News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Much Land Does a Man Need? (1886) by curuinor on Sunday January 05, 2020 @04:55PM (#21964423)
Basically, the social value of land is 100% socially constructed, but under a system of landownership, it's 100% privately held and all the profit goes to private hands. There are multiple empty lots very close to downtown SF which are worth millions, tens of millions that the landlord didn't do jack shit to improve, that everyone else improved the value of, that the entire value of is the location. But when the landlord sells, only they get the value.

But it's easy as hell to tax land and impossible to avoid the tax (just show up with cops, what the hell are they going to do, move the land? - and if they don't pay, just sell the land to someone else, although usually the aim is to collect the tax when transactions happen) So tax it. 100%. Georgism's tax suggestions go: have that 100% land tax (not property tax), have no other taxes, that's it. Also tax networks which have an inherent monopoly effect, it was also suggested by Henry George.

Nothing to do with agrarian points of view, really. Georgism was created in SF, it was most popular in NYC, and it was talking about the problems of the first properly modern cities in America and Britain.

Re:How Much Land Does a Man Need? (1886) by mc32 on Sunday January 05, 2020 @05:06PM (#21964487)
When you don't or can’t own land you end up with favela-like developments. It’s okay as a sort of transition from homelessness to home ownership but you don’t want that to be the end stage for a city.
Re:How Much Land Does a Man Need? (1886) by curuinor on Sunday January 05, 2020 @05:10PM (#21964512)
Land value tax isn't property tax. Despite my use of the word "expropriation", what George specifically suggested was that people would be able to own land, they just wouldn't benefit any from improvements in land value because of the land value tax. So you would have to improve property and do something with it to benefit from it.
Re:How Much Land Does a Man Need? (1886) by asdff on Monday January 06, 2020 @02:58AM (#21967406)
You get that in absence of building codes. Right now in many major cities people don't or can't own land, can't build rigid favelas due to building codes, and instead end up living in tent favelas on the sidewalk or sleep in their car. That's not a great end stage for a city, either, but that's the status quo in our investment driven real estate market.
Re:How Much Land Does a Man Need? (1886) by Barrin92 on Sunday January 05, 2020 @09:07PM (#21965829)
>Basically, the social value of land is 100% socially constructed, but under a system of landownership, it's 100% privately held and all the profit goes to private hands.

But this can be said for anything, no? After all the value of every asset is socially constructed, whether that's shares in a company or land seems irrelevant, so if you buy that logic I feel like the Marxist case makes more sense instead of just arbitrarily stopping at land.

It also seems counterintuitive because it would essentially mean that someone who holds billions in shares or digital assets has no tax burden under the Georgist logic but a small independent farmer does.

Re:How Much Land Does a Man Need? (1886) by lmm on Monday January 06, 2020 @12:04AM (#21966595)
You own the value of the goods you've made with your own hands (minus the value of their raw materials if you want to be strict about it), and by extension you can freely trade those. Land is the exception because people don't make it themselves, they lay claim to what's already there (even in the case of "artificial" land, most of the value is in the seabed that was there before rather than what you did).

> It also seems counterintuitive because it would essentially mean that someone who holds billions in shares or digital assets has no tax burden under the Georgist logic but a small independent farmer does.

Someone living like a billionaire probably owns a much higher value of land (if only what's under their mansion) than a small independent farmer. The land value tax would end up being built into food prices, so farmers wouldn't lose out on the whole unless they're currently growing wastefully; maybe farming would be pushed onto less valuable land, that's sort of the point (but in practice that mostly happens already; farmers near towns wanting to expand would get gradually pushed out via higher taxes rather than getting a windfall for selling up, which is bad for those individual farmers but better for society as a whole).

Re:How Much Land Does a Man Need? (1886) by nybble41 on Monday January 06, 2020 @03:47PM (#21973116)
> Land is the exception because people don't make it themselves ...

People don't make the land but they do make the value of the land. Even if that just consists of recognizing the potential in what is already there. LVT does nothing to distinguish between value resulting from the actions of the owner—apart from a very limited set of formally recognized "improvements", mainly permanent structures—and value resulting from the actions of others. And even if part of the "unimproved" value does result from others' actions, these others are not, in general, the ones receiving the tax.

Re:How Much Land Does a Man Need? (1886) by lmm on Monday January 06, 2020 @06:54PM (#21974976)
> LVT does nothing to distinguish between value resulting from the actions of the owner—apart from a very limited set of formally recognized "improvements", mainly permanent structures—and value resulting from the actions of others. And even if part of the "unimproved" value does result from others' actions, these others are not, in general, the ones receiving the tax.

