News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The 100 Year Starship by dfilppi on Friday January 17, 2020 @10:47AM (#22075614)
There should only be one Manhattan style project now: figure out how to download consciousness into a machine. Besides conferring immorality, this would also make interstellar travel time scales irrelevant.
Re:The 100 Year Starship by icandoit on Friday January 17, 2020 @11:01AM (#22075753)
If we could do this wouldn't we spin up minds-in-machines to do all sorts of cognitive tasks on demand and shut them off when the task is done (or they abandon their task) like a virtual machine.

Imagine making a copy of someone like Fabrice Bellard [1] and spinning up 100 of them to write your flappy bird clone for you and then shutting them off.

Would this be a terrible crime, or a paradise? This is an idea known as Hansons "ems" [2].

- https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fabrice_Bellard

- https://ideas.ted.com/are-you-ready-for-the-impending-age-of...

Re:The 100 Year Starship by wonderwonder on Friday January 17, 2020 @11:42AM (#22076215)
This is a pretty serious question and something that really should be answered. Is a digital conscious alive, and if so what rights does it have?

Ian Banks' Culture novels look at this a few times.

Appreciate the article links, will read them after work today.

Re:The 100 Year Starship by nradov on Friday January 17, 2020 @11:54AM (#22076397)
It's not at all a serious question. It's entirely speculative and there is zero hard scientific evidence that such a thing is even possible. Science fiction.
Re:The 100 Year Starship by TomMarius on Friday January 17, 2020 @12:10PM (#22076606)
Philosophy definitely can contemplate theoretical scenarios
Re:The 100 Year Starship by arethuza on Friday January 17, 2020 @11:06AM (#22075816)
That sounds like the "Fast Folk" from Ken MacLeod's Fall Revolution books:

https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Literature/FallRevolu...

Re:The 100 Year Starship by naravara on Friday January 17, 2020 @11:55AM (#22076414)
>this would also make interstellar travel time scales irrelevant.

Not really. You're assuming this "machine storage" mechanism can preserve state forever. Even if you manage to upload consciousness losslessly and maintain all the ineffable qualities of "life" or "soul" or whatever (that we don't even really have solid philosophical definitions for), you'd still need to contend with data corruption and bit rot over cosmic time-scales.

Re:The 100 Year Starship by m4rtink on Friday January 17, 2020 @12:44PM (#22077050)
There are many error correction techniques suitable for this, such as for example fountain codes:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fountain_code

You basically encode a message (say, it's 10 some data storage unit unit long) into a much bigger lot of chunks (say 1000 0000 units), which you then transmit. As long as you receive a pre-determined amount of the chunks (1000 units might be enough), regardless of order, you can reconstruct the original message.

With speed of light lag, you can't really expect re-sends & will have to use some encoding working on a similar principle to this one.

Re:The 100 Year Starship by adamisom on Friday January 17, 2020 @11:07AM (#22075825)
Although I think "immorality" was a typo and you meant "immortality", it's a funny typo, because ethics are definitely relevant.
Re:The 100 Year Starship by zentiggr on Friday January 17, 2020 @12:53PM (#22077191)
Frank Herbert's take on this had humans enslaved for a few centuries before the Butlerian Jihad got humans back in control of themselves and instituted a ten thousand year taboo on 'thinking machines'.

Sci-fi is great for postulating dystopian outcomes so we can at least anticipate bad choices and guard against them.

Re:The 100 Year Starship by lallysingh on Friday January 17, 2020 @12:00PM (#22076472)
I can probably train a simple AI to be "close enough" to lots of people. Does that count?

More seriously, if we can send software, why care about this muddy consciousness stuff?

Re:The 100 Year Starship by stanferder on Friday January 17, 2020 @11:03AM (#22075774)
I fear that the rush to integrate humans with machines will miss something essential and end up replacing true consciousnesses with philosophical zombies.
Re:The 100 Year Starship by naravara on Friday January 17, 2020 @11:59AM (#22076460)
Presumably there will always be some culture of holdouts who resist the upload process kind of like how the Amish resisted the industrial revolution.

Of course, if the philosophical zombies end up being evangelistic transhumanist zealots, we'd be screwed.

Re:The 100 Year Starship by krapp on Friday January 17, 2020 @11:05AM (#22075806)
Conferring immortality?

Are you under the impression that hardware never breaks down, or that media never rots, or that software never fails?

Re:The 100 Year Starship by close04 on Friday January 17, 2020 @11:50AM (#22076343)
I guess if the transfer process is perfected then you don't have to worry that much about HW failure or rot. Very little of today's data actually disappears due to these causes.

Imagine today's equivalent of having your data on 2-3 hard drives, in the cloud, on 3 email addresses, and in a printed copy. You will backup a brain dump every evening to a satellite backup storage and 3 data centers around the world, maybe even to a cold or hot spare body. Someone stealing or altering a copy of you, or altering you (lots of philosophical questions around who is you anymore) would be the real worry.

