News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hipmunk Says Goodbye by dmix on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @04:07PM (#22049255)
> after the wave of consolidation among airlines during the Obama years,

Ah the "too big to fail" years where everything consolidated and only got bigger including the big evil banks which took the brunt of the public's fury following the 2008 crisis (and occupy).

It's funny how so much of the regulations put in place had the opposite effect and made running small firms (ie, with more liability than the big ones) became almost impossible. Following the crisis there are now 5 mega banks who control everything and tons of the small banks shutdown and found it impossible to operate in the market with the new conditions,

It's sad that most people's consumer-interfacing perception of markets is often through these megacorps which exist in heavily regulated systems (which everyone then blames their poor experiences on markets), which are often structures which were the result of reactions to bad behaviours of a few big bad guys, which then resulted in policy only designed for the big bad firms. Meanwhile the other 90% of the marketplace, who did nothing wrong and who aren't the same size, were left dealing with the new overhead.

Automotive, airlines, finance, energy, bio/pharma, etc are all getting consolidating into smaller and smaller groups of megafirms or owned by opaque equity groups.

I don't know what the solution is but in so much of dystopian fiction the world is run by a few giant companies who control everything. That sort of system naturally creates a greater disconnect between the needs of the average consumer using the service and the whims and needs of the company (for ex: boycotts become meaningless/ineffective and consumer power lessens).

Meanwhile data is showing the number of new businesses being created are lessening and people are wondering why inequality keeps increasing, when forming small/medium sized companies used to be the main way to become upwardly mobile.

Soon the only option for upwards mobility is working your way up megacorps or making small companies who just get sold off to a bigger firm within the first 10yrs of operations.

I don't mean for this to be a diatribe against regulations but this sort of thing concerns me and regulation is only one of many forces pushing the economy towards this structure. I still think entrepreneurship is forever underrated in inequality discussions but its such a complex problem to confront, I just hope that the future really isn't just endless consolidation and an endless series of political barriers put in place preventing new shops from improving the mistakes of the past (which was a reliable source of progress for a long time).

Re:Hipmunk Says Goodbye by majormajor on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @04:24PM (#22049385)
I don't understand you using consolidation and abuse of power as a reason to dislike regulation. There are plenty of non-regulatory incentives for consolidation. Why not simply regulate consolidation? Target large holding companies and megacorps with aggressive taxation policies on revenue or headcount or market cap or similar? And then enforce the regulation with teeth?

There are always going to be creative people coming up with new ways to be bad actors, so regulation has to be an evolving constant. But responding with an aversion to regulation is just giving the game to the bad actors.

Re:Hipmunk Says Goodbye by stjohnswarts on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @05:29PM (#22049898)
I have always used this argument and agree with it. When it becomes obvious that a corporation is large and too powerful bust it up. Don't regulate the industry so much that you price control things (essentially) and add so many regulations that an army of lawyers is necessary to navigate. Industries almost always tend toward monopolies/oligopolies as people tend to try and concentrate power. Our Constitution (as long as we respect it) demands a split of power but the lassez-faire markets do not.
Re:Hipmunk Says Goodbye by dmix on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @09:30PM (#22051285)
I have similar views regarding nation state sizes. secessions are extremely rare and all we're left with is legacy states as guiding examples. Apparently federalism and confederation within larger entities has long ago lost it's allure, especially in the US.

I'm convinced the "political divide" that the US has long featured, well before the internet and the 2016 election, was largely to due to its size and expansive heterogeneousness.

Meanwhile the liberals look with envy at the governments of smaller states like Scandinavia, Australia, Canada, and others, with by compartision - a far smaller representative governments and very often less direct gov economic intervention (they prefer to gloss over that part) parthttps://www.wikiwand.com/en/Index_of_Economic_Freedom.

The US used to value its state-driven system with priority, the judiciary branch still seems to which I why I adore them - but the same can't be found in confress and senare, and I think it's long due for them to remembrance state sovereignty.

Each state should be as originally designed - individual experimental grounds for which other states to learn. If California or Oregon wants to be a super-liberal mecca - let them be - with aggressive climate policy and what not. Then they provide the world with a functioning model which to copy assuming it works well for them. Same with Texas or New Hampshire...if they really want to adopt a more

I loathe this trend towards the federal government doing and enforcing everything. It defeats a fundamental founding principles of the founding fathers - liberty via strong state sovereignty.

