News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by tomh- on Friday February 11, 2011 @05:37AM (#2205854)
So, what will happen?

1) Qt c++ devs will invest in Visual Studio and learn silverlight/XNA

or

2) Qt c++ devs simply switch to c++ development for iOS + Android

Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by blub on Friday February 11, 2011 @06:08AM (#2205903)
As a Qt dev, neither option is appealing to me right now. Maybe when things calm down...

By the way, the consensus in the Qt community is that this is bad news both for Qt and for the entire community.

Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by kjhghjkjh on Friday February 11, 2011 @10:06AM (#2206517)
And for the C++ community - not on mobiles.

What gui framework can we now use - MFC and Gnome?

Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by jdub on Friday February 11, 2011 @10:53AM (#2206708)
GNOME's C++ APIs are absolutely delicious for C++ developers who like modern, grown up C++.
Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by kjhghjkjh on Friday February 11, 2011 @11:36AM (#2206944)
I forgot - is this the year of the Linux desktop?
Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by gokhan on Friday February 11, 2011 @07:35AM (#2206089)
How about all the .Net developers out there? I'm one. Although I don't have time right now, from now on Windows on Nokia platform will be the native choice for me when I have time to play with it.

It's even better than MS + HTC or something. Being on Nokia has better visibility, especially in the eastern side of the world.

For Nokia, some Qt guys making the change + .Net ppl can't be smaller than than the current developer base.

Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by fungi on Friday February 11, 2011 @08:08AM (#2206168)
nokia is virtually non existent in korea, pulled out of japan, and is getting eaten alive in Indonesia by chinese phones, malaysia is building a wimax/android 4g ecosystem. and iphones are _everywhere_.

but nokia is huge, i get your point.

Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by pietrofmaggi on Friday February 11, 2011 @06:07AM (#2205902)
3) Qt c++ devs will learn Java or Obj-C and targets [iOS|Android], where there're already lot's of customers.
Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by justincormack on Friday February 11, 2011 @06:08AM (#2205905)
I cant imagine anyone switching to Silverlight now, its already dying, as MS have admitted, they only cant kill it before they release HTML5 for WP7 later this year.
Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by Tuna-Fish on Friday February 11, 2011 @06:22AM (#2205934)
Silverlight on the web is dead, but MS is pushing it hard as a local app platform, and for business applications. In those segments, it's far from dead.
Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by arethuza on Friday February 11, 2011 @07:32AM (#2206083)
I can see Silverlight perhaps finding a niche in internal application development - but that's a pretty big come down from the original goals of the technology (i.e. a Flash killer). So wouldn't that make Silverlight, if not dead, severely wounded?
Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by trezor on Friday February 11, 2011 @08:36AM (#2206281)
It would mean Microsoft has realized that competing for Flash's position is not worth the fight, effort or money as Flash and its position in general (plugin-based web-solutions) is losing grounds every single day. They are not willing to fight a battle which will eventually be lost anyway.

They are simply refocusing their efforts to get Silverlight (which is a pretty good piece of engineering IMO) put to use elsewhere.

As far as I can see, that is a pretty good strategic decision.

Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by stcredzero on Friday February 11, 2011 @08:59AM (#2206321)
Silverlight is competing internally with Windows Azure. (Some potential synergy there as well.)
Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by JonoW on Friday February 11, 2011 @12:06PM (#2207135)
What has Silverlight got to do with Azure? Don't see the link...
Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by stcredzero on Friday February 11, 2011 @12:39PM (#2207306)
It's another way of running rich functionality in a browser. It might be advantageous in some situations to solve uncommon difficulties with distributing UIs. It won't necessarily be a tool for the common case.
Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by JonoW on Friday February 11, 2011 @12:54PM (#2207375)
Azure is Microsofts cloud-computing platform, think you must mean something else?
Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by stcredzero on Friday February 11, 2011 @01:30PM (#2207538)
Nope. I'm sure there will be corner cases where Silverlight will actually be just the right tool.
Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by JonoW on Friday February 11, 2011 @03:44PM (#2208049)
Er,its liking comparing Flash with Amazon EC2, I'm sure you're thinking that Azure is something else
Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by stcredzero on Friday February 11, 2011 @04:05PM (#2208129)
Er,its liking comparing Flash with Amazon EC2, I'm sure you're thinking that Azure is something else

Silverlight and Azure are different things, but they're both marketed towards developers who would like to take functionality, much of it in the form of internal apps, and make it accessible on the web or otherwise over WAN. I know this, because some Microsoft folks were pitching Azure to me just yesterday!

Yes, things don't make sense if you're stuck on "compete = comparable." A little reflection, and you should realize this isn't a very good assumption. (Teleconferencing and airlines, anyone?)

Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by JonoW on Friday February 11, 2011 @05:51PM (#2208519)
Teleconferencing and airlines solve a common problem, but what common problem do Azure and Silverlight share? They've got basically nothing to do with each other, except for as you say, that they're marketed at developers (?)
Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by JonoW on Friday February 11, 2011 @05:45AM (#2205867)
I thought neither iOS or Android use C++?
Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by tomh- on Friday February 11, 2011 @05:59AM (#2205891)
Android now offers the possibility to create entire apps in C++ using the NDK. On iOS you can also use C++.
Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by veeti on Friday February 11, 2011 @06:29AM (#2205950)
Does the new NDK actually provide access to the UI API's?
Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by JonoW on Friday February 11, 2011 @06:19AM (#2205931)
I did not know that :) So if you can use C++ on iOS, why the hell are people using the horror that is Objective-C?
Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by mambodog on Friday February 11, 2011 @06:30AM (#2205955)
On iOS C++ is generally only used when you don't need to make much use of the Cocoa Touch APIs. If you do, you will be using the hybrid 'Objective-C++' language, and you will still need to use some Objective-C.

