News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SoftBank has walked away from startups, months after subm... by brenden2 on Monday January 06, 2020 @10:56AM (#21970061)
They're trying to make this a story about SoftBank being bad, but this just sounds like normal business. I have been "shafted" by VCs before, in similar ways, but none of them were SoftBank specifically. This is just an attempt to make a story (and drive clicks) out of the punching bag du jour.
Re:SoftBank has walked away from startups, months after subm... by austenallred on Monday January 06, 2020 @12:38PM (#21971101)
While it’s legal, it is not “normal” for VC funds to be backing out of a half dozen deals at the same time.

To continually do so without finding a carcass in the details would be reputation suicide for any legitimate VC.

Re:SoftBank has walked away from startups, months after subm... by toast0 on Monday January 06, 2020 @12:51PM (#21971221)
The timeline for the backing out is around the WeWork IPO debacle. This makes a lot of sense --- in reaction to that, maybe they have new standards for investing, maybe they don't even know what the new standards are yet, maybe they don't even know when the new standards will be available, (almost) all the deals in progress are going to be screwed.

This kind of stuff is more common with corporate acquirers than established VC, I would expect, but it's kind of part of the game. If you have leverage as the start up, you demand short timeframes and meaningful deposits to keep the investors on task; if you don't have leverage, you get a bad deal (6-month exclusivity is crazy).

Re:SoftBank has walked away from startups, months after subm... by austenallred on Monday January 06, 2020 @12:54PM (#21971251)
Nah, where there’s smoke there’s fire.

They’re fucked because their LPs are losing their minds, and as a result everything changed for them and they’re bailing on deals.

Re:SoftBank has walked away from startups, months after subm... by Kye on Monday January 06, 2020 @01:52PM (#21971862)
What's an LP in this context?
Re:SoftBank has walked away from startups, months after subm... by OnlineGladiator on Monday January 06, 2020 @02:01PM (#21971975)
LP stands for Limited Partner. They are the people that actually provided the funding, but they have an arrangement where they have severely limited control (basically none) as to how the money is managed once it's part of the fund. The reason for this is because they are trusting the VC firm to actually invest their money wisely, and the VC firm needs to able to do that without constant interference from the investors.

https://www.thebusinessofvc.com/blog/limited-partners-101

Re:SoftBank has walked away from startups, months after subm... by jonny_eh on Monday January 06, 2020 @03:24PM (#21972877)
All true. I suspect in this case Softbank was depending on the Vision Fund LPs to come back for round 2, but the WeWork fiasco scared them off, and now WeWork is in panic mode.
Re:SoftBank has walked away from startups, months after subm... by ganstyles on Monday January 06, 2020 @01:59PM (#21971948)
Limited Partner, the people who out up money in VC funds for the General Partner to invest/manage. iirc though LPs cant have an actual say in investment/strategy or else they risk losing the "Limited" status.
Re:SoftBank has walked away from startups, months after subm... by MartianSquirrel on Monday January 06, 2020 @01:59PM (#21971945)
LP is short for Limited Partner
Re:SoftBank has walked away from startups, months after subm... by elfexec on Monday January 06, 2020 @07:09PM (#21975129)
> While it’s legal, it is not “normal” for VC funds to be backing out of a half dozen deals at the same time.

Except that softbank vision fund is not a "normal" VC fund. They many times larger than the largest VC fund.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_venture_capital_firms

Softbank has $100 billion in assets. The 2nd closest VC fund has $17 billion. Proportionally, softbank backing out of 6 deals is like the 2nd VC fund backing out of 1 deal.

Re:SoftBank has walked away from startups, months after subm... by aguyfromnb on Monday January 06, 2020 @06:48PM (#21974918)
>reputation suicide for any legitimate VC.

A huge chunk of this fund is money from Saudi Arabia. You think reputation matters, or that startup founders are going to turn away their money?

Re:SoftBank has walked away from startups, months after subm... by avarun on Monday January 06, 2020 @11:57PM (#21977004)
Yes, 100%. Nobody wants to risk their business on empty promises from a VC with a poor track record, even if they're offering inflated valuations.
Re:SoftBank has walked away from startups, months after subm... by aguyfromnb on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @09:52AM (#21980402)
>Nobody wants to risk their business

The business most of these startups are in is burning venture capital.

Re:SoftBank has walked away from startups, months after subm... by sobani on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @03:43AM (#21989603)
That only works if you can actually get that money. If you don't trust a VC to actually give you the money they promised it's wiser to go with one you can.
Re:SoftBank has walked away from startups, months after subm... by jariel on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @10:08PM (#21987898)
Nobody is walking away from SoftBank, and they don't have a poor track record.

They're a major upstart, and will be around probably for quite some time. At least until a crash, probably longer.

There are very few players in town willing and able to bankroll what used to be IPO level funding. It's a new category of investing they've created, and they are still the leader.

Re:SoftBank has walked away from startups, months after subm... by JumpCrisscross on Monday January 06, 2020 @11:00AM (#21970110)
> this just sounds like normal business

All except Creator. Getting a company to enter into "an exclusive, six-month term sheet" is unusual and shitty.

