Of course, that may have meant that sites like YouTube and a lot of other content simply wouldn't exist.
The advertising supported web has created perverse incentives, which doesn’t serve web users.
I don't know what an internet without all of the worthless ad-supported "content" looks like, but however it looks, suspect it is the steady-state equilibrium that will exist in the future. Because the ad-supported business model -- bad UX by definition -- is so obviously a house of cards.
In this world, I can imagine a patronage model working: wealthy individuals support particular journalists, perhaps privately, and the infrastructure of the internet is used to get the word out in a way that is analogous to the chat or messaging of the present.
I don't see how paying for journalism solves anything on itself. You have to pay for specific kinds of journalism and create tools to allow discovery and differentiation of that journalism.
It really is a return to the bad old days of the late 90's web where one wrong click would kill your browser with 20 new popups. Except this time these corporations are willingly doing it to themselves. I wouldn't have believed it even a few years ago. Surely this must be killing engagement on their sites?