News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by forensic on Monday February 07, 2011 @03:32PM (#2190564)
If I can have dinners at expensive restaurants, yachts, manors, apartments throughout the world, unlimited access to high class prostitutes, the respect, deference, fear, and love of the masses who stand in awe of my wealth...

rich in pretty much ANY time.

No matter what year it is it's always better to be on top. That's where most of the human pleasure comes from.

Xboxes and iPhones are really no substitute for being on top of society.

Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by endtime on Monday February 07, 2011 @04:27PM (#2190856)
Sorry, but you sound like a shallow prick and possibly a sociopath.

If I can see my (future) children grow up happy and healthy, keep learning my whole life, earn my living solving interesting problems, etc., that's not just quantitatively worth more than a yacht; it's qualitatively a better life.

To answer the actual question, of 1973 vs. today, I'd take today. The Internet is, frankly, awesome. Not having the entire world living in fear of nuclear winter is also kind of nice. I don't think cryo firms like Alcor existed in 1973. Those are just a few things off the top of my head; I'm sure I could come up with a much longer list given time.

Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by flashgordon on Monday February 07, 2011 @05:12PM (#2190995)
Well I would have thought rich in 1973 would have been a no brainer. Not because of affording expensive things yada yada (ok thats a huge bonus too but not for me). But because having the (relative) wealth would mean having the luxury of choosing my job without having to worry about how the bills were being paid. Having the dough to invest in my passions (assuming one had them). Having the dough to invest in technology at the early stages! I mean yeah the internet is great now. But you could just as well ask, would you rather be rich now or middle class in 40 years time?
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by endtime on Monday February 07, 2011 @05:35PM (#2191081)
Definitely middle class in 40 years. I suspect 2051 will be as far ahead of us now as 2011 would be to someone in the 1940's or so.
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by flashgordon on Monday February 07, 2011 @10:05PM (#2191755)
I suppose it could be worse. We could be "poor" in 40 years time! Again I mean poor in the vaguest sense. Which makes you wonder. What would the bums be like in 40 years?
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by forensic on Monday February 07, 2011 @04:41PM (#2190905)
>If I can see my (future) children grow up happy and healthy, keep learning my whole life, earn my living solving interesting problems

If you're rich you can still do these things. Whether you're rich in Ancient Egypt or rich in 1973 you'll have access to this stuff.

Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by endtime on Monday February 07, 2011 @05:00PM (#2190958)
I don't disagree with you. I was responding directly to the person...to whom I was responding, who said:

>No matter what year it is it's always better to be on top. That's where most of the human pleasure comes from.

The second half of my comment addressed the 1973 question, and made it clear that it was doing so.

Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by rbanffy on Monday February 07, 2011 @04:35PM (#2190884)
> No matter what year it is it's always better to be on top. That's where most of the human pleasure comes from.

You know you will be happier if you enjoy what you have, not the fact you have and others don't.

Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by forensic on Monday February 07, 2011 @04:44PM (#2190911)
I wouldn't be enjoying what others don't have.

I would be enjoying what I DO have. Which is the ability to pay others to do whatever I want.

I want massages and blowjobs and chefs and chauffeurs and butlers and servants. Who doesn't want these things?

A rich person can get these things no matter what year it is. A poor person will always be denied these things no matter what year it is.

Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by rbanffy on Tuesday February 08, 2011 @03:15AM (#2192361)
massages and blowjobs and chefs and chauffeurs and butlers and servants grow old very quickly.
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by forensic on Tuesday February 08, 2011 @05:15AM (#2192487)
easy to say when you have them

if i get bored of blowjobs i'll do what other rich people do for fun - social engineering.

Tinker with the lives of the little people like the peons they are.

Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by diego on Monday February 07, 2011 @02:37PM (#2190309)
Relative wealth is what gets you the most mating opportunities and gives your genes a competitive advantage, to put it in a pseudo-academic language. Geoffrey Miller's The Mating Mind is way more interesting and deeper than this article if you are interested in the subject. Spent is even more about relative wealth as a fitness signal, but a bit fluffier.
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by Vivtek on Monday February 07, 2011 @02:32PM (#2190284)
Rich in 1900 is my choice. I'll bet the food then rocked - I'll just take one year's income at face value and the house I'm living in now, without 111 years of intervening decay. The rich industrialist who lived here in 1900 will have to find new digs.

