News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by aspyct on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @05:14AM (#22179044)
Who gives clearance to that kind of experiment?

Oxitec has done the same in the past with mosquitoes, with small to no result. Some say it's even worse now. https://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2019/09/...

Now the same company is toying with moths.

There's no way we can predict the outcome of such genetic engineering. If they achieve their goal and kill all moths, other species may decline. Or else they will simply make stronger moths, like they did with the mosquitoes: "very likely resulting in a more robust population than the pre-release population due to hybrid vigor."

I believe we should all oppose such practices. Who is Oxitec to decide to run that experiment and potentially ruin the world for everyone of us?

Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by CoolGuySteve on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @06:43AM (#22179497)
That mercola article was fascinating until I got to the very end. Then it finished with the paragraph below. Now I’m wondering if I just read a bunch of bullshit quackery.

> Available for Preorder

> In my upcoming book “EMF*D,” I reveal key strategies outlining how to protect yourself from 5G, Wi-Fi, “dirty” electricity and the harmful effects of electromagnetic fields from cellphones. There's no better time than today to start reducing your EMF exposure — preorder your copy now!

Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by the_gastropod on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @05:24PM (#22186599)
Oh, Mercola is a complete and total quack. Among other things, he says AIDS comes from psychological stress, not from HIV, sunscreen causes skin cancer, vaccines cause autism, and microwaving food destroys its nutrients. Conveniently, he sells many dietary supplements and knick-knacks to protect you from the fear-mongery nonsense he spouts.
Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by PunchTornado on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @04:38PM (#22186135)
thanks for saving my time.
Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by allovernow on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @04:48PM (#22186214)
My understanding is that Mercola is a generally pseudoscientific website.
Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by red75prime on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @06:10AM (#22179337)
I don't see how it differs from first thermonuclear bomb test or the large hadron collider. They were peeking into the unknown. After making their best judgement, of course.

The years to come will be the years of climate change. The best we can do is lower its severity a bit. Ecosystems will be straining to adapt. We can no longer hope that not doing anything to ecosystems will keep status quo. Proactive measures will be necessary. And we will be still in the dark about consequences of those measures, if we don't start doing experiments now.

Majority of people don't have sufficient knowledge to assess risks and benefits of genetically-modified-organisms-in-the-wild scenario, so it should be "Demand to tighten regulations", not "Oppose such practices".

Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by Sporktacular on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:03AM (#22180532)
That was considered by some scientists who would pay a price if they were wrong, concluding it wasn't a serious risk. The calculation here is being decided by a company who'll pay nothing if they're wrong yet will profit if they're not.

But say for a minute this statement isn't true: that they proceeded with hugely risky experiments without a careful analysis. Would that mean being so reckless again now is justified?

You would use blind luck last time to justify another round of Russian roulette?

Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by markus92 on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @06:32AM (#22179441)
The LHC and thermonuclear bombs don't usually reproduce themselves though, keeping the risk relatively contained.
Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by funklute on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @06:38AM (#22179479)
People didn't know that for sure - there was actually a fear that thermonuclear bombs would ignite the atmosphere and turn us into a sun.
Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by yesenadam on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @07:15AM (#22179663)
I remember reading a Feynman story where he was given the job of checking the calculations about that, and asking what if he made a mistake, was told not to worry, as no-one would ever find out. I googled for that but first found this article, which has a range of quotes about those fears from physicists, and some of the chemistry/physics of the actual fusion reactions people thought might happen. I hadn't read about that before - like the nitrogen in the atmosphere turning to magnesium! etc..

http://large.stanford.edu/courses/2015/ph241/chung1/

Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by red75prime on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @06:35AM (#22179458)
In this case it's "specifically designed to not reproduce". Hybrid vigor isn't extinction level threat. And evolution of population to be averse to sterile males is hardly unexpected.
Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by stefan_ on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @07:40AM (#22179822)
"There is no way we can predict the outcome", he said, writing from his climate controlled room surrounded by concrete for miles in any direction.

Don't worry, evolutionary systems are continuous and highly robust. Remember, nature is out there rolling dices and so far, no killer moths have been spotted, despite getting in 190 million years of moth gene dice rolls.

Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by aspyct on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:18AM (#22180686)
> writing from his climate controlled room surrounded by concrete for miles in any direction.

What does this have to do with genetic engineering?

I'm not worried about killer moths, obviously. But as we've seen in the past, eradicating a species can have surprising effects on the whole ecosystem. Take the extermination of wolves in the Yellowstone park for example: https://www.yellowstonepark.com/things-to-do/wolf-reintroduc...

