News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Shenzhen court rules AI-written article has copyright by jimnotgym on Sunday January 12, 2020 @10:47AM (#22026761)
Shouldn't the copyright therefore belong to the robot? The company is therefore not party to the ip infringement case.

Now as an employee my ip belongs to my employer, but I am paid for this.

A robot couldn't enter into a contract without 1) being paid (consideration) or 2) the intention to create a contract. Therefore if robots are to assign copyright they are going to need training about contracts.

Re:Shenzhen court rules AI-written article has copyright by jcranmer on Sunday January 12, 2020 @11:24AM (#22027072)
I don't know about Chinese law, but the US concept is "work made for hire". This is satisfied by one of two alternatives, the first being "a work prepared by an employee within the scope of his or her employment." If you believe that an AI has sufficient personhood to be capable of authorship, then it is not unreasonable to presume that it is being employed by whomever is running it.

In the US, there are three factors that govern whether or not someone is an employee. These are:

> Control by the employer over the work. For example, the employer determines how the work is done, has the work done at the employer’s location, and provides equipment or other means to create the work.

> Control by employer over the employee. For example, the employer controls the employee’s schedule in creating the work, has the right to have the employee perform other assignments, determines the method of payment, or has the right to hire the employee’s assistants.

> Status and conduct of employer. For example, the employer is in business to produce such works, provides the employee with benefits, or withholds tax from the employee’s payment.

Looking at those factors, it is really hard to argue that an AI is not an employee, as far as US law is concerned.

Re:Shenzhen court rules AI-written article has copyright by AmericanChopper on Sunday January 12, 2020 @03:20PM (#22028986)
This line of reasoning just seems weird an unnecessary to me.

An AI is just a computer program. It’s an intangible asset. Any IP it generates was the work of the AI programmer, or perhaps also the operator who provides it with input and instructions on how to process it.

Re:Shenzhen court rules AI-written article has copyright by bonzini on Sunday January 12, 2020 @03:46PM (#22029189)
We don't generally consider compiler output to be under the copyright of the author of the compiler.
Re:Shenzhen court rules AI-written article has copyright by yorwba on Sunday January 12, 2020 @05:31PM (#22030048)
GCC has a license exception specifically to allow compiling programs with it without "infecting" the resulting output with the compiler's GPL. https://www.gnu.org/licenses/gcc-exception-3.1-faq.html
Re:Shenzhen court rules AI-written article has copyright by jcranmer on Sunday January 12, 2020 @08:54PM (#22031223)
That's more to deal with the fact that compilers insert calls to various support routines to implement certain functionality--for example, there are division routines to support architectures without a division operator.

It's not currently understood that the result of compiling code implies a claim to copyright or derivative works of any resulting compiler output, which is GP's point.

Actually, there's an argument that, even if GCC and its support libraries did not have the compiler exception clause, then there still would be no GPL "infection" of compiled code. License to use a software program implicitly carries with it a right to make any necessary copies that are functionally required, even if the copies would otherwise be infringing. So the compiler inserting copies of itself into your program would enable you to distribute those copies with your program without any further agreement (i.e., licenses) required, so long as you had legitimate license to the compiler itself.

Re:Shenzhen court rules AI-written article has copyright by AmericanChopper on Sunday January 12, 2020 @03:58PM (#22029285)
I’m not sure that’s entirely analogous. Open source and commercially licensed compilers would have licensing agreements governing how they can be used. But I imagine if a person made their own compiler, and didn’t license it to anybody, but somebody somehow gained access to it and used it to compile their code, that the resulting output would infact be infringing the IP rights of the compilers author. I’m sure you could also publicly release a compiler with a license that assigned copyright of the output to the compiler’s author (though I doubt you could convince anybody to use it).
Re:Shenzhen court rules AI-written article has copyright by burpsnard on Sunday January 12, 2020 @07:48PM (#22030932)
Famously, early pc assembler a86/d86 claimed to able to identify unlicenced used from byte-patterns

http://eji.com/a86/

Re:Shenzhen court rules AI-written article has copyright by lozenge on Sunday January 12, 2020 @11:58AM (#22027342)
This is incorrect, "work for hire" only helps determine who owns the copyright on something, not whether that thing is actually copyrightable.
Re:Shenzhen court rules AI-written article has copyright by jcranmer on Sunday January 12, 2020 @12:03PM (#22027359)
GP is suggesting that the copyright should belong with the robot, I'm pointing out that work for hire would mean that it does not belong with the robot.
Re:Shenzhen court rules AI-written article has copyright by jimnotgym on Sunday January 12, 2020 @02:53PM (#22028756)
Surely it would fall foul of anti-slavery legislation though? Unless the Robot is paid?
Re:Shenzhen court rules AI-written article has copyright by Smoosh on Sunday January 12, 2020 @04:17PM (#22029457)
Perhaps more analogous to employing a minor (without pay). But who is the guardian of the robot who can approve their employment?
Re:Shenzhen court rules AI-written article has copyright by hashmal on Sunday January 12, 2020 @10:51AM (#22026791)
> Shouldn't the copyright therefore belong to the robot?

I would consider the robot to be a kind of pencil or typewriter.

Re:Shenzhen court rules AI-written article has copyright by awb on Sunday January 12, 2020 @11:47AM (#22027258)
While it's fun to think of AI as humanoid, it's not. It's just a new kind of software.

A robot duck that can sit on a nest, make duck sounds and get food for the babies is still a robot, not a duck. Even punting in the whole consciousness debate, I think this example is easier because we generally think of ducks as simply living to reproduce and if a robot isn't organically reproducing and passing genetic material onto it's offspring, it's missing a huge part of what it is to be a duck.

Re:Shenzhen court rules AI-written article has copyright by A_Parr on Sunday January 12, 2020 @11:04PM (#22031727)
Neuter a duck and it's a robot, got it.

Human level AI just got a lot easier to create.

Re:Shenzhen court rules AI-written article has copyright by koboll on Sunday January 12, 2020 @11:46AM (#22027256)
>Shouldn't the copyright therefore belong to the robot? The company is therefore not party to the ip infringement case.

A series of if/else blocks is not a "robot", or a legal person in any sense, any more than a paintbrush or a saxophone is.

Re:Shenzhen court rules AI-written article has copyright by joshspankit on Sunday January 12, 2020 @12:47PM (#22027702)
You’re being reductionist. At a certain point humans could also be argued as being composed of if/else blocks.
Re:Shenzhen court rules AI-written article has copyright by wpietri on Sunday January 12, 2020 @10:58AM (#22026852)
Only if the robot has its own corporate entity. Otherwise, like any machine, it's not a person under the law.
Re:Shenzhen court rules AI-written article has copyright by jimnotgym on Sunday January 12, 2020 @03:03PM (#22028833)
Then how could it produce a copyrightable work? The Berne convention only applies to 'Nationals and residents' of a country. Therefore if a court has held that the robot produced copyrighted material, then the robot must be a person.
Re:Shenzhen court rules AI-written article has copyright by wpietri on Monday January 13, 2020 @10:24AM (#22035184)
Because under the law, it didn't produce the work.

Look at all the AI-driven visual art we're seeing happen. Copyright goes to the artist who set up the system and then selected the work, because that's the actual creative activity.

Creators have always used tools. The tool isn't what gets copyright, no matter how elaborate the tools. Once the tools have consciousness, drive, and self-determination, we might think otherwise. But that's not where we are today.