News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Boeing Fought Lion Air on Proposed Max Simulator Training... by mattacular on Monday January 13, 2020 @05:59AM (#22033411)
The Boeing CEO exited the company with just 60 million dollars, which is a lot like being sent to prison.
Re:Boeing Fought Lion Air on Proposed Max Simulator Training... by Aloha on Monday January 13, 2020 @11:59AM (#22036199)
In fairness to the guy, he came from the Military side of the house, the program was basically ready for flight by the time he took over the CEO slot. Basically all of the fatal design decisions were made before he became CEO.

The 737 MAX was a failure of process, not by specific choices made by a leader - he was fired however for his poor response to the crashes, he committed many tactical and PR errors, which made the restoration process longer than it should have been.

If still you want to lay blame at any single persons feet, lay the blame at the feet of James McNerney, the CEO who ran Boeing while the bulk of the development of the MAX was done, he's the one who kicked the MAX program off.

Re:Boeing Fought Lion Air on Proposed Max Simulator Training... by cameldrv on Monday January 13, 2020 @01:42PM (#22037235)
This is excessively kind to Muilenberg. Arguably the biggest screw-up was promising the airlines too much with regards to delivery date and training requirements. That created too much of an incentive to ship an unsafe product.

The truly fatal decision though was made in 2016 when Muilenberg was CEO. That decision was to make MCAS a single sensor system vs. a two sensor system. Originally, MCAS would activate based on a combination of a G sensor and the AoA sensor. Sometime in the middle of 2016, when they did flight testing, they found that the undesirable handling characteristics could manifest without high G, so they took the G sensor out of the mix. In order to account for the low-speed, low-g handling problem, they also had to make the MCAS corrections be much more powerful, which made it much more dangerous. The FAA apparently wasn't informed of this.

This key moment was approximately one year into Muilenberg's tenure, and so the buck has to stop with him. Muilenberg was also CEO after the Lion Air crash, and he's responsible for the decision not to ground the fleet at that time. He's also responsible for not wanting to ground the fleet after the second crash, and pressuring the FAA to quickly certify a fix.

Re:Boeing Fought Lion Air on Proposed Max Simulator Training... by stefan_ on Monday January 13, 2020 @12:33PM (#22036557)
What do you mean? The policy set here was literally set at the highest level, a specific choice - "no training, no certification" was the precise goal for the 737 MAX. How can you claim that is a failure of process.
Re:Boeing Fought Lion Air on Proposed Max Simulator Training... by Aloha on Monday January 13, 2020 @12:49PM (#22036735)
I'll argue that making the MAX behave the same as a non MAX 737 is a reachable and reasonable engineering goal, the process failed because it didnt do it safely.

Airbus absolutely uses its fly-by-wire system to change the handling characteristics of its airplanes, to make them fly the same - I see no reason why Boeing couldn't do the same thing.

Re:Boeing Fought Lion Air on Proposed Max Simulator Training... by gsnedders on Monday January 13, 2020 @02:14PM (#22037555)
> Airbus absolutely uses its fly-by-wire system to change the handling characteristics of its airplanes, to make them fly the same - I see no reason why Boeing couldn't do the same thing.

AFAIK, being on the same type rating means the A320neo has the same behaviour as the A320ceo _even when in direct law_, where there's a 1:1 mapping between input and behaviour. (Yet alone the very limited mechanical fallback!)

Re:Boeing Fought Lion Air on Proposed Max Simulator Training... by cmurf on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @03:58PM (#22049181)
Of course the difference is, pilots have mandatory knowledge and training for all of an Airbus's "laws" including the direct mode that has no abstraction, i.e. joystick inputs directly translate to control surface deflections. Whereas with MCAS, pilots were not told about it, the operating manual has no mention of it, there was no training in sim based on it being upset due to a faulty angle of attack senstor, and most remarkably? No training with it disable via stabilizer trim set to cutoff. Appalling.

As a pilot and former CFI, without any question whatsoever, a pilot must know how the airplane behaves near stall. Student pilots have demonstrated certified pilot level competency of their particular make/model aircraft stall behavior, before any CFI feels comfortable doing a student pilot sign off for solo flight. It's that goddamn basic.

