Jumping rope is also very underrated. I’m just starting the CrossRopes challenge.
Weight training is fairly rated. Spinning fairly rated. Ellipticals are overrated.
this is the key thing that keeps me going as well and it seems underrated. Cardio and better looks and whatnot are nice but for me change in posture and back musculature has been a real boon.
I used to have headaches and back pain pretty frequently and just essentially felt like a slob when sitting and having some more muscles and dropping some weight has fixed a lot of it. In addition to rowing, I can also recommend swimming. In particular for people who haven't exercised in a long time and/or are overweight.
My last vacation to Florida I got out on the water with an 85 year old man that had been rowing for 50+ years. I got great instruction and he was full of sage wisdom. It was a ton of fun and I've never been so pleased to kick my butt kicked by a professional.
This is the only method that works for me. A scale with weight, body fat and muscle mass measurements each morning after waking up.
What gets measured gets done.
Kudos to OP/TFA for sticking with it, but I'm wondering if exploring other options would be beneficial for the long term. Real strength is not gotten from a treadmill alone, although it does have bone strengthening benefits that eg cycling does not.
Rowing seems like a great alternative to be added to the mix, as would weights.
A relative of mine was on a crew team for years. He got into very good shape, and developed extraordinary back muscles, but his chest became sort of small in comparison. It was similar to runners who end up with huge legs and undeveloped arms.
I wonder if rowing could be re-designed to target all the muscles somehow, not just pulling in one direction.
Are there complementary sports or exercises?
I counter it with general weight training in between rows. My schedule has two chest days a week.
So, I would say that my mousing was more than any average pointing and clicking one would typically do with consuming content.
I found that my muscles in my back would fall asleep / go numb and I would need to really focus on posture and take breaks to lay on a racket ball ort tennis ball between my shoulders to massage those muscles.
Now I get comments about my posture being so rock solid straight up when I sit at my machine due to how conscious I was of my back.
Now I just do it without thinking - but really having good posture and strong back to hold up at a machine for long hours is a must.
Set them up at the right height and your bar will be allowed to bounce off / touch the rib cage (where the movement should go, at least according to eg Rippetoe (1)), yet leave the area further up protected. You should be able to easily wriggle out; verify with bar only first.
My squat rack has numbered holes, this helps my setup time when switching J hooks from squats to bench.
(1) https://youtu.be/4T9UQ4FBVXI @ 8:40
See other comments about concept2, they're the erg standard by far.
Also, consider for a moment the physics involved. Air is a fluid, just like water, and behaves in exactly the same ways. It is simply less dense and requires greater surface area to produce the same resistance. Air is also compressible and seems to produce a much more consistent stroke.
If you want the real thing, get an actual row boat and put it on a lake. Adding water to the machine does not add any degree of authenticity to the experience.
Doing that consistently is impressive.
How do you measure that?
The only downside to all of this is that rowing is an activity that is very direct in its payout model. You have to intentionally push yourself harder because of how the resistance mechanism operates. Just sitting on a machine or boat and going through the motions for X amount of time does not entitle anyone to weight loss or any other health benefits. If it doesn't suck at least a little bit while you are doing it, I can pretty much guarantee you won't experience any upside afterwards. You will have to become the architect of your own individual hell when using a rowing machine. The worse it is during, the better the results will be after (but don't discourage yourself!).
In my personal experience, I literally cannot gain weight when doing at least 5 sessions of 5km (<25 minutes each) per week. Now, this ~25 minutes is pretty brutal, but it's all it takes to keep me at a healthy weight without even trying. I could drink a 6 pack of light beer every single day (obviously not recommended) and still not put on any appreciable weight. Being able to consume anything you want whenever you want is very liberating. Contrary to the parent post, I never bother to log my calories or weight. I just enforce the rowing output on a regular basis and keep it simple. Having the performance monitor module on the rower helps a ton with maintaining consistent output.
I purchased a Concept2 Model D about 4 years ago now, and it has already seen over 7000 km with not so much as a hint of breakdown. Just a little bit of 3-in-1 oil on the chain once in a while and it runs like a dream every time. 9/10 times if I can't get myself motivated to get in the car to go to the gym, I can at least talk myself into a 20-30 minute rowing session since it's just in the other room. This was probably the best purchase I've ever made if we are considering personal health as a high priority.
The big thing that worked for me was data. I weighed myself every day no matter what and even if I knew I was going over the calorie count for the day I logged it anyway.
For me that was when this vast mystery of diet was cleared. Once I saw how directly linked they were it became very easy to say no to things and it continues to do so.