News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Weight Loss Is Harder Than Rocket Science by falcolas on Sunday February 02, 2020 @06:25PM (#22220179)
A preview of coming attractions in this thread:

- Weight loss isn't hard, just eat fewer calories than you burn.

- Keto will obviously make you lose weight!

- I lost N lbs by meditation and intermittent fasting!

- Being hungry sucks.

- Anybody can do it, this one trainer put on 100 lbs, and then took it all off again!

- Being fat is just another sign that you're lazy.

- It's sugar's fault! (Alternatively: It's artificial sweetener's fault!)

- A vegan diet will make you lose weight.

I'll get us started: Being in a caloric deficiency for weeks or months is one of the most miserable experiences you can have. Constant hunger, no energy, always hangry... Yeah. Being hungry sucks.

Re:Weight Loss Is Harder Than Rocket Science by patrickaljord on Sunday February 02, 2020 @06:42PM (#22220275)
Ok, I'll start too.

I've lost 10kg recently and it's true that the most important factor is calorie deficit. I've been doing keto for the most part, but even on my cheat days when I ate more carbs than I should I was still losing weight as long as I had a calorie deficit. I find keto easier for me because fat helps with satiety but if you get satiety with just low fat high carb more power to you.

And yes, no matter the diet, dropping sugar and sweeteners is some of the things that will help the most. Intermittent fasting does help a lot and working out helps cut hunger the most (and so does intermittent fasting after a while, I haven't had a morning breakfast in months and not feeling hungry until lunch).

Re:Weight Loss Is Harder Than Rocket Science by taeric on Sunday February 02, 2020 @06:53PM (#22220338)
I also managed to lose about that much.

Wasn't as hard as I imagined it would be. Hardest part, by far, war not going somewhere I could see the other foods I used to eat. Basically, marketing works. Really well. So find ways to avoid it.

No, that isn't easy. Just I am at a weight I never thought I would be again. It is doable.

Re:Weight Loss Is Harder Than Rocket Science by cyphar on Sunday February 02, 2020 @06:39PM (#22220255)
Yes, being in a caloric defecit (relative to your previous normal) is hard. Most lifestyle changes are. Anyone who tells you different is lying to you. But it doesn't need to be excruciating, and if you plan around the foods you like to eat you can even end up enjoying it after a while.

The simplest solution is to eat less calorically dense foods -- hunger is partially determined by the volume of food you eat. As an extreme example, 1kg of broccoli has 340 calories -- there's no way you could be physically hungry if you ate that quantity of food for each meal. You shouldn't just eat broccoli (of course) but it's a motivating example of how minor food choices (double your portion of fibrous vegetables, and halve your portion of starchy carbohydrates) can impact your overall diet. Not to mention that fibrous carbohydrates are more satiating than starchy carbohydrates (the latter usually make you more hungry).

Not to mention there are lots of ways to massively reduce the amount of calories in food you commonly eat (though this does require you to cook your own food).

Also, for the love of all that is holy -- drink more water. The vast majority of people are dehydrated (your urine should be almost entirely clear, not yellow) and misinterpret thirst for hunger. Water doesn't have any calories.

