Re:Poll: How many (natural) languages are you fluent in?
by copper on Wednesday February 09, 2011 @01:17AM
(#2196599)
> I speak 3 and read another 3
Doesn't that mean you can speak 6?
The Indian subcontinent usually gets complicated, as there are usually a /lot/ of local dialects that people speak, and some of them may arguably deserve to be separate languages - at least, the speakers usually think so :)
Re:Poll: How many (natural) languages are you fluent in?
by mahmud on Wednesday February 09, 2011 @01:34AM
(#2196641)
Doesn't that mean you can speak 6?
No. It's possible to read formal prose in a language without speaking it.
Polite/learned communication, specially in writing, is often contrived and limited, often resembling an archaic form of the language. It's very possible to read formal text in a language, and glean meaning from it based on your expertise in the language family. Though you would be helpless in the street.
Re:Poll: How many (natural) languages are you fluent in?
by solipsist on Wednesday February 09, 2011 @12:22AM
(#2196472)
> My maternal grandmother speaks 7; but she can't read or write :-)
Very interesting to hear that. What are the languages that she speaks?
Re:Poll: How many (natural) languages are you fluent in?
by mahmud on Wednesday February 09, 2011 @12:27AM
(#2196490)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harar#People (+ arabic and turkish)
Rule of thumb is: sizable minority language + official/ruling language + one international language:
Cantonese / Mandarin / English
Swedish / Finish / English
Tamazighi / Arabic / French
Basque / Castilian / English
I speak 3 and read another 3. My father is fluent in 5 and can bullshit in Russian. My maternal grandmother speaks 7; but she can't read or write :-)