Re:SoftBank has walked away from startups, months after subm... by jagged-chisel on Monday January 06, 2020 @12:50PM (#21971214)
Having read this, I'd think (as the startup) I'd insist on a clause that the contract isn't binding until at least $X or %Y have been received from the VC (defining "received" as "the money deposited and cleared.") And if we find another investor before you send the money, the contract is dead and we renegotiate a new one.
Re:SoftBank has walked away from startups, months after subm... by jethro_tell on Monday January 06, 2020 @02:06PM (#21972016)
If you have the leverage for that, it could work. But you probably also wouldn't sign a 6mo exclusivity deal if you had that kind of leverage . . . so?
Re:SoftBank has walked away from startups, months after subm... by utopian3 on Monday January 06, 2020 @11:19AM (#21970304)
What are the negatives that the six-month term sheet implies that I'm missing (I'm not familiar with them)?
Re:SoftBank has walked away from startups, months after subm... by brenden2 on Monday January 06, 2020 @11:24AM (#21970344)
The negative is that you can't go out and do fundraising with any other parties until that 6 months is up. Depending on how much runway you have, that might be terminal for some startups.

I think 30 days is more typical, but YMMV. If the company is in dire need of funding then the VCs can usually get away with more.

Re:SoftBank has walked away from startups, months after subm... by OnlineGladiator on Monday January 06, 2020 @12:40PM (#21971124)
> The company pushed back, and SoftBank agreed to wire between $10 million and $15 million as a show of good faith.

It sounds like they probably came out ahead anyway, if runway was even slightly a concern for them.

Re:SoftBank has walked away from startups, months after subm... by Bartweiss on Monday January 06, 2020 @02:20PM (#21972180)
A six month lockup with no guarantee on the other side sounds crazy, but with a cash transfer to compensate and provide runway it looks a lot more reasonable.

(Of course, it depends a lot on the missing detail of what SoftBank took for that money in the absence of a deal. Was it a loan? A smaller investment at the same terms/valuation planned for the big one?)

Re:SoftBank has walked away from startups, months after subm... by OnlineGladiator on Monday January 06, 2020 @02:27PM (#21972234)
I'm not saying Softbank is a great fund (I've thought they made shitty investments long before the recent media frenzy in the past year), I just meant Creator isn't exactly a startup starlet that is drowning in funding opportunities. They're ~10 years old, have raised ~25 MM, and I heard their last round was already a downround (pretty bad considering how little they've raised and how long they've been around).

Looking from the outside, Creator was likely desperate for cash and happy to agree to anything - which they did. And unless they ended up with no cash at all after this brouhaha, they are probably still better off than they were initially.

And who knows - maybe Softbank will still give a stupid amount of cash to another terrible robotics startup. They've certainly done dumber things before.

Re:SoftBank has walked away from startups, months after subm... by Bartweiss on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @12:10PM (#21981945)
Yeah, all very true.

Out of all those stories, I'm most surprised SoftBank walked away on Seismic. Maybe they're scared that all the recent unicorns are going to lose value, but it's a pretty safe/standard company that wasn't depending on Softbank to live, and opening the Japanese market was a Softbank-specific perk.

Funding an already-unicorn at a high valuation isn't likely to get you the usual VC 10x, I guess. But it sounds like a way to help stabilize Softbank's rep with a modest win, not a risky bet to bail out of.

Re:SoftBank has walked away from startups, months after subm... by heyflyguy on Monday January 06, 2020 @12:06PM (#21970784)
It does suck that it happened, and I've been on a similar receiving end of that - but at the end of the day the founders had to sign and the board approved that "deal".
Re:SoftBank has walked away from startups, months after subm... by duxup on Monday January 06, 2020 @11:27AM (#21970376)
It might be shitty but it's not like they didn't know it was 6 months.

I'm not trying to absolve Softbank here but if 6 months is bad, Creator knew it... they signed it.

Re:SoftBank has walked away from startups, months after subm... by brenden2 on Monday January 06, 2020 @11:01AM (#21970118)
Indeed, 6 month does seem onerous. Definitely a tough lesson learned there.
Re:SoftBank has walked away from startups, months after subm... by CalChris on Monday January 06, 2020 @03:00PM (#21972620)
What did Creator get for this six months of exclusivity?
Re:SoftBank has walked away from startups, months after subm... by apozem on Monday January 06, 2020 @05:46PM (#21974348)
> They're trying to make this a story about SoftBank being bad

Don't overthink it and assume motivations with zero proof - they're reporting facts about how SoftBank is dragging their heels on some deals.

At the very least, it's informative and helpful to anyone who may deal with them in the near future.

Re:SoftBank has walked away from startups, months after subm... by rdiddly on Monday January 06, 2020 @07:02PM (#21975049)
If I WERE going to assume motivations, I would put it more like "They have SoftBank and the Vision Fund on a death watch ever since WeWork."
Re:SoftBank has walked away from startups, months after subm... by mindentropy on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @11:23PM (#21988324)
When you have words like "shafted" in a news about investments etc then what do you expect the story to be but unprofessional.
Re:SoftBank has walked away from startups, months after subm... by BitwiseFool on Monday January 06, 2020 @12:54PM (#21971257)
What do you mean by "Shafted"? I'm interested to know what they did.
Re:SoftBank has walked away from startups, months after subm... by brenden2 on Monday January 06, 2020 @01:56PM (#21971910)
The original title (before it was changed) included the word "shafted".