News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by philwelch on Wednesday December 25, 2019 @04:37PM (#21880624)
At some point we're going to have rotating, shielded space stations that are much safer than living in 0g aluminum tubes.

The real question is whether the effects of subnormal gravity are safe. If not, Mars isn't likely to work out and we'll instead have to build rotating habitats.

Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by nabla9 on Wednesday December 25, 2019 @04:47PM (#21880659)
That's really far into the future if ever.

Technology is not the problem, space economics is.

Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by philwelch on Wednesday December 25, 2019 @05:12PM (#21880764)
You can get rotating artificial gravity even with bolos, though wheel-shaped stations would be better.

If you store the station's water supply between the interior and exterior walls, you get a decent amount of shielding that way, and you need the water anyway so it's no extra mass. Alternatively, you could capture a near-earth asteroid and just tunnel your space station into it, using the material inside the asteroid for construction material.

I suspect any program to capture a near-earth asteroid and construct a station with artificial gravity would be approximately the same cost as a Mars mission.

Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by nabla9 on Wednesday December 25, 2019 @05:19PM (#21880794)
If there were only any near term intention to capture asteroids. Everything is technologically possible and it's funny to say how it could be done. But if you look at budgets, timetables etc. it's not looking very likely.

If we are going to Mars in next 30 years it's going to be some other path.

Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by chrisco255 on Wednesday December 25, 2019 @10:14PM (#21881835)
With Space Force being the newest branch of the U.S. military, look...if the CIA wants to make up some shit about Martians having WMDs and therefore we need to invade the planet immediately...I'm willing to go along with it.
Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by ryanmercer on Thursday December 26, 2019 @08:23AM (#21883598)
So I used to listen to Coast to Coast just as entertainment before it turned into a giant infomercial, I now listen to Mysterious Universe which is much better and much more entertaining and definitely worth a listen if you like crazy/paranormal things approached with lots of skepticism and humor, but a semi-regular guest on Coast to Coast claims that the CIA was on Mars ha!

The guest claimed that as part of a CIA project in his teens, he was on mars via teleportation and saw a young Barack Obama there. It's pure unsanity and obviously not fake but it's a hell of a rabbit hole to go down purely for amusement. The sad part is, at least from my impression, the guest really believed that he had been part of these alleged (fantastical) events. Here are some articles about it:

https://www.wired.com/2012/01/obama-mars/

https://www.inverse.com/article/6741-remembering-that-time-t...

The amusing thing is though there are FOIA documents from the CIA that mention Mars as a remote viewing target, for example this one https://www.cia.gov/library/readingroom/document/cia-rdp96-0...

So who knows, maybe the CIA has really had a legitimate interest in Mars at some point, they've taken interest in far stranger things (maybe they took too much of their own drugs from MKUltra).

Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by 0xBA5ED on Thursday December 26, 2019 @03:36AM (#21882634)
>you could capture a near-earth asteroid and just tunnel your space station into it, using the material inside the asteroid for construction material

This is a cool idea. Maybe you could get the whole thing spinning and have really efficient gravity generation due to its mass.

Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by m4rtink on Thursday December 26, 2019 @05:32AM (#21882979)
Scott Manley did a video about this - turns out this is pretty energy intensive (asteroids are heavy & you are spinning up the whole thing) & not doable at all for many asteroid types due to insufficient material strength of the asteroid. Therefore, internal centrifuges in an asteroid cavern or spinning stations made from metal and/or advanced materials (wheels up to ONeil Island 3 design) are a much better bet than spinning asteroids.
Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by fit2rule on Thursday December 26, 2019 @05:12AM (#21882929)
This had me thinking - are we looking for objects in space that should not be spinning, but are spinning?

This'd at lest let us know there is life out there with the same problem, right?

I really wonder if that's part of the checklist for 'an odd object in space which we should investigate further' ..

Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by m4rtink on Thursday December 26, 2019 @05:34AM (#21882987)
Any artificial extrasolar objects that use spin for gravity would be far to small for current telescopes to resolve, not to mention detect their spin, if they are circular.
Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by fit2rule on Thursday December 26, 2019 @05:40AM (#21883010)
I'm guessing we've exhausted the search for such objects in our own solar system ..
Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by m4rtink on Thursday December 26, 2019 @05:54AM (#21883054)
Oh, right - tha's actually a good idea & one can measure rotation rates of asteroids: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fast_rotators_(minor...

BTW, the recently discovered extra-solar asteroid also had quite some rotation IIRC.

Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by kgilpin on Thursday December 26, 2019 @09:45AM (#21884115)
I don’t think it would be too long before the aliens evolved away from the need to spin. There would be so many advantages to adapting to zero G.
Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by narag on Wednesday December 25, 2019 @06:18PM (#21881039)
Another option: build a rotating habitat inside a cave.
Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by m4rtink on Thursday December 26, 2019 @05:35AM (#21882991)
That seems like a much better bet - the asteroids own gravity should be negligiable & you should be able to get reasonably sized cavern rather easily. Also a non/slowly spinnong asteroid is in general easier to dock with.
Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by hoorayimhelping on Wednesday December 25, 2019 @05:25PM (#21880823)
>That's really far into the future if ever.

It's really not. It's not a far leap from "aluminium tube in space" to "slightly larger radius aluminium tube in space rotating along its axis surrounded by liquid hydrogen".

We don't need some magic force field to shield against radiation - water has already proven it can do this. Liquid hydrogen is an even better shield and it's something we currently have the technology to use.

Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by nabla9 on Wednesday December 25, 2019 @05:40PM (#21880883)
As far as I know there is nothing like in the horizon for next 30 years and no money for it.

As I said. Technologically possible. Plans or the budget are not there.

Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by njarboe on Wednesday December 25, 2019 @08:39PM (#21881550)
The combination of much cheaper launch costs of SpaceX's Starship, zero to negative interest rates, and a bunch of space-interested billionaires, might just get some rotating space hotels up and running sooner than you might think.
Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by ClumsyPilot on Thursday December 26, 2019 @01:05AM (#21882272)
SpaceX has been around for over a decade, and they have only designed and operated one rocket.

Even if money falls from the sky tomorrow this kind of stuff takes decades no matter who is doing it, spaceX or NASA.

Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by ben_w on Thursday December 26, 2019 @03:10AM (#21882570)
I count three, the latter two of which are already doing more for less than most were expecting.

And this has all been clearly chosen as a development sequence that leads to them being a space trucking company, so those “decades” plural have already start.

But if it takes two more decades, so what? The points, pro and con, still stand. Technologically achievable, but no clear economic reason as yet.

Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by ClumsyPilot on Thursday December 26, 2019 @03:28PM (#21886464)
I consider 30 years timeline as an optimistic scenario because we will have Super-Heavy rockets in operation in later half of 2020's, and from there onward the priorities for most major space agencies for manned spaceflight is return to the moon and in-situ resources. Which I believe should have been the focus for a while.

Most of innovation and commercial activity will be focused around lunar habitation and infrastructure, by the looks of it.

Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by ryandrake on Wednesday December 25, 2019 @07:02PM (#21881187)
Just a nit-pick: i think it’s a political problem, not an economic problem. Humankind as a whole has the money/resources to do it, perhaps unprofitably. There is just no political will to prioritize it and make it happen.
Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by hutzlibu on Thursday December 26, 2019 @07:07AM (#21883285)
Yeah and that might be because there are lots of problems down on earth right now, like climate change, requiring more effort and are maybe more important than space advance. And sadly I would agree, you don't?
Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by zabzonk on Wednesday December 25, 2019 @06:41PM (#21881116)
> Liquid hydrogen is an even better shield and it's something we currently have the technology to use.

First get your liquid hydrogen (and any other similar solutions) into orbit.

I used to be (in the 70s) gung-ho for space colonies, but really the economics simply don't make sense with anything like current drive technologies, or indeed any in the foreseeable future. In my opinion, the answer to the Fermi Paradox is that putting intelligent living organisms into space for their lifetimes is simply far, far too difficult.

Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by fit2rule on Thursday December 26, 2019 @05:13AM (#21882930)
So we put a big blob of water in space, surround it with materials to prevent its sublimation, then inside it build a ring that spins .. hmm ..
Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by njarboe on Wednesday December 25, 2019 @05:47PM (#21880926)
If SpaceX can get anything near what they hope for the Starship launch costs ($2 million per launch/ 150,000 kg to orbit per launch = $13.3 per kg to orbit), the economics of space will be fundamentally changed. Building the cheapest launch capability possible has been a goal for Elon Musk's SpaceX since the beginning and you can see that principle at work in the decisions that SpaceX makes at each step in the development of its rockets. This could happen in 5-10 years, if there are not any large setbacks.

Who knows if SpaceX will price their launch capabilities at that price though.

Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by modo_mario on Thursday December 26, 2019 @06:43AM (#21883202)
The only reason they can even hope for such prices is because they get boatloads of money from the US government tho. It would probably be more interesting to consider the real cost.
Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by Phenomenit on Wednesday December 25, 2019 @05:44PM (#21880906)
The problem is that the majority of earth's population is under-educated, if our economics system was conducive to education a lot of problems would be solved.
Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by daenz on Wednesday December 25, 2019 @04:43PM (#21880645)
We need to figure out how to live together before we live together in space. Imagine how easy it would be to damage or destroy a relatively flimsy man-made habitat that everyone literally depends on to survive.
Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by edgyquant on Wednesday December 25, 2019 @11:28PM (#21882018)
That isn't going to happen tho. People will be living in space way before they figure out how to get along because getting along is something that humans will never do: maybe what ever species we evolve in to might but that is surely thousands of years in the future.
Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by ars on Thursday December 26, 2019 @02:26AM (#21882478)
The drive to compete is what causes progress, and not getting along is an inevitable side effect of that.

Any species that gets along perfectly either has telepathy (or some sort of unfakeable hormonal equivalent), is some kind of hive/single individual, or is stagnant.

Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by ben_w on Thursday December 26, 2019 @03:18AM (#21882592)
For these purposes, all we need is to get rid of (or at the very least properly control) violent tendencies. We don’t need to make it so everyone’s singing religious rock songs around a fake camp fire to celebrate everyone getting a participation medal in cooperative soccer.
Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by ars on Thursday December 26, 2019 @04:03AM (#21882709)
But violence is the same as disagreement plus enforcing your opinion.

You obviously can't get rid of disagreement. And enforcing your opinion is the bedrock of change.

So I don't believe it's possible to get rid of the desire for violence without stagnation.

You can certainly get rid of it in action, but the desire is still there, just suppressed.

Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by ben_w on Thursday December 26, 2019 @05:34AM (#21882985)
My bosses have never needed violence to enforce their opinions, and I have never needed to resort to violence against them when working relationships have turned sour.

And ridding the action is all that is necessary for us to not die from civil disorder in a space settlement.

Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by keiferski on Thursday December 26, 2019 @06:34AM (#21883170)
This is only because the (threat of) violence has been outsourced to the state. Imagine that there is no state monopoly on violence [1] and your boss pays you directly in food, which you need to survive. Suddenly he refuses to pay you and you face starvation. Now you’re pretty likely to resort to violence.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopoly_on_violence

Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by ben_w on Thursday December 26, 2019 @08:14AM (#21883546)
I’ve mostly avoided needing to involve the state, too. My personality is more of “compete by being better” and I regard violence (and regulatory capture) as cheating.

Don’t get me wrong, I’m not an anarchist — I agree that state monopoly on violence would be spontaneously recreated if it was removed. I’m also a lot more dubious about the political future than about the technological future.

But, that’s beside the point: I’m saying that we could, plausibly, have social and political structures that suppress our violent tendencies and in so doing make it not ridiculously unsafe to live in a fragile space habitat.

This is not without precedent, as we are less violent now than we were a mere few hundred years ago, and have managed this with little in the way of actual evolution.

Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by int_19h on Wednesday December 25, 2019 @05:28PM (#21880833)
Perhaps that kind of forcing function is exactly what is needed?
Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by ryanmercer on Thursday December 26, 2019 @09:46AM (#21884123)
Without getting too spoilery, Ad Astra depicts some handheld weapons in space. The movie is slllowww but visually wonderful.

That isn't all that far fetched, both the USSR and the United States looked at various options for space weapons. Traditional firearms like the TP-82 carried by the soviets and various options were looked at for new weapons by both sides like the 'Soviet laser pistol' https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_laser_pistol

There are some documents out there like "The Meanderings of a Weapon Oriented Mind When Applied in a Vacuum Such as the Moon" (just Google the title, click the link you trust) that show various other types that we know were looked at.

The Soviets even put an autocannon on the Salyut 3, and even fired 20 rounds on orbit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Almaz#Defense_measures

Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by m4rtink on Thursday December 26, 2019 @05:38AM (#21883000)
Well, that's not too different from modern urban.infrastructure & we don't see such issues too much, outside of major armed conflicts.
Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by dsq on Thursday December 26, 2019 @08:52AM (#21883759)
Only by going to space will we develop the skills and economic resources to live better here on Earth.
Re:Are Humans Fit for Space? A ‘Herculean’ Study by ddorian43 on Wednesday December 25, 2019 @04:49PM (#21880664)
Space kamikaze