China does get credit for responding to the situation as they did after the central government got involved. However, we must remember that the situation would likely not have occurred in the first place if the people speaking out about it early on weren't punished, which wouldn't happen in most western countries as local governments have way less power and way less incentives to make that kind of thing happen. This situation is a good example of the problems of their authoritarian system, and a good reminder of why we value (or why we should value) the things we value in the West, like free speech.
I'm not saying the Chinese government doesn't have problems, nor am I saying free speech is bad, but I have no idea how you could come to this conclusion that free speech would somehow limit the spread of this disease. We have free speech in the US and that's literally led to the rise of anti inoculation advocacy.
Check out this video for the banquet: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6kft21UdBFI
In this particular instance, early warning would have gained precious days if not weeks to study and respond to the disease. In an emergency, every second counts, but the saving face mentality of the Communist Party cost weeks.
> We have free speech in the US and that's literally led to the rise of anti inoculation advocacy.
Even if you were right, that would have absolutely no bearing on the situation at hand.
Also, if any situation explodes, would the west be as capable in quarantining a huge urban population or building a quick hospital?
Would emergency aid be tossed around like a political game?
Due to the way China's government has lied in the past, I am hesitant to believe their numbers or their narrative until it can be confirmed by outside parties.
You say "didn't act swiftly". What is swift to you? A month went by since the first case before they started getting their act together, true, but how quickly do you think other nations could have acted? Compared to SARS, where it took them months, 1 month is a major improvement. It's still not good enough because the virus is that ruthless, but Rome isn't built in one day. I have reason to believe that they've learned a great deal from how SARS was handled, and that they'll respond even better in a future outbreak event.
This would then extend to academia as well, since most research is in some way funded by the state.
[0]: I know they have lied more than once. I'm not sure what a more appropriate word would have been.
I would not trust a political party’s economy numbers without external verification, however, because a party has an incentive to lie.
I can only speak for my country (France), but the precedent of the AIDS epidemic and particularly that of contaminated blood transfusion makes it pretty clear that any government official caught having lied in such a situation would be in deep trouble. And I'm pretty sure they're all keenly aware of that.
But it is not that they have once lied that it is a problem. It is instead, that just right now, a couple weeks ago, china was arresting journalists for this stuff.
If you want to say that we should ignore bad behavior from 20 years ago, because it is no longer relevant, thats fine. But we are not talking about stuff from 20 years ago. We are instead talking about behavior that china does all the time, right now.
If it takes time to act it is because the system causes this failure.
If the government acts swiftly, it is because they are in panic.
If it does not solve the situation, of course because they have a terrible oppressive culture.
If the problem is fixed. Of course, because these are one of the few advantages of having an authoritarian system.
No matter what China does, you will say something bad.
I know this makes me sound like CCP shill, but I am not. I only want to read an assessment made with the same level of rigour and sympathy, if, instead of China was Denmark or Australia.