- Due dates are hard (usually midnight)
- Everyone gets 3 "emergency tokens", which give you a 24 hour extension on the assignment, no questions asked. Max 2 per assignment.
- On occasion, you could get an extension without using a token by speaking to the professor in advance, if you had extenuating circumstances.
It was a good compromise between meaningful deadlines and humanity. One particular advantage is that, if you missed the midnight deadline, you knew you were using a town anyway, so there was no pressure to sacrifice sleep to get the assignment in "on time".
Most people I knew were happy with it.
They gave me the freedom I needed to make micro-adjustments to my college/life balance and greatly lowered stress.
As a student, it was, well, nice. It was true that it was a bit harder to be motivated to finish a paper right away, but it also made the process far less stressful. When I turned in papers I thought they were the best they could be.
Of course, I'm sure there were at least some students in her classes who ignored everything until the end of the term or something, and were quite stressed out at the end...
This doesn't work if your class builds on earlier material (most STEM classes). As the professor, I need some feedback as to how well the class understands what I just taught.
Though I ended up with weird reviews. I got just as many students saying I was their best teacher as those saying worst teacher. I also had a surprising number of students try to turn into me the skeleton code I provided them claiming they did the assignment (they'd add like a line or two). Also had students say I was unavailable even though I lived in my office with my door open (students frequently came by outside office hours) and replied to emails between 9am and 1am. Learned that the complaints don't always match what you're doing and are hard to interpret.
Tldr: students will complain no matter what. Just be human. It's easier and less stressful for everyone involved.
As a CS professor, the one thing I could do that flipped things on their head was running an automatic submission and testing system for any assignment.
You're getting 0% or 100%, but you know at all times over roughly 2 weeks exactly what score you are getting. You can resubmit over and over. Yes, I'm going to run extra tests once the deadline passes to make sure no one is punking me, but it's rare that someone who gets 100% on the initial tests doesn't get 100% on the later tests.
And, for those of you who think that 0%/100% is a poor programming assignment scoring system--I'll ask you the same question I ask my students: "0%/100% is bad? So which of you are cool with partial credit when I miscalculate your grades?"
Is there really? In my faculty, doors were kept open. I entered lectures at 20% of time left and nobody would bat an eyelid.
Hard deadline system with some conveniences.
It was possible to upload the work multiple times, and for an hour or so after deathline, to select which of the uploaded copies would be the hand over.
This allowed for e.g. uploading some code that works, and later progressively optimized/improved versions, without fear of uploading something partially broken by the end.
I have seen deadlines wrap all the way around a 24 hour cycle in this way. 5 PM is bad because people want to work at night, so delay to midnight. Well, people aren’t finishing, so delay to 5 AM, since everybody would be asleep then. Well now people are blaming you for “forcing” them to do all nighters, so delay to 9 AM. Now people say that’s unreasonable, because submitting later in the workday wouldn’t hurt anyone. So delay to 5 PM.
In my undergraduate education, toxic behavior like this was common. One professor who was a particular asshole deliberately assigned onerous assignments to coincide with an assignment for another critical, difficult class that 75% of the students were taking. Academic hazing was pretty common in CS.
From the instructor's point of view, there's no winning here -- there will always be a cutoff, and any position of it will lead to complaints. Even for an informal system, there's always a last person allowed in, and hence a cutoff.
If you have a good reason for an extension, you can still get it. But there's no reason anybody needs, specifically, the extra second after a formal deadline. If the deadline were moved to a second after midnight, you would try to submit two seconds after midnight and complain, and so on. (I mean, why do you think deadlines are at midnight in the first place? Because in-person collection would stop working at 5 PM, leading to complaints, so deadlines were extended to midnight to let people work at night.)
This is pointless slippage, and the resolution from the student side is so easy. Just pretend every deadline is 5 minutes earlier than it actually is, and you'll never have problems.