News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by ocfnash on Friday January 17, 2020 @06:56AM (#22073900)
"The crew went around, climbed to 8500 feet, depressurized the aircraft, opened the cockpit side window and cleaned the windscreen by hand."
Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by michaelt on Friday January 17, 2020 @09:36AM (#22074892)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Airways_Flight_9:

"The aircraft flew into a cloud of volcanic ash [...] resulting in the failure of all four engines. [...] The cloud sandblasted the windscreen and landing light covers [...] After landing, the flight crew found it impossible to taxi, due to glare from apron floodlights which made the already sandblasted windscreen opaque."

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/travel/news/pilots-awarded-medal... / http://euromaidanpress.com/2017/07/29/ukrainian-pilot-miracu...

"Soon after take-off, at 1,300 metres above the ground, the aircraft’s nose was pummelled by hailstones the size of golf balls, shattering the windscreen and leaving the pilots unable to see." "The pilot made a decision to return and was able to land by tilting the airplane to see the runway through the side window and by good coordination with the airport’s dispatchers."

Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by whycombagator on Friday January 17, 2020 @02:34PM (#22078295)
You missed my favourite part and quote from the pilot (Moody):

> As Flight 9 approached Jakarta, the crew found it difficult to see anything through the windscreen, and made the approach almost entirely on instruments, despite reports of good visibility. The crew decided to fly the instrument landing system (ILS); however, the vertical guidance system was inoperative, so they were forced to fly with only the lateral guidance as the first officer monitored the airport's distance measuring equipment (DME). He then called out how high they should be at each DME step along the final approach to the runway, creating a virtual glide slope for them to follow. Moody described it as "a bit like negotiating one's way up a badger's arse."

Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by djohnston on Friday January 17, 2020 @07:41PM (#22081283)
Wow, the number of failsafes in aviation is genuinely comforting
Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by joncrane on Friday January 17, 2020 @07:00AM (#22073919)
Twice! They tried to land at the original airport again, it happened again, they cleaned it again, then diverted.

The pictures are intense!

Edit: The original title was way more focused on the fact this is a Boeing 737; I feel the new post title is a good compromise.

BTW: I think this is gaining traction because it's a 737; however, can most airplane windshield wipers clean a thick layer of dead, crushed locusts off the windscreen?

I would argue that we should change the title to "airliner." I think the title is meant intentionally to capitalize on the notoriety of the model of airplane, when this incident is not specific to that model.

Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by pmyteh on Friday January 17, 2020 @07:09AM (#22073967)
There's no intention to capitalise here: Simon Hradecky (who runs the Aviation Herald) runs almost all his headlines in a standard format: (Crash|Accident|Incident|Report): <Airline> <aircraft type code> at <place> on <date>, <short description>.

The description is sometimes updated when more information comes in.

Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by dsfyu404ed on Friday January 17, 2020 @07:59AM (#22074204)
>can most airplane windshield wipers clean a thick layer of dead, crushed locusts off the windscreen?

Pretty much any rubber bladed windshield wiper will not be able to clear them after they dry out and at several hundred miles an hour with equatorial air temperatures that will happen very quickly.

Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by sangnoir on Friday January 17, 2020 @01:50PM (#22077808)
Wipers make it worse! I had the misfortune of driving through some flying termites (not dense - think 20 splats/minute). Insects have fatty/non-soluble insides: when I turned on the wipers, I managed smears the goop more uniformly across the windshield, making visibility infinitely worse. Spraying water does not help, unless it has some detergent in it.
Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by deeblering4 on Friday January 17, 2020 @09:05AM (#22074664)
Do aircraft have the ability to spray liquid on the windscreen, like cars do?
Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by VBprogrammer on Friday January 17, 2020 @09:23AM (#22074795)
Older aircraft had the ability to spray deicing fluid on the windshield. After that bleed air from the engines was used but now it's mostly electrically heated.
Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by pgt on Friday January 17, 2020 @07:23AM (#22074020)
Reminds me of the F-16 staple scene from Hot Shots! (1991): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TkdbqK4iUsU
Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by wereHamster on Friday January 17, 2020 @07:09AM (#22073968)
I want to know how it feels to open the cockpit window at 200 kts. Also, how far out do they need to lean to reach the whole window?
Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by base698 on Friday January 17, 2020 @08:08AM (#22074262)
I've exited an aircraft at 220kts a few times. It's very hard and feels almost like hitting a wall. I'll quote myself after the first time when it knocked me for a loop:

> That wind made me it's bitch.

Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by 0xfaded on Friday January 17, 2020 @07:27AM (#22074038)
I've done it at 140kts with a GoPro. Feels like your arm is in cold turbulant water. Presumably at 200kts the forces would be double.
Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by zubspace on Friday January 17, 2020 @07:26AM (#22074033)
I guess by looking at the picture of the cockpit inside that one of the pilots only cleaned the part of the window on the left side which was reachable.
Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by jefftk on Friday January 17, 2020 @10:20AM (#22075308)
Initially I thought that since Dire Dawa is 4200 feet above sea level it was weird that they'd climb to ~4300 feet above ground level. But Dire Dawa is just a few miles north of the Ahmar Mountains (part of the Ethiopian Highlands), and they probably needed to climb that much to clear them.
Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by jmkni on Friday January 17, 2020 @10:49AM (#22075639)
I know nothing about aviation, is that what pilots are supposed to do in a situation like this?
Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by alistairSH on Friday January 17, 2020 @01:17PM (#22077456)
Go arounds are a "normal" deviation from plan and pilots train for them. Reasons vary - airplane or traffic on runway, weather, and now bugs. As a passenger, you might not encounter one - my first time was in Sprint 2019, approaching Heathrow - traffic on the runway from a debris check, we were already on final, caught me off guard, but wasn't too scary.

As for the windscreen, I'm not sure if the 737 checklists include "depressurize and clean manually" for bug strikes, but I wouldn't be surprised if it did have instructions for general "windshield is obscured" conditions.

Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by jmkni on Friday January 17, 2020 @02:44PM (#22078407)
Thanks
Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by cushychicken on Friday January 17, 2020 @09:14AM (#22074733)
I'd love to see the entry in the situational playbook for scenarios like that.
Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by nathancahill on Friday January 17, 2020 @09:22AM (#22074789)
Here you go: https://hursts.org.uk/airbus-nonnormal/notes.pdf

Section 2.17. Volcanic Ash Encounter

Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by madaxe_again on Friday January 17, 2020 @07:21AM (#22074013)
I am slightly scratching my head as to why, unless the pilots were only qualified for VFR.

I learned to fly with the RAF as an air cadet. I vividly recall the first lesson in which my instructor whipped out a piece of cardboard, covered the windscreen, and said “land”.

It turns out that as long as you’ve ILS, you can do it with zero vis.

It looks like they had ILS available: https://worldaerodata.com/wad.cgi?id=ET86469

I can’t help but think a blind landing is safer than depressurising a cabin full of passengers.

Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by t0mas88 on Friday January 17, 2020 @07:31AM (#22074056)
I'm 100% sure they weren't only qualified for VFR. Every airline pilot is instrument rated, and there are no places that will give you a 737 type rating without IR.

Even when flying on instruments you still land visually, unless the aircraft is cat iii / autoland capable, the crew is certified and current and the airport has cat iii procedures in effect. Probably they didn't have one of these and didn't want to land with zero visibility.

Depressurizing at 8500ft is a good choice, the cabin is normally pressurized to the equivalent of 8000ft outside air pressure. So what they did was basically open the outflow valves and passengers wouldn't have noticed a thing.

Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by VBprogrammer on Friday January 17, 2020 @07:41AM (#22074084)
I've heard from a couple of sources that it is possible to land in zero visibility by manually following the localiser to the ground. Only from light piston types though.

Doing it in a commercial airliner full of passengers would absolutely be a last resort.

Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by t0mas88 on Friday January 17, 2020 @08:11AM (#22074279)
It is possible, but not legal. And you cannot really flare based on just the glideslope.