The same is true of the existing system - currently owners pocket all of the value increase despite the vast majority of it being nothing to do with them. LVT is a recognition that most of the value of land comes from the actions of others - not just a handful of immediate neighbours but the whole surrounding community (e.g. most of the value of land in a given city gets its value from the entirety of that city) - and so should rightfully go to an organisation that represents that community as a whole.

Re:How Much Land Does a Man Need? (1886) by nybble41 on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @12:38PM (#21982298)
> currently owners pocket all of the value increase

Except for the property taxes and local sales taxes which pay for all these things supposedly contributing "unearned" value to the land... and which over time add up to more than the increase in land value.

> despite the vast majority of it being nothing to do with them

> to an organisation that represents that community as a whole

[citation needed x 2]

LVT eliminates the financial incentive to take personal or collective private action to improve the community as a whole. Rather than increasing the value of your property (and your neighbours') your only reward is to be saddled with additional taxes above and beyond the cost of the improvements. The LVT model essentially assumes that the only source of community-level improvements worthy of remuneration is the government. Which is obviously nonsense. If I contribute to the community at my own expense, the benefits accrue not to me but to the government—which may represent "us" in a vague, manipulative sense but certainly doesn't represent me—to be spent more often than not on things I explicitly do not want and which are contrary to my own interests. Governments love to act as though they enjoy an agent/principal relationship with their constituents but neglect the fact that an agent has a individual duty to each principal, not just the majority position. It's an inherent conflict of interest to serve multiple principals with conflicting goals.

Of course, property taxes have a similar issue, but at least they don't have an explicit goal of negating all profit to the property owner; you don't get the full benefit of contributed improvements but you do get the majority of it.

Re:How Much Land Does a Man Need? (1886) by lmm on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @08:24PM (#21987295)
> The LVT model essentially assumes that the only source of community-level improvements worthy of remuneration is the government. Which is obviously nonsense.

Any organisation that purported to represent the community well enough to make community-level improvements (which will almost inevitably make things worse for some people even if they're a huge gain for the community as a whole), like "we should demolish these buildings to put a rail line in" or "should this area be a park or a factory", would have to incorporate the same feedback mechanisms and so on that would make it a de facto government.

If you're doing something that really improves the community as a whole, under LVT the community government should be willing to fund it, since they'll get back all the value. Indeed they have an incentive to seek out ways to improve the community and encourage neighbourhoods to improve themselves, unlike today.

> Governments love to act as though they enjoy an agent/principal relationship with their constituents but neglect the fact that an agent has a individual duty to each principal, not just the majority position. It's an inherent conflict of interest to serve multiple principals with conflicting goals.

Of course it is. Doing anything on a community scale is inherently difficult, and there will inherently be winners and losers. LVT actually helps even that out though - the gains of community-scale improvements accrue to the government of the community as a whole, but by the same token they also bear the cost of any local deteriorations.

> Of course, property taxes have a similar issue, but at least they don't have an explicit goal of negating all profit to the property owner; you don't get the full benefit of contributed improvements but you do get the majority of it.

Property taxes are a completely backwards way to approach this kind of thing, because they punish the owner for the one kind of community improvement that they actually fully control and spend their own money on. Under LVT you keep the full value of your buildings, landscaping and so on (which are the result of your own toil); you pay taxes on the value of the unimproved land, which is a function of the community as a whole rather than your individual efforts.

Re:How Much Land Does a Man Need? (1886) by throwno on Sunday January 05, 2020 @05:02PM (#21964468)
Do you suppose the owner of the land wants to build on it, but is being blocked by socialists in the government? Do you think this developer bought some lots in SF and left them empty just to make tech bros upset?
Re:How Much Land Does a Man Need? (1886) by curuinor on Sunday January 05, 2020 @05:12PM (#21964525)
In a Georgist system, they would throw up their hands and immediately sell. But the developer isn't selling it because the land is appreciating...
Re:How Much Land Does a Man Need? (1886) by rcurry on Sunday January 05, 2020 @06:20PM (#21964954)
“But it's easy as hell to tax land and impossible to avoid the tax (just show up with cops, what the hell are they going to do, move the land?“

The revenue man wanted granddaddy bad, headed up the holler with everything he had, ‘fore my time but I’ve been told, he never came back from Copperhead Road...

Re:How Much Land Does a Man Need? (1886) by curuinor on Sunday January 05, 2020 @06:28PM (#21965010)
If you shoot all the cops (and probably the army), then you have conquered the land, congratulations. You are now the state. Probably have to go and make your own cops now.