But no contest. I'd turn back that clock right now.

Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by HeyLaughingBoy on Monday February 07, 2011 @02:40PM (#2190325)
What kind of food do you think you'd get in 1900 that you couldn't get today?
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by yummyfajitas on Monday February 07, 2011 @03:13PM (#2190459)
This brings to mind a scene from Mad Men (taking place only in the 60's). Draper has gone AWOL to California, where he is screwing some rich teenager. She asks him: "Have you ever had Mexican food?" He hadn't.

Similarly, in the novel of Casino Royale, avocados are used to signify how exotic the casino is.

This only takes you back to the 60's.

Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by Vivtek on Monday February 07, 2011 @03:23PM (#2190515)
Grown right here. I grew up here - Good Food.

Well, in the summer, anyway. And in the winter I shall take the train to Cuba and have oranges till I burst.

Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by CamperBob on Monday February 07, 2011 @02:50PM (#2190355)
It would be like going to Mexico and drinking the local water. You'd have no immunity to whatever bugs were commonly in food at that (pre-refrigeration) time.
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by WildUtah on Monday February 07, 2011 @03:22PM (#2190507)
Nobody drinks the local water in Mexico, including Mexicans. It's the food that carries novel fauna.

And it isn't the food that would get you. It's the smallpox.

Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by T_S_ on Monday February 07, 2011 @02:42PM (#2190332)
Enjoy all the smoke. And don't forget to not get cancer.
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by GiraffeNecktie on Monday February 07, 2011 @03:57PM (#2190701)
If you're into the "local food" movement you might like the food in 1900. There was very little refrigeration and limited transportation. That meant plenty of fresh fruits and veggies in the summer and fall, but nothing but pickled and smoked food in the winter (along with root vegetables from the cold cellar). Preserving food was a serious business because your family could starve if you screwed up.
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by forinti on Monday February 07, 2011 @03:06PM (#2190431)
You'd change your mind very fast as soon as you needed a dentist...
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by cabalamat on Monday February 07, 2011 @03:11PM (#2190452)
Or a doctor.
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by petervandijck on Monday February 07, 2011 @02:59PM (#2190391)
No sushi. No TV. Few interesting books. I could go on.
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by hyperbovine on Monday February 07, 2011 @03:25PM (#2190534)
> Few interesting books.

Except for Dickens, Shakespeare, Poe, Austen, Twain, Dostoyevksy, Tolstoy, the Bronte sisters, Melville, Arthur Conan Doyle, Victor Hugo, Dumas, Thoreau, Marx, Henry James, H.G. Wells, Jules Verne, Joseph Conrad, Ibsen, George Eliot, Oscar Wilde ... (I could go on.)

Yep, it was a real literary dark ages back then.

Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by petervandijck on Monday February 07, 2011 @04:04PM (#2190733)
Quite honestly I find most of those pretty boring. Jules Verne is fine but not if you know Herbert Frank exists (or will exist).
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by Vivtek on Monday February 07, 2011 @03:29PM (#2190552)
Dude. I already know how to make sushi, and I don't have a TV now.

There are plenty of interesting books in a library that's way classier than the one we have now - and the Wright Brothers live down the street (well; they might have gone to Dayton by 1900) and plenty of other tinkers and inventors. There were more patents in this county in 1900 than any other county in the United States.

1900 in Richmond, Indiana was where it was at.

Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by colomon on Monday February 07, 2011 @05:04PM (#2190969)
Umm... how are you getting sushi quality fish in Richmond, Indiana in 1900? What's your source of nori and wasabi?
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by petervandijck on Monday February 07, 2011 @07:19PM (#2191362)
Yea. And good coffee :) There's a lot we take for granted. Then again, there's a lot we could probably do without.
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by artmageddon on Monday February 07, 2011 @03:16PM (#2190473)
No means of rapid transportation over extremely long distances.
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by georgieporgie on Monday February 07, 2011 @03:20PM (#2190496)
> I'll bet the food then rocked

Really?