Re:Hipmunk Says Goodbye by devcpp on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @05:28PM (#22049891)
Oh hell no. More lawyers to find more loopholes. How about addressing the root cause: the lack of competition? The way to do this is lower the barrier to entry, which is made of 100% over-regulation.

You can involve all the antitrust you want, as long as you don't lower the barrier to entry you're just lying to yourself and adding more useless middlemen.

Re:Hipmunk Says Goodbye by wpietri on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @05:55PM (#22050105)
The barrier to entry is definitely not "100% over-regulation". Starting an airline would be extremely difficult even if it were entirely unregulated. You need airplanes, pilots, and a variety of flight and ground crew. You need landing slots at busy airports. And then you need a customer base big enough to fill up your flights.

Even if all of that were easy, you still want anti-trust regulation, because airlines are a cutthroat business. If you start up NerdBird Inc, specializing in SF-Austin flights, it is absolutely in the interests of United and American to undercut you on that route for as long as it takes to drive you out of business. Which will probably not be very long, as airlines are expensive to run and margins are thin.

Re:Hipmunk Says Goodbye by bbarn on Wednesday January 15, 2020 @08:48AM (#22054055)
Look at what happened to Virgin America? It was a consumer-focused airline that was doing very well financially, and it was forcibly acquired because of regulations that US airlines must be US owned.
Re:Hipmunk Says Goodbye by wpietri on Wednesday January 15, 2020 @10:27AM (#22054995)
Nope. That was a problem early on for Virgin America. But Branson was quite explicit: consolidation was the problem: https://www.virgin.com/richard-branson/virgin-america
Re:Hipmunk Says Goodbye by bbarn on Friday January 17, 2020 @10:59AM (#22075732)
Yeah, read the article. He was against the merger - regulation drove the forced consolidation, which he did not want. He posted about it a ton when it happened.
Re:Hipmunk Says Goodbye by munificent on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @05:51PM (#22050071)
If you remove regulations, businesses will raise barriers to entry. Businesses don't like to compete. Competition is a zero-sum game that they might lose. Instead, they prefer to form cartels and turn it into a non-zero sum game where they all win (and consumers all lose).

World history clearly shows that lack of regulation inexorably leads to trusts, cartels, price fixing, price dumping, and all sorts of other anti-competitive agreements. It's trivially easy for a monopoly or cartel to raise their own barriers to entry to maintain their hegemony.

In fact, there's a good argument that the governmental barriers to entry you are lamenting were in fact driven by entrenched businesses as an example of regulatory capture and not a flaw in regulation itself.

If you let businesses get so big that not only are they not regulated, but they have taken over control of regulation itself, you're in a real pickle.

Re:Hipmunk Says Goodbye by dnautics on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @08:17PM (#22050915)
But what is the minimum size for a business to "get so big they have taken over control of regulation"? I have seen very small companies (like, think size of one) deftly manipulate state- and federal- level regulations to their advantage.
Re:Hipmunk Says Goodbye by munificent on Wednesday January 15, 2020 @01:27PM (#22056882)
> But what is the minimum size for a business to "get so big they have taken over control of regulation"?

This is sort of like asking, "What is the minimum weight you can put on a seesaw before it tips?" The answer depends entirely what's on the other side.

One way to look at free markets is that they provide economic stability in the same way that tensegrity [0] structures provide physical stability. They work not because any element provides stability, but because — when very carefully composed together! — the elements exert opposing forces which all balance out leading to a stable system.

The "brilliant idea" of markets is taking advantages of forces that already exist — human selfishness and the desire to profit — and harness that to produce a system with some level of efficiency. The downside is that there's no real way to evaluate market participants in isolation.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tensegrity

Re:Hipmunk Says Goodbye by chipotle_coyote on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @05:46PM (#22050039)
At least on its face, I don't buy that high barriers to entry in every market is "made of 100% over-regulation." Depending on the market in question, there may be extremely high capital costs that have little to do with regulation. What you're trying to do may be highly dependent on partners who be motivated not to give you the best products/services available at reasonable prices. Competition may be entrenched simply by virtue of having been in business much longer than their new competitors, taking advantage of their scale in ways that startups can't -- including locking up potential customers through contracts.