Re:Weight Loss Is Harder Than Rocket Science by loceng on Sunday February 02, 2020 @06:45PM (#22220289)
You didn't mention fasting (non-intermittent) so I'll leave this video here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tIuj-oMN-Fk - "Dr. Jason Fung - 'Therapeutic Fasting - Solving the Two-Compartment Problem'"
Re:Weight Loss Is Harder Than Rocket Science by alfonsodev on Sunday February 02, 2020 @06:31PM (#22220213)
I’ll contribute with another classic remark ”muscle weights more than fat, you should burn fat not lose weight”
Re:Weight Loss Is Harder Than Rocket Science by AmericanChopper on Sunday February 02, 2020 @06:52PM (#22220329)
Is this supposed to be controversial? It’s very easy for people to trick themselves by not accounting for that if all they’re tracking is weight. Either through losing muscle mass and thinking they’re losing fat, or more commonly through gaining muscle mass and thinking their exercise effort isn’t working.
Re:Weight Loss Is Harder Than Rocket Science by alfonsodev on Sunday February 02, 2020 @07:10PM (#22220416)
It wasn’t meant to be controversial, It’s one of the few things that are very easy to prove right, I mentioned it as a frequent comment so that it would be predictable that someone would pick up on the title saying “weight loss is harder than” should be “burning fat is harder than...” assuming we are playing to predict picky comments.
Re:Weight Loss Is Harder Than Rocket Science by rorykoehler on Sunday February 02, 2020 @06:50PM (#22220315)
Your last comment is why keto works quite well. It removes the insulin spikes and with it the energy troughs. The other reason I'm convinced keto works great is that it helps rebalance your microbiome. This is all from personal experience using Viome to measure effects however I wasnt using it for weight loss, that was just an (undesired for me) side effect. It should also be noted that a significant amount of weight loss from keto is actually water loss.
Re:Weight Loss Is Harder Than Rocket Science by ceratopisan on Sunday February 02, 2020 @07:37PM (#22220504)
I don't think I'll ever need to read one of these threads again, now.
Re:Weight Loss Is Harder Than Rocket Science by Gibbon1 on Sunday February 02, 2020 @08:24PM (#22220711)
Me.

- Something is terrible wrong on a global scale. Because we and especially children didn't suddenly _all_ become lazy sedentary face stuffing slobs in the last 40 years.

Re:Weight Loss Is Harder Than Rocket Science by AmericanChopper on Sunday February 02, 2020 @07:06PM (#22220403)
Weight loss might be hard, but it absolutely is not complicated. Perhaps the metabolic processes are, but it does really boil down to calories in/calories out, and absolutely no amount of contrivance can change that.

Life is also typically full of adversity and hardship, and managing weight is a hardship that all people share, regardless of their status. Perhaps “lazy” is a bit reductive, and everybody’s circumstance are different, but if somebody is overweight, the solution is simply to put in the effort that somebody who is not overweight puts in every day.

Re:Weight Loss Is Harder Than Rocket Science by acdha on Sunday February 02, 2020 @09:38PM (#22220985)
> Life is also typically full of adversity and hardship, and managing weight is a hardship that all people share, regardless of their status. Perhaps “lazy” is a bit reductive, and everybody’s circumstance are different, but if somebody is overweight, the solution is simply to put in the effort that somebody who is not overweight puts in every day.

“Effort” isn’t quite enough here: a huge factor is lifestyle related and many people have significant barriers which are hard to change: moving to a neighborhood which makes walking/biking/transit viable is often an expensive choice and almost always disruptive. Most of the 20th century was spent getting people to sit in cars, at desks, etc. and it’s not trivial to change that.

Re:Weight Loss Is Harder Than Rocket Science by AmericanChopper on Sunday February 02, 2020 @10:04PM (#22221085)
> moving to a neighborhood which makes walking/biking/transit viable is often an expensive choice and almost always disruptive

Pretty weak excuse tbh. You don’t need a gym membership or a scenic park across the street to get enough exercise into your day. There are valid reasons to reserve judgement, but this isn’t one of them. Mental health arguably is. Poverty can be in a couple of ways. The cheapest food is often very unhealthy, and if you’re working for 16 hours a day then you likely have less opportunity to eat healthily (for example look at how ~60% of nurses are overweight, compared to ~40% of the general population). But for most cases, the key personality difference between an overweight person and a healthy weight person is laziness.

Re:Weight Loss Is Harder Than Rocket Science by kohtatsu on Sunday February 02, 2020 @09:03PM (#22220858)
Your comment is still reductive. I don't put in any effort; I get away with not paying much mind to my diet, and not working out. I'm not overweight despite consuming more sugar than I should at work, and mostly consisting on milks (cow, goat, soy, coconut) and oatmeal.
Re:Weight Loss Is Harder Than Rocket Science by AmericanChopper on Sunday February 02, 2020 @09:31PM (#22220962)
> I don't put in any effort

Yes you do. Taking the rest of your comment at face value, there’s no way that you chow down on unhealthy food at any time and in any quantity you please. Your examples of unhealthy food (milk and oatmeal) are also not very unhealthy. You might say “but I have no desire to eat unhealthy food”, and while that would most certainly not be true, you likely have less of an appetite for it than somebody who’s overweight. But if a person who over eats unhealthy food fixed their diet, their excessive appetite would return to normal after a while. That’s simply part of settling the debt for all their accumulated poor health decisions.

