if even 'scientist' themselves fail, then society is heading toward an absurdly frightening faux-intellectual inquisitive period.
Fact checking, unfortunately, isn’t what we think it is. Despite the superficial appearance, fact checking isn’t a helpful tool for determining the truth and for forming an accurate opinion. Instead, it’s actually an in/out group filter which segregates people by belief and value, while allowing each group to believe they hold the Factual High-Ground, and to claim any subsequent moral position which proceeds from being “factually correct.
Sure it is. Not the bare conclusions viewed uncritically, but the support with references, if it exists (which in most notable fact checkers it does) absolutely is.
I apply this perspective to everything I see ("how are they getting money from this?") then work backwards and it seems to lead to accurate predictions, at least anecdotally. Perhaps I'm just jaded and cynical but it works well, unfortunately.
It works well for me too.
I've learned to extend the "how are they getting money from this?" question into a generalized, first-principles thinking - look at the incentive structures and think about what they imply, about what's the expected behavior of a system running under those incentives. Because while not everything is about the money, systems will evolve over time along the lines of the incentives contained in them.
The speculation referred to as the "Gell-Mann Amnesia effect" starts with a subject identifying a low-quality article riddled with errors from a section of the newspaper within their area of expertise. They then turn the page to another section of the newspaper outside their area of expertise and "treat it as gospel" without thinking critically.
Maybe it's true, maybe it's not. But you are adding another part-- colleagues who use relevant expertise to inform the subject that the other sections of the newspaper are also low-quality and riddled with errors.
With that addendum I'm confident that I can now beat the house. I will take the bet against this modified Gell-Mann Amnesia effect for any amount the casino is willing to let me wager.
Edit: clarification
It sounds very much like an academic equivalent of Gell-Mann Amnesia - the phenomenon in which you notice that every news article on a topic in your field is complete garbage, people you know in other professions report the same situation with articles on topics in their fields, and yet when you turn the page and see an article on something outside your field, you forget about the whole thing and treat it as a gospel.