In my opinion, providing legal drugs and rehabilitation to addicts, free of charge, would significantly reduce these kinds of thefts and break-ins, in addition to a lot of other huge societal benefits. The system works by only allowing the addict to consume the drug under supervision; they can't take anything outside of the clinic. It seems to work very well in some European countries.
If you can't know the intent (and you can't), then you must assume the worst intent and act accordingly. Anything else is naive.
Because I promise you one thing, I look up and see a stranger in my house, I'm attacking them immediately with no thought towards anything except protecting myself and everyone in the house. There will be no questions until it's over with.
If they were just looking to steal something for drugs, that can be sorted out once I've subdued them.
I was just saying drug addicts aren't necessarily garbage. They face lethal force because they've broken into one's home; not because "they're garbage".
A spree shooter killing innocent people in cold blood is garbage, and a terrorist blowing up a building is garbage, but a drug addict in awful pain due to terrible decisions acting purely on impulse to stymie the pain isn't garbage. They take their life in their hands if they break into someone's home, because that's how any break-in has to be treated, but that doesn't make them subhuman.
> Being kinder to garbage
See, that's where we probably don't think the same way. I consider few people "human trash". Drug addicts I don't count as "human trash", they're just victims of an addiction and in need of help.
People who are not drug addicts and are just plain evil, those would be "human trash" in my eyes (think Mengele).
The words we choose to frame a situation are important. Your mindset comes from a very aggressive mindset, at least that's how it seems to me.
I also regard violation of a family home as such a crime as to render the person difficult to redeem. The kind of people that make such choices aren't just high right now they are also bad unethical people.
The poster above made a conjecture that it was incorrect to assume one was in mortal danger from a robber and that shooting such a person was an overreaction.
I considered that. Actual stats say that 1/4 robbers that break in while individuals are home victimize the people therein and 39% had a weapon.
https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/ascii/vdhb.txt
This says to me that a house breaker is a substantial risk refuting the prior posters expressed idea.
You will note that both the original poster and I had a point regardless of whether you agree with either.
I'm not even sure what idea
>constant regurgitation of a corporatized and hateful memecomplex
Is supposed to express. What is the memecomplex and wherein is it puked up repeatedly?
Would you like to try to express yourself more clearly and respectfully?
I don't think anyone suggested that it was reasonable to respond to the police executing a no knock warrant with bullets. In fact a massive downside of no knock warrants is that a police search may be mistaken for a home invasion.
In a home invasion one can in most places render your home safe by shooting an invader but in most places shooting the cops will result in a very long prison sentence. We segwayed into a discussion of what the right thing to do in the event of an actual intruder. Perhaps you didn't notice?
> you may presume that you have done something to convince them that you are worth the effort of going above and beyond what is otherwise reasonable, as most jurisdictions with no-knock warrants require a reason for the surprising entry.
You presume wrongly about the cause of no knock warrants. Most are for drugs. Most find no drugs. 10% in new york city actually involved kicking down the wrong door.
https://www.newsmax.com/FastFeatures/no-knock-raids-SWAT-fac...
> It's not going to get more respectful
Yes. Yes it is.
Shooting at a burglar sounds like a great way to turn them into a robber or murderer.
Unless you miss, and take out your family member (or others) yourself.
Also, if you do take out someone in your house... they likely have relatives too. Who may become fairly interested in you and/or your family afterwards. Aka that "violence begets violence" thing. :/
1/4 of the time when a person is present for their burglary they are assaulted, robbed, raped, or murdered.
If someone breaks into your home and you shoot them to death they have zero chance of harming your family.
Decreasing the risk of breaking into people's homes incentivizes human trash to convert your valuables to drugs and put your family at risk in the process. Even junkies can grasp that housebreaking is dangerous which is why they try to at least avoid people most times.
Being kinder to garbage changes that dynamic.