And 737 MAX airplanes have two such stall behaviors, with MCAS and without (via stabilizer trim cutoff). I'd like to see every Boeing pilot involved in these decisions put on a hot seat and asked if they really think it's appropriate to sign off a pilot, as competent to fly, when they aren't completely aware of two different stall behaviors for this aircraft.

In my opinion it's unconscionable to have deprived pilots of this knowledge. I am aware of the make/model type certificate arguments. As yet no authority has said for sure whether MCAS knowledge requirements would have then required a new type certificate, or if in fact MCAS is improperly papering over an airworthiness deficiency.

What we do know is, it's damn suspicious that this make/model has been grounded this long, with multiple supposedly official statements that software fixes are done and tested and should be ready for FAA approval and deployment any day now, and yet that's been postponed at least 3 times that I'm aware of. If this is strictly a software fix, and a mere tweak back to the original basis of certification, why all the delays?

Re:Boeing Fought Lion Air on Proposed Max Simulator Training... by dTal on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @04:50AM (#22043308)
>making the MAX behave the same as a non MAX 737

The purpose of the MCAS is to make the aircraft certifiable - full stop. The MAX is dynamically unstable, in the sense that at high angles of attack it will tend to continue increasing AOA into a stall - a terrible airframe sin which they tried to fix in software. This is the real story, not this type rating stuff.

HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19695757

Re:Boeing Fought Lion Air on Proposed Max Simulator Training... by acqq on Monday January 13, 2020 @01:01PM (#22036864)
> I'll argue that making the MAX behave the same as a non MAX 737 is a reachable and reasonable engineering goal

And I argue the opposite: it can‘t be made to behave exactly the same as soon as the failure scenarios are considered.

In computer speak, you just look from the point of view of a “most common” run, not all the special cases, exceptions etc.

There are other impossibilities too, directly related to the certification requirements, already documented in the news articles before.

Re:Boeing Fought Lion Air on Proposed Max Simulator Training... by YawningAngel on Monday January 13, 2020 @02:24PM (#22037642)
The normal failure scenario for safety critical electronics on an aircraft is that you have an entirely redundant system that takes over. I don't see why that approach wouldn't have been sufficient here.
Re:Boeing Fought Lion Air on Proposed Max Simulator Training... by acqq on Monday January 13, 2020 @02:45PM (#22037852)
It is documented in the articles: failure modes have to be trained if they aren’t the same, and with MCAS as it should be (not as if was and failed catastrophically twice) they can’t be the same. New devices have to be recertified. Two sensors can’t be redundant, three would be again not the same plane. Newer computers won’t be the same plane etc.

Wait to see what the final opinion of European agencies are once the latest changes are evaluated and you’ll see that it’s not the same plane, even if Boeing all the time bent over backwards over the dead bodies of others.

Re:Boeing Fought Lion Air on Proposed Max Simulator Training... by everybodyknows on Monday January 13, 2020 @04:55PM (#22039143)
Try reading "failure of process" as "bad decisions made earlier, and enforced now by persons too powerful to challenge."
Re:Boeing Fought Lion Air on Proposed Max Simulator Training... by notatoad on Monday January 13, 2020 @02:12PM (#22037539)
>the program was basically ready for flight by the time he took over the CEO slot

isn't the whole problem here that the program wasn't ready for flight?

Re:Boeing Fought Lion Air on Proposed Max Simulator Training... by slumdev on Monday January 13, 2020 @01:17PM (#22037030)
> The 737 MAX was a failure of process

So they use SAFe Agile at Boeing, too?

Re:Boeing Fought Lion Air on Proposed Max Simulator Training... by Animats on Monday January 13, 2020 @01:27PM (#22037117)
Perhaps Indonesia will ask the US to extradite him for trial in Indonesia.
Re:Boeing Fought Lion Air on Proposed Max Simulator Training... by sorokod on Monday January 13, 2020 @07:32AM (#22033851)
Yea, in the game of monopoly
Re:Boeing Fought Lion Air on Proposed Max Simulator Training... by lowdose on Monday January 13, 2020 @06:45AM (#22033595)
Sounds like a Bob Rubin trade to me.
Re:Boeing Fought Lion Air on Proposed Max Simulator Training... by andbberger on Monday January 13, 2020 @11:56AM (#22036167)
Wow poor guy hope he's okay...
Re:Boeing Fought Lion Air on Proposed Max Simulator Training... by close04 on Monday January 13, 2020 @06:12AM (#22033454)
It's because in the US it takes much more than knowingly allowing such issues to directly kill hundreds to go to prison.