Getting rid of the moths is only a patch on a deeper problem. Like every patch, it's only going to move the problem, and possibly create others.

The issue with GE is that we're not merely talking about concrete. Concrete doesn't move, doesn't reproduce. Living beings do so, and sometimes a lot faster than we expect.

There's already so many changes going on at the moment with climate change. Insect populations are changing, birds migrate, crustaceans' shells dissolve in the ocean. There's no telling the consequences of GE for anything. And once it starts to be a mess, there's very little we can do to control it.

Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by pvaldes on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @07:37PM (#22187741)
> remember no killer moths have been spotted

We probably should know better and stop underestimating the capability of evolution and the planet to knit complicated nets and put nasty surprises in our path.

Nature has filled that checkbox long time ago. Of course there are killer moths and they are very efficient. There are reports of more than 500 humans killed by moths in recent times (plus another 2000 people sent to the hospital with a massive bleeding syndrome). Family Saturniidae.

Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by close04 on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @07:59AM (#22179966)
> no killer moths have been spotted, despite getting in 190 million years of moth gene dice rolls

Nature works much slower than humans and with different "targets". There's a reason we shun engineering of deadly pathogens that could wipe out the entire population, and the assumption that "it can't be done otherwise nature would have done it already" doesn't hold.

Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by red75prime on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:43AM (#22180331)
Unintended consequences are unintended because they weren't actively searched for. Why do you think that they will be more dangerous than random search performed in nature?
Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by ngcc_hk on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @11:37AM (#22182445)
It is the unknown unknown you worry about when change like this. I wonder the China part as well. Not sure still about the military lab on virus in wuhan.

What is the governance and ethic model here?

Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by sorokod on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @07:51AM (#22179901)
Evolution stopping is not a concern, it's direction is.
Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by bilekas on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @05:23AM (#22179082)
Actually the release of mosquitoes which would steralise was very successfull but there was a huge amount of caution and push back against releasing them into the wild.

There are real debates to be had over these things, and I don't think anyone will have the scope of the impact ever understood.

That said, when its costing farmers/companies 4-5 Billion a year, you can be sure there will be a push to move this along. Right or wrong, money will move mountains.

Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by stubish on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @06:55AM (#22179562)
The economic cost of Malaria and the other major mosquito borne diseases is also huge, but governments don't choose to push this. It has always seemed odd to me given how popular a move it would be in affected regions.
Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by skc on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:08AM (#22180047)
We don't know if it would be a popular move in affected regions.

Take GM crops for example. There is an awful lot of suspicion around the motives of the organisations/corps pushing this stuff. Not all of it unwarranted.

Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by stubish on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:47AM (#22181037)
I think we know. Knowing your kids are most likely to suffer Dengue Fever 2-3 times before they finish high school, just like you have suffered, means you have a vastly different outlook than those in non-affected regions. These are painful, debilitating diseases that affect every family in certain regions.
Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by mrfusion on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:15AM (#22180093)
On the other hand we don’t want to put up too many hurdles especially for fighting mosquitos spreading terrible diseases.

When trying new things I say Let’s do what makes sense, and not be paralyzed by fear.

Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by TomMarius on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @08:20AM (#22180144)
The problem is that it is becoming easier and easier to single-handedly destroy the ecosystem in a large surrounding area.

And I say that as an opposer of regulation.

Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by Sporktacular on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:10AM (#22180599)
These mosquitos are a benefit for thousands of species, and thus the natural world in general. But they're a problem for one species so they have to go?

This is the response to the tired "but humans and therefore all their actions are natural too" argument. This is why it doesn't 'make sense'.

Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by andyjpb on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @11:24AM (#22182244)
Thanks for the link.

The guarantees they present in that article seem a lot stronger than the HN submission. They explain what they intend by "self limiting" and then it turns out that it doesn't work anyway (with a 4% survival rate of Female carriers in the wild).

In the HN submission (a later experiment) they don't seem to be anywhere near as careful. They just say it's "self limiting" but that the genes are passed onto offspring (of which, the males survive).

I'm not an expert in genetic biology and my differential calculus is rusty but, intuitively, I'd expect that if you had even a small percentage of matings that didn't produce Female offspring then the overall proportion of males would rise. It's not immediately clear what the equilibrium point of male carriers would be.

...so how does it "self limit" in the case where the limit is not merely "all (female) moths have died"? Do all males end up infected?

What is the range of these moths? Can they fly to other places and gradually spread out over a geography?

