News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:36C3 Staff Assaulted Me for Political Reasons by Tomte on Sunday December 29, 2019 @09:58AM (#21906171)
German law has extraordinary self-defense statutes, both civil and criminal. The following applies to criminal self-defense:

Any ongoing[1] illegal attack on any legal right may be warded off using force, including insults (that's an attack against personal honor).

The force does not have to be proportional, only necessary (it must not be more severe than another one that would lead to success) and effective (it must have a reasonable expectation of success to start with).

Apart from that there are only minor exceptions (for small children and so on).

[1] "ongoing" is again much wider than you'd think: someone robbing you and running away with the loot? Still ongoing. You following them and striking them down? Still ongoing. Meeting them on the street next day by chance? Not ongoing.

Re:36C3 Staff Assaulted Me for Political Reasons by Tomte on Sunday December 29, 2019 @10:03AM (#21906193)
> illegal attack on any legal right

Except abortion, strangely.

That's for historic reasons, Germany also had a long debate about abortion, and the compromise found was that abortion is illegal, but does not lead to criminal culpability.

According to that, it would be possible to use self-defense for the unborn child against the mother and doctors when she tries to abort.

Obviously, nobody wants burning abortion clinics, and the courts settled on that abortion cannot trigger self-defense.

That's un-principled, and I'm not aware of any legal expert actually justifying it on doctrinal grounds, but it's useful to keep the peace in the debate.

Re:36C3 Staff Assaulted Me for Political Reasons by scurvy on Sunday December 29, 2019 @10:09AM (#21906225)
I'd guess there's a bar to meet here on immediate danger, and my guess it wasn't here?

Uninvited guest shows up to the party, you should call the police.

Seems like there were 0 cool heads and everyone involved is guilty of something.

Re:36C3 Staff Assaulted Me for Political Reasons by Tomte on Sunday December 29, 2019 @10:14AM (#21906259)
I'm not trying to judge whether whatever anybody did in this specific example (as little as we know) was valid self-defense. I'm just trying to convey some aspects of German law which may be very strange to people from other legal cultures.

For example, whenever I'm reading an article about "the new Texan shoot-first-ask-later law"[1]/stand-your-ground/castle-doctrine I'm very disappointed in the emotional reporting, because it seems so mild and almost pacifist.

[1] to use the cliché

Re:36C3 Staff Assaulted Me for Political Reasons by glogla on Sunday December 29, 2019 @10:08AM (#21906223)
We have the same setup! So this is where our (Czech) lawmakers got it from. I thought it was a bit too smart for them!

Thanks for the fascinating explanation.

Re:36C3 Staff Assaulted Me for Political Reasons by Tomte on Sunday December 29, 2019 @10:11AM (#21906243)
That was the very short version, of course. The real legal analysis of self-defense is fascinating, but complex. Just take a look at the table of contents in https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Notwehr_(Deutschland)