News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by xkjkls on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @06:45PM (#22187310)
Tesla still lost $800 million this year and has never had a profitable year, on both record car sales and record regulatory credit sales. What about that indicates sustainability?
Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by jussij on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @11:56PM (#22188963)
The financial results from the link don't show a $800 million loss for this year.

From that document in the FINANCIAL SUMMARY section there are these quarterly profit/loss number:

    Income (loss) from operations 
    Q1-2019  Q2-2019  Q3-2019   Q4-2019  
       -522     -167      261       359
So for the first half of the year Tesla did lose 689 million dollars.

But for the whole year that was only a loss of 69 million dollars.

I think what the market likes is the Tesla cash position.

If you look at those it would appear Tesla is no longer burning cash.

    Cash and cash equivalents 
    Q4-2018   Q1-2019  Q2-2019  Q3-2019   Q4-2019  QoQ   YoY
    3,686     2,198    4,955    5,338     6,268    17%   70%
The fact that the year on year cash position grew by 70% would be pretty comforting to shareholders.
Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by xkjkls on Thursday January 30, 2020 @12:14AM (#22189045)
You’re using non-GAAP numbers. By GAAP standards, they lost $800 million
Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by blaser-waffle on Thursday January 30, 2020 @09:44AM (#22191569)
LOL, it was ONLY ~$70 million.

How does this stack up to last year, and forecasts for next year? If they were in the hole $120MM last year and now only 69, with forecasts for ~20MM or less next year then there is a clear road to profitability and I might be willing to do the Long thing.

Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by trhway on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @06:53PM (#22187389)
$800M loss on $25B sales (which are growing YoY while R&D actually resulting in new models and features is maintained stable) is a noise at this point.
Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by neosat on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @07:00PM (#22187455)
Agree. Given the growth numbers and their market leadership in the EV area, there's a strong case to be made that this 'loss' is more of an 'investment' to set up for future revenue growth and consequently profits that come with increasing maturity and operational cost reductions.
Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by xkjkls on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @07:03PM (#22187473)
They have shrunk in sales YoY in the US and Norway, their two largest markets. They managed to grow globally by finding the most advantageous subsidies for them to take advantage of. However, even that only gave them 1% growth of the past year.
Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by woodandsteel on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @07:15PM (#22187579)
The low growth was because of production problems and because they maxed out their single factory. Now they have another factory producing and a third under construction.

As to subsidies, governments are pushing ev's harder and harder. The EU has continually-increasing fleet standards that can be met only by adding more ev's, and China has continually increasing ev production standards. Ev sales are going to keep increasing, and Tesla makes the best ev's. Sales, revenues and profits are going to keep going up.

Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by xkjkls on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @07:26PM (#22187662)
Why were they able to meet a run rate or 500k cars a year in Q4 of last year and not sustain it if their factory was maxed out? And why would they claim in projections that their factory was capable of producing that if they didn’t meet that?

Companies are rarely production constrained. Many claim they are, but the fact that Tesla sales in their two largest markets declined doesn’t indicate to me that production is their number one issue.

Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by woodandsteel on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @07:40PM (#22187761)
At 500k per year they were still nowhere near meeting global demand, and they decided to move sales away from markets they were already well-established in, and into new ones.

The nice thing about this disagreement we are having is it will be settled by what happens in the next year. I say Tesla's sales will go up strongly now that it has another factory. I take it you think they won't, and all that new capacity will go unsold.

Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by xeromal on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:10PM (#22188284)
You're spot on with everything. I think the biggest hitch this year will be China. That is such a huge market
Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by xkjkls on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @11:53PM (#22188940)
Again they produced 367k, not 500k, like they claimed they could. If they could produce 500k, why claim they could, and why didn’t they?

And I would say Tesla’s revenue growth will start to flatline, yes, as the last two quarters have shown.

Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by woodandsteel on Thursday January 30, 2020 @09:56PM (#22198574)
Their production capacity increased in every quarter. By the end of the year it was at a 500k per year rate. And it is continuing to go up rapidly, now that it has a new factory.
Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by xkjkls on Sunday February 02, 2020 @03:22PM (#22219187)
Did it? They only produced a small number more than they did per quarter at the end of last year. Why do we think they are production constrained?
Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by xkjkls on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @07:01PM (#22187464)
R&D isn’t even meeting depreciation though. Either these factories are some how never before seen in accounting history or this company is underinvesting in its futures
Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by zaroth on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:34PM (#22188124)
Actually there’s a third option which has been discussed on their financial calls.

Their capital efficiency has markedly increased.

To put it less glamorously, they burned boatloads of money chasing “alien dreadnaught” style fully automated production, and after recognizing that failure (better late than never) they now find they are able to build out new production lines at a fraction of the first line’s cost.

Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by DarmokJalad1701 on Thursday January 30, 2020 @12:03AM (#22189001)
If you look at their letter you can see a comparison between the layouts of their California and Shanghai factories. Massive difference in efficiency. They learned a lot from their initial debacle of Model 3 ramp-up. Cap-ex per unit was announced as being 65% lower in the China factory.
Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by QuantumGood on Thursday January 30, 2020 @07:39AM (#22190897)
65% lower cap-ex per unit in China is astonishing. Elon's "machine that builds the machine" vision really created a lot of misprioritization.
Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by xkjkls on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @11:56PM (#22188957)
Maybe. My bet is that they have been underinvesting in order to meet financial results, and that that will catch up to them. Looking at other financial statement history, this seems like a safe bet.
Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by woodandsteel on Thursday January 30, 2020 @09:58PM (#22198580)
It is really hard to say they are underinvesting when they just opened a new factory and have a new vehicle, the Y, that just started production.
Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by xkjkls on Sunday February 02, 2020 @03:23PM (#22219193)
It’s really hard to ever say a company is properly investing if their CapEx on their income statements exceeds their depreciation. Can you name other fast growing companies that is true for?
Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by woodandsteel on Sunday February 02, 2020 @06:40PM (#22220264)
I don't understand enough about financials to understand what you are saying.

