News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:36C3 Staff Assaulted Me for Political Reasons by itg on Sunday December 29, 2019 @09:40AM (#21906069)
Did you watch the video that was linked? This wasn't an eviction, they started to physically assault him. Fortunately, it looks like the prosecutor has started a case against the assaulters.
Re:36C3 Staff Assaulted Me for Political Reasons by zxexz on Sunday December 29, 2019 @09:44AM (#21906091)
What I see in the video looks like security removing somebody from the premises.
Re:36C3 Staff Assaulted Me for Political Reasons by pnako on Sunday December 29, 2019 @09:53AM (#21906144)
It looks like a bunch of teenagers jumping someone. They don't look or behave like professional security agents. The bad chokehold one of them was attempting is actually banned from many police forces.
Re:36C3 Staff Assaulted Me for Political Reasons by tastroder on Sunday December 29, 2019 @09:57AM (#21906168)
> They don't look or behave like professional security agents.

Well they aren't. Security roles at congress are performed by volunteers and that's a good thing, they don't usually have to physically evict people.

Re:36C3 Staff Assaulted Me for Political Reasons by namibj on Sunday December 29, 2019 @10:38AM (#21906406)
Gate/door watch is volunteer/"angel shifts".

The CrewCrew bouncers are hired as far as I know. Angels don't have a reason to assault anyone except in personal self-defense, i.e. punching someone who's trying to jab a screwdriver into them or similar 1 on 1 assault defense cases.

The gate access control angels are instructed to dial 110 on DECT which connects them to CrewCrew dispatch/triage.

Re:36C3 Staff Assaulted Me for Political Reasons by scurvy on Sunday December 29, 2019 @10:05AM (#21906210)
Call the police. Don't use a nerd militia.
Re:36C3 Staff Assaulted Me for Political Reasons by eqvinox on Sunday December 29, 2019 @11:10AM (#21906578)
(Posted in another branch, here for reference:)

The "they should've called the police" argument is legally wrong in Germany. The allies were pretty pissed off after WW2 and wanted to eliminate the "bystander" excuse for people who watched Jews getting gassed. That's where the "failure to render aid" law comes from. Of course, you're not expected to endanger yourself, but - say, there's an average guy assaulting someone, and you're travelling in a group of 5 reasonably muscular, capable guys... your excuse to not step in is gone.

Re:36C3 Staff Assaulted Me for Political Reasons by scurvy on Sunday December 29, 2019 @11:52AM (#21906882)
It doesn't seem that the "aggressor" here was very aggressive and remained largely passive. No laws are absolute and that's what judges are for.

I doubt the "failure to render aid" law in Germany is interpreted as everyone is deputized to enforce every law, everywhere, at all times. There's probably a narrower view on what's appropriate and when.

(More related to the actual events) if someone illegally parks their car in your driveway, you should call the police to have it cited and towed. You can't break the windows and try to move it yourself under normal circumstances. However, if there were a fire and the car were blocking some sort of escape, then sure, break the windows and drop the parking brake to get the car moved.

Again, this is why we have judges and you should call the police in almost every case except those involving grave danger.

Re:36C3 Staff Assaulted Me for Political Reasons by glogla on Sunday December 29, 2019 @09:48AM (#21906114)
I think might be a cultural difference? To _physically_ move someone who doesn't want to be move, you have to _physically_ grab them and move them. You usually do this with multiple people, in case the person might get violent or something.

But I know that in some jurisdictions, just grabbing someone, not to mention moving them, is considered assault.

So there's a conflict I guess? I'm not sure how to reconcile this, just be advised that customs around the world differ.

Re:36C3 Staff Assaulted Me for Political Reasons by eqvinox on Sunday December 29, 2019 @09:51AM (#21906136)
German law covers this in §32 StGB ("emergency defense"), which includes emergency assistance. If people were reasonably convinced that he was threatening others, they're done & out clear.

P.S.: in German law, it's actually a crime to _not_ render assistance to others in danger - StGB §323c ("failure to render assistance")

Re:36C3 Staff Assaulted Me for Political Reasons by Tomte on Sunday December 29, 2019 @09:58AM (#21906171)
German law has extraordinary self-defense statutes, both civil and criminal. The following applies to criminal self-defense:

Any ongoing[1] illegal attack on any legal right may be warded off using force, including insults (that's an attack against personal honor).

The force does not have to be proportional, only necessary (it must not be more severe than another one that would lead to success) and effective (it must have a reasonable expectation of success to start with).

Apart from that there are only minor exceptions (for small children and so on).

[1] "ongoing" is again much wider than you'd think: someone robbing you and running away with the loot? Still ongoing. You following them and striking them down? Still ongoing. Meeting them on the street next day by chance? Not ongoing.

