We require any companies who collect interest payments on things like student loans to automatically report that to the IRS. We could then have the IRS fill that in for your tax return automatically.
But special interests don't want that to happen.
For better or for worse, tax software does add utility for most people.
Hopefully this reform from the IRS actually improves the situation.
Between overly complex rules, heavy advertising, and lobbying, the tax prep companies have us all convinced we'll go jail if we don't pay $40-$400+ for prep services.
Yes, there are several million people with special cases. If there were 3 million of them, that's not even 1% of the population. A significant group, but hardly demonstrative of "basically no-one".
Income - [ 3 or 4 basic deductible items ] - [ N * exemptions ] - standard deduction => go to tax table => tax. Done.
If I was an older person who wasn't super comfortable dealing with computer programs, I would absolutely pay a CPA a few hundred bucks to do my taxes. It saves me time and I don't have to worry about screwing it up.
It's the same reason people get food delivered. I'm paying someone to cook food and bring it to my house. It's something I could do myself, but its a hassle that I can pay to avoid. Plus, I can be confident that a professional chef is much less likely to prepare me burnt / raw / untasty food than I would be myself.
In Norway, the government already has the data needed for your tax return: Withholdings, bank interest, capital gains, property income, loans, etc. The exceptions are things like foreign income, property, etc. that don't get automatically reported.
The tax return is automatically filled out for you, and if you don't amend it by the deadline (which you do by logging into the government portal and editing the form, adding additional forms, etc., all digitally), it's automatically submitted as-is.
(And the forms are simple! When I look at my US tax returns, which are prepared by a CPA, I can barely make heads or tails of it. But I could easily do a Norwegian tax return from scratch myself without a CPA.)
Most people don't need to anything at all, even if they have a situation that in the US would require a bunch of number crunching.
The above is also true about most European countries, by the way.
No it is like buying a stick of gum at the gas station, you give the cashier a $10 and he gives you $8 back. That $8 isn't a gift, the cashier was giving you back money you gave him that you didn't owe. The majority of tax refunds are exact this, a refund of your own money that the government took from you, and is now giving back to you without paying interest for holding it for ~1 years
And truthfully, it's not a lot of money. I would gladly pay $30-40 just to not have to deal with the hassle of filling out a piece of paper and mailing it and all that. Now that the IRS seems to have a decent electronic system, I'll give that a go this year and see if turbo tax is worth it anymore.
Yeah, turbo tax is a pretty scummy company with all the lobbying and deception. I won't argue that. But their product is genuinely good and provides utility to me, and I'm sure I'm not the only one.