I have so many questions and, to a non-expert, it all sounds rather scary!

Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by folli on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @05:21AM (#22179075)
Meh, the most likely outcome of such experiments is that the introduced gene will vanish from the gene pool midterm.
Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by mr__y on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @06:21AM (#22179392)
...or the introducend gene combined with some previously existing genes will create an unexpected feature which will dominate the species and wipe out specimens without it[0].

I believe we don't know enough (yet) to take a risk of such experiments in the wild. More, I think that possibly even proper assesment of such risk is currently not possible

[0] while this scenario is probably very unlikely I'm not sure that such risk should be taken

Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by folli on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @07:42AM (#22179840)
The gene pool of a species is much more dynamic than you assume in your scenario. Combinations, deletions, mutations, introduction of new genes from other species is very common on biological timelines.

To put it as an optimization problem: a huge portion of the search space has been (and is actively being) searched already, with the current species as the optimal solution for the given ecological niche. Changing the genomic setup will with a high likelihood move away from this optimum, rendering your "new" species less fit for its niche.

Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by Sporktacular on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:36AM (#22180903)
And so even though you could be wrong you're prepared to take this gamble?

Both genetics and ecology are hugely complex subjects that no one is even close to fully understanding. So we don't know in advance that this will be ultimately beneficial for humans, don't know that the success (for humans) of a previous program for mosquitos will translate into success here, we don't know that infertility won't be circumvented by other genetic factors, don't know that the modification won't become a permanent part of that moth's gene pool, what effects that will have on the moths, don't know how it will affect species that consume these moths and don't know how this will affect the numbers of species these moths consume. And we don't mind that the profits made will probably be private and any costs socialised or paid by the wider ecosystem.

But meh, let's not apply the precautionary principle. Let's just roll the dice with an unknown number of sides.

Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by Shorel on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @09:00AM (#22180508)
Of course, that's the point. The offspring doesn't grow to adulthood.

New self-limiting moths need to be released each season.

Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by aspyct on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @05:29AM (#22179099)
So basically, it's a temporary solution that we will keep reusing until some genes mix and things really go awry. Great.
Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by onreact on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @06:03AM (#22179299)
Also some genes are known to actually "jump" between species.

We may end up "limiting" other animals too.

As if Frankenfood and pesticides weren't hazardous enough.

Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by Accujack on Wednesday January 29, 2020 @05:01PM (#22186334)
>Also some genes are known to actually "jump" between species.

Simple microscopic organisms, sure. Viruses, maybe. There's no evidence it's ever happened in something as large as a moth larva.

Even if these genes somehow (let's say a nice Sci-Fi virus) caused these genes to "jump" species... a gene that limits whether female larvae of these moths survive is unlikely to affect whether e.g. bats grow to adulthood or mate.

In fact, genes jumping from e.g. a moth larvae to another species (like humans) is rather rare... you haven't seen much on the evening news about humans suddenly developing moth wings, have you? Why do you think that is so?

Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by onreact on Thursday January 30, 2020 @07:12AM (#22190795)
Please update your science here:

https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2007/03/070308220454.h... (2007)

and here:

https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2018/07/180709101216.h... (2018)

"Far from just being the product of our parents, scientists have now shown that widespread transfer of genes between species has radically changed the genomes of today's mammals, and been an important driver of evolution."

Re:Genetically engineered moth is released into an open field by Accujack on Thursday January 30, 2020 @09:29AM (#22191483)
Update yours, and read more carefully.

Direct genetic transfer among higher organisms doesn't happen, and in fact the mechanism for how it happens indirectly isn't really known, but probably includes viruses and some carrier for them between species like mosquitos.

Also, the chunks of information being transferred aren't coding for specific functions, they're transposable, meaning they're non specific enough that even if you copied them from one organism to another in corresponding area of the DNA strands, the results would be completely different.

It'd be like copying the letters "lp" from the word "alphabet" to the word integer, as in "ilpnteger". The result is very different in function to the original. It probably doesn't make sense (not a viable organism) and while it does help drive genetic variation which is important for evolution, that's very different from a wholesale copying of meaning (phenotype, or the function of the genes in the original organism) to the new word.

Putting it more simply, if you copy the genes for a bat's wings wholesale to a human, you don't get a winged human. The most likely result is something that won't grow beyond a single cell, or if it does it wouldn't be recognizable as human or even an organism. The chances of getting something resembling wings are very low, and a human that could fly using them is literally impossible.

You can't copy the moth's "stale offspring" feature to another organism by copying genes, it just doesn't work.