I don't have experience in Hipmunk's field, but I do have experience, in another life, with CLECs, "competitive local exchange carriers." CLECs bloomed thanks to deregulation of their industry in the early 1990s, which is great -- but they were virtually all gone within a decade, not due to re-regulation but to the simple fact that achieving scale and profitability was monumentally expensive and difficult. The company I was at, Intermedia Communications, was bringing in close to a billion dollars of revenue annually by the time they threw in the towel and agreed to be purchased... and they still hadn't come close to turning a profit. But by that point the writing was already on the wall, and the industry was collapsing from hundreds of players to dozens. (The rise of wireless, of course, was the final death blow, but the industry was basically undead by then.)

I don't take Hipmunk's demise as a sign of "too much regulation" at all; airlines went through a similar contraction to CLECs, and what killed Hipmunk -- airlines choking off their pricing data -- will act to prevent any new competitors. That's not a function of too much regulation -- it's a function of not regulating the right things. What if airline pricing data was subject to FRAND ("fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory") licensing?

Regulation is absolutely used too often to protect incumbents, but you simply can't blame lack of competition in every industry on too much regulation. Arguably, when implemented correctly, regulation can increase competition, not harm it.

Re:Hipmunk Says Goodbye by majormajor on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @06:24PM (#22050271)
Do you expect to ever end the arms race of finding loopholes vs closing them? What would this look like?

I don't believe it's possible. You can't fight bad actors by hoping they'll just somehow lose. The unregulated "more competition" market quickly turns into a "less competition" market as the most ruthless parties establish dominance through whatever means necessary. Your barriers to entry, in the extreme case, become things like physical intimidation.

Re:Hipmunk Says Goodbye by charlesu on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @05:37PM (#22049964)
Maybe but in this case, a lower barrier to entry wouldn't have helped but regulation would have.
Re:Hipmunk Says Goodbye by soyiuz on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @05:53PM (#22050089)
How would you lower the barrier to entry into something like Facebook or Amazon? Or Google trips for that matter? Or in this example, Hipmunk?
Re:Hipmunk Says Goodbye by paulryanrogers on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @07:51PM (#22050799)
Require federation. And prohibit dropping interoperability.

Remember that golden era when XMPP was federated across Facebook, Google Talk, AOL, etc. It wasn't perfect but did give users more options.

Re:Hipmunk Says Goodbye by iamaelephant on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @06:42PM (#22050403)
> I don't mean for this to be a diatribe against regulations

I don't know how to tell you this, but it definitely is a diatribe against regulations.

Re:Hipmunk Says Goodbye by thawaway1837 on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @06:40PM (#22050391)
Right, because the biggest financial crisis since the Second World War has nothing to do with the consolidation. It must have been the regulations.

Despite the fact that the new regulations were a fraction of what was done in several decades before that time, and the fact that states that are more regulated tend to show no more monopolisation than states that are less regulated (if anything the opposite is true).

Re:Hipmunk Says Goodbye by omegaworks on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @05:01PM (#22049692)
>It's funny how so much of the regulations put in place had the opposite effect and made running small firms (ie, with more liability than the big ones) became almost impossible.

What did you expect? Obama was a policy wonk, preferring to craft intricate rulesets and mandates to coddle entrenched players rather than prosecute fraud directly or engage in structural reform. He tours the country now on the corporate talk circuit shouting down reasonable populist policy.

We have a choice to change that now, in the Democratic primary.

Re:Hipmunk Says Goodbye by rb808 on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @05:09PM (#22049749)
> owned by opaque equity groups.

or owned by index funds, who really don't care much how management operates.

Re:Hipmunk Says Goodbye by smabie on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @05:37PM (#22049960)
That's not true, Fink of BlackRock is always sending letters about something. Here's the most recent example:

https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/14/business/dealbook/larry-f...

Re:Hipmunk Says Goodbye by nemothekid on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @09:27PM (#22051272)
Letters are meaningless. BlackRock touts sustainability when just last month they decided to buy up a huge sum of Aramco