My own post is a bit cheeky to make fun of it, but if I can deter the flames a bit early on, I’ll take the potential hit.
EDIT: The real question is why is it such a religious war? I believe, perhaps incorrectly, that people put a lot of value on their weight. When that weight gets too high, anything that lowers that weight becomes inherently virtuous to the individual. Any nay-saying against that virtuous something becomes an attack against something that they value, something that increased their perception of themselves.
Someone convinced of Keto’s efficacy will not believe you when you say “I tried that, I gained weight”. Instead, you’re just not doing it right.
Someone convinced of the effacy of fasting won’t believe a claim of “I stayed the same weight”. Instead, you “must be lying”.
Someone convinced you’re just lazy will call it all excuses.
It’s just not worth the effort. Even here.