News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mozilla Wants Young People to Consider ‘Ethical Issues’ B... by behringer on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @01:28PM (#22120433)
When I tell people to grow a pair and say no, they tell me to grow up, it's not how the "real" world works, they say. The fact is, they have no role models to look up to and teach them how to say no to corruption and immoral or unethical behavior.
Re:Mozilla Wants Young People to Consider ‘Ethical Issues’ B... by ditonal on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @01:57PM (#22120748)
The other favorite arguments are, "if we don't do <unethical> thing, someone else will, therefore it's ethical". I call it the "selling crack to teenagers" argument but it was the go-to by Google employees defending the autoaim killbot project Maven.

There was also an idea that, Google employees are the "good guys" compared to "evil Amazon", therefore when Google does something, it's de facto good, and it's better for Google to do the unethical thing since they will do it less unethically than Amazon.

Google employees care a lot about their "TC" and "GSUs" - that's it. What bugs me is that at least Goldman employees and their ilk kind of have that tacit acknowledgement that they are in it for the lucre. A lot of Googlers really act like they are in it for the greater good even when the company picks money over ethics at literally every junction.

Re:Mozilla Wants Young People to Consider ‘Ethical Issues’ B... by save_ferris on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @02:36PM (#22121166)
I faced this when I worked at a company that was building a custom fundraising platform for the Catholic Church while the church was spending millions to lobby states not to modify statute of limitations to benefit victims of sex abuse[0].

This is a publicly traded company that explicitly states its mission as “helping the world do good”, and the executive team used the exact same argument when someone questioned them on this during an all-hands meeting. It was one of the most demoralizing moments of my career.

0: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/catholic-church-scandal-spent-1...

Re:Mozilla Wants Young People to Consider ‘Ethical Issues’ B... by tropo on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @04:49PM (#22122417)
It's easy to hate on those accused of heinous crimes (both the person and their employer) but what about the concept of a fair trial?

Imagine you were accused of doing something decades ago. Do you have an alibi for December 17, 1955? (adjust if you are younger, or imagine being accused of today's crime in 2077) You will have lost receipts, calendars, and ticket stubs. The people you were with, who could have served as witnesses, are long dead. You'll go up against a jury that hears a tragic story about some helpless child you supposedly harmed. Good luck with that.

It's especially bad that changes in statue of limitations don't just apply going forward. It really feels like ex-post-facto law, which is expressly forbidden by the United States Constitution. Cases from about 70 years back are pushing Scouting BSA into Chapter 11.

Re:Mozilla Wants Young People to Consider ‘Ethical Issues’ B... by justizin on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @05:20PM (#22122693)
If you're a member of the Catholic Church and that child was a member of your congregation and you definitely had contact with them during that time this isn't going to boil down to dinner receipts.
Re:Mozilla Wants Young People to Consider ‘Ethical Issues’ B... by milsorgen on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @09:37PM (#22124325)
That is a very shortsighted viewpoint.
Re:Mozilla Wants Young People to Consider ‘Ethical Issues’ B... by save_ferris on Thursday January 23, 2020 @02:59PM (#22131224)
I completely agree with the concept of a fair trial, but the church isn’t a person, nor should they be shielding predators from facing trial.

The church is simply acting to prevent further legal exposure to what has to be the largest child sex abuse scandal in history. They’re not interested in protecting the innocent. If they were, they’d be much more transparent and cooperative with authorities than they have been.

Re:Mozilla Wants Young People to Consider ‘Ethical Issues’ B... by pb7 on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @05:40PM (#22122841)
> Google employees care a lot about their "TC" and "GSUs" - that's it.

You’re generalizing 100,000+ people of all ages and backgrounds from all around the world.

Re:Mozilla Wants Young People to Consider ‘Ethical Issues’ B... by m0zg on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @08:30PM (#22123980)
Exactly. And I'd also like to point out that earning good money and ethics aren't mutually exclusive things at all. I certainly didn't spend my years there for comp alone. I like to think, as well, that my work there helped improve the world in some small way, and I could justify that position pretty easily, with evidence.

I get that people on this site get a raging hard-on against tracking on the web, I suffer from the same, but to say that getting site owners to snitch on you in exchange for their sites being able to exist is some huge breach of ethics is not a rational position to take.

When one is inclined to blame someone or some company for all the troubles in the world, it is helpful to ask them about the _specific_ harm that they feel the object of their ire is causing them. If they respond with a laundry list of things, that's a tell they aren't thinking rationally about it.