We're not talking about "calculated" deaths like the ones VW's CEO hopefully goes to prison for. Rather directly attributable ones like the 737MAX or GM's faulty ignition switch scandals.

Re:Boeing Fought Lion Air on Proposed Max Simulator Training... by sseveran on Monday January 13, 2020 @07:37AM (#22033874)
VW's former CEO isn't being charged with killing anyone one. He has been charged with committing fraud by knowingly lying to regulators.
Re:Boeing Fought Lion Air on Proposed Max Simulator Training... by close04 on Monday January 13, 2020 @08:26AM (#22034229)
I wasn't suggesting that either VW's, GM's, or Boeing's CEOs actually go to prison for "killing" anyone but rather for "knowingly allowing such issues to directly kill". And as the GM example stands to show, it's not particularly hard to get away with this in the US if you are the CEO of a powerful company.
Re:Boeing Fought Lion Air on Proposed Max Simulator Training... by ryanlol on Monday January 13, 2020 @08:47AM (#22034389)
Can you provide examples of CEOs of less powerful companies not getting away with this? Your comment seems to necessitate examples of such.
Re:Boeing Fought Lion Air on Proposed Max Simulator Training... by close04 on Monday January 13, 2020 @08:54AM (#22034444)
A gogle helped me here: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/top-10-ceos-in-prison-whyd-they...

Given that Boeing and GM are/were some of the most powerful in the US stands to reason that most companies will fall under the "less powerful" characterization. But I think my point was clear already: the more powerful the company, the more clout they have when it comes to keeping their CEOs out of prison. whether or not this is doable for smaller players is irrelevant when talking about a heavyweight like Boeing.

Re:Boeing Fought Lion Air on Proposed Max Simulator Training... by Aaargh20318 on Monday January 13, 2020 @09:45AM (#22034839)
I can't help but notice that all these are examples of CEO's going to prison for making rich people less rich. None a single one for making poor people dead.
Re:Boeing Fought Lion Air on Proposed Max Simulator Training... by close04 on Monday January 13, 2020 @10:10AM (#22035037)
> I can't help but notice

Then I'm sure you also noticed none of this makes my point* less valid. Despite the wave of downvotes (which are probably aimed at me explicitly mentioning the US) I can't see any rebuttal of something I actually said:

*Given the precedents (like the GM scandal), CEOs of big/powerful companies (Boeing) in the US (where Boeing "lives") will pretty much get away with anything, including knowingly allowing hundreds to die (which Boeing/CEO did).

Later edit:

> simply trying to lockup CEOs I don't think is the right way to go.

Indeed, it's just a good first step. The very same companies and CEOs will always fight any legal changes that would further a culture of safety first because that usually hurts the bottom line.

Re:Boeing Fought Lion Air on Proposed Max Simulator Training... by sseveran on Monday January 13, 2020 @11:00AM (#22035545)
I mean that is a pretty strong statement. It's not like it was really possible to criminally charge Tony Hayward with being at fault for a faulty blow out preventer design, even though a number of people died. In some ways we were probably less safe with him fired, given that one of his objectives was to develop a much stronger engineering centric culture at BP.

In Brazil Vale and a number of its executives (along with the European dam inspector) are expected to be indicted. It will like be about falsifying documents related to dam safety.

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-vale-sa-disaster-exclusiv...

Proving that the CEO is the one that should go to jail, while satisfying, is actually quite difficult. While I would probably agree with one piece of your sentiment, senior executives are often able to escape prosecution for things that are clearly illegal (looking at you HSBC), simply trying to lockup CEOs I don't think is the right way to go.

Re:Boeing Fought Lion Air on Proposed Max Simulator Training... by ryanlol on Monday January 13, 2020 @10:30AM (#22035260)
> Then I'm sure you also noticed none of this makes my point* less valid

But you don’t have a single example of less powerful executives going to prison in situations comparable to the one we’re discussing, right?

[dead]
Re:Boeing Fought Lion Air on Proposed Max Simulator Training... by ryanlol on Monday January 13, 2020 @07:35PM (#22040501)
Okay, so which Boeing executive did something as obviously bad?