If anyone told you today your life depends on a piece of electronic data in your possession I'm sure you wouldn't let HW failure or data rot become a problem. Your birth certificate is in a single paper copy and it's damn hard to get a replacement and yet most people have no problem keeping it safe for decades.

Re:The 100 Year Starship by naravara on Friday January 17, 2020 @12:01PM (#22076488)
> Your birth certificate is in a single paper copy and it's damn hard to get a replacement and yet most people have no problem keeping it safe for decades.

Decades might as well be seconds if we're talking about interstellar travel times.

Re:The 100 Year Starship by close04 on Friday January 17, 2020 @12:16PM (#22076685)
Sure. But pieces of paper might as well be nothing compared to the technology we have available once we're capable of downloading consciousness into a machine and interstellar travel. So the challenge may be bigger but also the tools at your disposal.

You are projecting today's problems on tomorrow's technology. And I'm being generous here, we're actually talking about multiple generations probably. We're just as close to understanding such future technology as people (scientists) 100-150 years ago were to understanding ours. Saying "in 200 years we'd surely lose the data to HW failure and bit rot" is no different from them saying "you can't fly without flapping the wings" 150 years ago.

Those future generations face challenges we can't even imagine today. Like if I whip up 5 copies of myself who is "me"? And if 4 died will it be a loss of data or just loss of redundancy? Will it actually be just one combined copy running on multiple machines (Borg style)?

Re:The 100 Year Starship by naravara on Friday January 17, 2020 @03:35PM (#22078949)
>You are projecting today's problems on tomorrow's technology.

Entropy is just a fundamental aspect of how time progresses. It's basically axiomatic that anything we have degrades without actively recreating/reinforcing it with additional work.

Re:The 100 Year Starship by krapp on Friday January 17, 2020 @12:06PM (#22076550)
You can't have a perfect transfer process, thermodynamics prohibits that, and you have to have some kind of physical media which will fail over time, and thus require regular upkeep and maintenance, as well as a constant supply of power (which is also not infinitely available or free.)

TANSTAAFL.

Re:The 100 Year Starship by close04 on Friday January 17, 2020 @12:29PM (#22076870)
But there is such a thing as "good enough for all intents and purposes". I didn't say any transfer has to be perfect, or that the media is absolutely perfect, or that it has to be done for free, with no energy consumption, etc. just that if we achieve practical interstellar travel and can transfer consciousness to a machine I'd say the tech will be advanced enough for these issues to not be the major concern. You're introducing additional constraints and expecting my previous comment to account for them.

Theseus's ship, theoretically you are not the same you from 10 years ago, cells have changed, DNA was altered, shape, consciousness, etc. are all slightly different. But for all intents and purposes you are you. So having a "good enough" copy of yourself may just be enough. Once it's in a machine it does not matter anymore. Thermodynamics allowed this comment you are reading now to be transferred from my mind to your mind (in its literal form, regardless of personal interpretation) or at least from my keyboard to your screen exactly how it was intended, with no discernible loss of fidelity.

You're taking the purely theoretical stance where it's not the same photon of information. I'm taking the practical stance where it doesn't have to be. And even losing some bits of your data might not be a practical concern.

Re:The 100 Year Starship by zentiggr on Friday January 17, 2020 @01:11PM (#22077390)
Presuming technology has advanced to the point where transferring a consciousness to a machine form is possible, it can be presupposed that the power and maintenance requirements would have been worked out in parallel.

The main thread of discussion is interesting enough to set aside quibbles about support technology that would have to be developed in tandem for it to be a viable process.

Re:The 100 Year Starship by kaybe on Friday January 17, 2020 @11:02AM (#22075765)
We definitely need to get our environmental problems and ressource consumption under control first.
Re:The 100 Year Starship by m4rtink on Friday January 17, 2020 @12:26PM (#22076838)
That sounds more like a recipe for missing the window of opportunity, that should over time fix all our environmental & resource issues once and for all thanks to the (in comparison to Earth) limitless resources of Earth.
Re:The 100 Year Starship by sxu on Friday January 17, 2020 @10:51AM (#22075663)
What about reproduction?
Re:The 100 Year Starship by icandoit on Friday January 17, 2020 @10:54AM (#22075694)
We can do both. One doesn't limit the other does it?
Re:The 100 Year Starship by ceejayoz on Friday January 17, 2020 @11:11AM (#22075869)
cp -R me/ me2/
Re:The 100 Year Starship by bencoder on Friday January 17, 2020 @11:36AM (#22076138)
Yep, I would fork myself.

Merging and deconflicting if you want to reunite forks could be a fun problem to solve in the future

Re:The 100 Year Starship by ceejayoz on Friday January 17, 2020 @01:02PM (#22077301)
You might enjoy the Bobiverse trilogy: https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0753LBFQ7/
Re:The 100 Year Starship by zentiggr on Friday January 17, 2020 @12:57PM (#22077237)
Future person: "Who are you?"

Future forks: "One of us."

(Thanks to I, Robot for a cute scene.)