Re:Mozilla Wants Young People to Consider ‘Ethical Issues’ B... by noxToken on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @02:33PM (#22121132)
Sometimes saying "Yes" or "No" is the difference between having a job the next day or being unemployed. It would be different if everyone was declining unethical development, but there is surely someone to replace you. 3 months without work can really crush people - especially those who have a family to support with no safety net.

This isn't always about role models and being upstanding citizens. A lot of us in this field are fortunate enough to be able to decline work based on ethical stances. Anyone can say no. Can they afford the consequences?

Re:Mozilla Wants Young People to Consider ‘Ethical Issues’ B... by ForHackernews on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @03:33PM (#22121701)
Any engineer working for Google or Facebook can go get another job tomorrow. Maybe it won't pay quite as much, but it will still pay very very well in absolute terms.

If the "consequence" of making ethical career choices is you earn only $250,000/year instead of $300,000/year, you should probably reflect on why you value your soul so cheaply.

Re:Mozilla Wants Young People to Consider ‘Ethical Issues’ B... by noxToken on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @03:40PM (#22121766)
Not everyone works for Google, Facebook, or a prestigious tech company. There are smaller companies making ethically questionable choices with customer data. Not all tech workers are employed by prestigious tech companies.
Re:Mozilla Wants Young People to Consider ‘Ethical Issues’ B... by pb7 on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @05:45PM (#22122876)
Can you name some ethical companies that pay $250K/year to people with just a few years of experience? I would love to apply.
[dead]
Re:Mozilla Wants Young People to Consider ‘Ethical Issues’ B... by dang on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @11:32PM (#22124890)
Personal attacks will get you banned on HN. We've had to ask you to follow the site guidelines more than once before. Would you please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules when posting here?
[deleted]
Re:Mozilla Wants Young People to Consider ‘Ethical Issues’ B... by dang on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @11:32PM (#22124891)
Personal attacks are not allowed here. Being provoked doesn't make it ok.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Mozilla Wants Young People to Consider ‘Ethical Issues’ B... by pb7 on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @01:37PM (#22120527)
It’s easy to lambast people for their decisions when you don’t have to bear the associated cost.
Re:Mozilla Wants Young People to Consider ‘Ethical Issues’ B... by FisDugthop on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @03:40PM (#22121763)
It's easy to make unethical technical decisions when you don't have to bear the cost, either. And yet, we expect better from people.
Re:Mozilla Wants Young People to Consider ‘Ethical Issues’ B... by behringer on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @02:38PM (#22121177)
That argument doesn't work on me just like it does not work on your judge or your parole officer. I've given up quite a bit over the years.
Re:Mozilla Wants Young People to Consider ‘Ethical Issues’ B... by Nasrudith on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @02:59PM (#22121388)
It should though - because the obligation is to the law and not ethics. While it is certainly messed up morally and a reflection of twisted norms there is a point about social contracts and expectations. One can argue it is wrong for a bystander to lock and bar the door in a mass shooting or not attempt an ambush of a shooter as they got closer but there is no expectation to risk their life like that and such outside demands of bravado would be wrong. Unreasonable demands make a parody of justice no matter the potential outcome.

That said it is possible for multiple people to be in the wrong in multiple dimensions and there is room for nuance. Robbing a bank is wrong, but doing so when under duress saying that the robber should be punished would be wrong but not if they were instead tasked to outright murder.

Re:Mozilla Wants Young People to Consider ‘Ethical Issues’ B... by behringer on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @09:59PM (#22124431)
Maybe your obligation is to the law but that doesn't mean everybody else should be. The law of the US is corrupt and immoral in countless ways. Anybody who is "law abiding" and nothing else is corrupt to the core.
Re:Mozilla Wants Young People to Consider ‘Ethical Issues’ B... by dylan604 on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @05:04PM (#22122555)
Have you ever countered by asking these same individuals if they would be okay working in defense contractors or oil&gas or pharmaceutical. I've heard from some younger people that are very much opposed to the above list, but have not equated the privacy violators into the same category of "evil".
Re:Mozilla Wants Young People to Consider ‘Ethical Issues’ B... by notacoward on Wednesday January 22, 2020 @07:13PM (#22123506)
> When I tell people to grow a pair

Putting it in such an offensive way undercuts any moral claims you might make. Maybe that's why you get such strong push-back. People don't choose to work for "evil" companies out of fear. Some just don't think about it. Some just don't care. Neither of those make their decisions right, but that's not the same as fear either. Some people have different ideas of what's right. Some people believe they can turn something that's currently negative into something more positive. Agree or disagree, it's still not about fear. "Grow a pair" isn't an argument. It's an attack, and people respond to it as such. If you wanted to make an effective argument instead of just giving yourself a dopamine hit, you might try engaging with the actual reasons people decide as they do.