News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Survey of scientists sheds light on reproducibility crisi... by inimino on Sunday January 05, 2020 @06:23PM (#21964979)
Isn't it the exact opposite? Presumably the papers scientists are reading are primarily the ones in their own field.
Re:Survey of scientists sheds light on reproducibility crisi... by Frost1x on Sunday January 05, 2020 @07:30PM (#21965404)
That depends on how critical you are. Our current incentive structure is out of control across the board and everything is skewing towards maximizing ROI in about every aspect of life money is involved in.

I apply this perspective to everything I see ("how are they getting money from this?") then work backwards and it seems to lead to accurate predictions, at least anecdotally. Perhaps I'm just jaded and cynical but it works well, unfortunately.

Re:Survey of scientists sheds light on reproducibility crisi... by TeMPOraL on Sunday January 05, 2020 @07:42PM (#21965466)
> Perhaps I'm just jaded and cynical but it works well, unfortunately.

It works well for me too.

I've learned to extend the "how are they getting money from this?" question into a generalized, first-principles thinking - look at the incentive structures and think about what they imply, about what's the expected behavior of a system running under those incentives. Because while not everything is about the money, systems will evolve over time along the lines of the incentives contained in them.

Re:Survey of scientists sheds light on reproducibility crisi... by TeMPOraL on Sunday January 05, 2020 @06:29PM (#21965023)
I'm arguing that the phenomena seem identical in their underlying structures. In both cases, we're dealing with a situation in which a person faces mountains of evidence that a source (a newspaper, or scientific papers in a given field) keeps pumping out inaccurate or wrong publications, but despite all that evidence, they assume that whatever isn't explicitly pointed out as wrong must be 100% true, accurate and honest.
Re:Survey of scientists sheds light on reproducibility crisi... by inimino on Sunday January 05, 2020 @06:37PM (#21965078)
Ah, yes. Wishful thinking.
Re:Survey of scientists sheds light on reproducibility crisi... by asdff on Sunday January 05, 2020 @09:33PM (#21965949)
Ideally, but once you are deep in a field what a field even is becomes murky. You have a biology paper you submit for review, but methodologically it's not really a biology paper, but maybe a statistics paper, or a computer science paper, or a theoretical math paper. Who reviews that paper, the person who knows the biology in question or the methods through and through? Sometimes the only person in the world who knows the theory and the technology in question the best is the author.