But more to the point, what exactly do you think Tesla should have been spending its money on that it didn't?

And let add to my original comment that Tesla also has the Semi going into production later this year, and recently brought out a greatly improved version of its solar roof, and is working like crazy on self-driving.

But back to my question: what should it have been spending its money on that it didn't?

Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by xkjkls on Monday February 03, 2020 @02:42PM (#22228113)
> I don't understand enough about financials to understand what you are saying.

Capital Expenditures are what a company spends on land, buildings, equipment -- all of those sort of long term assets. Depreciation is how much the value of those assets decline over time with usage and would eventually require maintenance or repair costs.

Usually, when depreciation exceeds CapEx, it means the company isn't spending enough to maintain their current assets, and this will eventually catch up to them. For growing companies investing in the future, CapEx is usually a great deal more than depreciation, since there will be a large amount spent on future assets.

> But more to the point, what exactly do you think Tesla should have been spending its money on that it didn't?

> And let add to my original comment that Tesla also has the Semi going into production later this year, and recently brought out a greatly improved version of its solar roof, and is working like crazy on self-driving.

> But back to my question: what should it have been spending its money on that it didn't?

My point is that the PR statements that Tesla releases don't match the financials. It's easy to announce that a factory is being built or a new car is going into production, but we should be extremely skeptical of these statements when they aren't backed up by audited financial information.

Generally when investing in a company you should look at their financials first, as they are going to be the most honest, and PR statements/rumors last, as they will be the least honest.

Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by woodandsteel on Tuesday February 04, 2020 @07:51PM (#22242935)
>My point is that the PR statements that Tesla releases don't match the financials. It's easy to announce that a factory is being built or a new car is going into production, but we should be extremely skeptical of these statements when they aren't backed up by audited financial information.

Oh dear, are you saying that Tesla did not actually recently open a new factory in Shanghai, or start a new one outside Berlin? In spite of all the news stories and announcements by the governments in each of the countries. And ditto it has not been developing the Y in spite of all the reported sightings? Or that the new version of the solar roof did not go into production, in spite of all the reviews of it, and all the people who have said they have ordered one? It is all an extremely elaborate hoax? And even when their latest quarterly report discusses all this?

You know, when someone is so far gone into conspiracy theories as you appear to be, there is no reasoning them.

Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by xkjkls on Thursday February 06, 2020 @03:45PM (#22260108)
How many of these things exist currently? As far as I know I’ve only seen a total of 10 deliveries from the Chinese factory, there has not been a single Model Y sold to the public yet, the German factory hasn’t even broken ground, and the Solar Roof, despite being in production for three and a half years still hasn’t had even a thousand customers install yet.

Companies exaggerate in their PR statements. It’s very easy to claim a factory is complete but not have meaningful production. It’s very easy to claim that the Model Y is just around the corner. It’s apparently very easy to bilk investors that solar roofs are beyond a concept phase for three plus years. That doesn’t mean they are.

It’s not a conspiracy theory to want a company to produce audited financials that show that they have done the complete investment in all of these projects and they aren’t vaporware.

Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by optimiz3 on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:37AM (#22190400)
Our TSLA brokerage accounts thank you and your /r/RealTesla brethren for your sacrifice.
Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by dang on Friday January 31, 2020 @11:08PM (#22208586)
Please don't post unsubstantive and/or flamewar comments.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by xkjkls on Thursday January 30, 2020 @02:13PM (#22194367)
Well, let's check back next year. The bears are already 1-0 against Elon Musk, given that a large percentage of Tesla bears were originally short SolarCity.
Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by optimiz3 on Thursday January 30, 2020 @03:17PM (#22195060)
Bears are down over 5B in mark to market losses. Sure, call that 1-0.
Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by xkjkls on Thursday January 30, 2020 @04:11PM (#22195639)
Tesla has lost -6.5 billion, so, yeah, I'd still stick with the Bears.
Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by dang on Friday January 31, 2020 @11:08PM (#22208588)
Please don't post unsubstantive and/or flamewar comments.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by lazyjones on Thursday January 30, 2020 @05:18AM (#22190311)
Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by xkjkls on Thursday January 30, 2020 @02:12PM (#22194360)
Using non-GAAP numbers. Non-GAAP gives you substantial lee-way to not charge things to your bottom line. I don't think you get to claim to run a profitable business just because you started paying your employees completely in stock.
Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by woodandsteel on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @07:11PM (#22187534)
Because it has overcome the problems that lead to the losses, and it is set in a number of ways to be highly profitable this year and into the future.
Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by xkjkls on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @07:17PM (#22187601)
This company has been unprofitable for ten consecutive years as a public company. That’s a record. I’ll hold my breath on people saying the future will be different.
Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by rjdagost on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:19PM (#22188333)
This is what a speculative bubble looks like. Enjoy popcorn on the sidelines until people start pricing in financial reality. Manias sometimes take a while to fizzle out. Year over year revenue growth is actually flat to slightly negative for the past 2 quarters. If top-line revenue growth continues to stall out, that's often a catalyst for corrections.
Re:Tesla Financial Results 2019 Q4 by xkjkls on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @11:56PM (#22188964)
Yeah, it will be hard for Q1 to be as bad as last year, but it doesn’t look pretty from there.