Sure, sun-ripened fruits eaten at their peak would be delicious. But you'd be stuck eating whatever could be had within a few miles of your home. You could migrate with the seasons to widen your annual food selection, but that would be extremely costly.

The quality of many individual food items in the early 1900s would probably be better than 1960. Take instant coffee, Coors, and Wonderbread for example. But Starbucks and micro brews have paved the way back to high standards for these items nowadays.

Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by jerf on Monday February 07, 2011 @04:47PM (#2190924)
"more authentic pleasures like books, films, music, and jet travel to exotic spots (without T&A frisking at airports)"

Yeah, but... 2011 is a win on every front there except the last. (And that may be debatable; you better like your exotic spots very exotic.) If you do not confine yourself to pre-1970s books, firms, and music right now, it's because you like the stuff that came later better, no matter how nostalgic you think you are. You may think there's more garbage in 2011 but there's a lot more good stuff, too, and a lot more well-populated niches.

I mean, sure, wealthy in 1973 over middle class today in the broad sense, but not for that reason. And I will take middle-class 2011 over rich 1900. I'm not sure where the exact cross-over is, but it's certainly within that bound.

Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by NickPollard on Monday February 07, 2011 @02:50PM (#2190351)
Maybe it's just the fact that I'm a hacker and a child of the digital age, but I'd take the ability to have a 1ghz computer in my pocket connected to the entire world for a couple of hundred bucks, against paying thousands of dollars for a machine that probably can't even do truetype rendering.
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by _delirium on Monday February 07, 2011 @03:16PM (#2190475)
When it comes to computers, I think I'd pick 1985 over either one. Access to affordable home computers, networkability via BBSs and BBS networks, a sense of cyberspace-can-be-anything possibilities, a nice mesh of connected-but-not-flattened online communities, etc. I guess I don't care that much about truetype rendering; I even like 1985-era videogames better.

Wikipedia, open-access academic literature, online reservations for various things, and home data-crunching abilities are nice, though.

Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by jhamburger on Monday February 07, 2011 @02:56PM (#2190382)
It depends on whether this is a time-travel question, or a 'when would you rather be born' question. You wouldn't miss things that you don't know exist.
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by NickPollard on Monday February 07, 2011 @03:00PM (#2190396)
That doesn't seem relevant though - you have to judge 2011 against 1973 based on the conditions of the time.

In 500 BC I wouldn't know about vaccines so I wouldn't miss them, but that doesn't change the fact that living in a world with vaccines is a hell of a lot nicer.

Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by jhamburger on Monday February 07, 2011 @03:10PM (#2190444)
That works for vaccines but what about smartphones? Do they really make the world a hell of a lot nicer, or are they just inextricably tied into our lifestyles?
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by yummyfajitas on Monday February 07, 2011 @05:47PM (#2191126)
I truly enjoy having a large library in my pocket. My commute is a lot better with it than without it.
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by orangecat on Monday February 07, 2011 @03:11PM (#2190454)
You wouldn't miss things that you don't know exist.

I "miss" not having a heads-up display in my glasses or contacts or optic nerve, and not being able to prevent my body and mind from failing due to aging. I'd choose middle class in 2049 over rich in 2011 for the same reasons that I'd choose 2011 over 1973.

Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by jhamburger on Monday February 07, 2011 @03:26PM (#2190536)
Yes but you're talking about life-altering technology...That's the author's whole point, most of that stuff already happened by 1973. That's why he'd take 1973 instead of 1900 or whenever. We mostly live the same way now as we did in 1973, just with more gadgets. If you said "I miss not having holographic phones and VR porn" that would be a better example.
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by colomon on Monday February 07, 2011 @03:42PM (#2190626)
All I can say is, your life must be a hell of a lot different than mine.

My job (writing programs used by people around the world, all from my home office in small city Michigan) could not have existed in 1973. Indeed, my house probably has computing power equivalent to that of a good-sized university of the time. A sizable percentage of the food I eat was not available anywhere outside of a Chinatown then. My favorite genre of games, role-playing games, had not yet been invented. Nor had the high blood pressure pills I take. The surgery I had at new year's would have meant days rather than hours in the hospital.

And my son could never have been born. Life-altering? Hell yes.

Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by rbanffy on Monday February 07, 2011 @02:19PM (#2190220)
Rich in '73 is such an obvious choice...
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by caixa on Monday February 07, 2011 @02:35PM (#2190300)
I'm not sure if my being born in the late 1980s would make me more or less likely to choose 1973 over 2011. On the one hand it would take some getting used to a world without computers and the like, having never experienced that before. On the other, it would be more like travelling to a new place than going back in time, which at least sounds more exciting.

My question is - how far back would you go?

Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by rbanffy on Monday February 07, 2011 @04:34PM (#2190880)
> My question is - how far back would you go?

If seriously confronted with this proposition, I would probably not take the risk. My father died of cancer, as did one of my aunts (from my mother's family), so, I would be weary of being too far from more modern treatments and/or diagnostics. It would be tempting, of course, to be able to witness some key events in our industry first hand (maybe even nudge them in a better direction). I would, certainly, be at the homebrew computer club meeting when Woz presented his Apple I. About a year later I would talk Woz into (or help him with - I still remember 6502 well enough) integrating floating point into Apple's BASIC. Then, I would try to persuade the IBM execs not to ditch CP/M-86 for PC-DOS. And then I would call it a day and head back to a much nicer 2011.

I could also lobby for Thorium reactors in the 50's...

Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by weavejester on Monday February 07, 2011 @02:52PM (#2190366)
Why? I'd personally opt for middle class in 2011. No contest.
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by fuzzythinker on Monday February 07, 2011 @03:42PM (#2190624)
Would you rather be middle class in 2040 or rich in 2011?
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by cabalamat on Monday February 07, 2011 @03:14PM (#2190463)
Rich in '73 -- I'd invent Smalltalk before Alan Kay did.
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by codebaobab on Monday February 07, 2011 @04:07PM (#2190749)
Too late. :) He already had Smalltalk-72 under his belt by then.
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by johngalt on Monday February 07, 2011 @07:52PM (#2191450)
Seems like a false comparison:

1973->2011 = 38years

1900->1973 = 73years

Although it does make me aware of an interesting question. Obviously I'd rather be rich last year over middle class this year. How about five years ago? Ten? A hundred?

As fun as questions like this are, we don't get to make that choice. Might as well just focus on getting rich now :-/

Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by gte910h on Monday February 07, 2011 @03:57PM (#2190700)
You've not taken into account the social changes:

You'd hate the way people talk and act in 1973.

Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by aristidb on Monday February 07, 2011 @02:56PM (#2190383)
"But I suppose everyone thinks their youth was some sort of Golden Age."
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by joubert on Monday February 07, 2011 @02:29PM (#2190273)
Do I die in 1974?
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by Luc on Monday February 07, 2011 @03:17PM (#2190478)
I would have loved to have been rich, or even middle class, at the start of the home computer revolution.
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by tastybites on Monday February 07, 2011 @03:07PM (#2190432)
Rich in 1973, because people who were rich in 1973 are, by and large, even richer in 2011.
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by something on Monday February 07, 2011 @03:09PM (#2190440)
they're also a lot closer to dead.
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by tastybites on Monday February 07, 2011 @03:10PM (#2190445)
So be will you, in 2031.
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by Charuru on Monday February 07, 2011 @03:03PM (#2190413)
I'd rather be in the lowest 10% 100 years from now.
Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by johnohara on Monday February 07, 2011 @03:06PM (#2190430)
Here's an interesting document from the US Census Bureau:

http://www2.census.gov/prod2/popscan/p60-097.pdf

In 1973, 628,000 families made less than $1000.00 per year. That's $.48 per hour for a 40-hour week. 8.1 million (14.1%) families made less that $5000 that year.

In 2011, annual unemployment benefits for an individual can reach about $20,000. In 1973, that amount would rank in the upper 18% of all family incomes.

Making $50,000+ in 1973 would rank in the top 1%.

Re:Would You Rather Be Middle Class in 2011 or Rich in 1973? by georgecmu on Tuesday February 08, 2011 @12:18AM (#2192053)
You're comparing apples to oranges. At a very minimum, you must adjust for inflation. Most people here, though, are more interested in how much you can get for a dollar today vs in the past.