As an absolute last resort in a small piston you can try to do what we learned to do in case of a night landing where all lighting etc fails: Fly it slightly nose up, no flaps, with a 100 ft/min descend and wait until you hit the runway. You will basically fly it into the runway at a speed that doesn't break anything. Only works for small planes on a big runway.

Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by VBprogrammer on Friday January 17, 2020 @08:47AM (#22074546)
Yes, is very similar to a glass water landing in float planes. For a number of reasons the glideslope is unreliable below minimums anyway.

The legality doesn't matter much if you are doing it in an emergency (say unforcast fog shutting down all runways within the aircraft's remaining range).

Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by t0mas88 on Friday January 17, 2020 @01:01PM (#22077291)
True, they recommended LPV in this case. That remains quite stable all the way to the ground. It also doesn't require any ground equipment and this scenario is only likely in case of a total power loss at a remote airport.
Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by fh973 on Friday January 17, 2020 @08:21AM (#22074345)
No, you are not allowed to do an ILS landing with zero ground visibility. And I doubt you get the flare right without any visiblity.

All available categories have a decision height > 0ft: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Instrument_landing_system#ILS_...

Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by jillesvangurp on Friday January 17, 2020 @09:20AM (#22074767)
Most jets have been capable of doing landing automatically for decades. This is allowed only on certified planes and runways and actually required for poor visibility situations. ILS CAT IIIc has no decision height or run way visibility requirements but no airport actually supports that yet. The main reason for this is that taxiing blind is kind of tricky. Landing and stopping the plane on the other hand is a solved problem. CAT IIIb landings are fully automatic.

The plane approaches, flares, and lands and keeps the plane on centerline (in some cases). Most (if not all) currently flying 737s are capable of this. The question is of course if this particular airport was ready for that (if not, I'm not sure if the autopilot would allow this) and whether the pilots were certified for this.

https://thepointsguy.com/guide/aircraft-operating-foggy-cond...

Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by JorgeGT on Friday January 17, 2020 @08:56AM (#22074609)
Cat III can be done with no DH, but you still require some RVR>0 (flare is done by the autoland system). Only IIIc could be done in theory with a blocked windscreen like in this case, but that's still not in standard operation anywhere that I know of.
Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by dsfyu404ed on Friday January 17, 2020 @07:41AM (#22074092)
>I can’t help but think a blind landing is safer than depressurising a cabin full of passengers.

We're talking about 1000ft above Mexico city amount of altitude, here, not Mt. Everest. Any inherent risk from that is below the threshold of what's quantifiable. Skydivers routinely jump from 10,000ft.

Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by jvm_ on Friday January 17, 2020 @08:19AM (#22074326)
Where they finally landed, Addis Ababa is at 7,726, Mexico City is 7,350.
Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by LeifCarrotson on Friday January 17, 2020 @08:56AM (#22074612)
That makes a lot more sense. When I initially read the article, I assumed they were landing at a typical runway within ~1000 feet of sea level and for some unfathomable reason decided to ascend many thousands of feet before opening the window. I forget how high Addis Ababa is!
Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by erdeszt on Friday January 17, 2020 @07:59AM (#22074197)
In the remarks section: "IFR flt are not permitted to tkof fr Rwy 15 or apch and ldg on Rwy 33." So depending on the wind they might not had the option to land IFR.
Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by base698 on Friday January 17, 2020 @08:11AM (#22074278)
You can circle to land if the approach is only one direction. Basically shoot the approach to minimums. Tower will say, circle to land north/south and you fly a normalish pattern, lower to the other end of the runway.
Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by t0mas88 on Friday January 17, 2020 @08:25AM (#22074384)
Circle to land requires visibility, you need to keep the runway in sight during the whole maneuver. So that wouldn't really have helped them in this situation.
Re:Incident: Ethiopian B737 at Dire Dawa on Jan 9th, swarm o... by pc86 on Friday January 17, 2020 @09:30AM (#22074848)
It's one thing to land below minimums (as 0/0 certainly is) in the military, where you can very often be expected to do things with a low probability of survival.

It's another thing entirely to do it in a passenger airliner, and "depressurizing" at 8500' is nothing, you don't even need oxygen at all below 12,5 and even then only occasional usage for required crewmembers until 14,5.