See this Stackoverflow answer: http://stackoverflow.com/questions/3804219/what-is-the-diffe...

Basically, it's probably easier and less messy to just learn Obj-C.

Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by oscardelben on Friday February 11, 2011 @06:25AM (#2205939)
Because Objective-C is far from being an horror language, but perhaps your impression (and so mine) is conditioned by your past experience with your languages of choice.
Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by JonoW on Friday February 11, 2011 @07:08AM (#2206027)
I'm probably being unfair, I've never actually done any development in Objective-C (I have in C++), so I'm going on how it "looks" from the code I've seen, I just find it very unreadable. But in fairness I haven't tried to get into it, and I'm probably biased toward the C#/Java style syntax...
Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by neutronicus on Friday February 11, 2011 @09:16AM (#2206362)
Cocoa is an incredible API. Much more pleasant to work with than Qt, hands down.

The runtime method dispatch of Objective-C (protocols!) makes it possible. Basically Objective-C gives you what Qt had to kludge in with qmake/moc. And it's still pretty fast!

When I see how little code I have to write to do something basic in Cocoa/Obj-C, and how well it turns out, any problems I have with syntax go out with the window.

Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by spatulon on Friday February 11, 2011 @07:27AM (#2206076)
Your initial reaction to Obj-C is not at all uncommon amongst developers used to C++/Java/C#. My impression is that most of them quite like it once they get past the novelty.
Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by orangecat on Friday February 11, 2011 @11:21AM (#2206845)
As a counterpoint I've written ObjC code for over 5 years for Mac OS X and iOS, and I'm not a fan. Sure it's better than C++, but that should be in the dictionary under "damning with faint praise". Header files, primitive types, and reliance on raw pointers should have gone out 10 years ago. The kicker was when I switched to Android development last year; when a language makes Java look comparatively elegant and concise, that's not a good sign.
Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by getsat on Friday February 11, 2011 @08:46AM (#2206298)
I neglected to give more than a cursory glance at Obj-C back when the iPhone 3G and app store first came out. I hugely regret it now, but I was doing C++ at the time and thought it was the cat's pajamas.

If you can think abstractly and use/like languages like Ruby and Lisp (and their reflection/metaprogramming features), I think you'll be surprised by the amount of stuff you can do at runtime in native code. I started doing Obj-C a week ago and am about to submit my first free, 90% custom-drawn control app to Apple for approval.

Yes, the syntax is initially unappealing, but you get over it after about a day. On top of that, Xcode + Interface Builder is the best GUI dev environment I've used yet.

Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by statictype on Friday February 11, 2011 @06:58AM (#2206006)
As ugly and annoying as Objective-C is, I find it's still an order of magnitude better than C++.
Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by nika on Friday February 11, 2011 @07:48AM (#2206123)
Back when Java was my favorite language, I was once challenged to spend an hour looking at Objective-C and see if I didn't grok it in that time period, and then a week working with Cocoa-- and was promised that I'd love it if I did.

They were right.

I still believe Objective-C, paired with Cocoa is far and away the best programming language and environment out there. I've worked on the internals of windows, lots of C++, lots of Java (used to be my favorite), done .net, done a bunch of scripting languages, python, perl, lingo and actionscript, and lisp and erlang.

On the server it should be erlang (for serious code, for less serious use your favorite script)... and on desktop and mobile, Objective-C and Cocoa are really quite spectacular.

Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by kaylarose on Friday February 11, 2011 @10:19AM (#2206555)
This is my experience too. I resisted learning Objective-C very much, and tried to avoid learning it via MacRuby. But once I actually resigned myself to really learning Objective-C, I really enjoyed it.

Like Ruby/Python it has a specific style that gives you a different perspective than other languages. I now find myself using ObjC style-isms in other languages.

Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by nika on Friday February 11, 2011 @10:48AM (#2206686)
I think people find a language they like- maybe their first language, or one of the first couple- and then it is really hard to be interested in everything else. If you can't read it right off the bat, it "sucks".

This is how I felt about erlang. But the importance of concurrency was so high to me that I forced myself to learn the language, and now I love it.

A couple times learning a new language after being annoyed that it isn't like the language you already know, and I think people might recognize that every language has a reason for being....

Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by leon_ on Friday February 11, 2011 @08:35AM (#2206273)
because ... well ... you're uninformed and obj-c is not a horror?
Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by JonoW on Friday February 11, 2011 @12:03PM (#2207117)
See my reply within the thread above
Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by 0x44 on Friday February 11, 2011 @05:49AM (#2205877)
C++ is one of the languages blessed by Apple in addition to C, Objective-C, and Javascript.
Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by dawgr on Friday February 11, 2011 @05:59AM (#2205894)
If they were going to switch to iOS, can't they just switch to Objective-C too even if they used to work with C++ before?
Re:Nokia to developers: no Qt for Windows Phone development by abdulla on Friday February 11, 2011 @06:15AM (#2205919)
They have very different programming models, think Simula versus Smalltalk. You can use the two-headed beast that is Objective-C++, but there's varying levels of compatibility between the languages (in the 64 bit ABI, they share exceptions, in the 32 bit, they don't) and other various oddities they essentially mean they still remain two separate languages that have been kludged together.