Re:36C3 Staff Assaulted Me for Political Reasons
by Tomte on Sunday December 29, 2019 @10:03AM
(#21906193)
> illegal attack on any legal right
Except abortion, strangely.
That's for historic reasons, Germany also had a long debate about abortion, and the compromise found was that abortion is illegal, but does not lead to criminal culpability.
According to that, it would be possible to use self-defense for the unborn child against the mother and doctors when she tries to abort.
Obviously, nobody wants burning abortion clinics, and the courts settled on that abortion cannot trigger self-defense.
That's un-principled, and I'm not aware of any legal expert actually justifying it on doctrinal grounds, but it's useful to keep the peace in the debate.
Except abortion, strangely.
That's for historic reasons, Germany also had a long debate about abortion, and the compromise found was that abortion is illegal, but does not lead to criminal culpability.
According to that, it would be possible to use self-defense for the unborn child against the mother and doctors when she tries to abort.
Obviously, nobody wants burning abortion clinics, and the courts settled on that abortion cannot trigger self-defense.
That's un-principled, and I'm not aware of any legal expert actually justifying it on doctrinal grounds, but it's useful to keep the peace in the debate.