News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:To Store Renewable Energy, Try Freezing Air by dredmorbius on Thursday January 09, 2020 @01:03AM (#21998906)
Efficiency is only one measure of a storage system's overall usefulness.

Other dimensions are total capacity, total cost, ramp-up / ramp-down times, storage and delivery rates, and various elements of technical complexity.

Batteries offer moderate-scale, fairly-expensive, moderate density, and relatively low storage and delivery rate, energy storage. They're exceptionally useful for mobile uses (from handheld to vehicular), but may not be as desirable for stationary systems.

There's a spectrum of energy storage options, ranging from capacitive storage (very responsive, but also expensive, inefficient, high-rate but low-yield.), flywheel, battery, physical mechanisms (pumped hydro, compressed / liquified air energy storage), and chemical (electrolysis, fuel cell, fuel synthesis).

If you're storing energy when it's abundant and releasing it when it's highly scarce, net efficiency doesn't matter nearly as much as matching generation and load capacity. Losing energy because you don't have the capacity or capture rates means a theoretically highly-efficient process is actually lower in net efficiency.

The duration of energy storage, ranging from a few seconds (capacitors) or minutes (flywheel) to proven-at-hundreds-of-million-years (hydrocarbon chemical energy storage) also matters. If you're trying to smooth out transients, capacitors or flywheels (mimicking "spinning reserve" or inertia) are your tool. If you're shifting over a period of hours, batteries, CAES, and pumped hydro come into play, with the latter offering long-term capacity of months if needed. Fuel synthesis could in theory allow shifting by years or decades, with very stable storage, though a net round-trip efficiency of ~15-20% (losses in synthesis compounding Carnot efficiencies of thermal energy generation, if used for electrical generation).

I've got concerns over LAES, well reflected in @aurizon's comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21996594

Thermal losses in cooling, and the need to supply energy to re-heat the liquified air, make me question this method.

There are no comments on this comment yet.