Re:36C3 Staff Assaulted Me for Political Reasons by Tomte on Sunday December 29, 2019 @10:03AM (#21906193)
> illegal attack on any legal right

Except abortion, strangely.

That's for historic reasons, Germany also had a long debate about abortion, and the compromise found was that abortion is illegal, but does not lead to criminal culpability.

According to that, it would be possible to use self-defense for the unborn child against the mother and doctors when she tries to abort.

Obviously, nobody wants burning abortion clinics, and the courts settled on that abortion cannot trigger self-defense.

That's un-principled, and I'm not aware of any legal expert actually justifying it on doctrinal grounds, but it's useful to keep the peace in the debate.

Re:36C3 Staff Assaulted Me for Political Reasons by scurvy on Sunday December 29, 2019 @10:09AM (#21906225)
I'd guess there's a bar to meet here on immediate danger, and my guess it wasn't here?

Uninvited guest shows up to the party, you should call the police.

Seems like there were 0 cool heads and everyone involved is guilty of something.

Re:36C3 Staff Assaulted Me for Political Reasons by Tomte on Sunday December 29, 2019 @10:14AM (#21906259)
I'm not trying to judge whether whatever anybody did in this specific example (as little as we know) was valid self-defense. I'm just trying to convey some aspects of German law which may be very strange to people from other legal cultures.

For example, whenever I'm reading an article about "the new Texan shoot-first-ask-later law"[1]/stand-your-ground/castle-doctrine I'm very disappointed in the emotional reporting, because it seems so mild and almost pacifist.

[1] to use the cliché

Re:36C3 Staff Assaulted Me for Political Reasons by glogla on Sunday December 29, 2019 @10:08AM (#21906223)
We have the same setup! So this is where our (Czech) lawmakers got it from. I thought it was a bit too smart for them!

Thanks for the fascinating explanation.

Re:36C3 Staff Assaulted Me for Political Reasons by Tomte on Sunday December 29, 2019 @10:11AM (#21906243)
That was the very short version, of course. The real legal analysis of self-defense is fascinating, but complex. Just take a look at the table of contents in https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Notwehr_(Deutschland)
Re:36C3 Staff Assaulted Me for Political Reasons by glogla on Sunday December 29, 2019 @09:55AM (#21906158)
Just out of curiosity, how does it work?

Interesting, my country has a kind of strange "necessary defence" law - it covers defending something that is protected by lay, not necessarily your own thing - as long as the defence is appropriate.

So you can "defend" someone else, or stop a thief even if they are not threatening you, because you are upholding the law - but you don't get to shoot a thief for example, because that would not be appropriate.

Is this how it works in Germany? I'm kind of curious if we just stolen this from our neighbour.

EDIT: Tomte replied on the side.

Re:36C3 Staff Assaulted Me for Political Reasons by FDSGSG on Sunday December 29, 2019 @09:55AM (#21906157)
> If people were reasonably convinced that he was threatening others

You're the first person to suggest that he was threatening others.

Re:36C3 Staff Assaulted Me for Political Reasons by eqvinox on Sunday December 29, 2019 @11:08AM (#21906568)
No, I'm the first person to suggest that (multiple) people believed he was threatening others. Please read carefully :)

It doesn't matter whether he was intending to threaten, or ignorant about the rules, or just stupid. If he leaves the boundary of socially acceptable behaviour (yes this is subjective and established by the community) then he may full well get evicted, and with force if necessary.

On the legal side, a judge or jury would repeat that consideration, and establish whether his behaviour was beyond acceptable for the context he was in. Not by the judge's or jury's social standards, but by trying to understand the situation and determine whether the crowd acted "reasonable." Since there's quite a bunch of people involved in his getting kicked out video, I would wager a guess that there was consensus that his behaviour was inacceptable, and a judge/jury would side with that.

German law doesn't do "I spilled hot Starbucks, now I sue Starbucks for damages". You're expected to have a brain and some level of common sense (or be certified psychologically ill, if you prefer).

Relatedly, the "they should've called the police" argument is legally wrong in Germany too. The allies were pretty pissed off after WW2 and wanted to eliminate the "bystander" excuse for people who watched Jews getting gassed. That's where the "failure to render aid" law comes from. Of course, you're not expected to endanger yourself, but - say, there's an average guy assaulting someone, and you're travelling in a group of 5 reasonably muscular, capable guys... your excuse to not step in is gone.

Re:36C3 Staff Assaulted Me for Political Reasons by FDSGSG on Sunday December 29, 2019 @09:34PM (#21910324)
>(multiple) people believed he was threatening others

Do you have any evidence to support this claim? Unless you're implying that his eviction in itself is evidence, which sounds pretty insane to me.