You also likely exercise more than a typical overweight person. I personally think it’s no effort at all to walk reasonably short distances to do things like run errands or go to a restaurant, but for somebody who lives a sedentary lifestyle, that could potentially be considered a unacceptably significant effort.

You may consider the effort to be trivial, but any person who’s not overweight does some combination or eating less calories/exercising more than any person who is overweight.

Re:Weight Loss Is Harder Than Rocket Science by kohtatsu on Sunday February 02, 2020 @09:55PM (#22221050)
I do eat a lot of sweets (cookies, coffee cake, etc), probably one a day, and the milk I drink is often with some syrup; I work at a cafe.

Drinks are free so I'll drink a handful day to save money; sometimes with half-and-half or heavy cream.

I do get a bit of exercise making drinks, but otherwise I drive everywhere and don't walk, though I'd like to start. I imagine my weight is thanks to a combination of my height, metabolism, and not eating proper meals. (I cook with my girlfriend every now and again)

Re:Weight Loss Is Harder Than Rocket Science by AmericanChopper on Sunday February 02, 2020 @10:15PM (#22221141)
One portion of sweets per day and some syrup in your coffee is far less than “a lot”. This is also the first time I’ve ever heard of a seated role in for working a cafe.
Re:Weight Loss Is Harder Than Rocket Science by xxs on Sunday February 02, 2020 @06:31PM (#22220216)
That's not reddit, though...
Re:Weight Loss Is Harder Than Rocket Science by falcolas on Sunday February 02, 2020 @06:43PM (#22220277)
I honestly wish that these kinds of remarks were limited to reddit. They’re not. Folks even here can get in ridiculous religious wars about weight management and dieting.

My own post is a bit cheeky to make fun of it, but if I can deter the flames a bit early on, I’ll take the potential hit.

EDIT: The real question is why is it such a religious war? I believe, perhaps incorrectly, that people put a lot of value on their weight. When that weight gets too high, anything that lowers that weight becomes inherently virtuous to the individual. Any nay-saying against that virtuous something becomes an attack against something that they value, something that increased their perception of themselves.

Re:Weight Loss Is Harder Than Rocket Science by eska on Sunday February 02, 2020 @06:51PM (#22220321)
You're not really contributing to a better discussion environment with your attitude. How about you post rebuttals instead of a snide remark?
Re:Weight Loss Is Harder Than Rocket Science by falcolas on Sunday February 02, 2020 @06:57PM (#22220354)
Because rebuttals will do nothing. From my past experience here offering rebuttals and considerate arguments, this definitely falls in the category of “rejecting that which doesn’t fit their world view”.

Someone convinced of Keto’s efficacy will not believe you when you say “I tried that, I gained weight”. Instead, you’re just not doing it right.

Someone convinced of the effacy of fasting won’t believe a claim of “I stayed the same weight”. Instead, you “must be lying”.

Someone convinced you’re just lazy will call it all excuses.

It’s just not worth the effort. Even here.

Re:Weight Loss Is Harder Than Rocket Science by eska on Monday February 03, 2020 @05:15AM (#22222907)
If you think you can't have a discussion here to the extent that you don't even want one anymore, then it's probably better if you stop posting. Being serious here.
Re:Weight Loss Is Harder Than Rocket Science by rorykoehler on Sunday February 02, 2020 @06:57PM (#22220351)
Your post reads like "these are all the things recommended that I haven't tried but I'm going to shit on them anyways because I think I'll be hungry all the time". As your conclusion is way off the mark which invalidates the rest of your post. Even if you cut sugar and sweeteners and didn't lose weight you'd still notice a marked health improvement. Processed food western diet is absolutely terrible for your health.
Re:Weight Loss Is Harder Than Rocket Science by BubRoss on Sunday February 02, 2020 @06:38PM (#22220251)
Mark me down for sugar's fault and that sugar should be thought of as an addiction for people who are obese.