetomain on Monday February 03, 2020 @08:11AM (#22223802)
> While the company might give you what you ask for this one time, they will feel blackmalied and will see you as a flight risk, ready to leave for greener pastures at any moment anyway, so they'll prepare themselves by restricting your access to promotions, trainings and critical work so you don't pull that stunt again and slowly reduce its dependency on you

This is a pretty reliable trope. I feel like I hear this every time someone mentions putting the screws to their employer. Yet I have yet to see it borne out by evidence.

It sounds scary. In practice I have never experienced it.

The reality is that institutional memory at most institutions is so fleeting that this above threat has never become an issue in practice.

Mind you in all cases I’ve always been prepared to walk, so that’s something to keep in mind, but I’ve never experienced worse treatment for leveraging what scraps I have. It’s pretty much been the opposite. Once I have that promotion by whatever means, magically I’m treated better. It has never failed.

Re:Hard negotiations: why a softer approach yields better ou... by watwut on Monday February 03, 2020 @04:54AM (#22222813)
> My intuition is, that as long as the talk is progressing in a pleasant manner, you're inching towards your goal.

Not in my experience. Plenty of people able to progress talk in super pleasant manner without moving from their original position. Or to pleasantly promis and then conveniently forget that. Or most often, to make it sound like they agree, make vague pleasant statements that mean nothing.

Re:Hard negotiations: why a softer approach yields better ou... by Proziam on Monday February 03, 2020 @05:37AM (#22223000)
This sounds like a process issue to me. If you document what was discussed as it happens ("Just to confirm, you're happy with X?) and have a record of that (actually recording a conversation, with everyone's approval of course) is a good way to keep everyone honest.

That's not to say you can't have a dishonest counterpart - they certainly do happen. But in my experience when there's an issue like you described above there is fault to be found on both sides of the table. Leaving your notes visible in some form during a chat is another way to solve this. By having it written and in plain view it suddenly becomes much harder for the other party to come back later and say 'well I didn't actually agree to...'

Re:Hard negotiations: why a softer approach yields better ou... by watwut on Monday February 03, 2020 @07:07AM (#22223458)
That requires power I don't have. And I can not reasonably demand to record conversations with local management. And no matter how much notes I write to myself, the management simply does not care, because I don't have power to force them to follow own words. Visible notes do nothing if couterpart does not mind being dishonest or worst treats notes is being rude. (Not working in that worst group anymore, but it played in dishonest way with multiple people.)

Dishonest people set up process and culture so that it is easy to be dishonest. They do happen quite often. And it is not fault of people who are being intentionally lied to.

Re:Hard negotiations: why a softer approach yields better ou... by magicalhippo on Monday February 03, 2020 @08:24AM (#22223912)
Clearly it's rather different to negotiate when you're in a symmetric relationship vs an asymmetric relationship.

What Proziam mentioned "[if] they don't take a fair deal when offered, be prepared to walk away" doesn't work if walking away means not eating for the next week, for example.

Re:Hard negotiations: why a softer approach yields better ou... by lbj on Monday February 03, 2020 @05:51AM (#22223058)
I should have added a better explanation. Im not saying you shouldn't negotiate hard, Im saying keep a vibe of optimism and friendliness, remembering why you're there in the first place. Make sure every concession is written down and signed directly following the meeting. Be prepared to pull the plug if the negotation is not headed in the direction you want and dont be afraid to let the other party know if they're crossing that line where it's no longer an acceptable deal for you.
Re:Hard negotiations: why a softer approach yields better ou... by irateswami on Monday February 03, 2020 @08:47AM (#22224055)
If a company ever told me I cannot work on other things in my personal time, I would promptly tell them to suck on a rock and walk out. You can't negotiate with asinine people/corporations with asinine policies. If they feel comfortable telling you what you can and cannot do on your own time, imagine what they feel comfortable telling you to do while you're working.
Re:Hard negotiations: why a softer approach yields better ou... by astura on Monday February 03, 2020 @08:58AM (#22224124)
It's not as "asinine" as it seems at first glance.

https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2016/12/09/developers-side-pr...

Re:Hard negotiations: why a softer approach yields better ou... by irateswami on Monday February 03, 2020 @09:04AM (#22224162)
Telling someone they can't do projects on their own time is a different question than the ownership of said projects.